Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.06248 · Quantum

Bounding the Minimum Time of a Quantum Measurement

Nathan Shettell, Federico Centrone, Luis Pedro García-Pintos

Published Nov 14, 2023• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Measurements take a singular role in quantum theory. While they are often idealized as an instantaneous process, this is in conflict with all other physical processes in nature. In this Letter, we adopt a standpoint where the interaction with an environment is a crucial ingredient for the occurrence of a measurement. Within this framework, we derive lower bounds on the time needed for a measurement to occur. Our bound scales proportionally to the change in entropy of the measured system, and decreases as the number of of possible measurement outcomes or the interaction strength driving the measurement increases. We evaluate our bound in two examples where the environment is modelled by bosonic modes and the measurement apparatus is modelled by spins or bosons.

DOI
10.22331/q-2023-11-14-1182

Related papers

Universal Lower Bound on Quantum Measurement Timescales

Robin Bisht

The quantum measurement problem the tension between unitary Schrödinger evolution and the projection postulate has been with us since the early days of quantum theory. Here we derive a lower bound on the time required for any quantum measurement, treating the measurement as quantum channel discrimination carried out by the environment. The resulting bound, \tau_{\mathcal{M}} \ge \frac{\ln N}{2\pi\gamma}, relates the measurement time \tau_{\mathcal{M}} to the number of distinguishable outcomes N and the system-environment coupling strength \gamma. It follows from combining a finite channel-capacity limit on information transfer with the thermodynamic cost of erasing information, as set by Landauer's principle. The bound explains why measurements look instantaneous at macroscopic scales while still being bounded away from zero, gives a timescale for the onset of classical objectivity under quantum Darwinism, and yields concrete, testable predictions for weak-measurement experiments in cavity quantum electrodynamics and superconducting circuits.

•Jun 16, 2026•0 citations

THE QUANTUM MEASUREMENT PROBLEM : NATURE OF THE APPARATUS

Anu Venugopalan, Deepak Kumar, Rupamanjari Ghosh

By considering the measurement of a quantum spin by two different models of the measuring apparatus, we try to throw some light on the nature of the apparatus that can perform quantum measurement. Our scheme is to consider a quantum spin in interaction with another quantum system playing the role of an apparatus, which in turn is dissipatively coupled to an environment. The coupling with the environment drives the density matrix of the apparatus to a diagonal form. However, measurement is performed only when the reduced density matrix of the apparatus contains correlations with the states of the spin. The two examples considered here show that this happens when the quantum apparatus has a well-defined classical limit. If the apparatus does not have a well-defined classical limit, the reduced density matrix of the apparatus is not correlated with the states of the measured system.

•Jan 10, 1995•7 citations

Quantum measurements and equilibration: The emergence of objective outcomes via entropy maximization

Emanuel Schwarzhans, Felix C. Binder, Marcus Huber +1 more

The measurement postulate of quantum theory stands in conflict with the laws of thermodynamics and has evoked debate regarding what actually constitutes a measurement. With the help of modern quantum statistical mechanics, we take the first step in formalizing the hypothesis that quantum measurements are driven by the natural tendency of closed systems to maximize entropy, a notion that we call the measurement-equilibration hypothesis. In this paradigm, we investigate how classical measurement outcomes can emerge within a purely unitary framework, and find that (1) the interactions used in standard measurement models fail to spontaneously encode information classically and (2) while ideal projective measurements are impossible, one can (for a given form of Hamiltonian) approximate them exponentially well as more physical systems are collected together into an “observer” system. We thus lay the groundwork for self-contained models of quantum measurement, proposing improvements to our simple scheme.

arXiv:2302.11253•Physical Review Research•Nov 8, 2025•19 citations

Limits on quantum measurement engines

Guillermo Perna, Esteban Calzetta

A quantum measurement involves energy exchanges between the system to be measured and the measuring apparatus. Some of them involve energy losses, for example because energy is dissipated into the environment or is spent in recording the measurement outcome. Moreover, these processes take time. For this reason, these exchanges must be taken into account in the analysis of a quantum measurement engine, and set limits to its efficiency and power. We propose a quantum engine based on a spin 1/2 particle in a magnetic field and study its limitations due to the quantum nature of the evolution. The coupling with the electromagnetic vacuum is taken into account and plays the role of a measurement apparatus. We fully study its dynamics, work, power, and efficiency.

arXiv:2312.08148•Physical review. E•Apr 1, 2024•8 citations

The First Observer in the Room: An Operational Resolution of the Quantum Measurement Problem

