Quasiparticle Spectroscopy, Transport, and Magnetic Properties of Nb Films Used in Superconducting Qubits
Kamal R. Joshi, Sunil Ghimire, Makariy A. Tanatar, Amlan Datta, Jin‐Su Oh, Lin Zhou, Cameron Kopas, Jayss Marshall, J. Mutus, Julie Slaughter, Matthew Joseph Kramer, James A. Sauls, R. Prozorov
Niobium thin films on silicon substrate used in the fabrication of superconducting qubits have been characterized using scanning and transmission electron microscopy, electrical transport, magnetization, the London penetration depth - based quasiparticle spectroscopy, and real-space real-time magneto-optical imaging. We study niobium films to provide an example of a comprehensive analytical set that may benefit superconducting circuits such as those used in quantum computers. The films have a superconducting transition temperature of ${T}_{c}=9.35$ K and a fairly clean superconducting gap. The estimated superfluid density is enhanced at intermediate temperatures. These observations are consistent with the recent theory of anisotropic strong-coupling superconductivity in $\mathrm{Nb}$ and indicate outstanding quality. However, the response to the magnetic field is complicated, exhibiting significantly irreversible behavior and insufficient heat dissipation (to a substrate), leading to thermomagnetic instabilities. This may present a challenge for further improvement of transmon quantum coherence. Possible mitigation strategies are discussed.
Niobium thin films on silicon substrate used in the fabrication of superconducting qubits have been characterized using scanning and transmission electron microscopy, electrical transport, magnetization, the London penetration depth - based quasiparticle spectroscopy, and real-space real-time magneto-optical imaging. We study niobium films to provide an example of a comprehensive analytical set that may benefit superconducting circuits such as those used in quantum computers. The films have a superconducting transition temperature of Tc=9.35 K and a fairly clean superconducting gap. The estimated superfluid density is enhanced at intermediate temperatures. These observations are consistent with the recent theory of anisotropic strong-coupling superconductivity in Nb and indicate outstanding quality. However, the response to the magnetic field is complicated, exhibiting significantly irreversible behavior and insufficient heat dissipation (to a substrate), leading to thermomagnetic instabilities. This may present a challenge for further improvement of transmon quantum coherence. Possible mitigation strategies are discussed.
Niobium is a practical material platform for superconducting microwave circuits; however, device-level performance can vary significantly depending on film growth and processing conditions. We compare three epitaxial Nb films grown on c−plane sapphire substrates under nominally identical conditions, except for the deposition temperature. To correlate internal quality factors, Qi, with material properties, we combine magneto-optical imaging of magnetic flux distribution with quasiparticle spectroscopy via measurements of the London penetration depth, λ(T). In the low-Qi film, there is a lesser ability to screen the magnetic field and an irregular temperature variation of λ(T), implying the existence of localized in-gap states. High Qi films show the opposite trend. We conclude that our measurements provide an efficient method for characterizing and optimizing superconducting films for quantum informatics applications.
Abstract Among the recognized sources of decoherence in superconducting qubits, the spatial inhomogeneity of the superconducting state and the possible presence of magnetic-flux vortices remain comparatively underexplored. Niobium is commonly used as a structural material in transmon qubits that host Josephson junctions, and excess dissipation anywhere in the transmon can become a bottleneck that limits overall quantum performance. The metal/substrate interfacial layer may simultaneously host pair-breaking loss channels (e.g. two-level systems) and control thermal transport, thereby affecting dissipation and temperature stability. Here, we use quantitative magneto-optical imaging of the magnetic-flux distribution to characterize the homogeneity of the superconducting state and the critical current density, j c , in niobium films fabricated under different sputtering conditions. The imaging reveals distinct flux-penetration regimes, ranging from a nearly ideal Bean critical state to strongly nonuniform thermo-magnetic dendritic avalanches. By fitting the measured magnetic-induction profiles, we extract j c and try to correlate it with film physical properties and with measured qubit internal quality factors. Our results indicate that the Nb/Si interlayer can be a significant contributor to decoherence and should be considered an important factor that must be optimized.
