Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2206.02304 · Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics

Variational approach to quantum state tomography based on maximal entropy formalism

Rishabh Gupta, Manas Sajjan, Raphael David Levine, Sabre Kais

Published Jan 1, 2022• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum state tomography is an integral part of quantum computation and offers the starting point for the validation of various quantum devices. One of the central tasks in the field of state tomography is to reconstruct, with high fidelity, the quantum states of a quantum system. From an experiment on a real quantum device, one can obtain the mean measurement values of different operators. With such data as input, in this report we employ the maximal entropy formalism to construct the least biased mixed quantum state that is consistent with the given set of expectation values. Even though, in principle, the reported formalism is quite general and should work for an arbitrary set of observables, in practice we shall demonstrate the efficacy of the algorithm on an informationally complete (IC) set of Hermitian operators. Such a set possesses the advantage of uniquely specifying a single quantum state from which the experimental measurements have been sampled and hence renders the rare opportunity not only to construct a least-biased quantum state but even replicate the exact state prepared experimentally within a preset tolerance. The primary workhorse of the algorithm is reconstructing an energy function which we designate as the effective Hamiltonian of the system, and parameterizing it with Lagrange multipliers, according to the formalism of maximal entropy. These parameters are thereafter optimized variationally so that the reconstructed quantum state of the system converges to the true quantum state within an error threshold. To this end, we employ a parameterized quantum circuit and a hybrid quantum-classical variational algorithm to obtain such a target state, making our recipe easily implementable on a near-term quantum device.

DOI
10.1039/d2cp04493e

Related papers

Maximal Entropy Approach for Quantum State Tomography

Rishabh Gupta, Rongxin Xia, Raphael David Levine +1 more

Quantum computation has been growing rapidly in both theory and experiments.In particular, quantum computing devices with a large number of qubits have been developed by IBM, Google, IonQ, and others.The current quantum computing devices are noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, and so approaches to validate quantum processing on these quantum devices are needed.One of the most common ways of validation for an n-qubit quantum system is quantum tomography, which tries to reconstruct a quantum system's density matrix by a complete set of observables.However, the inherent noise in the quantum systems and the intrinsic limitations pose a critical challenge to precisely know the actual measurement operators that make quantum tomography impractical in experiments.Here, we propose an alternative approach to quantum tomography, based on the maximal information entropy, that can predict the values of unknown observables based on the available mean measurement data.This can then be used to reconstruct the density matrix with high fidelity even though the results for some observables are missing.Of additional contexts, a practical approach to the inference of the quantum mechanical state using only partial information is also needed.

arXiv:2009.00815•PRX Quantum•Feb 2, 2021•36 citations

Convergence of a Reconstructed Density Matrix to a Pure State Using the Maximal Entropy Approach

Rishabh Gupta, Raphael David Levine, Sabre Kais

Impressive progress has been made in the past decade in the study of technological applications of varied types of quantum systems. With industry giants like IBM laying down their roadmap for scalable quantum devices with more than 1000-qubits by the end of 2023, efficient validation techniques are also being developed for testing quantum processing on these devices. The characterization of a quantum state is done by experimental measurements through the process called quantum state tomography (QST) which scales exponentially with the size of the system. However, QST performed using incomplete measurements is aptly suited for characterizing these quantum technologies especially with the current nature of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices where not all mean measurements are available with high fidelity. We, hereby, propose an alternative approach to QST for the complete reconstruction of the density matrix of a quantum system in a pure state for any number of qubits by applying the maximal entropy formalism on the pairwise combinations of the known mean measurements. This approach provides the best estimate of the target state when we know the complete set of observables, which is the case of convergence of the reconstructed density matrix to a pure state. Our goal is to provide a practical inference of a quantum system in a pure state that can find its applications in the field of quantum error mitigation on a real quantum computer that we intend to investigate further.

arXiv:2107.01191•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Aug 19, 2021•18 citations

Maximal Entropy Formalism and the Restricted Boltzmann Machine

Vinit Singh, Rishabh Gupta, Manas Sajjan +3 more

The connection between the maximum entropy (MaxEnt) formalism and restricted Boltzmann machines (RBMs) is natural as both give rise to a Boltzmann-like distribution with constraints enforced by Lagrange multipliers, which correspond to RBM parameters. We integrate RBMs into quantum state tomography by using them as probabilistic models to approximate quantum states while satisfying MaxEnt constraints. Additionally, we employ polynomially efficient quantum sampling techniques to enhance RBM training, enabling scalable and high-fidelity quantum state reconstruction. This approach provides a computationally efficient framework for applying RBMs to MaxEnt-based quantum tomography. Furthermore, our method applies to the general and previously unaddressed case of reconstructing arbitrary mixed quantum states from incomplete and potentially noncommuting sets of expectations of observables while still ensuring maximal entropy.

