Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.02587

Is there truly classical information?

Andrei T. Patrascu

Published Aug 4, 2022• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

All entropy is entanglement entropy. This appears as the result of the existence of black holes. The origin of entropy and the way in which it defines the perceived time direction in macroscopic systems has been discussed and can be debated as long as one ignores black holes. In such a case, thermodynamic entropy may define the arrow of time and entanglement entropy defines some special globally defined entropy encoding information in a non-local sense. With black holes however, if we accept that in-falling objects must have their information encoded outside, for example through non-local fluctuations away from thermalisation of the Hawking radiation, and that the horizon of a black hole cuts all classical information from the outside, then all the entropy that can be added to the black hole, which is basically any form of entropy, must be translated into some form of entanglement entropy to be detected outside. A discussion about the nature of information channels shows that spacetime may not be a correlation-insensitive channel as usually employed in the engineering of quantum computing. Time may emerge as a property of the complexity of entanglement spreading.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2209.02587

Related papers

Quantum entanglement and Hawking temperature

S. Santhosh Kumar, S. Shankaranarayanan

The thermodynamic entropy of an isolated system is given by its von Neumann entropy. Over the last few years, there has been an intense activity to understand the thermodynamic entropy from the principles of quantum mechanics. More specifically, is there a relation between the (von Neumann) entropy of entanglement between a system and some (separate) environment and the thermodynamic entropy? It is difficult to obtain the relation for many body systems, hence, most of the work in the literature has focused on small number systems. In this work, we consider black holes—which are simple yet macroscopic systems—and show that a direct connection could not be made between the entropy of entanglement and the Hawking temperature. In this work, within the adiabatic approximation, we explicitly show that the Hawking temperature is indeed given by the rate of change of the entropy of entanglement across a black hole’s horizon with regard to the system energy. This is yet other numerical evidence leading to understanding the key features of black-hole thermodynamics from the viewpoint of quantum information theory.

arXiv:1504.00501•The European Physical Journal C•Jul 1, 2016•9 citations

The black hole information puzzle and the quantum de Finetti theorem

Renato Renner, Jinzhao Wang

The black hole information puzzle arises from a discrepancy between conclusions drawn from general relativity and quantum theory about the nature of the radiation emitted by a black hole. According to Hawking's original argument, the radiation is thermal and its entropy thus increases monotonically as the black hole evaporates. Conversely, due to the reversibility of time evolution according to quantum theory, the radiation entropy should start to decrease after a certain time, as predicted by the Page curve. This decrease has been confirmed by new calculations based on the replica trick, which also exhibit its geometrical origin: spacetime wormholes that form between the replicas. Here we analyse the discrepancy between these and Hawking's original conclusions from a quantum information theory viewpoint, using in particular the quantum de Finetti theorem. The theorem implies the existence of extra information, $W$, which is neither part of the black hole nor the radiation, but plays the role of a reference. The entropy obtained via the replica trick can then be identified to be the entropy $S(R|W)$ of the radiation conditioned on the reference $W$, whereas Hawking's original result corresponds to the non-conditional entropy $S(R)$. The entropy $S(R|W)$, which mathematically is an ensemble average, gains an operational meaning in an experiment with $N$ independently prepared black holes: For large $N$, it equals the normalised entropy of their joint radiation, $S(R_1 \cdots R_N)/N$. The discrepancy between this entropy and $S(R)$ implies that the black holes are correlated. The replica wormholes may thus be interpreted as the geometrical representation of this correlation. Our results also suggest a many-black-hole extension of the widely used random unitary model, which we support with non-trivial checks.

arXiv:2110.14653•Oct 27, 2021•25 citations

The Topological Page Curve and Fast Scrambling of Information in QGEFT Black Holes

