Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2207.14325 · Nature Communications

Probing coherent quantum thermodynamics using a trapped ion

O. Onishchenko, Giacomo Guarnieri, Pablo Rosillo-Rodes, D. R. M. Pijn, Janine Hilder, Ulrich Poschinger, Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Jens Eisert, Ferdinand Schmidt‐Kaler

Published Aug 14, 2024• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum thermodynamics is aimed at grasping thermodynamic laws as they apply to thermal machines operating in the deep quantum regime, where coherence and entanglement are expected to matter. Despite substantial progress, however, it has remained difficult to develop thermal machines in which such quantum effects are observed to be of pivotal importance. In this work, we demonstrate the possibility to experimentally measure and benchmark a genuine quantum correction, induced by quantum friction, to the classical work fluctuation-dissipation relation. This is achieved by combining laser-induced coherent Hamiltonian rotations and energy measurements on a trapped ion. Our results demonstrate that recent developments in stochastic quantum thermodynamics can be used to benchmark and unambiguously distinguish genuine quantum coherent signatures generated along driving protocols, even in presence of experimental SPAM errors and, most importantly, beyond the regimes for which theoretical predictions are available (e.g., in slow driving).

DOI
10.1038/s41467-024-51263-3

Related papers

Towards physical realisations of quantum thermodynamics

Zoë Holmes

Quantum thermodynamics seeks to extend the laws of thermodynamics to equilibrium and non-equilibrium systems on the nano-scale. Over the last decade a large body of theoretical research into quantum thermodynamics has been produced; however, experimental research is yet to catch up with the impressive lead set by theory. This is especially true of quantum information theoretic approaches which have proven an effective means of incorporating quantum effects into thermodynamics but seem resistant to experimental implementation. This thesis aims to counter this shortcoming by proposing concrete physical realisations} of quantum thermodynamics to help bridge the gap between theory and experiment. This task is approached directly in chapter 2 by constructing an experimental implementation of a fluctuation relation developed from a quantum information theoretic perspective. Our proposal involves the autonomous evolution of a trapped ion and uses a tapered laser beam to implement a position dependent AC Stark shift. In order to test the fluctuation relation we convert the abstract framework of an autonomous quantum Crooks equality into quantum Crooks equalities for coherent, squeezed and cat states. These new relations highlight the physical origins and implications of coherence induced corrections to classical fluctuation relations and prompt a discussion on the interplay between coherence and irreversibility. In chapter 3 we turn our attention to Gibbs' iconic thought experiments on the work that can be extracted from the mixing of gases. Here we argue that optomechanical setups, involving a cavity in which a membrane is inserted, provide a suitable platform both to generalise such thought experiments to the quantum regime and to explore quantum thermodynamic signatures of distinguishability. We find, in contrast to classical thermodynamics, that the work that can be extracted from the mixing of the two photon gases varies continuously with their distinguishability. Finally, we demonstrate that the bunching of photons, arising from their Bosonic character, generates an energetic footprint that does not exist in classical thermodynamics.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Certifying quantum enhancements in thermal machines beyond the Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation

José A. Almanza-Marrero, Gonzalo Manzano

Quantum coherence has been shown to impact the operational capabilities of quantum systems performing thermodynamic tasks in a significant way, and yet the possibility and conditions for genuine coherence-enhanced thermodynamic operation remain unclear. Introducing a comparison with classical machines using the same set of thermodynamic resources, we show that for steady-state quantum thermal machines – both autonomous and externally driven – that interact weakly with thermal reservoirs and work sources, the presence of coherence induced by perturbations in the machine Hamiltonian guarantees a genuine thermodynamic advantage under mild conditions. This advantage applies to both cases where the induced coherence is between levels with different energies or between degenerate levels. On the other hand, we show that engines subjected to noise-induced coherence can be outperformed by classical stochastic engines using exactly the same set of (incoherent) resources. We illustrate our results with three prototypical models of heat engines and refrigerators: the three-level amplifier, the three-qubit autonomous refrigerator, and a noise-induced-coherence machine.

