Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.00918 · Physical Review A

Optical interpretation of linear-optics superradiance and subradiance

Stephan Asselie, A. Cipris, William Guerin

Published Dec 19, 2022• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Super- and subradiance are usually described in the framework of Dicke collective states, which is an ``atomic picture'' in which the electromagnetic field only provides an effective interaction between the atoms. Here, we discuss a complementary picture, in which we describe the propagation and scattering of light in the atomic medium, which provides a complex susceptibility and scatterers. This ``optical picture'' is valid in the linear-optics regime for disordered samples and is mainly relevant at low density, when the susceptibility and scattering cross section can be computed from simple textbook formulas. In this picture, superradiance is a dispersion effect due to a single scattering event dressed by an effective refractive index, whereas subradiance is due to multiple scattering. We present numerical and experimental data supporting our interpretation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.106.063712

Related papers

Superradiance as single scattering embedded in an effective medium

P. Weiss, A. Cipris, Robin Kaiser +2 more

We present an optical picture of linear-optics superradiance, based on a single scattering event embedded in a dispersive effective medium composed by the other atoms. This linear-dispersion theory is valid at low density and in the single-scattering regime, i.e., when the exciting field is largely detuned. The comparison with the coupled-dipole model shows a perfect agreement for the superradiant decay rate. Then we use two advantages of this approach. First we make a direct comparison with experimental data, without any free parameter, and show a good quantitative agreement. Second, we address the problem of moving atoms, which can be efficiently simulated by adding the Doppler broadening to the theory. In particular, we discuss how to recover superradiance at high temperature.

arXiv:2011.05201•Physical Review A•Feb 3, 2021•17 citations

Light interacting with atomic ensembles: collective, cooperative and mesoscopic effects

William Guerin, Mohamed Taha Rouabah, Robin Kaiser

Cooperative scattering has been the subject of intense research in the last years. In this article, we discuss the concept of cooperative scattering from a broad perspective. We briefly review the various collective effects that occur when light interacts with an ensemble of atoms. We show that some effects that have been recently discussed in the context of ‘single-photon superradiance’, or cooperative scattering in the linear-optics regime, can also be explained by ‘standard optics’, i.e. using macroscopic quantities such as the susceptibility or the diffusion coefficient. We explain why some collective effects depend on the atomic density, and others on the optical depth. In particular, we show that, for a large and dilute atomic sample driven by a far-detuned laser, the decay of the fluorescence, which exhibits superradiant and subradiant dynamics, depends only on the on-resonance optical depth. We also discuss the link between concepts that are independently studied in the quantum-optics community and in the mesoscopic-physics community. We show that the coupled-dipole model predicts a departure from Ohm’s law for the diffuse light, that incoherent multiple scattering can induce a saturation of fluorescence and we also show the similarity between the weak-localization correction to the diffusion coefficient and the inaccuracy of Lorentz local field correction to the susceptibility.

arXiv:1605.02439•Journal of Modern Optics•Aug 5, 2016•134 citations

Subradiance in dilute atomic ensembles: Role of pairs and multiple scattering

Y. A. Fofanov, I. M. Sokolov, Robin Kaiser +1 more

We study numerically the slow (subradiant) decay of the fluorescence of motionless atoms after a weak pulsed excitation. We show that, in the linear-optics regime and for an excitation detuned by several natural linewidths, the slow decay rate can be dominated by close pairs of atoms (dimers) forming superradiant and subradiant states. However, for a large-enough resonant optical depth and at later time, the dynamics is dominated by collective many-body effects. In this regime, we study the polarization and the spectrum of the emitted light, as well as the spatial distribution of excitation inside the sample, as a function of time during the decay dynamics. The behavior of these observables is consistent with what would be expected for radiation trapping of nearly resonant light. This finding sheds light on subradiance in dilute samples by providing an interpretation based on the light behavior of the system (multiple scattering) which is complementary to the more commonly used picture of the collective atomic Dicke state.

arXiv:2012.10659•Physical Review A•Aug 9, 2021•21 citations

Population of collective modes in light scattering by many atoms

William Guerin, Robin Kaiser

The interaction of light with an atomic sample containing a large number of particles gives rise to many collective (or cooperative) effects, such as multiple scattering, superradiance, and subradiance, even if the atomic density is low and the incident optical intensity weak (linear optics regime). Tracing over the degrees of freedom of the light field, the system can be well described by an effective atomic Hamiltonian, which contains the light-mediated dipole-dipole interaction between atoms. This long-range interaction is at the origin of the various collective effects, or of collective excitation modes of the system. Even though an analysis of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of these collective modes does allow distinguishing superradiant modes, for instance, from other collective modes, this is not sufficient to understand the dynamics of a driven system, as not all collective modes are significantly populated. Here, we study how the excitation parameters, i.e., the driving field, determines the population of the collective modes. We investigate in particular the role of the laser detuning from the atomic transition, and demonstrate a simple relation between the detuning and the steady-state population of the modes. This relation allows understanding several properties of cooperative scattering, such as why superradiance and subradiance become independent of the detuning at large enough detuning without vanishing, and why superradiance, but not subradiance, is suppressed near resonance. We also show that the spatial properties of the collective modes allow distinguishing diffusive modes, responsible for radiation trapping, from subradiant modes.

