Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2210.07235 · Physical Review Letters

Abundance of Hard-Hexagon Crystals in the Quantum Pyrochlore Antiferromagnet

Robin Schäfer, Benedikt Placke, Owen Benton, Roderich Moessner

Published Aug 30, 2023• 22 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a simple family of valence-bond crystals as potential ground states of the S=1/2 and S=1 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the pyrochlore lattice. Exponentially numerous in the linear size of the system, these can be visualized as hard-hexagon coverings, with each hexagon representing a resonating valence-bond ring. This ensemble spontaneously breaks rotation, inversion, and translation symmetries. A simple, yet accurate, variational wave function allows a precise determination of the energy, confirmed by the density matrix renormalization group and numerical linked cluster expansion, and extended by an analysis of excited states. The identification of the origin of the stability indicates applicability to a broad class of frustrated lattices, which we demonstrate for the checkerboard and ruby lattices. Our work suggests a perspective on such quantum magnets, in which unfrustrated motifs are effectively uncoupled by the frustration of their interactions.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.131.096702

Related papers

Closely competing valence bond crystal orders in the ground state of the spin- 1 2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice: A large scale unrestricted variational study

Cheng Rong, Tao Li

The spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice(PAFH) is arguably the most well known strongly frustrated quantum magnet in three spatial dimension. However, due to the rapid scaling of Hilbert space with the linear size of such a three dimensional system, the nature of its ground state in the thermodynamic limit remains elusive after about 30 years' intense debate. Here we apply a recently developed powerful algorithm to perform large scale unrestricted variational optimization of the ground state of the spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ PAFH from the resonating valence bond(RVB) theory perspective. We find a highly competitive candidate ground state of the system. This novel state features a maximally resonating valence bond crystal(VBC) pattern with $2\vec{a}_{1}\times2\vec{a}_{2}\times2\vec{a}_{3}$ periodicity. There are at least four levels of hierarchical structure in such a VBC state, with the first and the second level of hierarchy related to the breaking of the inversion and the translational symmetry. Intriguingly, we find that within the RVB framework such a maximally resonating VBC state is almost degenerate with a recently proposed VBC state that is obtained from dressing hard hexagon covering of the pyrochlore lattice, although they have very different structures. We also find that further symmetry breaking will occur in the dressed hard hexagon VBC state under unrestricted optimization, which results in strong disparity in $\langle \hat{\mathbf{S}}^{2}_{u} \rangle$ for up and down tetrahedrons as we observe in the maximally resonating VBC state. We show that the maximally resonating VBC state found here will be favored by a tiny next-neighboring exchange coupling over the dressed hard hexagon covering VBC state.

arXiv:2509.13746•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 20, 2026•3 citations

Planar pyrochlore: A valence-bond crystal

J.-B. Fouet, Matthieu Mambrini, Philippe Sindzingre +1 more

Exact diagonalizations of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on the checkerboard lattice have been performed for sizes up to $N=36$ in the full Hilbert space and $N=40$ in the restricted subspace of first neighbor dimers. This antiferromagnet does not break SU(2) symmetry and displays long-range order in four-spin $S=0$ plaquettes. Both the symmetry properties of the spectrum and various correlations functions are extensively studied. At variance with the kagom\'e antiferromagnet, the Heisenberg quantum model on a checkerboard lattice is a valence bond crystal. Some results concerning the three-dimensional spin-1/2 pyrochlore magnet (for sizes 16 and 32) are also shown: this system could behave differently from its two-dimensional analog.

arXiv:cond-mat/0108070•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 10, 2003•118 citations

Broken-Symmetry Ground States of the Heisenberg Model on the Pyrochlore Lattice

Nikita Astrakhantsev, Tom Westerhout, Apoorv Tiwari +5 more

The spin-1=2 Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice is an iconic frustrated three-dimensional spin system with a rich phase diagram.Besides hosting several ordered phases, the model is debated to possess a spin-liquid ground state when only nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions are present.Here, we contest this hypothesis with an extensive numerical investigation using both exact diagonalization and complementary variational techniques.Specifically, we employ a resonating-valence-bond-like, manyvariable, Monte Carlo ansatz and convolutional neural network quantum states for (variational) calculations with up to 4 × 4 3 and 4 × 3 3 spins, respectively.We demonstrate that these techniques yield consistent results, allowing for reliable extrapolations to the thermodynamic limit.We consider the ðλ; j 2 =j 1 Þ parameter space, with j 2 , j 1 being nearest and next-to-nearest neighbor interactions and λ the XXZ interaction anisotropy.Our main results are (1) the determination of the phase transition between the putative spin-liquid phase and the neighboring magnetically ordered phase and (2) a careful characterization of the ground state in terms of symmetry-breaking tendencies.We find clear indications of a dimer order with spontaneously broken inversion and rotational symmetry, calling the scenario of a featureless quantum spin liquid into question.Our work showcases how many-variable variational techniques can be used to make progress in answering challenging questions about three-dimensional frustrated quantum magnets.