arXiv:2504.03634•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Jun 10, 2025•6 citations

Quantum State Tomography via Variational Quantum Algorithms

Jincheng Zhang

Quantum state tomography (QST) is a fundamental technique in quantum information science, aiming to reconstruct the density matrix of an unknown quantum state from experimental measurements. However, traditional QST methods often suffer from significant computational demands and are highly susceptible to measurement noise, hindering their practical application, particularly with near-term quantum computers. This work proposes a novel approach to QST utilizing variational quantum algorithms (VQAs). VQAs iteratively optimize a parameterized quantum circuit to minimize a cost function related to the fidelity between the desired state and the state predicted by the circuit. This approach dramatically reduces the number of required measurements and offers the potential for achieving high-fidelity state reconstruction with lower quantum resource requirements. We detail the theoretical framework, outlining the core algorithms and mathematical formulations. The key advantage lies in the ability to learn the state directly, mitigating the limitations of traditional methods. We explore the optimization landscape and discuss strategies for improving convergence and robustness. The results demonstrate a promising path toward scalable and robust QST on quantum devices.

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

Parametrized Variational Quantum Tomography

V. A. Penas, M. Losada, D. Tielas +1 more

Quantum state tomography provides a fundamental framework for reconstructing quantum states. When the measurement data are not informationally complete, the observed statistics admit multiple compatible density matrices, making the reconstruction problem inherently underdetermined and calling for the selection of a meaningful estimator. Two well-established approaches to address this ambiguity are Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt) and Variational Quantum Tomography (VQT). A variant of VQT, named VQT$_\infty$, has been introduced to reproduce MaxEnt-like solutions. In this work, we generalize this approach by introducing a parametrized cost function that interpolates between the 1-norm and the infinity norm, thereby unifying VQT and VQT$_\infty$ within a single framework. By tuning the associated hyperparameters, the proposed method enables controlled exploration of the set of compatible density matrices. We show that this interplay yields reconstructed states with higher fidelity to the MaxEnt solution than those obtained via VQT$_\infty$ while preserving computational tractability.

quant-pharXiv:2604.27135•May 1, 2026•0 citations

Experimental Quantum State Tomography via Compressed Sampling

Wei-Tao Liu, Ting Zhang, Jiying Liu +2 more

A fundamental difficulty in demonstrating quantum state tomography is that the required resources grow exponentially with the system size. For pure states and nearly pure states, the task of tomography can be more efficient. We proposed two methods for state reconstruction, by (1) minimizing entropy and (2) maximizing likelihood. The algorithm of compressed sampling is employed to solve the optimization problem. Experiments are demonstrated considering 4-qubit photonic states. The results show that (1) much fewer measurements than the standard tomography are sufficient to obtain high fidelity, and (2) the method of maximizing likelihood is more accurate and noise robust than the original reconstruction method of compressed sampling. Furthermore, the physical meaning of the methods of minimizing entropy and maximizing likelihood is clear.

