Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2207.11520

Mixer Hamiltonian with QAOA for Max k-coloring : numerical evaluations

Eric Bourreau, Gérard Fleury, Philippe Lacomme

Published Jul 23, 2022• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This paper concerns quantum heuristics based on Mixer Hamiltonians that allow to restrict investigation on a specific subspace. Mixer Hamiltonian based approaches can be included in QAOA algorithm and we can state that Mixer Hamiltonians are mapping functions from the set of qubit-strings to the set of solutions. Mixer Hamiltonian offers an approach very similar to indirect representations commonly used in routing or in scheduling community for decades. After the initial publication of Cheng et al. in 1996 (Cheng et al., 1996), numerous propositions in OR lies on 1-to-n mapping functions, including the split algorithm that transform one TSP solution into a VRP solution. The objective is at first to give a compact and readable presentation of these Mixer Hamiltonians considering the functional analogies that exist between the OR community practices and the quantum field. Our experiments encompass numerical evaluations of circuit using the Qiskit library of IBM meeting the theoretical considerations.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2207.11520

Related papers

A Warm-start QAOA based approach using a swap-based mixer for the TSP: theoretical considerations,implementation and experiments

Eric Bourreau, Gérard Fleury, Philippe Lacomme

This paper investigates quantum heuristics based on Mixer Hamiltonians, which allow the search to be restricted to a specific subspace and enable warm-start strategies for solving the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP). Approaches involving Mixer Hamiltonians can be integrated into the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), where the Mixer acts as a mapping function that transforms qubit strings into feasible solution sets. We first introduce a swap-based mixer tailored to the TSP, which ensures that only qubit strings representing valid TSP solutions are explored during the QAOA process. Second, we propose a warm-start technique that initializes QAOA with a solution generated by any classical heuristic, thereby promoting faster convergence. These two contributions are combined into a Warm-Start QAOA framework with a Swap-Based Mixer, leveraging both structural and initialization advantages. Experimental results on a custom TSP instance involving five customers demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, providing, for the first time, a viable integration of warm-start and swap-based mixers for the TSP within a quantum optimization framework.

arXiv:2505.01214•May 2, 2025•5 citations

Equivariant Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm

Boris Tsvelikhovskiy, Ilya Safro, Yuri Alexeev

Constructing effective mixer Hamiltonians is essential for enhancing the performance of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) in solving combinatorial optimization problems. In this work, we develop a systematic methodology for designing QAOA mixers that align with the symmetries of the classical objective function, with the goal of achieving values (mean, median, and minimum over multiple runs) that are closer to the true optimum. Our main idea is to design QAOA operators that are explicitly adapted to the action of symmetry groups on the Hilbert space. We focus on subgroups of the symmetric group$ S_{d}$, where$ d = 2^\ell$, to ensure compatibility with qudit-based quantum architectures. In particular, we construct QAOA mixers invariant under the full symmetric group$ S_{d}$as well as its cyclic subgroup$ \mathbb {Z}_{d} \subset S_{d}$. These constructions are natural in that they respect the decomposition of the Hilbert space into isotypic components under the symmetry group action. Notably, to the best of our knowledge, the QAOA algorithm based on the$ \mathbb {Z}_{d}$-invariant mixer provides the first example of a QAOA protocol whose dynamics (up to final measurement) are confined entirely within a nontrivial irreducible representation of a symmetry group of the objective function. Although our work does not investigate the benefits of exploiting such subspaces as computational resources, we think that the very realization of a variational algorithm whose evolution is restricted to a nontrivial symmetry-adapted subspace is of fundamental conceptual interest. We provide closed-form expressions for these mixers, together with explicit quantum circuit implementations. To empirically evaluate our approach, we compare QAOA variants employing the standard mixer$B = \sum X_{i}$with those using our proposed Hamiltonians$H_{M}$and$H_\chi$on edge coloring and graph partitioning problems. Across multiple graph instances, our symmetry-adapted mixers consistently yield objective values closer to the optimum, demonstrating statistically significant improvements over classical baselines.

arXiv:2405.07211•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2026•10 citations

The Quantum Approximate Algorithm for Solving Traveling Salesman Problem

Yue Ruan, S. Marsh, Xilin Xue +2 more

The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is an algorithmic framework for finding approximate solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. It consists of interleaved unitary transformations induced by two operators labelled the mixing and problem Hamiltonians. To fit this framework, one needs to transform the original problem into a suitable form and embed it into these two Hamiltonians. In this paper, for the well-known NP-hard Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), we encode its constraints into the mixing Hamiltonian rather than the conventional approach of adding penalty terms to the problem Hamiltonian. Moreover, we map edges (routes) connecting each pair of cities to qubits, which decreases the search space significantly in comparison to other approaches. As a result, our method can achieve a higher probability for the shortest round-trip route with only half the number of qubits consumed compared to IBM Q’s approach. We argue the formalization approach presented in this paper would lead to a generalized framework for finding, in the context of QAOA, high-quality approximate solutions to NP optimization problems.