arXiv:2403.19280•Quantum•Oct 7, 2025•15 citations

Minimally invasive measurement of work in coherent quantum systems

Cyril Elouard, Karen Hovhannisyan, Giulia Rubino

A central challenge in quantum thermodynamics is to access work fluctuations in coherent processes without distorting the energetics of the unmeasured evolution. In standard two-point schemes, the initial energy measurement dephases coherent inputs, causing the measured average work to differ from that of the unmeasured evolution. Here, we develop an operational scheme for accessing work statistics for closed quantum systems based on the abstract notion of variation in the Heisenberg picture Hamiltonian. This scheme preserves energetically relevant coherences, thereby faithfully reproducing unmeasured work, while still producing positive probabilities. We derive modified Jarzynski and Crooks relations, as well as a thermodynamic uncertainty relation, identifying coherence-induced correction terms. Furthermore, we show that this scheme can reliably quantify the performance of a coherent engine in situations where the two-point energy measurement would suppress work output. In addition, the scheme requires only a single measurement and can predict the work associated with a subsequent unitary transformation. We exploit this feature to construct a Maxwell-demon protocol that can outperform energy-based feedback engines for coherent work extraction. Our results establish this scheme as a framework for accessing coherent work fluctuations without erasing the coherence that drives quantum thermodynamic performance.

quant-pharXiv:2607.02652•Jul 6, 2026•2 citations

Coherence and measurement in quantum thermodynamics

P. Kammerlander, Janet Anders

Thermodynamics is a highly successful macroscopic theory widely used across the natural sciences and for the construction of everyday devices, from car engines to solar cells. With thermodynamics predating quantum theory, research now aims to uncover the thermodynamic laws that govern finite size systems which may in addition host quantum effects. Recent theoretical breakthroughs include the characterisation of the efficiency of quantum thermal engines, the extension of classical non-equilibrium fluctuation theorems to the quantum regime and a new thermodynamic resource theory has led to the discovery of a set of second laws for finite size systems. These results have substantially advanced our understanding of nanoscale thermodynamics, however putting a finger on what is genuinely quantum in quantum thermodynamics has remained a challenge. Here we identify information processing tasks, the so-called projections, that can only be formulated within the framework of quantum mechanics. We show that the physical realisation of such projections can come with a non-trivial thermodynamic work only for quantum states with coherences. This contrasts with information erasure, first investigated by Landauer, for which a thermodynamic work cost applies for classical and quantum erasure alike. Repercussions on quantum work fluctuation relations and thermodynamic single-shot approaches are also discussed.

arXiv:1502.02673•Scientific Reports•Feb 26, 2016•208 citations

Stochastic Thermodynamics at the Quantum-Classical Boundary: A Self-Consistent Framework Based on Adiabatic-Response Theory

Joshua Eglinton, Federico Carollo, Igor Lesanovsky +1 more

Microscopic thermal machines promise to play an important role in future quantum technologies. Making such devices widely applicable will require effective strategies to channel their output into easily accessible storage systems like classical degrees of freedom. Here, we develop a self-consistent theoretical framework that makes it possible to model such quantum-classical hybrid devices in a thermodynamically consistent manner. Our approach is based on the assumption that the quantum part of the device is subject to strong decoherence and dissipation induced by a thermal reservoir. Due to the ensuing separation of time scales between slowly evolving classical and fast relaxing quantum degrees of freedom, the dynamics of the hybrid system can be described by means of adiabatic-response theory. We show that, upon including fluctuations in a minimally consistent way, the resulting equations of motion can be equipped with a first and second law, both on the ensemble level and on the level of individual trajectories of the classical part of the system, where thermodynamic quantities like heat and work become stochastic variables. As an application of our theory, we work out a physically transparent model of a quantum-classical hybrid engine, whose working system consists of a chain of Rydberg atoms, which is confined in an optical cavity and driven by periodic temperature variations. We demonstrate through numerical simulations that the engine can sustain periodic oscillations of a movable mirror, which acts as a classical load, against external friction and extract the full distributions of input heat and output work. By making the statistics of thermodynamic processes in quantum-classical hybrid systems accessible without the need to further specify a measurement protocol, our work contributes to bridging the long-standing gap between classical and quantum stochastic thermodynamics.

arXiv:2404.10118•Quantum•Sep 26, 2024•4 citations

STUDIES IN NONEQUILIBRIUM QUANTUM THERMODYNAMICS

Andrew Maven Smith

The first part of this thesis focuses on verifying the quantum nonequilibrium work relation in the presence of decoherence. The nonequilibrium work relation is a generalization of the second law of thermodynamics that links nonequilibrium work measurements to equilibrium free energies via an equality. Despite being well established for classical systems, a quantum work relation is conceptually difficult to construct for systems that interact with their environment. We argue that for a quantum system which undergoes decoherence but not dissipation, these conceptual difficulties do not arise and the work relation can be proven similarly to the case of an isolated system. This result is accompanied by an experimental demonstration using trapped ions. The second part of this thesis examines the relationship between quantum work and coherence by constructing analogous quantities in classical physics. It has recently been shown that quantum coherence can function as a resource for work extraction. Furthermore, it has been suggested that this property could be a truly quantum aspect of thermodynamics with no classical analog. We examine this assertion within the framework of classical Hamiltonian mechanics and canonical quantization. For classical states we define a so called non-uniformity measure and show that it is a resource for work extraction similar to quantum coherence. Additionally, we show that work extracted from non-uniformity and coherence agree in the classical limit. This calls into question the idea that coherence qualitatively separates classical and quantum thermodynamics. The final part of this thesis explores the connection between decoherence and adiabatic (quasistatic) driving. This topic is inspired by an experiment where it was seen that strong dephasing suppressed energy level transitions. Using a perturbative method we investigate this mechanism in the regime of small to moderate decoherence rate and ask if decoherence can help suppress energy transitions when compared with an adiabatic process without decoherence. We find that strategies that include decoherence are inferior to those where decoherence is absent.

