Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.02508 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Tensor network investigation of the hard-square model

Samuel Nyckees, Frédéric Mila

Published Nov 28, 2022• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group to contract the tensor network that describes its partition function, we investigate the nature of the phase transitions of the hard-square model, one of the exactly solved models of statistical physics for which Baxter has found an integrable manifold. The motivation is twofold: assess the power of tensor networks for such models, and probe the 2D classical analog of a 1D quantum model of hard-core bosons that has recently attracted significant attention in the context of experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. Accordingly, we concentrate on two planes in the 3D parameter space spanned by the activity and the coupling constants in the two diagonal directions. We first investigate the only case studied so far with Monte Carlo simulations, the case of opposite coupling constants. We confirm that, away and not too far from the integrable 3-state Potts point, the transition out of the period-3 phase appears to be unique in the Huse-Fisher chiral universality class, albeit with significantly different exponents as compared to Monte Carlo. We also identify two additional phase transitions not reported so far for that model, a Lifshitz disorder line, and an Ising transition for large enough activity. To make contact with 1D quantum models of Rydberg atoms, we then turn to a plane where the ferromagnetic coupling is kept fixed, and we show that the resulting phase diagram is very similar, the only difference being that the Ising transition becomes first-order through a tricritical Ising point, in agreement with Baxter's prediction that this plane should contain a tricritical Ising point, and in remarkable, almost quantitative agreement with the phase diagram of the 1D quantum version of the model.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.106.174433

Related papers

Identifying the Huse-Fisher universality class of the three-state chiral Potts model

Samuel Nyckees, Jeanne Colbois, Frédéric Mila

Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group approach, we revisit the three-state chiral Potts model on the square lattice, a model proposed in the eighties to describe commensurate-incommensurate transitions at surfaces, and with direct relevance to recent experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. This model was suggested by Huse and Fisher to have a chiral transition in the vicinity of the Potts point, a possibility that turned out to be very difficult to definitely establish or refute numerically. Our results confirm that the transition changes character at a Lifshitz point that separates a line of Pokrosky-Talapov transitions far enough from the Potts point from a line of direct continuous order-disorder transition close to it. Thanks to the accuracy of the numerical results, we have been able to base the analysis entirely on effective exponents to deal with the crossovers that have hampered previous numerical investigations. The emerging picture is that of a new universality class with exponents that do not change between the Potts point and the Lifshitz point, and that appear to be consistent with those of a self-dual version of the model, namely correlation lengths exponents νx=2/3 in the direction of the asymmetry and νy=1 perpendicular to it, an incommensurability exponent β¯=2/3, a specific heat exponent that keeps the value α=1/3 of the three-state Potts model, and a dynamical exponent z=3/2. These results are in excellent agreement with experimental results obtained on reconstructed surfaces in the nineties, and shed light on recent Kibble-Zurek experiments on the period-3 phase of chains of Rydberg atoms.

arXiv:2008.08408•Nuclear Physics B•Mar 5, 2021•10 citations

Blume-Emery-Griffiths-Potts model in two dimensions: Phase diagram and critical properties from a position-space renormalization group

A. Nihat Berker, Michael Wortis

The spin-1 Ising model on the square lattice with nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic exchange interactions [both bilinear ($J$) and biquadratic ($K$) and crystal-field interaction ($\ensuremath{\Delta}$) is studied via a renormalization-group transformation in position space. The phase diagram in $J$, $K$, $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ space is found to have one surface of critical phase transitions and two surfaces of first-order phase transitions. These surfaces are variously bounded by an ordinary tricritical line, an isolated critical line, and a line of critical end points. These three lines joint at a special tricritical point corresponding to the transition of the three-state Potts model. The over-all phase diagram is qualitatively similar to that obtained with the mean-field approximation, except in the vicinity of the Potts transition where a four-phase coexistence line in mean-field theory shrinks into a special tricritical point in renormalization-group theory. Symmetry considerations guide the construction of our truncated renormalization-group transformation. The global connectivity and local exponents of the thirteen separate fixed points underlying this quite complicated structure are determined. Local analysis with respect to magnetic field ($H$) and another odd interaction ($L$) is performed. A one-adjusted-parameter version of our transformation yields remarkably quantitative results, predicting the Potts transition temperature, for example, within 0.3% of the exact value.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Dec 1, 1976•370 citations