Computers, materials & continua/Computers, materials & continua (Print)•Jan 1, 2020•54 citations

Warm-Starting QAOA With XY Mixers: A Novel Approach for Traveling Salesman Problem

Rafael Simões do Carmo, Marcos Cleison Silva Santana, F. F. Fanchini +2 more

Quantum optimization algorithms, such as the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), are emerging as promising heuristics for solving complex combinatorial problems. To improve performance, several extensions to the standard QAOA framework have been proposed in recent years. Two notable directions include: warm-starting techniques, which incorporate classical approximate solutions to guide the quantum evolution, and custom mixer Hamiltonians, such as$XY$mixers, which constrain the search to feasible subspaces aligned with the structure of the problem. In this work, we propose an approach that integrates these two strategies: a warm-start initialization with an$XY$mixer ansatz, enabling constraint, preserving quantum evolution biased toward high-quality classical solutions. The method begins by reformulating the combinatorial problem as a MaxCut instance, solved approximately using the Goemans-Williamson algorithm. The resulting binary solution is relaxed and used to construct a biased superposition over one-hot quantum states that preserves the Hamming weight 1, maintaining compatibility with the$XY$mixers constraints. We evaluate the approach on 5-city instances of the Traveling Salesperson Problem, a canonical optimization problem frequently encountered as a subroutine in real-world route planning problems. Our method is benchmarked against both the standard$XY$-mixer QAOA and a warm-start-only variant based on MaxCut relaxation. Results show that the proposed combination consistently outperforms both baselines in terms of the percentage and rank of optimal solutions, demonstrating the effectiveness of combining structured initializations with constraint-aware quantum evolution for optimization problems.

arXiv:2504.19934•IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems•Jan 1, 2026•11 citations

Quantum algorithms for combinatorial optimization

Vanessa Minouche Dehn

Combinatorial Optimization problems play an important role in various domains such as logis- tics, life science or the financial sector. As their complexity in general grows exponentially with their problem size, finding the optimal solution classically becomes infeasible very fast. This raises the central question of whether quantum computers are in principle suitable for solving combinatorial optimization problems better and faster than classical computers. In order to find answers to that question, one needs to study quantum algorithms designed for those problems under ideal conditions (i.e., simulations, which are however limited due to exponential scaling) to investigate their potential, but one also needs real quantum hardware to test its viability and evaluate whether practical advantages are reasonable. In this regard, we consider variational quantum algorithms, especially the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) consisting of a problem and a mixer Hamiltonian with freely selectable parameters, originally proposed as variational hybrid ansatz with classical optimization. This algorithm structure of- fers flexible and relatively shallow circuits, which makes it suitable for current NISQ hardware. However, optimizing the variational circuit parameters can be an NP-hard problem at worst. In this thesis, we study different versions of QAOA, especially with a focus on limitations, perfor- mance and potential advantages opposite classical methods. The first part of the thesis concerns the investigation of various aspects regarding the imple- mentation of the variational QAOA protocol such as: the incorporation of a problem constraint either by adding a suitable penalty term of by choosing a suitable mixer (that restricts the search space), the scaling of the problem Hamiltonian in comparison to the mixer Hamiltonian, the choice of the initial values for the classical optimization of the circuit parameters, and finally the choice of the function to be minimized (i.e., CVaR vs. expectation value). We apply this proto- col to both the portfolio optimization and the feature selection and evaluate the performance. In order to improve QAOA, we consider the warm-start QAOA for different problem instances and analyze its improved performance with regard to involved quantum effects. For this purpose, we propose a classical pre-processing method and demonstrate that the warm-start results can be reproduced or even exceeded by this method. The second part addresses the issue that the standard variational form requires a high number of circuit parameters that have to be optimized at a sufficiently large depth, which is a major limitationforachievingpotentialscalingadvantagescomparedtoclassicalmethods. Toovercome this limitation, we investigate and further develop fixed schedules for QAOA, which only rely on two free parameters. We start with introducing the continuous adiabatic theorem as it motivates the form of QAOA and show its limitations, which we address by applying a discrete version of the theorem. With our findings, a new version of QAOA based on linear-ramps (LR-QAOA) is introduced and further developed. In order to derive suitable parameter values for this schedule, we propose a method based on extrapolation from smaller towards larger problem sizes. With our results obtained on a noiseless emulator, we evaluate the quantum runtime scaling and discuss whether a scaling advantage can be achieved compared to classical methods.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