Michael Patrick Aiello

The quantum measurement problem persists because physics has never provided an operational definition of "observer" specifying which physical interactions constitute observations. We apply a thermodynamic operational definition developed from a prior observer framework: an observer is any self-maintaining bounded system that reduces entropy through differential environmental processing, where the system's persistence depends on the character of that processing. We distinguish between measurement (any interaction satisfying the definition's first two conditions, producing decoherence that suppresses quantum interference) and observation (an interaction involving a system satisfying all three conditions, producing autonomous, feedback-sustained decoherence). This distinction resolves the observer ambiguity in the canonical measurement-problem thought experiments: it specifies which systems observe, where in any causal chain observation occurs, and why the intuitive placement of the Heisenberg cut at the apparatus is practically correct. The Frauchiger-Renner inconsistency becomes identifiable and addressable once observer status is operationally assigned, because the definition identifies where the domain of unrestricted unitary description must be constrained. The nature of that constraint (collapse, irreversible branching, transaction completion) is interpretation-dependent; the criterion for where it applies is not, though the strength of the resulting resolution varies across interpretations. The definition does not resolve the problem of definite outcomes, derive the Born rule, or select the preferred basis. It resolves the component of the measurement problem that has blocked progress on those questions: the absence of any criterion for which systems perform observations.

