Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2208.08945 · Scientific Reports

Physical interpretation of non-normalizable harmonic oscillator states and relaxation to pilot-wave equilibrium

Indrajit Sen

Published Jan 13, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Non-normalizable states are difficult to interpret in the orthodox quantum formalism but often occur as solutions to physical constraints in quantum gravity. We argue that pilot-wave theory gives a straightforward physical interpretation of non-normalizable quantum states, as the theory requires only a normalized density of configurations to generate statistical predictions. In order to better understand such states, we conduct the first study of non-normalizable solutions of the harmonic oscillator from a pilot-wave perspective. We show that, contrary to intuitions from orthodox quantum mechanics, the non-normalizable eigenstates and their superpositions are bound states in the sense that the velocity field [Formula: see text] at large [Formula: see text]. We argue that defining a physically meaningful equilibrium density for such states requires a new notion of equilibrium, named pilot-wave equilibrium, which is a generalisation of the notion of quantum equilibrium. We define a new H-function [Formula: see text], and prove that a density in pilot-wave equilibrium minimises [Formula: see text], is equivariant, and remains in equilibrium with time. We prove an H-theorem for the coarse-grained [Formula: see text], under assumptions similar to those for relaxation to quantum equilibrium. We give an explanation of the emergence of quantization in pilot-wave theory in terms of instability of non-normalizable states due to perturbations and environmental interactions. Lastly, we discuss applications in quantum field theory and quantum gravity, and implications for pilot-wave theory and quantum foundations in general.

DOI
10.1038/s41598-023-50814-w

Related papers

Long-time relaxation in pilot-wave theory

E. Abraham, Samuel Colin, Antony Valentini

We initiate the study of relaxation to quantum equilibrium over long timescales in pilot-wave theory. We simulate the time evolution of the coarse-grained H-function Hbar(t) for a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator. For a (periodic) wave function that is a superposition of the first 25 energy states we confirm an approximately exponential decay of Hbar over five periods. For a superposition of only the first four energy states we are able to calculate Hbar(t) over 50 periods. We find that, depending on the set of phases in the initial wave function, Hbar can decay to a large nonequilibrium residue exceeding 10% of its initial value or it can become indistinguishable from zero (the equilibrium value). We show that a large residue in Hbar is caused by a tendency for the trajectories to be confined to sub-regions of configuration space for some wave functions, and that this is less likely to occur for larger numbers of energy states (if the initial phases are chosen randomly). Possible cosmological implications are briefly discussed.

arXiv:1310.1899•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 16, 2014•33 citations

Quantum relaxation in a system of harmonic oscillators with time-dependent coupling

Francisco Bento Lustosa, Samuel Colin, Santiago E. Perez Bergliaffa

In the context of the de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, numerical simulations for simple systems have shown that states that are initially out of quantum equilibrium—thus violating the Born rule—usually relax over time to the expected | ψ | 2 distribution on a coarse-grained level. We analyse the relaxation of non-equilibrium initial distributions for a system of coupled one-dimensional harmonic oscillators in which the coupling depends explicitly on time through numerical simulations, focusing on the influence of different parameters such as the number of modes, the coarse-graining length and the coupling constant. We show that in general the system studied here tends to equilibrium, but the relaxation can be retarded depending on the values of the parameters, particularly to the one related to the strength of the interaction. Possible implications on the detection of relic non-equilibrium systems are discussed.

arXiv:2007.02939•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Apr 1, 2021•6 citations

Evolution of quantum non-equilibrium for coupled harmonic oscillators

Francisco Bento Lustosa, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Antony Valentini

In the context of de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, violations of the Born rule are allowed and can be considered as describing non-equilibrium distributions. We study the effects of interactions on quantum relaxation towards equilibrium for a system of one-dimensional coupled harmonic oscillators. We show by numerical simulations that interactions can delay or even prevent complete relaxation for some initial states. We also discuss how this effect might be relevant for cosmological scenarios and how non-equilibrium could be detected in some models.

arXiv:2205.13701•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jan 1, 2023•9 citations

