Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.12767 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Variational thermal quantum simulation of the lattice Schwinger model

Xu-Dan Xie, Xingyu Guo, Hongxi Xing, Zheng‐Yuan Xue, Dan-Bo Zhang, Shi-Liang Zhu

Published Sep 21, 2022• 42 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Confinement of quarks due to the strong interaction and the deconfinement at high temperatures and high densities are a basic paradigm for understanding the nuclear matter. Their simulation, however, is very challenging for classical computers due to the sign problem of solving equilibrium states of finite-temperature quantum chromodynamical systems at finite density. In this paper, we propose a variational approach, using the lattice Schwinger model, to simulate the confinement or deconfinement by investigating the string tension. We adopt an ansatz that the string tension can be evaluated without referring to quantum protocols for measuring the entropy in the free energy. Results of numeral simulation show that the string tension decreases both along the increasing of the temperature and the chemical potential, which can be an analog of the phase diagram of QCD. Through numerical simulations on the classical computer, we demonstrate the potential of exploiting near-term quantum computers for investigating the phase diagram of finite-temperature and finite-density nuclear matters.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.106.054509

Related papers

The phase diagram of quantum chromodynamics in one dimension on a quantum computer

Anton T. Than, Y. Y. Atas, A. Chakraborty +8 more

The quantum chromodynamics (QCD) phase diagram, which reveals the state of strongly interacting matter at different temperatures and densities, is key to answering open questions in physics, ranging from the behaviour of particles in neutron stars to the conditions of the early universe. However, classical simulations of QCD face significant computational barriers, such as the sign problem at finite matter densities. Quantum computing offers a promising solution to overcome these challenges. Here, we take an important step toward exploring the QCD phase diagram with quantum devices by preparing thermal states in one-dimensional non-Abelian gauge theories. We experimentally simulate the thermal states of SU(2) and SU(3) gauge theories at finite densities on a trapped-ion quantum computer using a variational method. This is achieved by introducing two features: Firstly, we add motional ancillae to the existing qubit register to efficiently prepare thermal probability distributions. Secondly, we introduce charge-singlet measurements to enforce colour-neutrality constraints. This work pioneers the quantum simulation of QCD at finite density and temperature for two and three colours, laying the foundation to explore QCD phenomena on quantum platforms. Quantum simulations of the phase diagram of quantum chromodynamics faces hard challenges, such as having to prepare mixed states and enforcing the non-Abelian gauge symmetry constraints. Here, the authors show how to solve the two above problems in a trapped-ion device using motional ancillae and charge-singlet measurements.

arXiv:2501.00579•Nature Communications•Nov 21, 2025•67 citations

Hamiltonian simulation of the Schwinger model at finite temperature

Boye Buyens, Frank Verstraete, Karel Van Acoleyen

Using matrix product operators, the Schwinger model is simulated in thermal equilibrium. The variational manifold of gauge-invariant matrix product operators is constructed to represent Gibbs states. As a first application, the chiral condensate in thermal equilibrium is computed, and agreement with earlier studies is found. Furthermore, as a new application, the Schwinger model is probed with a fractional charged static quark-antiquark pair separated infinitely far from each other. A critical temperature beyond which the string tension is exponentially suppressed is found and is in qualitative agreement with analytical studies in the strong coupling limit. Finally, the $CT$ symmetry breaking is investigated, and our results strongly suggest that the symmetry is restored at any nonzero temperature.

arXiv:1606.03385•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 21, 2016•94 citations

Variational Quantum Simulation of the Interacting Schwinger Model on a Trapped-Ion Quantum Processor

Melzer, Christian, Schuster, Stephan, Diego Olvera Millán +4 more

Simulations in high-energy physics are currently emerging as an application of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers. In this work, we explore the multi-flavor lattice Schwinger model - a toy model inspired by quantum chromodynamics - in one spatial dimension and with nonzero chemical potential by means of variational quantum simulation on a shuttling-based trapped-ion quantum processor. This fermionic problem becomes intractable for classical numerical methods even for small system sizes due to the notorious sign problem. We employ a parametric quantum circuit executed on our quantum processor to identify ground states in different parameter regimes of the model, mapping out a quantum phase transition which is the hallmark feature of the model. The resulting states are analyzed via quantum state tomography, to reveal how characteristic properties such as correlations in the output state change across the phase transition. Moreover, we use the results to determine the phase boundaries of the model.