arXiv:1702.01053•Physical Review A•May 26, 2017•34 citations

Role of disorder in super- and subradiance of cold atomic clouds

Florent Cottier, Robin Kaiser, Romain Bachelard

The presence of superradiance and subradiance in microscopic and mean-field approaches to light scattering in atomic media is investigated. We show that these phenomena are present in both descriptions, with only minor quantitative differences, so neither rely on disorder. In particular, they are most prominent in media with high resonant optical depth yet far-detuned light, i.e., in the single-scattering regime.

arXiv:1804.01923•Physical Review A•Jul 20, 2018•46 citations

Superradiance and Topological Quantum Optics in Atomic Medium and Cavity QED

Han Cai

In this dissertation we focused on two topics: 1. atomic cooperative effect, including superradiance, subradiance and collective Lamb shift in an atomic ensemble; 2. novel topological effect in quantum optics system, such as Haldane model, synthetic magnetic field in superradiance lattice and synthetic spin-orbit interaction in Fock-state lattices. \n\nIn the first part, we start from the Dicke state, an N-particle atomic ensemble excited by a single photon. Due to the interaction of the atoms with a continuum of vacuum modes, the Dicke state has a larger decay rate compared with an isolated atom, termed the single photon superradiance. In the “opposite” case, the single-photon subradiance state does not decay because of the destructive interference of the atomic transitions. We study the protection of subradiant states by the symmetry of the atomic distributions in the Dicke limit, in which collective Lamb shifts cannot be neglected. We find that antisymmetric states are subradiant states for distributions with reflection symmetry. Continuous symmetry can also be used to achieve subradiance in an extended ensemble. This study is relevant to the problem of robust quantum memory with long storage time and fast readout.\n\nIn the second part, we start from introducing the concepts, methods, and models from quantum optics or condensed matter physics. They include the timed-Dicke states, electromagnetically induced transparency, coupled wave equations, tight-binding model, band theory, Floquet theory, superradiance lattice, integer quantum Hall effect, Haldane model, etc.. Based upon these tools, we study three topological quantum optics systems: (i) a Haldane model with in situ tunable topological properties in a two-dimensional momentumspace superradiance lattice composed of timed Dicke states in electromagnetically induced transparency; (ii) a spin-orbit coupled Fock-state lattice, which introduce a novel quantum operation to generate mesoscopic superposition states, e.g., the NOON states and cat states; (iii) a synthetic magnetic field created in a quasi one dimensional superradiance lattice, which is predicted to be observed in thermal vapours of alkali atoms instead of only in cold atoms (as in previous experiments). This study aims to provide a novel, highly tunable platform simulating exotic phenomena in condensed matter physics and offers a basis of topological quantum optics and novel photonic devices.