Time scales for dynamical relaxation to the Born rule

Mike D. Towler, N. J. Russell, Antony Valentini

We illustrate through explicit numerical calculations how the Born rule probability densities of non-relativistic quantum mechanics emerge naturally from the particle dynamics of de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory. The time evolution of a particle distribution initially not equal to the absolute square of the wave function is calculated for a particle in a two-dimensional infinite potential square well. Under the de Broglie–Bohm ontology, the box contains an objectively existing ‘pilot wave’ which guides the electron trajectory, and this is represented mathematically by a Schrödinger wave function composed of a finite out-of-phase superposition of M energy eigenstates (with M ranging from 4 to 64). The electron density distributions are found to evolve naturally into the Born rule ones and stay there; in analogy with the classical case this represents a decay to ‘quantum equilibrium’. The proximity to equilibrium is characterized by the coarse-grained subquantum H -function which is found to decrease roughly exponentially towards zero over the course of time. The time scale τ for this relaxation is calculated for various values of M and the coarse-graining length ε . Its dependence on M is found to disagree with an earlier theoretical prediction. A power law, τ ∝ M −1 , is found to be fairly robust for all coarse-graining lengths and, although a weak dependence of τ on ε is observed, it does not appear to follow any straightforward scaling. A theoretical analysis is presented to explain these results. This improvement in our understanding of time scales for relaxation to quantum equilibrium is likely to be of use in the development of models of relaxation in the early Universe, with a view to constraining possible violations of the Born rule in inflationary cosmology.

arXiv:1103.1589•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 30, 2011•123 citations

Pilot-wave theory and the search for new physics

Antony Valentini

We show how pilot-wave theory points to new physics, beyond quantum mechanics, in three distinct ways. First, generalised cosmological initial conditions, departing from the Born rule, can lead to observable anomalies in the cosmic microwave background and in relic cosmological particles. Second, a breakdown of the Born rule in the deep quantum-gravity regime, with gravitational corrections that render the Born rule semiclassically unstable, can create anomalies in Hawking radiation from evaporating black holes. Third, a regularised equation of motion that remains finite at nodes of the wave function generates corrections to the Born rule at short distances, while a natural time-dependent generalisation implies an instability of quantum equilibrium at short times, effects which may be observable in high-energy collisions.

arXiv:2411.10782•Nov 16, 2024•4 citations

The trouble with pilot-wave theory: a critical evaluation

Antony Valentini

Abstract Objections to pilot-wave theory frequently come in three mutually-contradictory categories: that the theory is too bizarrely different from ordinary physics, that the theory is not radically different enough, and that the physics of pilot-wave theory is after all just the same as quantum physics. After a brief review of pilot-wave theory, we critically evaluate these objections. We show how the radical nature of pilot-wave theory is often misunderstood or overlooked. We highlight the novelty of its dynamics, and clarify its implications for our understanding of measurement, as well as discussing the status of Lorentz invariance, conservation laws, and the Born rule. We examine Einstein’s early work on pilot-wave theory and argue that he turned away from it for reasons which are no longer compelling. We urge that the theory be understood on its own terms, as a generalised nonequilibrium theory empirically distinct from quantum mechanics, with all its potentially revolutionary implications

