Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2210.11281 · Physical Review A

Doubling the order of approximation via the randomized product formula

Chien‐Hung Cho, Dominic William Berry, Min-Hsiu Hsieh

Published Jun 24, 2024• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hamiltonian simulation is a major application of quantum computing, for example, enabling prediction of the properties of molecules. Prior work has used product formulas with randomization to improve performance, but has only yielded modest improvements over the excellent performance provided by deterministic high-order product formulas. In this work, we provide a randomized scheme that greatly increases the order of product formulas, thereby providing a large advantage over the best-performing deterministic schemes. Our scheme is based on applying randomly chosen corrections to a high-order symmetric product formula. If the original product formula is of order $2k$ (so the error is of order $2k+1$), then the corrected formula is of order $4k+1$, corresponding to a doubling of the order of the error. In practice, applying the corrections in a quantum algorithm requires some structure to the Hamiltonian, for example, the Pauli strings as are commonly used in the simulation of quantum chemistry.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.109.062431

Related papers

Randomizing multi-product formulas for Hamiltonian simulation

Paul K. Faehrmann, Mark Steudtner, Richard Kueng +2 more

Quantum simulation, the simulation of quantum processes on quantum computers, suggests a path forward for the efficient simulation of problems in condensed-matter physics, quantum chemistry, and materials science. While the majority of quantum simulation algorithms are deterministic, a recent surge of ideas has shown that randomization can greatly benefit algorithmic performance. In this work, we introduce a scheme for quantum simulation that unites the advantages of randomized compiling on the one hand and higher-order multi-product formulas, as they are used for example in linear-combination-of-unitaries (LCU) algorithms or quantum error mitigation, on the other hand. In doing so, we propose a framework of randomized sampling that is expected to be useful for programmable quantum simulators and present two new multi-product formula algorithms tailored to it. Our framework reduces the circuit depth by circumventing the need for oblivious amplitude amplification required by the implementation of multi-product formulas using standard LCU methods, rendering it especially useful for early quantum computers used to estimate the dynamics of quantum systems instead of performing full-fledged quantum phase estimation. Our algorithms achieve a simulation error that shrinks exponentially with the circuit depth. To corroborate their functioning, we prove rigorous performance bounds as well as the concentration of the randomized sampling procedure. We demonstrate the functioning of the approach for several physically meaningful examples of Hamiltonians, including fermionic systems and the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev model, for which the method provides a favorable scaling in the effort.

arXiv:2101.07808•Quantum•Sep 19, 2022•59 citations

Phase Estimation with Partially Randomized Time Evolution

Jakob Günther, Freek Witteveen, Alexander Schmidhuber +3 more

Quantum phase estimation combined with Hamiltonian simulation is the most promising algorithmic framework to computing ground-state energies on quantum computers. Its main computational overhead derives from the Hamiltonian simulation subroutine. In this paper we use randomization to speed up product formulas, one of the standard approaches to Hamiltonian simulation. We propose partially randomized Hamiltonian simulation methods in which some terms are kept deterministically and others are randomly sampled. We perform a detailed resource estimate for single-ancilla phase estimation using partially randomized product formulas for benchmark systems in quantum chemistry and obtain orders-of-magnitude improvements compared to other simulations based on product formulas. When applied to the hydrogen chain, we have numerical evidence that our methods exhibit asymptotic scaling with the system size that is competitive with the best known qubitization approaches.