arXiv:2101.08787•Physical Review X•Oct 29, 2021•102 citations

Frustrating antiferromagnetic exchange interactions enhance specific valence-bond-pair motifs

Xiaoming Zhang, Jin Xu, K. S. D. Beach

We present variational results for the ground state of the antiferromagnetic quantum Heisenberg model with frustrating next-nearest-neighbour interactions. The trial wave functions employed are of resonating-valence-bond type, elaborated to account for various geometric motifs of adjacent bond pairs. The calculation is specialized to a square-lattice cluster consisting of just sixteen sites, large enough that the system can accommodate nontrivial singlet dimer correlations but small enough that exhaustive enumeration of states in the total spin zero sector is still feasible. A symbolic computation approach allows us to generate an algebraic expression for the expectation value of any observable and hence to carry out the energy optimization exactly. While we have no measurements that could unambiguously identify a spin liquid state in the controversial region at intermediate frustration, we can say that the bond-bond correlation factors that emerge do not appear to be consistent with the existence of a columnar valence bond crystal. Furthermore, our results suggest that the magnetically disordered region may accommodate two distinct phases.

arXiv:1310.6030•Oct 22, 2013•5 citations

Singlet Excitations in Pyrochlore: A Study of Quantum Frustration

Erez Berg, Ehud Altman, Assa Auerbach

We apply the contractor renormalization (CORE) method to the spin half Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the frustrated checkerboard and pyrochlore lattices. Their ground states are spin-gapped singlets which break lattice symmetry. Their effective Hamiltonians describe fluctuations of orthogonal singlet pairs on tetrahedral blocks, at an emergent low energy scale. We discuss low temperature thermodynamics and new interpretations of finite size numerical data. We argue that our results are common to many models of quantum frustration.

arXiv:cond-mat/0206384•Physical Review Letters•Apr 10, 2003•118 citations

Dimerization tendencies of the pyrochlore Heisenberg antiferromagnet: A functional renormalization group perspective

Max Hering, Vincent Noculak, Francesco Ferrari +2 more

We investigate the ground-state properties of the spin-$1/2$ pyrochlore Heisenberg antiferromagnet using pseudofermion functional renormalization group techniques. The first part of our analysis is based on an enhanced parton mean-field approach, which takes into account fluctuation effects from renormalized vertex functions. Our implementation of this technique extends earlier approaches and resolves technical difficulties associated with a diagrammatic overcounting. Using various parton ans\"atze for quantum spin liquids, dimerized and nematic states our results indicate a tendency for lattice symmetry breaking in the ground state. While overall quantum spin liquids seem unfavorable in this system, the recently proposed monopole state still shows the strongest support among all spin liquid ans\"atze that we have tested, which is further confirmed by our complementary variational Monte Carlo calculations. In the second part of our investigation, we probe lattice symmetry breaking more directly by applying the pseudofermion functional renormalization group to perturbed systems. Our results from this technique confirm that the system's ground state either exhibits broken ${C}_{3}$ rotation symmetry, or a combination of inversion and ${C}_{3}$ symmetry breaking.