arXiv:2408.05403•Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 1, 2025•1 citation
Non-normalizable states are difficult to interpret in the orthodox quantum formalism but often occur as solutions to physical constraints in quantum gravity. We argue that pilot-wave theory gives a straightforward physical interpretation of non-normalizable quantum states, as the theory requires only a normalized density of configurations to generate statistical predictions. In order to better understand such states, we conduct the first study of non-normalizable solutions of the harmonic oscillator from a pilot-wave perspective. We show that, contrary to intuitions from orthodox quantum mechanics, the non-normalizable eigenstates and their superpositions are bound states in the sense that the velocity field [Formula: see text] at large [Formula: see text]. We argue that defining a physically meaningful equilibrium density for such states requires a new notion of equilibrium, named pilot-wave equilibrium, which is a generalisation of the notion of quantum equilibrium. We define a new H-function [Formula: see text], and prove that a density in pilot-wave equilibrium minimises [Formula: see text], is equivariant, and remains in equilibrium with time. We prove an H-theorem for the coarse-grained [Formula: see text], under assumptions similar to those for relaxation to quantum equilibrium. We give an explanation of the emergence of quantization in pilot-wave theory in terms of instability of non-normalizable states due to perturbations and environmental interactions. Lastly, we discuss applications in quantum field theory and quantum gravity, and implications for pilot-wave theory and quantum foundations in general.
We initiate the study of relaxation to quantum equilibrium over long timescales in pilot-wave theory. We simulate the time evolution of the coarse-grained H-function Hbar(t) for a two-dimensional harmonic oscillator. For a (periodic) wave function that is a superposition of the first 25 energy states we confirm an approximately exponential decay of Hbar over five periods. For a superposition of only the first four energy states we are able to calculate Hbar(t) over 50 periods. We find that, depending on the set of phases in the initial wave function, Hbar can decay to a large nonequilibrium residue exceeding 10% of its initial value or it can become indistinguishable from zero (the equilibrium value). We show that a large residue in Hbar is caused by a tendency for the trajectories to be confined to sub-regions of configuration space for some wave functions, and that this is less likely to occur for larger numbers of energy states (if the initial phases are chosen randomly). Possible cosmological implications are briefly discussed.
In the context of the de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, numerical simulations for simple systems have shown that states that are initially out of quantum equilibrium—thus violating the Born rule—usually relax over time to the expected | ψ | 2 distribution on a coarse-grained level. We analyse the relaxation of non-equilibrium initial distributions for a system of coupled one-dimensional harmonic oscillators in which the coupling depends explicitly on time through numerical simulations, focusing on the influence of different parameters such as the number of modes, the coarse-graining length and the coupling constant. We show that in general the system studied here tends to equilibrium, but the relaxation can be retarded depending on the values of the parameters, particularly to the one related to the strength of the interaction. Possible implications on the detection of relic non-equilibrium systems are discussed.
In the context of de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, violations of the Born rule are allowed and can be considered as describing non-equilibrium distributions. We study the effects of interactions on quantum relaxation towards equilibrium for a system of one-dimensional coupled harmonic oscillators. We show by numerical simulations that interactions can delay or even prevent complete relaxation for some initial states. We also discuss how this effect might be relevant for cosmological scenarios and how non-equilibrium could be detected in some models.
We illustrate through explicit numerical calculations how the Born rule probability densities of non-relativistic quantum mechanics emerge naturally from the particle dynamics of de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory. The time evolution of a particle distribution initially not equal to the absolute square of the wave function is calculated for a particle in a two-dimensional infinite potential square well. Under the de Broglie–Bohm ontology, the box contains an objectively existing ‘pilot wave’ which guides the electron trajectory, and this is represented mathematically by a Schrödinger wave function composed of a finite out-of-phase superposition of M energy eigenstates (with M ranging from 4 to 64). The electron density distributions are found to evolve naturally into the Born rule ones and stay there; in analogy with the classical case this represents a decay to ‘quantum equilibrium’. The proximity to equilibrium is characterized by the coarse-grained subquantum H -function which is found to decrease roughly exponentially towards zero over the course of time. The time scale τ for this relaxation is calculated for various values of M and the coarse-graining length ε . Its dependence on M is found to disagree with an earlier theoretical prediction. A power law, τ ∝ M −1 , is found to be fairly robust for all coarse-graining lengths and, although a weak dependence of τ on ε is observed, it does not appear to follow any straightforward scaling. A theoretical analysis is presented to explain these results. This improvement in our understanding of time scales for relaxation to quantum equilibrium is likely to be of use in the development of models of relaxation in the early Universe, with a view to constraining possible violations of the Born rule in inflationary cosmology.
We show how pilot-wave theory points to new physics, beyond quantum mechanics, in three distinct ways. First, generalised cosmological initial conditions, departing from the Born rule, can lead to observable anomalies in the cosmic microwave background and in relic cosmological particles. Second, a breakdown of the Born rule in the deep quantum-gravity regime, with gravitational corrections that render the Born rule semiclassically unstable, can create anomalies in Hawking radiation from evaporating black holes. Third, a regularised equation of motion that remains finite at nodes of the wave function generates corrections to the Born rule at short distances, while a natural time-dependent generalisation implies an instability of quantum equilibrium at short times, effects which may be observable in high-energy collisions.
Abstract Objections to pilot-wave theory frequently come in three mutually-contradictory categories: that the theory is too bizarrely different from ordinary physics, that the theory is not radically different enough, and that the physics of pilot-wave theory is after all just the same as quantum physics. After a brief review of pilot-wave theory, we critically evaluate these objections. We show how the radical nature of pilot-wave theory is often misunderstood or overlooked. We highlight the novelty of its dynamics, and clarify its implications for our understanding of measurement, as well as discussing the status of Lorentz invariance, conservation laws, and the Born rule. We examine Einstein’s early work on pilot-wave theory and argue that he turned away from it for reasons which are no longer compelling. We urge that the theory be understood on its own terms, as a generalised nonequilibrium theory empirically distinct from quantum mechanics, with all its potentially revolutionary implications