Yaniv Cohen

The black-hole information paradox is usually formulated as a conflict between two semiclassical statements: Hawking evaporation appears to radiate away mass in a nearly thermal manner, while unitary quantum dynamics forbids the destruction of information. In this paper we construct a macroscopic black-hole surrogate inside the discrete, background-free Quantum Graph Emergent Field Theory (QGEFT) and track both horizon-entanglement proxies and the topological fate of explicitly injected information. Starting from a thermalized Unified Phase 3 universe with N = 1024 sites, we force a localized geometric collapse by driving one node to target degree k = 160, then inject a structured quark-like defect whose internal edges are tracked exactly through 100 subsequent Monte Carlo sweeps. The key observable is a horizon cut-size proxy: the number of edges crossing between the black-hole region and the exterior vacuum, together with a normalized entanglement proxy built from that cut. In the present benchmark the horizon cut-size rises from 1027 to a peak of 1030 edges at sweep 1, while the normalized cut-based entanglement proxy rises from 2.7483 to 2.7563, then trends downward with fluctuations to 2.5941 by sweep 100 as the black-hole core shrinks from degree 161 to 132. At the same time, direct tracking of the infalling quark reveals incomplete local reconstruction: only 25% of the tracked edges appear outside the horizon as distinct edges at any given sampled frame, and the best structural-overlap score reaches only 0.3946. The narrow conclusion supported by the current data is therefore mixed. The black hole exhibits a real topological evaporation channel and a measurable Page-like turnover in the horizon entanglement proxy, but local observables remain Hawking-leaning and do not by themselves recover the full infalling structure. In the QGEFT interpretation, this is evidence for fast scrambling rather than literal information destruction: the information is not recovered as a small intact motif, but is dispersed into the global topological microstate of the graph.

•May 15, 2026•0 citations

Can the entanglement entropy be the origin of black-hole entropy?

Shinji Mukohyama A, Masafumi Seriu, Hideo Kodama

Entanglement entropy is often speculated as a strong candidate for the origin of black-hole entropy. To judge whether or not this speculation is true, it is effective to investigate the whole structure of thermodynamics obtained from the entanglement entropy, rather than just to examine the apparent structure of the entropy alone or to compare it with that of black-hole entropy. This is because entropy acquires a physical significance only when it is related to the energy and the temperature of a system. From this point of view, we construct a ``thermodynamics of entanglement'' by introducing an entanglement energy and compare it with black-hole thermodynamics. We consider two possible definitions of entanglement energy. Then we construct two different kinds of thermodynamics by combining each of these different definitions of entanglement energy with the entanglement entropy. We find that both of these two kinds of thermodynamics show significant differences from black-hole thermodynamics if no gravitational effects are taken into account. These differences are, in particular, highlighted in the context of the third law of thermodynamics. Finally we see how the inclusion of gravity alters the thermodynamics of the entanglement. We give a suggestive argument that the thermodynamics of the entanglement behaves like black-hole thermodynamics if the gravitational effects are included properly. Thus the entanglement entropy passes a nontrivial check to be the origin of black-hole entropy.

arXiv:gr-qc/9701059•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 15, 1997•41 citations

Black Holes, Information Loss, and Hidden Variables

Antony Valentini

We consider black-hole evaporation from a hidden-variables perspective. It is suggested that Hawking information loss, associated with the transition from a pure to a mixed quantum state, is compensated for by the creation of deviations from Born-rule probabilities outside the event horizon. The resulting states have non-standard or 'nonequilibrium' distributions of hidden variables, with a specific observable signature - a breakdown of the sinusoidal modulation of quantum probabilities for two-state systems. Outgoing Hawking radiation is predicted to contain statistical anomalies outside the domain of the quantum formalism. Further, it is argued that even for a macroscopic black hole, if one half of an entangled EPR-pair should fall behind the event horizon, the other half will develop similar statistical anomalies. We propose a simple rule, whereby the relative entropy of the nonequilibrum (hidden-variable) distribution generated outside the horizon balances the increase in von Neumann entropy associated with the pure-to-mixed transition. It is argued that there are relationships between hidden-variable and von Neumann entropies even in non-gravitational physics. We consider the possibility of observing anomalous polarisation probabilities, in the radiation from primordial black holes, and in the atomic cascade emission of entangled photon pairs from black-hole accretion discs.

arXiv:hep-th/0407032•Jul 6, 2004•35 citations

Quantum Information Entanglement of Consciousness and Space-Time

Francisco Di Biase

Bekenstein and Hawking show black holes have temperature and entropy. Susskind studies (2008) discovered a relationship between entropy, and area as a consequence of entanglement. Atlan and Di Biase have been proposing to see entropy as the information and complexity content of a system, and Susskind developed a mathematic to calculate the information content of an object. He could quantize space-time and develop a quantum theory of gravity that is holographic. Jacobson shows that entropy multiplied by temperature is the energy of a system and a simple energy - entropy relationship can relate mass energy space-time and quantum information theory. Maldacena could demonstrate that wormholes would only form if blackholes were quantum-entangled in the outsides a revolutionary conclusion that suggests entanglement is what binds space-time together! Di Biase have been conjecturing that consciousness is non-local quantum information with a status equal to energy, matter, energy and space-time, and Wheeler described an elegant information-participatory universe putting together quantum information theory consciousness and physics with ‘the it from bit’ concept. For Bohm, the superimplicate order allows us to understanding consciousness, energy and matter as expression varieties of a same informational order. Pribram’s neural network equation is similar to Schrödinger’s wave equation and permits as I show an elegant and beautiful holoinformational brain-mind entanglement with the quantum-holographic universe that I see as an extended holoinformational universal consciousness interconnectedness.