arXiv:2503.05647•PRX Quantum•Mar 31, 2026•39 citations

Randomized product formulas beyond optimal deterministic scaling

Leeseok Kim, Luis Pedro García-Pintos

Product formulas, also known as Trotter formulas, are among the most widely used and practical methods for simulating quantum systems on quantum computers. Here we introduce two new classes of randomized product formulas for simulating Hamiltonians with separated energy scales, $H=A+αB$, where $α$ is small. In the standard access model, where one can implement exponentials of $A$ and $B$ separately, our randomized formulas achieve $\mathcal O(α^2)$ error scaling at the cost of only doubling the gate depth of the corresponding deterministic formula. We further prove an $Ω(α)$ lower bound for deterministic product formulas. In a stronger access model, allowing exponentials of $A+αB_\ell$ for $B = \sum_{\ell}B_\ell$, our randomized formula, based on Trotter Heuristic Resource Improved Formulas for Time-dynamics (THRIFT)~[J. L. Bosse et al., Nat. Commun. 16, 2673 (2025)], achieves $\mathcal O(α^3)$ error scaling with only constant-factor expected gate overhead. We also establish an $Ω(α^2)$ lower bound for deterministic product formulas in this access model. Numerical simulations confirm gate-count reductions for simulating physically motivated systems.

quant-pharXiv:2608.07720•Aug 11, 2026•1 citation

Selection and Improvement of Product Formulae for Best Performance of Quantum Simulation

Mauro E. S. Morales, Pedro C. S. Costa, Giacomo Pantaleoni +3 more

Abstract Quantum algorithms for simulation of Hamiltonian evolution are often based on product formulae. The fractal methods give a systematic way to find arbitrarily high-order product formulae, but result in a large number of exponentials. On the other hand, product formulae with fewer exponentials can be found by numerical solution of simultaneous non-linear equations. It is also possible to reduce the cost of long-time simulations by processing, where a kernel is repeated and a processor need only be applied at the beginning and end of the simulation. In this work, we found thousands of new product formulae, and numerically tested these formulae, together with many formulae from prior literature. We provide methods to fairly compare product formulae of different lengths and different orders. For the case of 8th order, we have found new product formulae with exceptional performance, about two orders of magnitude better accuracy than prior work, both in the processed and non-processed cases. The processed product formula provides the best performance due to being shorter than the non-processed product formula. It outperforms all other tested product formulae over a range of many orders of magnitude in system parameters T (time) and ε (allowable error). That includes reasonable combinations of parameters to be used in quantum algorithms, where the size of the simulation is large enough to be classically intractable, but not so large it takes an impractically long time on a quantum computer.

arXiv:2210.15817•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 31, 2025•32 citations

Faster Algorithmic Quantum and Classical Simulations by Corrected Product Formulas

Mohsen Bagherimehrab, Luis Mantilla Calderón, Dominic William Berry +6 more

Hamiltonian simulation using product formulas is arguably the most straightforward and practical approach for algorithmic simulation of a quantum system’s dynamics on a quantum computer. Here we present corrected product formulas (CPFs), a variation of product formulas achieved by injecting auxiliary terms called correctors into standard product formulas. We establish several correctors that improve the accuracy of standard product formulas by orders of magnitude when simulating Hamiltonians comprised of two exactly simulatable partitions, a common structure of lattice Hamiltonians. Importantly, injecting these correctors increases the overall simulation cost by only a small additive or multiplicative factor. We show that correctors are particularly advantageous for perturbed systems, where one partition has a relatively small norm compared to the other, as they allow the small norm to be utilized as an additional parameter for controlling the simulation error. We demonstrate the performance of CPFs by numerical simulations for several lattice Hamiltonians. Numerical results show that our theoretical error bounds for CPFs match or outperform the empirical error scaling of standard product formulas for these systems. We also demonstrate improvements offered by CPFs by implementing small-size systems on actual quantum hardware, as well as on noisy and noiseless quantum simulators. CPFs could be a valuable algorithmic tool for early fault-tolerant quantum computers with limited computing resources. As for standard product formulas, CPFs could also be used for simulations on a classical computer.

arXiv:2409.08265•PRX Quantum•May 28, 2026•11 citations

When is randomization advantageous in quantum simulation?