MG-Net: Learn to Customize QAOA with Circuit Depth Awareness

Yang Qian, Xinbiao Wang, Yuxuan Du +2 more

Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and its variants exhibit immense potential in tackling combinatorial optimization challenges. However, their practical realization confronts a dilemma: the requisite circuit depth for satisfactory performance is problem-specific and often exceeds the maximum capability of current quantum devices. To address this dilemma, here we first analyze the convergence behavior of QAOA, uncovering the origins of this dilemma and elucidating the intricate relationship between the employed mixer Hamiltonian, the specific problem at hand, and the permissible maximum circuit depth. Harnessing this understanding, we introduce the Mixer Generator Network (MG-Net), a unified deep learning framework adept at dynamically formulating optimal mixer Hamiltonians tailored to distinct tasks and circuit depths. Systematic simulations, encompassing Ising models and weighted Max-Cut instances with up to 64 qubits, substantiate our theoretical findings, highlighting MG-Net's superior performance in terms of both approximation ratio and efficiency.

arXiv:2409.18692•neural information processing systems•Jan 1, 2024•1 citation
This paper concerns quantum heuristics based on Mixer Hamiltonians that allow to restrict investigation on a specific subspace. Mixer Hamiltonian based approaches can be included in QAOA algorithm and we can state that Mixer Hamiltonians are mapping functions from the set of qubit-strings to the set of solutions. Mixer Hamiltonian offers an approach very similar to indirect representations commonly used in routing or in scheduling community for decades. After the initial publication of Cheng et al. in 1996 (Cheng et al., 1996), numerous propositions in OR lies on 1-to-n mapping functions, including the split algorithm that transform one TSP solution into a VRP solution. The objective is at first to give a compact and readable presentation of these Mixer Hamiltonians considering the functional analogies that exist between the OR community practices and the quantum field. Our experiments encompass numerical evaluations of circuit using the Qiskit library of IBM meeting the theoretical considerations.
This paper investigates quantum heuristics based on Mixer Hamiltonians, which allow the search to be restricted to a specific subspace and enable warm-start strategies for solving the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP). Approaches involving Mixer Hamiltonians can be integrated into the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), where the Mixer acts as a mapping function that transforms qubit strings into feasible solution sets. We first introduce a swap-based mixer tailored to the TSP, which ensures that only qubit strings representing valid TSP solutions are explored during the QAOA process. Second, we propose a warm-start technique that initializes QAOA with a solution generated by any classical heuristic, thereby promoting faster convergence. These two contributions are combined into a Warm-Start QAOA framework with a Swap-Based Mixer, leveraging both structural and initialization advantages. Experimental results on a custom TSP instance involving five customers demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, providing, for the first time, a viable integration of warm-start and swap-based mixers for the TSP within a quantum optimization framework.
Constructing effective mixer Hamiltonians is essential for enhancing the performance of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) in solving combinatorial optimization problems. In this work, we develop a systematic methodology for designing QAOA mixers that align with the symmetries of the classical objective function, with the goal of achieving values (mean, median, and minimum over multiple runs) that are closer to the true optimum. Our main idea is to design QAOA operators that are explicitly adapted to the action of symmetry groups on the Hilbert space. We focus on subgroups of the symmetric group$ S_{d},where, where,where d = 2^\ell,toensurecompatibilitywithqudit−basedquantumarchitectures.Inparticular,weconstructQAOAmixersinvariantunderthefullsymmetricgroup, to ensure compatibility with qudit-based quantum architectures. In particular, we construct QAOA mixers invariant under the full symmetric group,toensurecompatibilitywithqudit−basedquantumarchitectures.Inparticular,weconstructQAOAmixersinvariantunderthefullsymmetricgroup S_{d}aswellasitscyclicsubgroupas well as its cyclic subgroupaswellasitscyclicsubgroup \mathbb {Z}_{d} \subset S_{d}.TheseconstructionsarenaturalinthattheyrespectthedecompositionoftheHilbertspaceintoisotypiccomponentsunderthesymmetrygroupaction.Notably,tothebestofourknowledge,theQAOAalgorithmbasedonthe. These constructions are natural in that they respect the decomposition of the Hilbert space into isotypic components under the symmetry group action. Notably, to the best of our