•Dec 28, 2017•0 citations
All entropy is entanglement entropy. This appears as the result of the existence of black holes. The origin of entropy and the way in which it defines the perceived time direction in macroscopic systems has been discussed and can be debated as long as one ignores black holes. In such a case, thermodynamic entropy may define the arrow of time and entanglement entropy defines some special globally defined entropy encoding information in a non-local sense. With black holes however, if we accept that in-falling objects must have their information encoded outside, for example through non-local fluctuations away from thermalisation of the Hawking radiation, and that the horizon of a black hole cuts all classical information from the outside, then all the entropy that can be added to the black hole, which is basically any form of entropy, must be translated into some form of entanglement entropy to be detected outside. A discussion about the nature of information channels shows that spacetime may not be a correlation-insensitive channel as usually employed in the engineering of quantum computing. Time may emerge as a property of the complexity of entanglement spreading.
The thermodynamic entropy of an isolated system is given by its von Neumann entropy. Over the last few years, there has been an intense activity to understand the thermodynamic entropy from the principles of quantum mechanics. More specifically, is there a relation between the (von Neumann) entropy of entanglement between a system and some (separate) environment and the thermodynamic entropy? It is difficult to obtain the relation for many body systems, hence, most of the work in the literature has focused on small number systems. In this work, we consider black holes—which are simple yet macroscopic systems—and show that a direct connection could not be made between the entropy of entanglement and the Hawking temperature. In this work, within the adiabatic approximation, we explicitly show that the Hawking temperature is indeed given by the rate of change of the entropy of entanglement across a black hole’s horizon with regard to the system energy. This is yet other numerical evidence leading to understanding the key features of black-hole thermodynamics from the viewpoint of quantum information theory.
The black hole information puzzle arises from a discrepancy between conclusions drawn from general relativity and quantum theory about the nature of the radiation emitted by a black hole. According to Hawking's original argument, the radiation is thermal and its entropy thus increases monotonically as the black hole evaporates. Conversely, due to the reversibility of time evolution according to quantum theory, the radiation entropy should start to decrease after a certain time, as predicted by the Page curve. This decrease has been confirmed by new calculations based on the replica trick, which also exhibit its geometrical origin: spacetime wormholes that form between the replicas. Here we analyse the discrepancy between these and Hawking's original conclusions from a quantum information theory viewpoint, using in particular the quantum de Finetti theorem. The theorem implies the existence of extra information, WWW, which is neither part of the black hole nor the radiation, but plays the role of a reference. The entropy obtained via the replica trick can then be identified to be the entropy S(R∣W)S(R|W)S(R∣W) of the radiation conditioned on the reference WWW, whereas Hawking's original result corresponds to the non-conditional entropy S(R)S(R)S(R). The entropy S(R∣W)S(R|W)S(R∣W), which mathematically is an ensemble average, gains an operational meaning in an experiment with NNN independently prepared black holes: For large NNN, it equals the normalised entropy of their joint radiation, S(R1⋯RN)/NS(R_1 \cdots R_N)/NS(R1​⋯RN​)/N. The discrepancy between this entropy and S(R)S(R)S(R) implies that the black holes are correlated. The replica wormholes may thus be interpreted as the geometrical representation of this correlation. Our results also suggest a many-black-hole extension of the widely used random unitary model, which we support with non-trivial checks.
The black-hole information paradox is usually formulated as a conflict between two semiclassical statements: Hawking evaporation appears to radiate away mass in a nearly thermal manner, while unitary quantum dynamics forbids the destruction of information. In this paper we construct a macroscopic black-hole surrogate inside the discrete, background-free Quantum Graph Emergent Field Theory (QGEFT) and track both horizon-entanglement proxies and the topological fate of explicitly injected information. Starting from a thermalized Unified Phase 3 universe with N = 1024 sites, we force a localized geometric collapse by driving one node to target degree k = 160, then inject a structured quark-like defect whose internal edges are tracked exactly through 100 subsequent Monte Carlo sweeps. The key observable is a horizon cut-size proxy: the number of edges crossing between the black-hole region and the exterior vacuum, together with a normalized entanglement proxy built from that cut. In the present benchmark the horizon cut-size rises from 1027 to a peak of 1030 edges at sweep 1, while the normalized cut-based entanglement proxy rises from 2.7483 to 2.7563, then trends downward with fluctuations