Francesco Paganelli, Michele Grossi, Andrea Giachero +2 more

We study the regimes in which Hamiltonian simulation benefits from randomization. We introduce a sparse-QSVT construction based on composite stochastic decompositions, where dominant terms are treated deterministically and smaller contributions are sampled stochastically. Crucially, we analyze how stochastic and approximation errors propagate through block-encoding and QSVT procedures. To benchmark this approach, we construct ensembles of random Hamiltonians with controlled coefficient dispersion, locality, and number of terms, designed to favor randomization, and therefore providing an upper bound on its practical advantage. For Hamiltonians with many terms and highly inhomogeneous coefficient distributions, randomized methods reduce gate counts by up to an order of magnitude. However, this advantage is confined to moderate-precision regimes: as the target error decreases, deterministic methods become more efficient, with a crossover near $\varepsilon \sim 10^{-3}$. Although this regime partially overlaps with quantum chemistry Hamiltonians, realistic systems exhibit additional structure, such as commutation patterns, not captured by our model, which are expected to further favor deterministic approaches.

quant-pharXiv:2604.07448•Apr 10, 2026•3 citations
Hamiltonian simulation is a major application of quantum computing, for example, enabling prediction of the properties of molecules. Prior work has used product formulas with randomization to improve performance, but has only yielded modest improvements over the excellent performance provided by deterministic high-order product formulas. In this work, we provide a randomized scheme that greatly increases the order of product formulas, thereby providing a large advantage over the best-performing deterministic schemes. Our scheme is based on applying randomly chosen corrections to a high-order symmetric product formula. If the original product formula is of order 2k2k2k (so the error is of order 2k+12k+12k+1), then the corrected formula is of order 4k+14k+14k+1, corresponding to a doubling of the order of the error. In practice, applying the corrections in a quantum algorithm requires some structure to the Hamiltonian, for example, the Pauli strings as are commonly used in the simulation of quantum chemistry.
Quantum simulation, the simulation of quantum processes on quantum computers, suggests a path forward for the efficient simulation of problems in condensed-matter physics, quantum chemistry, and materials science. While the majority of quantum simulation algorithms are deterministic, a recent surge of ideas has shown that randomization can greatly benefit algorithmic performance. In this work, we introduce a scheme for quantum simulation that unites the advantages of randomized compiling on the one hand and higher-order multi-product formulas, as they are used for example in linear-combination-of-unitaries (LCU) algorithms or quantum error mitigation, on the other hand. In doing so, we propose a framework of randomized sampling that is expected to be useful for programmable quantum simulators and present two new multi-product formula algorithms tailored to it. Our framework reduces the circuit depth by circumventing the need for oblivious amplitude amplification required by the implementation of multi-product formulas using standard LCU methods, rendering it especially useful for early quantum computers used to estimate the dynamics of quantum systems instead of performing full-fledged quantum phase estimation. Our algorithms achieve a simulation error that shrinks exponentially with the circuit depth. To corroborate their functioning, we prove rigorous performance bounds as well as the concentration of the randomized sampling procedure. We demonstrate the functioning of the approach for several physically meaningful examples of Hamiltonians, including fermionic systems and the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev model, for which the method provides a favorable scaling in the effort.
Quantum phase estimation combined with Hamiltonian simulation is the most promising algorithmic framework to computing ground-state energies on quantum computers. Its main computational overhead derives from the Hamiltonian simulation subroutine. In this paper we use randomization to speed up product formulas, one of the standard approaches to Hamiltonian simulation. We propose partially randomized Hamiltonian simulation methods in which some terms are kept deterministically and others are randomly sampled. We perform a detailed resource estimate for single-ancilla phase estimation using partially randomized product formulas for benchmark systems in quantum chemistry and obtain orders-of-magnitude improvements compared to other simulations based on product formulas. When applied to the hydrogen chain, we have numerical evidence that our methods exhibit asymptotic scaling with the system size that is competitive with the best known qubitization approaches.