knowledge, the QAOA algorithm based on the.TheseconstructionsarenaturalinthattheyrespectthedecompositionoftheHilbertspaceintoisotypiccomponentsunderthesymmetrygroupaction.Notably,tothebestofourknowledge,theQAOAalgorithmbasedonthe \mathbb {Z}_{d}−invariantmixerprovidesthefirstexampleofaQAOAprotocolwhosedynamics(uptofinalmeasurement)areconfinedentirelywithinanontrivialirreduciblerepresentationofasymmetrygroupoftheobjectivefunction.Althoughourworkdoesnotinvestigatethebenefitsofexploitingsuchsubspacesascomputationalresources,wethinkthattheveryrealizationofavariationalalgorithmwhoseevolutionisrestrictedtoanontrivialsymmetry−adaptedsubspaceisoffundamentalconceptualinterest.Weprovideclosed−formexpressionsforthesemixers,togetherwithexplicitquantumcircuitimplementations.Toempiricallyevaluateourapproach,wecompareQAOAvariantsemployingthestandardmixer-invariant mixer provides the first example of a QAOA protocol whose dynamics (up to final measurement) are confined entirely within a nontrivial irreducible representation of a symmetry group of the objective function. Although our work does not investigate the benefits of exploiting such subspaces as computational resources, we think that the very realization of a variational algorithm whose evolution is restricted to a nontrivial symmetry-adapted subspace is of fundamental conceptual interest. We provide closed-form expressions for these mixers, together with explicit quantum circuit implementations. To empirically evaluate our approach, we compare QAOA variants employing the standard mixer−invariantmixerprovidesthefirstexampleofaQAOAprotocolwhosedynamics(uptofinalmeasurement)areconfinedentirelywithinanontrivialirreduciblerepresentationofasymmetrygroupoftheobjectivefunction.Althoughourworkdoesnotinvestigatethebenefitsofexploitingsuchsubspacesascomputationalresources,wethinkthattheveryrealizationofavariationalalgorithmwhoseevolutionisrestrictedtoanontrivialsymmetry−adaptedsubspaceisoffundamentalconceptualinterest.Weprovideclosed−formexpressionsforthesemixers,togetherwithexplicitquantumcircuitimplementations.Toempiricallyevaluateourapproach,wecompareQAOAvariantsemployingthestandardmixerB = \sum X_{i}withthoseusingourproposedHamiltonianswith those using our proposed HamiltonianswiththoseusingourproposedHamiltoniansH_{M}andandandH_\chi$on edge coloring and graph partitioning problems. Across multiple graph instances, our symmetry-adapted mixers consistently yield objective values closer to the optimum, demonstrating statistically significant improvements over classical baselines.
The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is an algorithmic framework for finding approximate solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. It consists of interleaved unitary transformations induced by two operators labelled the mixing and problem Hamiltonians. To fit this framework, one needs to transform the original problem into a suitable form and embed it into these two Hamiltonians. In this paper, for the well-known NP-hard Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), we encode its constraints into the mixing Hamiltonian rather than the conventional approach of adding penalty terms to the problem Hamiltonian. Moreover, we map edges (routes) connecting each pair of cities to qubits, which decreases the search space significantly in comparison to other approaches. As a result, our method can achieve a higher probability for the shortest round-trip route with only half the number of qubits consumed compared to IBM Q’s approach. We argue the formalization approach presented in this paper would lead to a generalized framework for finding, in the context of QAOA, high-quality approximate solutions to NP optimization problems.
Quantum optimization algorithms, such as the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA), are emerging as promising heuristics for solving complex combinatorial problems. To improve performance, several extensions to the standard QAOA framework have been proposed in recent years. Two notable directions include: warm-starting techniques, which incorporate classical approximate solutions to guide the quantum evolution, and custom mixer Hamiltonians, such asXYXYXYmixers, which constrain the search to feasible subspaces aligned with the structure of the problem. In this work, we propose an approach that integrates these two strategies: a warm-start initialization with anXYXYXYmixer ansatz, enabling constraint, preserving quantum evolution biased toward high-quality classical solutions. The method begins by reformulating the combinatorial problem as a MaxCut instance, solved approximately using the Goemans-Williamson algorithm. The resulting binary solution is relaxed and used to construct a biased superposition over one-hot quantum states that preserves the Hamming weight 1, maintaining compatibility with theXYXYXYmixers constraints. We evaluate the approach on 5-city instances of the Traveling Salesperson Problem, a canonical optimization problem frequently encountered as a subroutine in real-world route planning problems. Our method is benchmarked against both the standardXYXYXY-mixer QAOA and a warm-start-only variant based on MaxCut relaxation. Results show that the proposed combination consistently outperforms both baselines in terms of the percentage and rank of optimal solutions, demonstrating the effectiveness of combining structured initializations with constraint-aware quantum evolution for optimization problems.