•Jan 1, 2019•1 citation
Quantum thermodynamics is aimed at grasping thermodynamic laws as they apply to thermal machines operating in the deep quantum regime, where coherence and entanglement are expected to matter. Despite substantial progress, however, it has remained difficult to develop thermal machines in which such quantum effects are observed to be of pivotal importance. In this work, we demonstrate the possibility to experimentally measure and benchmark a genuine quantum correction, induced by quantum friction, to the classical work fluctuation-dissipation relation. This is achieved by combining laser-induced coherent Hamiltonian rotations and energy measurements on a trapped ion. Our results demonstrate that recent developments in stochastic quantum thermodynamics can be used to benchmark and unambiguously distinguish genuine quantum coherent signatures generated along driving protocols, even in presence of experimental SPAM errors and, most importantly, beyond the regimes for which theoretical predictions are available (e.g., in slow driving).
Quantum thermodynamics seeks to extend the laws of thermodynamics to equilibrium and non-equilibrium systems on the nano-scale. Over the last decade a large body of theoretical research into quantum thermodynamics has been produced; however, experimental research is yet to catch up with the impressive lead set by theory. This is especially true of quantum information theoretic approaches which have proven an effective means of incorporating quantum effects into thermodynamics but seem resistant to experimental implementation. This thesis aims to counter this shortcoming by proposing concrete physical realisations} of quantum thermodynamics to help bridge the gap between theory and experiment. This task is approached directly in chapter 2 by constructing an experimental implementation of a fluctuation relation developed from a quantum information theoretic perspective. Our proposal involves the autonomous evolution of a trapped ion and uses a tapered laser beam to implement a position dependent AC Stark shift. In order to test the fluctuation relation we convert the abstract framework of an autonomous quantum Crooks equality into quantum Crooks equalities for coherent, squeezed and cat states. These new relations highlight the physical origins and implications of coherence induced corrections to classical fluctuation relations and prompt a discussion on the interplay between coherence and irreversibility. In chapter 3 we turn our attention to Gibbs' iconic thought experiments on the work that can be extracted from the mixing of gases. Here we argue that optomechanical setups, involving a cavity in which a membrane is inserted, provide a suitable platform both to generalise such thought experiments to the quantum regime and to explore quantum thermodynamic signatures of distinguishability. We find, in contrast to classical thermodynamics, that the work that can be extracted from the mixing of the two photon gases varies continuously with their distinguishability. Finally, we demonstrate that the bunching of photons, arising from their Bosonic character, generates an energetic footprint that does not exist in classical thermodynamics.
Quantum coherence has been shown to impact the operational capabilities of quantum systems performing thermodynamic tasks in a significant way, and yet the possibility and conditions for genuine coherence-enhanced thermodynamic operation remain unclear. Introducing a comparison with classical machines using the same set of thermodynamic resources, we show that for steady-state quantum thermal machines – both autonomous and externally driven – that interact weakly with thermal reservoirs and work sources, the presence of coherence induced by perturbations in the machine Hamiltonian guarantees a genuine thermodynamic advantage under mild conditions. This advantage applies to both cases where the induced coherence is between levels with different energies or between degenerate levels. On the other hand, we show that engines subjected to noise-induced coherence can be outperformed by classical stochastic engines using exactly the same set of (incoherent) resources. We illustrate our results with three prototypical models of heat engines and refrigerators: the three-level amplifier, the three-qubit autonomous refrigerator, and a noise-induced-coherence machine.
A central challenge in quantum thermodynamics is to access work fluctuations in coherent processes without distorting the energetics of the unmeasured evolution. In standard two-point schemes, the initial energy measurement dephases coherent inputs, causing the measured average work to differ from that of the unmeasured evolution. Here, we develop an operational scheme for accessing work statistics for closed quantum systems based on the abstract notion of variation in the Heisenberg picture Hamiltonian. This scheme preserves energetically relevant coherences, thereby faithfully reproducing unmeasured work, while still producing positive probabilities. We derive modified Jarzynski and Crooks relations, as well as a thermodynamic uncertainty relation, identifying coherence-induced correction terms. Furthermore, we show that this scheme can reliably quantify the performance of a coherent engine in situations where the two-point energy measurement would suppress work output. In addition, the scheme requires only a single measurement and can predict the work associated with a subsequent unitary transformation. We exploit this feature to construct a Maxwell-demon protocol that can outperform energy-based feedback engines for coherent work extraction. Our results establish this scheme as a framework for accessing coherent work fluctuations without erasing the coherence that drives quantum thermodynamic performance.