•Apr 14, 2026•0 citations

Environment-induced superselection rules

Wojciech Hubert Zurek

We show how the correlations of a quantum system with other quantum systems may cause one of its observables to behave in a classical manner. In particular, "reduction of the wave packet," postulated by von Neumann to explain definiteness of an outcome of an individual observation, can be explained when a realistic model of an apparatus is adopted. Instead of an isolated quantum apparatus with a number of states equal to the number of possible distinct outcomes of the measurement, discussed by von Neumann, we consider an apparatus interacting with other physical systems, described here summarily as "environment." The interaction of the quantum apparatus with the environment results in correlations. Correlations impose effective superselection rules which prevent apparatus from appearing in a superposition of states corresponding to different eigenvalues of the privileged pointer observable. It is the propagation of the correlations with the pointer basis states which is ultimately responsible for the choice of the pointer observable. It can be thought of as a process of amplification in which the state of many distinct physical systems becomes correlated with the pointer basis state. Whether these environment systems are regarded as a part of the apparatus setup, or as a part of its environment is irrelevant. What is crucial is the redundancy of the record concerning the pointer observable which is imprinted into the correlations. Eigenspaces of the pointer observable provide a natural basis for the pointer of the quantum apparatus and determine the to-be-measured observable of the quantum system. Decay of those elements of the apparatus-system density matrix, which are off-diagonal in the pointer observable, is caused by the natural evolution of the combined system-apparatus-environment object. For a hypothetical finite environment with $N$ distinct eigenvalues of the apparatus-environment interaction Hamiltonian, off-diagonal terms will decay to become of the order of ${N}^{\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}}$, and will recur only on a Poincar\'e time scale. No recurrences will be observed in realistic circumstances. As the correlations spread through the environment on a time scale typically much shorter than the recurrence time scale calculated for the environment already correlated with the pointer observable, the measurement becomes effectively irreversible. Relevance of this model of the measurement process for the understanding of the second law of thermodynamics and its relation to Bohr's "irreversible act of amplification" is briefly discussed. The emergence of the pointer observable can be interpreted as a clue about the resolution of the measurement problem in case of no environment. It points towards the possibility that properties of quantum systems have no absolute meaning. Rather, they must be always characterized with respect to other physical systems.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Oct 15, 1982•1,413 citations
Measurements take a singular role in quantum theory. While they are often idealized as an instantaneous process, this is in conflict with all other physical processes in nature. In this Letter, we adopt a standpoint where the interaction with an environment is a crucial ingredient for the occurrence of a measurement. Within this framework, we derive lower bounds on the time needed for a measurement to occur. Our bound scales proportionally to the change in entropy of the measured system, and decreases as the number of of possible measurement outcomes or the interaction strength driving the measurement increases. We evaluate our bound in two examples where the environment is modelled by bosonic modes and the measurement apparatus is modelled by spins or bosons.
The quantum measurement problem the tension between unitary Schrödinger evolution and the projection postulate has been with us since the early days of quantum theory. Here we derive a lower bound on the time required for any quantum measurement, treating the measurement as quantum channel discrimination carried out by the environment. The resulting bound, \tau_{\mathcal{M}} \ge \frac{\ln N}{2\pi\gamma}, relates the measurement time \tau_{\mathcal{M}} to the number of distinguishable outcomes N and the system-environment coupling strength \gamma. It follows from combining a finite channel-capacity limit on information transfer with the thermodynamic cost of erasing information, as set by Landauer's principle. The bound explains why measurements look instantaneous at macroscopic scales while still being bounded away from zero, gives a timescale for the onset of classical objectivity under quantum Darwinism, and yields concrete, testable predictions for weak-measurement experiments in cavity quantum electrodynamics and superconducting circuits.
By considering the measurement of a quantum spin by two different models of the measuring apparatus, we try to throw some light on the nature of the apparatus that can perform quantum measurement. Our scheme is to consider a quantum spin in interaction with another quantum system playing the role of an apparatus, which in turn is dissipatively coupled to an environment. The coupling with the environment drives the density matrix of the apparatus to a diagonal form. However, measurement is performed only when the reduced density matrix of the apparatus contains correlations with the states of the spin. The two examples considered here show that this happens when the quantum apparatus has a well-defined classical limit. If the apparatus does not have a well-defined classical limit, the reduced density matrix of the apparatus is not correlated with the states of the measured system.
The measurement postulate of quantum theory stands in conflict with the laws of thermodynamics and has evoked debate regarding what actually constitutes a measurement. With the help of modern quantum statistical mechanics, we take the first step in formalizing the hypothesis that quantum measurements are driven by the natural tendency of closed systems to maximize entropy, a notion that we call the measurement-equilibration hypothesis. In this paradigm, we investigate how classical measurement outcomes can emerge within a purely unitary framework, and find that (1) the interactions used in standard measurement models fail to spontaneously encode information classically and (2) while ideal projective measurements are impossible, one can (for a given form of Hamiltonian) approximate them exponentially well as more physical systems are collected together into an “observer” system. We thus lay the groundwork for self-contained models of quantum measurement, proposing improvements to our simple scheme.
A quantum measurement involves energy exchanges between the system to be measured and the measuring apparatus. Some of them involve energy losses, for example because energy is dissipated into the environment or is spent in recording the measurement outcome. Moreover, these processes take time. For this reason, these exchanges must be taken into account in the analysis of a quantum measurement engine, and set limits to its efficiency and power. We propose a quantum engine based on a spin 1/2 particle in a magnetic field and study its limitations due to the quantum nature of the evolution. The coupling with the electromagnetic vacuum is taken into account and plays the role of a measurement apparatus. We fully study its dynamics, work, power, and efficiency.
The quantum measurement problem persists because physics has never provided an operational definition of "observer" specifying which physical interactions constitute observations. We apply a thermodynamic operational definition developed from a prior observer framework: an observer is any self-maintaining bounded system that reduces entropy through differential environmental processing, where the system's persistence depends on the character of that processing. We distinguish between measurement (any interaction satisfying the definition's first two conditions, producing decoherence that suppresses quantum interference) and observation (an interaction involving a system satisfying all three conditions, producing autonomous, feedback-sustained decoherence). This distinction resolves the observer ambiguity in the canonical measurement-problem thought experiments: it specifies which systems observe, where in any causal chain observation occurs, and why the intuitive placement of the Heisenberg cut at the apparatus is practically correct. The Frauchiger-Renner inconsistency becomes identifiable and addressable once observer status is operationally assigned, because the definition identifies where the domain of unrestricted unitary description must be constrained. The nature of that constraint (collapse, irreversible branching, transaction completion) is interpretation-dependent; the criterion for where it applies is not, though the strength of the resulting resolution varies across interpretations. The definition does not resolve the problem of definite outcomes, derive the Born rule, or select the preferred basis. It resolves the component of the measurement problem that has blocked progress on those questions: the absence of any criterion for which systems perform observations.
We show how the correlations of a quantum system with other quantum systems may cause one of its observables to behave in a classical manner. In particular, "reduction of the wave packet," postulated by von Neumann to explain definiteness of an outcome of an individual observation, can be explained when a realistic model of an apparatus is adopted. Instead of an isolated quantum apparatus with a number of states equal to the number of possible distinct outcomes of the measurement, discussed by von Neumann, we consider an apparatus interacting with other physical systems, described here summarily as "environment." The interaction of the quantum apparatus with the environment results in correlations. Correlations impose effective superselection rules which prevent apparatus from appearing in a superposition of states corresponding to different eigenvalues of the privileged pointer observable. It is the propagation of the correlations with the pointer basis states which is ultimately responsible for the choice of the pointer observable. It can be thought of as a process of amplification in which the state of many distinct physical systems becomes correlated with the pointer basis state. Whether these environment systems are regarded as a part of the apparatus setup, or as a part of its environment is irrelevant. What is crucial is the redundancy of the record concerning the pointer observable which is imprinted into the correlations. Eigenspaces of the pointer observable provide a natural basis for the pointer of the quantum apparatus and determine the to-be-measured observable of the quantum system. Decay of those elements of the apparatus-system density matrix, which are off-diagonal in the pointer observable, is caused by the natural evolution of the combined system-apparatus-environment object. For a hypothetical finite environment with NNN distinct eigenvalues of the apparatus-environment interaction Hamiltonian, off-diagonal terms will decay to become of the order of ${N}^{\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}}$, and will recur only on a Poincar\'e time scale. No recurrences will be observed in realistic circumstances. As the correlations spread through the environment on a time scale typically much shorter than the recurrence time scale calculated for the environment already correlated with the pointer observable, the measurement becomes effectively irreversible. Relevance of this model of the measurement process for the understanding of the second law of thermodynamics and its relation to Bohr's "irreversible act of amplification" is briefly discussed. The emergence of the pointer observable can be interpreted as a clue about the resolution of the measurement problem in case of no environment. It points towards the possibility that properties of quantum systems have no absolute meaning. Rather, they must be always characterized with respect to other physical systems.