to 2.5941 by sweep 100 as the black-hole core shrinks from degree 161 to 132. At the same time, direct tracking of the infalling quark reveals incomplete local reconstruction: only 25% of the tracked edges appear outside the horizon as distinct edges at any given sampled frame, and the best structural-overlap score reaches only 0.3946. The narrow conclusion supported by the current data is therefore mixed. The black hole exhibits a real topological evaporation channel and a measurable Page-like turnover in the horizon entanglement proxy, but local observables remain Hawking-leaning and do not by themselves recover the full infalling structure. In the QGEFT interpretation, this is evidence for fast scrambling rather than literal information destruction: the information is not recovered as a small intact motif, but is dispersed into the global topological microstate of the graph.
Entanglement entropy is often speculated as a strong candidate for the origin of black-hole entropy. To judge whether or not this speculation is true, it is effective to investigate the whole structure of thermodynamics obtained from the entanglement entropy, rather than just to examine the apparent structure of the entropy alone or to compare it with that of black-hole entropy. This is because entropy acquires a physical significance only when it is related to the energy and the temperature of a system. From this point of view, we construct a ``thermodynamics of entanglement'' by introducing an entanglement energy and compare it with black-hole thermodynamics. We consider two possible definitions of entanglement energy. Then we construct two different kinds of thermodynamics by combining each of these different definitions of entanglement energy with the entanglement entropy. We find that both of these two kinds of thermodynamics show significant differences from black-hole thermodynamics if no gravitational effects are taken into account. These differences are, in particular, highlighted in the context of the third law of thermodynamics. Finally we see how the inclusion of gravity alters the thermodynamics of the entanglement. We give a suggestive argument that the thermodynamics of the entanglement behaves like black-hole thermodynamics if the gravitational effects are included properly. Thus the entanglement entropy passes a nontrivial check to be the origin of black-hole entropy.
We consider black-hole evaporation from a hidden-variables perspective. It is suggested that Hawking information loss, associated with the transition from a pure to a mixed quantum state, is compensated for by the creation of deviations from Born-rule probabilities outside the event horizon. The resulting states have non-standard or 'nonequilibrium' distributions of hidden variables, with a specific observable signature - a breakdown of the sinusoidal modulation of quantum probabilities for two-state systems. Outgoing Hawking radiation is predicted to contain statistical anomalies outside the domain of the quantum formalism. Further, it is argued that even for a macroscopic black hole, if one half of an entangled EPR-pair should fall behind the event horizon, the other half will develop similar statistical anomalies. We propose a simple rule, whereby the relative entropy of the nonequilibrum (hidden-variable) distribution generated outside the horizon balances the increase in von Neumann entropy associated with the pure-to-mixed transition. It is argued that there are relationships between hidden-variable and von Neumann entropies even in non-gravitational physics. We consider the possibility of observing anomalous polarisation probabilities, in the radiation from primordial black holes, and in the atomic cascade emission of entangled photon pairs from black-hole accretion discs.
Bekenstein and Hawking show black holes have temperature and entropy. Susskind studies (2008) discovered a relationship between entropy, and area as a consequence of entanglement. Atlan and Di Biase have been proposing to see entropy as the information and complexity content of a system, and Susskind developed a mathematic to calculate the information content of an object. He could quantize space-time and develop a quantum theory of gravity that is holographic. Jacobson shows that entropy multiplied by temperature is the energy of a system and a simple energy - entropy relationship can relate mass energy space-time and quantum information theory. Maldacena could demonstrate that wormholes would only form if blackholes were quantum-entangled in the outsides a revolutionary conclusion that suggests entanglement is what binds space-time together! Di Biase have been conjecturing that consciousness is non-local quantum information with a status equal to energy, matter, energy and space-time, and Wheeler described an elegant information-participatory universe putting together quantum information theory consciousness and physics with ‘the it from bit’ concept. For Bohm, the superimplicate order allows us to understanding consciousness, energy and matter as expression varieties of a same informational order. Pribram’s neural network equation is similar to Schrödinger’s wave equation and permits as I show an elegant and beautiful holoinformational brain-mind entanglement with the quantum-holographic universe that I see as an extended holoinformational universal consciousness interconnectedness.