arXiv:2110.08160•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 24, 2022•33 citations
We propose a simple family of valence-bond crystals as potential ground states of the S=1/2 and S=1 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the pyrochlore lattice. Exponentially numerous in the linear size of the system, these can be visualized as hard-hexagon coverings, with each hexagon representing a resonating valence-bond ring. This ensemble spontaneously breaks rotation, inversion, and translation symmetries. A simple, yet accurate, variational wave function allows a precise determination of the energy, confirmed by the density matrix renormalization group and numerical linked cluster expansion, and extended by an analysis of excited states. The identification of the origin of the stability indicates applicability to a broad class of frustrated lattices, which we demonstrate for the checkerboard and ruby lattices. Our work suggests a perspective on such quantum magnets, in which unfrustrated motifs are effectively uncoupled by the frustration of their interactions.
The spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice(PAFH) is arguably the most well known strongly frustrated quantum magnet in three spatial dimension. However, due to the rapid scaling of Hilbert space with the linear size of such a three dimensional system, the nature of its ground state in the thermodynamic limit remains elusive after about 30 years' intense debate. Here we apply a recently developed powerful algorithm to perform large scale unrestricted variational optimization of the ground state of the spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ PAFH from the resonating valence bond(RVB) theory perspective. We find a highly competitive candidate ground state of the system. This novel state features a maximally resonating valence bond crystal(VBC) pattern with 2a⃗1×2a⃗2×2a⃗32\vec{a}_{1}\times2\vec{a}_{2}\times2\vec{a}_{3}2a1​×2a2​×2a3​ periodicity. There are at least four levels of hierarchical structure in such a VBC state, with the first and the second level of hierarchy related to the breaking of the inversion and the translational symmetry. Intriguingly, we find that within the RVB framework such a maximally resonating VBC state is almost degenerate with a recently proposed VBC state that is obtained from dressing hard hexagon covering of the pyrochlore lattice, although they have very different structures. We also find that further symmetry breaking will occur in the dressed hard hexagon VBC state under unrestricted optimization, which results in strong disparity in ⟨S^u2⟩\langle \hat{\mathbf{S}}^{2}_{u} \rangle⟨S^u2​⟩ for up and down tetrahedrons as we observe in the maximally resonating VBC state. We show that the maximally resonating VBC state found here will be favored by a tiny next-neighboring exchange coupling over the dressed hard hexagon covering VBC state.
Exact diagonalizations of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on the checkerboard lattice have been performed for sizes up to N=36N=36N=36 in the full Hilbert space and N=40N=40N=40 in the restricted subspace of first neighbor dimers. This antiferromagnet does not break SU(2) symmetry and displays long-range order in four-spin S=0S=0S=0 plaquettes. Both the symmetry properties of the spectrum and various correlations functions are extensively studied. At variance with the kagom\'e antiferromagnet, the Heisenberg quantum model on a checkerboard lattice is a valence bond crystal. Some results concerning the three-dimensional spin-1/2 pyrochlore magnet (for sizes 16 and 32) are also shown: this system could behave differently from its two-dimensional analog.
The spin-1=2 Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice is an iconic frustrated three-dimensional spin system with a rich phase diagram.Besides hosting several ordered phases, the model is debated to possess a spin-liquid ground state when only nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions are present.Here, we contest this hypothesis with an extensive numerical investigation using both exact diagonalization and complementary variational techniques.Specifically, we employ a resonating-valence-bond-like, manyvariable, Monte Carlo ansatz and convolutional neural network quantum states for (variational) calculations with up to 4 × 4 3 and 4 × 3 3 spins, respectively.We demonstrate that these techniques yield consistent results, allowing for reliable extrapolations to the thermodynamic limit.We consider the ðλ; j 2 =j 1 Þ parameter space, with j 2 , j 1 being nearest and next-to-nearest neighbor interactions and λ the XXZ interaction anisotropy.Our main results are (1) the determination of the phase transition between the putative spin-liquid phase and the neighboring magnetically ordered phase and (2) a careful characterization of the ground state in terms of symmetry-breaking tendencies.We find clear indications of a dimer order with spontaneously broken inversion and rotational symmetry, calling the scenario of a featureless quantum spin liquid into question.Our work showcases how many-variable variational techniques can be used to make progress in answering challenging questions about three-dimensional frustrated quantum magnets.
We present variational results for the ground state of the antiferromagnetic quantum Heisenberg model with frustrating next-nearest-neighbour interactions. The trial wave functions employed are of resonating-valence-bond type, elaborated to account for various geometric motifs of adjacent bond pairs. The calculation is specialized to a square-lattice cluster consisting of just sixteen sites, large enough that the system can accommodate nontrivial singlet dimer correlations but small enough that exhaustive enumeration of states in the total spin zero sector is still feasible. A symbolic computation approach allows us to generate an algebraic expression for the expectation value of any observable and hence to carry out the energy optimization exactly. While we have no measurements that could unambiguously identify a spin liquid state in the controversial region at intermediate frustration, we can say that the bond-bond correlation factors that emerge do not appear to be consistent with the existence of a columnar valence bond crystal. Furthermore, our results suggest that the magnetically disordered region may accommodate two distinct phases.
We apply the contractor renormalization (CORE) method to the spin half Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the frustrated checkerboard and pyrochlore lattices. Their ground states are spin-gapped singlets which break lattice symmetry. Their effective Hamiltonians describe fluctuations of orthogonal singlet pairs on tetrahedral blocks, at an emergent low energy scale. We discuss low temperature thermodynamics and new interpretations of finite size numerical data. We argue that our results are common to many models of quantum frustration.
We investigate the ground-state properties of the spin-1/21/21/2 pyrochlore Heisenberg antiferromagnet using pseudofermion functional renormalization group techniques. The first part of our analysis is based on an enhanced parton mean-field approach, which takes into account fluctuation effects from renormalized vertex functions. Our implementation of this technique extends earlier approaches and resolves technical difficulties associated with a diagrammatic overcounting. Using various parton ans\"atze for quantum spin liquids, dimerized and nematic states our results indicate a tendency for lattice symmetry breaking in the ground state. While overall quantum spin liquids seem unfavorable in this system, the recently proposed monopole state still shows the strongest support among all spin liquid ans\"atze that we have tested, which is further confirmed by our complementary variational Monte Carlo calculations. In the second part of our investigation, we probe lattice symmetry breaking more directly by applying the pseudofermion functional renormalization group to perturbed systems. Our results from this technique confirm that the system's ground state either exhibits broken C3{C}_{3}C3​ rotation symmetry, or a combination of inversion and C3{C}_{3}C3​ symmetry breaking.