Tricriticality in crossed Ising chains

Tyler Cary, Rajiv R. P. Singh, Richard T. Scalettar

We explore the phase diagram of Ising spins on one-dimensional chains that criss-cross in two perpendicular directions and that are connected by interchain couplings. This system is of interest as a simpler, classical analog of a quantum Hamiltonian that has been proposed as a model of magnetic behavior in Nb_{12}O_{29} and also, conceptually, as a geometry that is intermediate between one and two dimensions. Using mean-field theory as well as Metropolis Monte Carlo and Wang-Landau simulations, we locate quantitatively the boundaries of four ordered phases. Each becomes an effective Ising model with unique effective couplings at large interchain coupling. Away from this limit, we demonstrate nontrivial critical behavior, including tricritical points that separate first- and second-order phase transitions. Finally, we present evidence that this model belongs to the two-dimensional Ising universality class.

arXiv:1608.02974•Physical review. E•Oct 9, 2017•4 citations

Tricriticality of Interacting Hard Squares: Some Exact Results

David A. Huse

Baxter has solved a restricted class of square lattice gas models with nearest-neighbor exclusion (thus "hard squares") and next-nearest-neighbor interactions. Arguments are presented which demonstrate that the subspace spanned by his exact solution contains the line of tricritical points and the associated surface of first-order transitions of hard squares with attractive next-nearest-neighbor interactions. The tricritical exponents so identified confirm those obtained by Nienhuis for a dilute Ising model.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 18, 1982•53 citations

Tensor network simulation for the frustrated J1−J2 Ising model on the square lattice

Hong Li, Li-Ping Yang

By using extensive tensor network calculations, we map out the phase diagram of the frustrated J_{1}-J_{2} Ising model on the square lattice. In particular, we focus on the cases with controversy in the phase diagram, especially the stripe transition in the regime g=|J_{2}/J_{1}|>1/2 (J_{2}>0,J_{1}<0). While recent studies claimed that the phase transition is of first order when 1/2<g<g^{*} (with the smallest g^{*} being 0.67), our simulations suggest that if there is such a first-order region, it is smaller than those found in earlier studies by other methods. Combining with the analysis of critical properties, we provide evidence that the classical J_{1}-J_{2} model evolves continuously from two decoupled Ising models (g→∞ with central charge c=1) to a point belonging to the tricritical Ising universality class (with c=0.7) as g decreases to g^{*}≃0.54.

arXiv:2103.09464•Physical review. E•Aug 16, 2021•38 citations

First-order transition and marginal critical behavior in a two-dimensional frustrated Ising model with efficient tensor-network implementation

Christophe Chatelain

The phase diagram of a two-dimensional frustrated Ising model with both anti-ferromagnetic and ferromagnetic couplings is studied using tensor network renormalization group techniques. This model can be seen as two antiferromagnetic Ising replicas coupled by nonlocal spin-spin interactions, designed in such a way that the continuum limit matches that of the still-debated J_{1}-J_{2} model and induces a marginal critical behavior. Our model has the advantage of having more symmetries than the J_{1}-J_{2} model and of allowing a more straightforward implementation of tensor network renormalization group algorithms. We demonstrate the existence of two transition lines, featuring both first- and second-order regimes. In the latter, the central charge and the critical exponents are shown to be compatible with the Ashkin-Teller universality class. This picture is consistent with that given by Monte Carlo simulations of the J_{1}-J_{2} model but not with recent studies with tensor network techniques.