Physical Review Letters•Apr 24, 2012•84 citations
Quantum state tomography is an integral part of quantum computation and offers the starting point for the validation of various quantum devices. One of the central tasks in the field of state tomography is to reconstruct, with high fidelity, the quantum states of a quantum system. From an experiment on a real quantum device, one can obtain the mean measurement values of different operators. With such data as input, in this report we employ the maximal entropy formalism to construct the least biased mixed quantum state that is consistent with the given set of expectation values. Even though, in principle, the reported formalism is quite general and should work for an arbitrary set of observables, in practice we shall demonstrate the efficacy of the algorithm on an informationally complete (IC) set of Hermitian operators. Such a set possesses the advantage of uniquely specifying a single quantum state from which the experimental measurements have been sampled and hence renders the rare opportunity not only to construct a least-biased quantum state but even replicate the exact state prepared experimentally within a preset tolerance. The primary workhorse of the algorithm is reconstructing an energy function which we designate as the effective Hamiltonian of the system, and parameterizing it with Lagrange multipliers, according to the formalism of maximal entropy. These parameters are thereafter optimized variationally so that the reconstructed quantum state of the system converges to the true quantum state within an error threshold. To this end, we employ a parameterized quantum circuit and a hybrid quantum-classical variational algorithm to obtain such a target state, making our recipe easily implementable on a near-term quantum device.
Quantum computation has been growing rapidly in both theory and experiments.In particular, quantum computing devices with a large number of qubits have been developed by IBM, Google, IonQ, and others.The current quantum computing devices are noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, and so approaches to validate quantum processing on these quantum devices are needed.One of the most common ways of validation for an n-qubit quantum system is quantum tomography, which tries to reconstruct a quantum system's density matrix by a complete set of observables.However, the inherent noise in the quantum systems and the intrinsic limitations pose a critical challenge to precisely know the actual measurement operators that make quantum tomography impractical in experiments.Here, we propose an alternative approach to quantum tomography, based on the maximal information entropy, that can predict the values of unknown observables based on the available mean measurement data.This can then be used to reconstruct the density matrix with high fidelity even though the results for some observables are missing.Of additional contexts, a practical approach to the inference of the quantum mechanical state using only partial information is also needed.
Impressive progress has been made in the past decade in the study of technological applications of varied types of quantum systems. With industry giants like IBM laying down their roadmap for scalable quantum devices with more than 1000-qubits by the end of 2023, efficient validation techniques are also being developed for testing quantum processing on these devices. The characterization of a quantum state is done by experimental measurements through the process called quantum state tomography (QST) which scales exponentially with the size of the system. However, QST performed using incomplete measurements is aptly suited for characterizing these quantum technologies especially with the current nature of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices where not all mean measurements are available with high fidelity. We, hereby, propose an alternative approach to QST for the complete reconstruction of the density matrix of a quantum system in a pure state for any number of qubits by applying the maximal entropy formalism on the pairwise combinations of the known mean measurements. This approach provides the best estimate of the target state when we know the complete set of observables, which is the case of convergence of the reconstructed density matrix to a pure state. Our goal is to provide a practical inference of a quantum system in a pure state that can find its applications in the field of quantum error mitigation on a real quantum computer that we intend to investigate further.
The connection between the maximum entropy (MaxEnt) formalism and restricted Boltzmann machines (RBMs) is natural as both give rise to a Boltzmann-like distribution with constraints enforced by Lagrange multipliers, which correspond to RBM parameters. We integrate RBMs into quantum state tomography by using them as probabilistic models to approximate quantum states while satisfying MaxEnt constraints. Additionally, we employ polynomially efficient quantum sampling techniques to enhance RBM training, enabling scalable and high-fidelity quantum state reconstruction. This approach provides a computationally efficient framework for applying RBMs to MaxEnt-based quantum tomography. Furthermore, our method applies to the general and previously unaddressed case of reconstructing arbitrary mixed quantum states from incomplete and potentially noncommuting sets of expectations of observables while still ensuring maximal entropy.
Quantum state tomography (QST) is a fundamental technique in quantum information science, aiming to reconstruct the density matrix of an unknown quantum state from experimental measurements. However, traditional QST methods often suffer from significant computational demands and are highly susceptible to measurement noise, hindering their practical application, particularly with near-term quantum computers. This work proposes a novel approach to QST utilizing variational quantum algorithms (VQAs). VQAs iteratively optimize a parameterized quantum circuit to minimize a cost function related to the fidelity between the desired state and the state predicted by the circuit. This approach dramatically reduces the number of required measurements and offers the potential for achieving high-fidelity state reconstruction with lower quantum resource requirements. We detail the theoretical framework, outlining the core algorithms and mathematical formulations. The key advantage lies in the ability to learn the state directly, mitigating the limitations of traditional methods. We explore the optimization landscape and discuss strategies for improving convergence and robustness. The results demonstrate a promising path toward scalable and robust QST on quantum devices.
Quantum state tomography provides a fundamental framework for reconstructing quantum states. When the measurement data are not informationally complete, the observed statistics admit multiple compatible density matrices, making the reconstruction problem inherently underdetermined and calling for the selection of a meaningful estimator. Two well-established approaches to address this ambiguity are Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt) and Variational Quantum Tomography (VQT). A variant of VQT, named VQT∞_\infty∞​, has been introduced to reproduce MaxEnt-like solutions. In this work, we generalize this approach by introducing a parametrized cost function that interpolates between the 1-norm and the infinity norm, thereby unifying VQT and VQT∞_\infty∞​ within a single framework. By tuning the associated hyperparameters, the proposed method enables controlled exploration of the set of compatible density matrices. We show that this interplay yields reconstructed states with higher fidelity to the MaxEnt solution than those obtained via VQT∞_\infty∞​ while preserving computational tractability.
A fundamental difficulty in demonstrating quantum state tomography is that the required resources grow exponentially with the system size. For pure states and nearly pure states, the task of tomography can be more efficient. We proposed two methods for state reconstruction, by (1) minimizing entropy and (2) maximizing likelihood. The algorithm of compressed sampling is employed to solve the optimization problem. Experiments are demonstrated considering 4-qubit photonic states. The results show that (1) much fewer measurements than the standard tomography are sufficient to obtain high fidelity, and (2) the method of maximizing likelihood is more accurate and noise robust than the original reconstruction method of compressed sampling. Furthermore, the physical meaning of the methods of minimizing entropy and maximizing likelihood is clear.