arXiv:2504.20824•Apr 29, 2025•3 citations

Schwinger model at finite temperature and density with beta VQE

Akio Tomiya

We investigate a quantum gauge theory at finite temperature and density using a variational algorithm for near-term quantum devices. We adapt $β$-VQE to evaluate thermal and quantum expectation values and study the phase diagram for massless Schwinger model along with the temperature and density. By compering the exact variational free energy, we find the variational algorithm work for $T>0$ and $μ>0$ for the Schwinger model. No significant volume dependence of the variational free energy is observed in $μ/g \in[0, 1.4]$. We calculate the chiral condensate and take the continuum extrapolation. As a result, we obtain qualitative picture of the phase diagram for massless Schwinger model.

arXiv:2205.08860•May 18, 2022•17 citations

T-mu phase diagram using classical-quantum hybrid algorithm

Akio Tomiya

We study the Schwinger model at finite temperature and density using a variational algorithm for near-term quantum devices. We adapt $\beta$-VQE, a classical-quantum hybrid algorithm with a neural network, to evaluate thermal and quantum expectation values and study the phase diagram for the massless Schwinger model along with the temperature and density. By comparing the exact variational free energy, we find that the variational algorithm works for the Schwinger model for $T>0$ and $\mu$>0. As a result, we obtain a qualitative picture of the phase diagram for the massless Schwinger model.

International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory (LATTICE)•Jan 6, 2023•1 citation

Variational quantum simulation of the quantum critical regime

Zhi-Quan Shi, Xu-Dan Xie, Dan-Bo Zhang

The quantum critical regime marks a zone in the phase diagram where quantum fluctuation around the critical point plays a significant role at finite temperatures. While it is of great physical interest, simulation of the quantum critical regime can be difficult on a classical computer due to its intrinsic complexity. Herein, we propose a variational approach, which minimizes the variational free energy, to simulate and locate the quantum critical regime on a quantum computer. The variational quantum algorithm adopts an ansatz by performing an unitary operator on a product of a single-qubit mixed state, in which the entropy can be analytically obtained from the initial state, and thus the free energy can be accessed conveniently. With numeral simulation, using the one-dimensional Kitaev model as a demonstration we show that the quantum critical regime can be identified by accurately evaluating the temperature crossover line. Moreover, the dependencies of both the correlation length and the phase coherence time with temperature are evaluated for the thermal states. Our work suggests a practical way as well as a first step for investigating quantum critical systems at finite temperatures on quantum devices with few qubits.