Thermodynamics is a highly successful macroscopic theory widely used across the natural sciences and for the construction of everyday devices, from car engines to solar cells. With thermodynamics predating quantum theory, research now aims to uncover the thermodynamic laws that govern finite size systems which may in addition host quantum effects. Recent theoretical breakthroughs include the characterisation of the efficiency of quantum thermal engines, the extension of classical non-equilibrium fluctuation theorems to the quantum regime and a new thermodynamic resource theory has led to the discovery of a set of second laws for finite size systems. These results have substantially advanced our understanding of nanoscale thermodynamics, however putting a finger on what is genuinely quantum in quantum thermodynamics has remained a challenge. Here we identify information processing tasks, the so-called projections, that can only be formulated within the framework of quantum mechanics. We show that the physical realisation of such projections can come with a non-trivial thermodynamic work only for quantum states with coherences. This contrasts with information erasure, first investigated by Landauer, for which a thermodynamic work cost applies for classical and quantum erasure alike. Repercussions on quantum work fluctuation relations and thermodynamic single-shot approaches are also discussed.
Microscopic thermal machines promise to play an important role in future quantum technologies. Making such devices widely applicable will require effective strategies to channel their output into easily accessible storage systems like classical degrees of freedom. Here, we develop a self-consistent theoretical framework that makes it possible to model such quantum-classical hybrid devices in a thermodynamically consistent manner. Our approach is based on the assumption that the quantum part of the device is subject to strong decoherence and dissipation induced by a thermal reservoir. Due to the ensuing separation of time scales between slowly evolving classical and fast relaxing quantum degrees of freedom, the dynamics of the hybrid system can be described by means of adiabatic-response theory. We show that, upon including fluctuations in a minimally consistent way, the resulting equations of motion can be equipped with a first and second law, both on the ensemble level and on the level of individual trajectories of the classical part of the system, where thermodynamic quantities like heat and work become stochastic variables. As an application of our theory, we work out a physically transparent model of a quantum-classical hybrid engine, whose working system consists of a chain of Rydberg atoms, which is confined in an optical cavity and driven by periodic temperature variations. We demonstrate through numerical simulations that the engine can sustain periodic oscillations of a movable mirror, which acts as a classical load, against external friction and extract the full distributions of input heat and output work. By making the statistics of thermodynamic processes in quantum-classical hybrid systems accessible without the need to further specify a measurement protocol, our work contributes to bridging the long-standing gap between classical and quantum stochastic thermodynamics.
The first part of this thesis focuses on verifying the quantum nonequilibrium work relation in the presence of decoherence. The nonequilibrium work relation is a generalization of the second law of thermodynamics that links nonequilibrium work measurements to equilibrium free energies via an equality. Despite being well established for classical systems, a quantum work relation is conceptually difficult to construct for systems that interact with their environment. We argue that for a quantum system which undergoes decoherence but not dissipation, these conceptual difficulties do not arise and the work relation can be proven similarly to the case of an isolated system. This result is accompanied by an experimental demonstration using trapped ions. The second part of this thesis examines the relationship between quantum work and coherence by constructing analogous quantities in classical physics. It has recently been shown that quantum coherence can function as a resource for work extraction. Furthermore, it has been suggested that this property could be a truly quantum aspect of thermodynamics with no classical analog. We examine this assertion within the framework of classical Hamiltonian mechanics and canonical quantization. For classical states we define a so called non-uniformity measure and show that it is a resource for work extraction similar to quantum coherence. Additionally, we show that work extracted from non-uniformity and coherence agree in the classical limit. This calls into question the idea that coherence qualitatively separates classical and quantum thermodynamics. The final part of this thesis explores the connection between decoherence and adiabatic (quasistatic) driving. This topic is inspired by an experiment where it was seen that strong dephasing suppressed energy level transitions. Using a perturbative method we investigate this mechanism in the regime of small to moderate decoherence rate and ask if decoherence can help suppress energy transitions when compared with an adiabatic process without decoherence. We find that strategies that include decoherence are inferior to those where decoherence is absent.