•Dec 8, 2017•0 citations
Super- and subradiance are usually described in the framework of Dicke collective states, which is an atomic picture'' in which the electromagnetic field only provides an effective interaction between the atoms. Here, we discuss a complementary picture, in which we describe the propagation and scattering of light in the atomic medium, which provides a complex susceptibility and scatterers. This optical picture'' is valid in the linear-optics regime for disordered samples and is mainly relevant at low density, when the susceptibility and scattering cross section can be computed from simple textbook formulas. In this picture, superradiance is a dispersion effect due to a single scattering event dressed by an effective refractive index, whereas subradiance is due to multiple scattering. We present numerical and experimental data supporting our interpretation.
We present an optical picture of linear-optics superradiance, based on a single scattering event embedded in a dispersive effective medium composed by the other atoms. This linear-dispersion theory is valid at low density and in the single-scattering regime, i.e., when the exciting field is largely detuned. The comparison with the coupled-dipole model shows a perfect agreement for the superradiant decay rate. Then we use two advantages of this approach. First we make a direct comparison with experimental data, without any free parameter, and show a good quantitative agreement. Second, we address the problem of moving atoms, which can be efficiently simulated by adding the Doppler broadening to the theory. In particular, we discuss how to recover superradiance at high temperature.
Cooperative scattering has been the subject of intense research in the last years. In this article, we discuss the concept of cooperative scattering from a broad perspective. We briefly review the various collective effects that occur when light interacts with an ensemble of atoms. We show that some effects that have been recently discussed in the context of ‘single-photon superradiance’, or cooperative scattering in the linear-optics regime, can also be explained by ‘standard optics’, i.e. using macroscopic quantities such as the susceptibility or the diffusion coefficient. We explain why some collective effects depend on the atomic density, and others on the optical depth. In particular, we show that, for a large and dilute atomic sample driven by a far-detuned laser, the decay of the fluorescence, which exhibits superradiant and subradiant dynamics, depends only on the on-resonance optical depth. We also discuss the link between concepts that are independently studied in the quantum-optics community and in the mesoscopic-physics community. We show that the coupled-dipole model predicts a departure from Ohm’s law for the diffuse light, that incoherent multiple scattering can induce a saturation of fluorescence and we also show the similarity between the weak-localization correction to the diffusion coefficient and the inaccuracy of Lorentz local field correction to the susceptibility.
We study numerically the slow (subradiant) decay of the fluorescence of motionless atoms after a weak pulsed excitation. We show that, in the linear-optics regime and for an excitation detuned by several natural linewidths, the slow decay rate can be dominated by close pairs of atoms (dimers) forming superradiant and subradiant states. However, for a large-enough resonant optical depth and at later time, the dynamics is dominated by collective many-body effects. In this regime, we study the polarization and the spectrum of the emitted light, as well as the spatial distribution of excitation inside the sample, as a function of time during the decay dynamics. The behavior of these observables is consistent with what would be expected for radiation trapping of nearly resonant light. This finding sheds light on subradiance in dilute samples by providing an interpretation based on the light behavior of the system (multiple scattering) which is complementary to the more commonly used picture of the collective atomic Dicke state.
The interaction of light with an atomic sample containing a large number of particles gives rise to many collective (or cooperative) effects, such as multiple scattering, superradiance, and subradiance, even if the atomic density is low and the incident optical intensity weak (linear optics regime). Tracing over the degrees of freedom of the light field, the system can be well described by an effective atomic Hamiltonian, which contains the light-mediated dipole-dipole interaction between atoms. This long-range interaction is at the origin of the various collective effects, or of collective excitation modes of the system. Even though an analysis of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of these collective modes does allow distinguishing superradiant modes, for instance, from other collective modes, this is not sufficient to understand the dynamics of a driven system, as not all collective modes are significantly populated. Here, we study how the excitation parameters, i.e., the driving field, determines the population of the collective modes. We investigate in particular the role of the laser detuning from the atomic transition, and demonstrate a simple relation between the detuning and the steady-state population of the modes. This relation allows understanding several properties of cooperative scattering, such as why superradiance and subradiance become independent of the detuning at large enough detuning without vanishing, and why superradiance, but not subradiance, is suppressed near resonance. We also show that the spatial properties of the collective modes allow distinguishing diffusive modes, responsible for radiation trapping, from subradiant modes.
In this dissertation we focused on two topics: 1. atomic cooperative effect, including superradiance, subradiance and collective Lamb shift in an atomic ensemble; 2. novel topological effect in quantum optics system, such as Haldane model, synthetic magnetic field in superradiance lattice and synthetic spin-orbit interaction in Fock-state lattices. \n\nIn the first part, we start from the Dicke state, an N-particle atomic ensemble excited by a single photon. Due to the interaction of the atoms with a continuum of vacuum modes, the Dicke state has a larger decay rate compared with an isolated atom, termed the single photon superradiance. In the “opposite” case, the single-photon subradiance state does not decay because of the destructive interference of the atomic transitions. We study the protection of subradiant states by the symmetry of the atomic distributions in the Dicke limit, in which collective Lamb shifts cannot be neglected. We find that antisymmetric states are subradiant states for distributions with reflection symmetry. Continuous symmetry can also be used to achieve subradiance in an extended ensemble. This study is relevant to the problem of robust quantum memory with long storage time and fast readout.\n\nIn the second part, we start from introducing the concepts, methods, and models from quantum optics or condensed matter physics. They include the timed-Dicke states, electromagnetically induced transparency, coupled wave equations, tight-binding model, band theory, Floquet theory, superradiance lattice, integer quantum Hall effect, Haldane model, etc.. Based upon these tools, we study three topological quantum optics systems: (i) a Haldane model with in situ tunable topological properties in a two-dimensional momentumspace superradiance lattice composed of timed Dicke states in electromagnetically induced transparency; (ii) a spin-orbit coupled Fock-state lattice, which introduce a novel quantum operation to generate mesoscopic superposition states, e.g., the NOON states and cat states; (iii) a synthetic magnetic field created in a quasi one dimensional superradiance lattice, which is predicted to be observed in thermal vapours of alkali atoms instead of only in cold atoms (as in previous experiments). This study aims to provide a novel, highly tunable platform simulating exotic phenomena in condensed matter physics and offers a basis of topological quantum optics and novel photonic devices.