arXiv:2302.07438•Chinese Physics B•Apr 7, 2023•0 citations
Confinement of quarks due to the strong interaction and the deconfinement at high temperatures and high densities are a basic paradigm for understanding the nuclear matter. Their simulation, however, is very challenging for classical computers due to the sign problem of solving equilibrium states of finite-temperature quantum chromodynamical systems at finite density. In this paper, we propose a variational approach, using the lattice Schwinger model, to simulate the confinement or deconfinement by investigating the string tension. We adopt an ansatz that the string tension can be evaluated without referring to quantum protocols for measuring the entropy in the free energy. Results of numeral simulation show that the string tension decreases both along the increasing of the temperature and the chemical potential, which can be an analog of the phase diagram of QCD. Through numerical simulations on the classical computer, we demonstrate the potential of exploiting near-term quantum computers for investigating the phase diagram of finite-temperature and finite-density nuclear matters.
The quantum chromodynamics (QCD) phase diagram, which reveals the state of strongly interacting matter at different temperatures and densities, is key to answering open questions in physics, ranging from the behaviour of particles in neutron stars to the conditions of the early universe. However, classical simulations of QCD face significant computational barriers, such as the sign problem at finite matter densities. Quantum computing offers a promising solution to overcome these challenges. Here, we take an important step toward exploring the QCD phase diagram with quantum devices by preparing thermal states in one-dimensional non-Abelian gauge theories. We experimentally simulate the thermal states of SU(2) and SU(3) gauge theories at finite densities on a trapped-ion quantum computer using a variational method. This is achieved by introducing two features: Firstly, we add motional ancillae to the existing qubit register to efficiently prepare thermal probability distributions. Secondly, we introduce charge-singlet measurements to enforce colour-neutrality constraints. This work pioneers the quantum simulation of QCD at finite density and temperature for two and three colours, laying the foundation to explore QCD phenomena on quantum platforms. Quantum simulations of the phase diagram of quantum chromodynamics faces hard challenges, such as having to prepare mixed states and enforcing the non-Abelian gauge symmetry constraints. Here, the authors show how to solve the two above problems in a trapped-ion device using motional ancillae and charge-singlet measurements.
Using matrix product operators, the Schwinger model is simulated in thermal equilibrium. The variational manifold of gauge-invariant matrix product operators is constructed to represent Gibbs states. As a first application, the chiral condensate in thermal equilibrium is computed, and agreement with earlier studies is found. Furthermore, as a new application, the Schwinger model is probed with a fractional charged static quark-antiquark pair separated infinitely far from each other. A critical temperature beyond which the string tension is exponentially suppressed is found and is in qualitative agreement with analytical studies in the strong coupling limit. Finally, the CTCTCT symmetry breaking is investigated, and our results strongly suggest that the symmetry is restored at any nonzero temperature.
Simulations in high-energy physics are currently emerging as an application of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers. In this work, we explore the multi-flavor lattice Schwinger model - a toy model inspired by quantum chromodynamics - in one spatial dimension and with nonzero chemical potential by means of variational quantum simulation on a shuttling-based trapped-ion quantum processor. This fermionic problem becomes intractable for classical numerical methods even for small system sizes due to the notorious sign problem. We employ a parametric quantum circuit executed on our quantum processor to identify ground states in different parameter regimes of the model, mapping out a quantum phase transition which is the hallmark feature of the model. The resulting states are analyzed via quantum state tomography, to reveal how characteristic properties such as correlations in the output state change across the phase transition. Moreover, we use the results to determine the phase boundaries of the model.
We investigate a quantum gauge theory at finite temperature and density using a variational algorithm for near-term quantum devices. We adapt βββ-VQE to evaluate thermal and quantum expectation values and study the phase diagram for massless Schwinger model along with the temperature and density. By compering the exact variational free energy, we find the variational algorithm work for T>0T>0T>0 and μ>0μ>0μ>0 for the Schwinger model. No significant volume dependence of the variational free energy is observed in μ/g∈[0,1.4]μ/g \in[0, 1.4]μ/g∈[0,1.4]. We calculate the chiral condensate and take the continuum extrapolation. As a result, we obtain qualitative picture of the phase diagram for massless Schwinger model.
We study the Schwinger model at finite temperature and density using a variational algorithm for near-term quantum devices. We adapt β\betaβ-VQE, a classical-quantum hybrid algorithm with a neural network, to evaluate thermal and quantum expectation values and study the phase diagram for the massless Schwinger model along with the temperature and density. By comparing the exact variational free energy, we find that the variational algorithm works for the Schwinger model for T>0T>0T>0 and μ\muμ>0. As a result, we obtain a qualitative picture of the phase diagram for the massless Schwinger model.
The quantum critical regime marks a zone in the phase diagram where quantum fluctuation around the critical point plays a significant role at finite temperatures. While it is of great physical interest, simulation of the quantum critical regime can be difficult on a classical computer due to its intrinsic complexity. Herein, we propose a variational approach, which minimizes the variational free energy, to simulate and locate the quantum critical regime on a quantum computer. The variational quantum algorithm adopts an ansatz by performing an unitary operator on a product of a single-qubit mixed state, in which the entropy can be analytically obtained from the initial state, and thus the free energy can be accessed conveniently. With numeral simulation, using the one-dimensional Kitaev model as a demonstration we show that the quantum critical regime can be identified by accurately evaluating the temperature crossover line. Moreover, the dependencies of both the correlation length and the phase coherence time with temperature are evaluated for the thermal states. Our work suggests a practical way as well as a first step for investigating quantum critical systems at finite temperatures on quantum devices with few qubits.