Combinatorial Optimization problems play an important role in various domains such as logis- tics, life science or the financial sector. As their complexity in general grows exponentially with their problem size, finding the optimal solution classically becomes infeasible very fast. This raises the central question of whether quantum computers are in principle suitable for solving combinatorial optimization problems better and faster than classical computers. In order to find answers to that question, one needs to study quantum algorithms designed for those problems under ideal conditions (i.e., simulations, which are however limited due to exponential scaling) to investigate their potential, but one also needs real quantum hardware to test its viability and evaluate whether practical advantages are reasonable. In this regard, we consider variational quantum algorithms, especially the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) consisting of a problem and a mixer Hamiltonian with freely selectable parameters, originally proposed as variational hybrid ansatz with classical optimization. This algorithm structure of- fers flexible and relatively shallow circuits, which makes it suitable for current NISQ hardware. However, optimizing the variational circuit parameters can be an NP-hard problem at worst. In this thesis, we study different versions of QAOA, especially with a focus on limitations, perfor- mance and potential advantages opposite classical methods. The first part of the thesis concerns the investigation of various aspects regarding the imple- mentation of the variational QAOA protocol such as: the incorporation of a problem constraint either by adding a suitable penalty term of by choosing a suitable mixer (that restricts the search space), the scaling of the problem Hamiltonian in comparison to the mixer Hamiltonian, the choice of the initial values for the classical optimization of the circuit parameters, and finally the choice of the function to be minimized (i.e., CVaR vs. expectation value). We apply this proto- col to both the portfolio optimization and the feature selection and evaluate the performance. In order to improve QAOA, we consider the warm-start QAOA for different problem instances and analyze its improved performance with regard to involved quantum effects. For this purpose, we propose a classical pre-processing method and demonstrate that the warm-start results can be reproduced or even exceeded by this method. The second part addresses the issue that the standard variational form requires a high number of circuit parameters that have to be optimized at a sufficiently large depth, which is a major limitationforachievingpotentialscalingadvantagescomparedtoclassicalmethods. Toovercome this limitation, we investigate and further develop fixed schedules for QAOA, which only rely on two free parameters. We start with introducing the continuous adiabatic theorem as it motivates the form of QAOA and show its limitations, which we address by applying a discrete version of the theorem. With our findings, a new version of QAOA based on linear-ramps (LR-QAOA) is introduced and further developed. In order to derive suitable parameter values for this schedule, we propose a method based on extrapolation from smaller towards larger problem sizes. With our results obtained on a noiseless emulator, we evaluate the quantum runtime scaling and discuss whether a scaling advantage can be achieved compared to classical methods.
Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and its variants exhibit immense potential in tackling combinatorial optimization challenges. However, their practical realization confronts a dilemma: the requisite circuit depth for satisfactory performance is problem-specific and often exceeds the maximum capability of current quantum devices. To address this dilemma, here we first analyze the convergence behavior of QAOA, uncovering the origins of this dilemma and elucidating the intricate relationship between the employed mixer Hamiltonian, the specific problem at hand, and the permissible maximum circuit depth. Harnessing this understanding, we introduce the Mixer Generator Network (MG-Net), a unified deep learning framework adept at dynamically formulating optimal mixer Hamiltonians tailored to distinct tasks and circuit depths. Systematic simulations, encompassing Ising models and weighted Max-Cut instances with up to 64 qubits, substantiate our theoretical findings, highlighting MG-Net's superior performance in terms of both approximation ratio and efficiency.