Product formulas, also known as Trotter formulas, are among the most widely used and practical methods for simulating quantum systems on quantum computers. Here we introduce two new classes of randomized product formulas for simulating Hamiltonians with separated energy scales, H=A+αBH=A+αBH=A+αB, where ααα is small. In the standard access model, where one can implement exponentials of AAA and BBB separately, our randomized formulas achieve O(α2)\mathcal O(α^2)O(α2) error scaling at the cost of only doubling the gate depth of the corresponding deterministic formula. We further prove an Ω(α)Ω(α)Ω(α) lower bound for deterministic product formulas. In a stronger access model, allowing exponentials of A+αBℓA+αB_\ellA+αBℓ​ for B=∑ℓBℓB = \sum_{\ell}B_\ellB=∑ℓ​Bℓ​, our randomized formula, based on Trotter Heuristic Resource Improved Formulas for Time-dynamics (THRIFT)~[J. L. Bosse et al., Nat. Commun. 16, 2673 (2025)], achieves O(α3)\mathcal O(α^3)O(α3) error scaling with only constant-factor expected gate overhead. We also establish an Ω(α2)Ω(α^2)Ω(α2) lower bound for deterministic product formulas in this access model. Numerical simulations confirm gate-count reductions for simulating physically motivated systems.
Abstract Quantum algorithms for simulation of Hamiltonian evolution are often based on product formulae. The fractal methods give a systematic way to find arbitrarily high-order product formulae, but result in a large number of exponentials. On the other hand, product formulae with fewer exponentials can be found by numerical solution of simultaneous non-linear equations. It is also possible to reduce the cost of long-time simulations by processing, where a kernel is repeated and a processor need only be applied at the beginning and end of the simulation. In this work, we found thousands of new product formulae, and numerically tested these formulae, together with many formulae from prior literature. We provide methods to fairly compare product formulae of different lengths and different orders. For the case of 8th order, we have found new product formulae with exceptional performance, about two orders of magnitude better accuracy than prior work, both in the processed and non-processed cases. The processed product formula provides the best performance due to being shorter than the non-processed product formula. It outperforms all other tested product formulae over a range of many orders of magnitude in system parameters T (time) and ε (allowable error). That includes reasonable combinations of parameters to be used in quantum algorithms, where the size of the simulation is large enough to be classically intractable, but not so large it takes an impractically long time on a quantum computer.
Hamiltonian simulation using product formulas is arguably the most straightforward and practical approach for algorithmic simulation of a quantum system’s dynamics on a quantum computer. Here we present corrected product formulas (CPFs), a variation of product formulas achieved by injecting auxiliary terms called correctors into standard product formulas. We establish several correctors that improve the accuracy of standard product formulas by orders of magnitude when simulating Hamiltonians comprised of two exactly simulatable partitions, a common structure of lattice Hamiltonians. Importantly, injecting these correctors increases the overall simulation cost by only a small additive or multiplicative factor. We show that correctors are particularly advantageous for perturbed systems, where one partition has a relatively small norm compared to the other, as they allow the small norm to be utilized as an additional parameter for controlling the simulation error. We demonstrate the performance of CPFs by numerical simulations for several lattice Hamiltonians. Numerical results show that our theoretical error bounds for CPFs match or outperform the empirical error scaling of standard product formulas for these systems. We also demonstrate improvements offered by CPFs by implementing small-size systems on actual quantum hardware, as well as on noisy and noiseless quantum simulators. CPFs could be a valuable algorithmic tool for early fault-tolerant quantum computers with limited computing resources. As for standard product formulas, CPFs could also be used for simulations on a classical computer.
We study the regimes in which Hamiltonian simulation benefits from randomization. We introduce a sparse-QSVT construction based on composite stochastic decompositions, where dominant terms are treated deterministically and smaller contributions are sampled stochastically. Crucially, we analyze how stochastic and approximation errors propagate through block-encoding and QSVT procedures. To benchmark this approach, we construct ensembles of random Hamiltonians with controlled coefficient dispersion, locality, and number of terms, designed to favor randomization, and therefore providing an upper bound on its practical advantage. For Hamiltonians with many terms and highly inhomogeneous coefficient distributions, randomized methods reduce gate counts by up to an order of magnitude. However, this advantage is confined to moderate-precision regimes: as the target error decreases, deterministic methods become more efficient, with a crossover near ε∼10−3\varepsilon \sim 10^{-3}ε∼10−3. Although this regime partially overlaps with quantum chemistry Hamiltonians, realistic systems exhibit additional structure, such as commutation patterns, not captured by our model, which are expected to further favor deterministic approaches.