Niobium metal occupies nearly 100\% of the volume of a typical 2D transmon device. While the aluminum Josephson junction is of utmost importance, maintaining quantum coherence across the entire device means that pair-breaking in Nb leads, capacitive pads, and readout resonators can be a major source of decoherence. The established contributors are surface oxides and hydroxides, as well as absorbed hydrogen and oxygen. Metal encapsulation of freshly grown surfaces with non-oxidizing metals, preferably without breaking the vacuum, is a successful strategy to mitigate these issues. While the positive effects of encapsulation are undeniable, it is important to understand its impact on the macroscopic behavior of niobium films. We present a comprehensive study of the bulk superconducting properties of Nb thin films encapsulated with gold and palladium/gold, and compare them to those of bare Nb films. Magneto-optical imaging, magnetization, resistivity, and London and Campbell penetration depth measurements reveal significant differences in encapsulated samples. Both sputtered, and epitaxial Au-capped films exhibit the highest residual resistivity ratio and superconducting transition temperature, as well as the lowest upper critical field, London penetration depth, and critical current. These results are in good agreement with the microscopic theory of anisotropic normal and superconducting states of Nb. We conclude that pair-breaking in the bulk of niobium films, driven by disorder throughout the film rather than just at the surface, is a significant source of quantum decoherence in transmons. We also conclude that gold capping not only passivates the surface but also affects the properties of the entire film, significantly reducing the scattering rate due to defects likely induced by surface diffusion if the film is not protected immediately after fabrication.
Niobium is a widely accepted material for quantum computing device as well as superconducting radio frequency (SRF) technology. Superconducting niobium is a marginal type II superconductor which has a very narrow gap (~20-30 mT) of the mixed state at 2K, even showing the intermediate state (IMS) at the early stage of magnetic vortex penetration. Tremendous progress has been made in understanding the impact of the Nb surface and bulk superconductivities on SRF resonator performance. However, the effect of thin superconducting Nb films for quantum computing applications requires further examination. In this study, we explore the fundamental superconducting properties of various thin Nb films and compare them with respect to the energy relaxation time, T1, measured from superconducting qubit fabricated with these films. The Nb films are fabricated both with or without a surface protective layer that prevents the formation of lossy Nb2O5. Electromagnetic properties are characterized by means of bulk magnetization, electromagnetic transport, and dynamics of surface superconductivity. In addition, analytical electron microscopy is implemented to further connect the superconducting properties to microstructure.
ABSTRACT Niobium (Nb) films have emerged as a crucial material in the development of superconducting qubits, which are key components in quantum computing technology. This review provides a comprehensive examination of Nb films from a materials perspective, focusing on their intrinsic properties, fabrication methods/techniques, and their influence on qubit performance, particularly through surface and interface driven loss mechanisms. We discuss the key material properties that are essential for qubit operation. Various deposition techniques for Nb thin films, such as sputtering, evaporation, molecular beam epitaxy, and atomic layer deposition, are explored, alongside their impact on film quality, uniformity, and qubit performance. Additionally, the influence of surface roughness, thin‐film thickness, and substrate materials on quantum coherence is analyzed. Challenges such as defects and material degradation in Nb films are reviewed, along with strategies to mitigate these issues. Finally, we present the latest advancements and future directions in Nb film research, including potential improvements to enhance qubit coherence and scalability for large‐scale quantum computing systems. Ultimately, a deeper understanding of surface and interface phenomena is essential for pushing the limits of qubit performance and realizing next‐generation quantum technologies.
Niobium thin films are central to superconducting qubits, but their complex native oxides contribute significantly to microwave losses. A promising mitigation strategy is to suppress oxide formation using engineered thin-film encapsulation layers. Recent experiments have shown that ∼10 nm metallic overlayers on Nb capacitor films can improve the energy relaxation time T 1 of transmon qubits. Here, we present a comparative study of Au-capped Nb films fabricated in situ by molecular beam epitaxy and ex situ by sequential deposition benchmarked against bare Nb films. Using complementary structural, chemical, and spectroscopic techniques, we correlate the interface quality with superconducting electronic properties of the Au surface. Low-temperature scanning tunneling spectroscopy (STS) provides spatially resolved quasiparticle density-of-states maps. While both Au-capped Nb samples exhibit large areas with uniform, fully gapped density of states, clear differences emerge between the two interfaces. Compared to in situ Nb–Au, ex situ Nb–Au exhibits a reduced induced superconducting gap, broadened coherence peak, and localized in-gap states, consistent with a residual Nb x O y layer at the interface. Supported by complementary structural and chemical analyses, these findings demonstrate that STS directly links nanoscale superconducting properties to interface preparation, highlighting the importance of controlled in situ encapsulation for minimizing dissipation and improving quantum coherence.