arXiv:2410.01460•Physical review. E•Feb 6, 2025•7 citations
Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group to contract the tensor network that describes its partition function, we investigate the nature of the phase transitions of the hard-square model, one of the exactly solved models of statistical physics for which Baxter has found an integrable manifold. The motivation is twofold: assess the power of tensor networks for such models, and probe the 2D classical analog of a 1D quantum model of hard-core bosons that has recently attracted significant attention in the context of experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. Accordingly, we concentrate on two planes in the 3D parameter space spanned by the activity and the coupling constants in the two diagonal directions. We first investigate the only case studied so far with Monte Carlo simulations, the case of opposite coupling constants. We confirm that, away and not too far from the integrable 3-state Potts point, the transition out of the period-3 phase appears to be unique in the Huse-Fisher chiral universality class, albeit with significantly different exponents as compared to Monte Carlo. We also identify two additional phase transitions not reported so far for that model, a Lifshitz disorder line, and an Ising transition for large enough activity. To make contact with 1D quantum models of Rydberg atoms, we then turn to a plane where the ferromagnetic coupling is kept fixed, and we show that the resulting phase diagram is very similar, the only difference being that the Ising transition becomes first-order through a tricritical Ising point, in agreement with Baxter's prediction that this plane should contain a tricritical Ising point, and in remarkable, almost quantitative agreement with the phase diagram of the 1D quantum version of the model.
Using the corner-transfer matrix renormalization group approach, we revisit the three-state chiral Potts model on the square lattice, a model proposed in the eighties to describe commensurate-incommensurate transitions at surfaces, and with direct relevance to recent experiments on chains of Rydberg atoms. This model was suggested by Huse and Fisher to have a chiral transition in the vicinity of the Potts point, a possibility that turned out to be very difficult to definitely establish or refute numerically. Our results confirm that the transition changes character at a Lifshitz point that separates a line of Pokrosky-Talapov transitions far enough from the Potts point from a line of direct continuous order-disorder transition close to it. Thanks to the accuracy of the numerical results, we have been able to base the analysis entirely on effective exponents to deal with the crossovers that have hampered previous numerical investigations. The emerging picture is that of a new universality class with exponents that do not change between the Potts point and the Lifshitz point, and that appear to be consistent with those of a self-dual version of the model, namely correlation lengths exponents νx=2/3 in the direction of the asymmetry and νy=1 perpendicular to it, an incommensurability exponent β¯=2/3, a specific heat exponent that keeps the value α=1/3 of the three-state Potts model, and a dynamical exponent z=3/2. These results are in excellent agreement with experimental results obtained on reconstructed surfaces in the nineties, and shed light on recent Kibble-Zurek experiments on the period-3 phase of chains of Rydberg atoms.
The spin-1 Ising model on the square lattice with nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic exchange interactions [both bilinear (JJJ) and biquadratic (KKK) and crystal-field interaction ($\ensuremath{\Delta}$) is studied via a renormalization-group transformation in position space. The phase diagram in JJJ, KKK, $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ space is found to have one surface of critical phase transitions and two surfaces of first-order phase transitions. These surfaces are variously bounded by an ordinary tricritical line, an isolated critical line, and a line of critical end points. These three lines joint at a special tricritical point corresponding to the transition of the three-state Potts model. The over-all phase diagram is qualitatively similar to that obtained with the mean-field approximation, except in the vicinity of the Potts transition where a four-phase coexistence line in mean-field theory shrinks into a special tricritical point in renormalization-group theory. Symmetry considerations guide the construction of our truncated renormalization-group transformation. The global connectivity and local exponents of the thirteen separate fixed points underlying this quite complicated structure are determined. Local analysis with respect to magnetic field (HHH) and another odd interaction (LLL) is performed. A one-adjusted-parameter version of our transformation yields remarkably quantitative results, predicting the Potts transition temperature, for example, within 0.3% of the exact value.
We explore the phase diagram of Ising spins on one-dimensional chains that criss-cross in two perpendicular directions and that are connected by interchain couplings. This system is of interest as a simpler, classical analog of a quantum Hamiltonian that has been proposed as a model of magnetic behavior in Nb_{12}O_{29} and also, conceptually, as a geometry that is intermediate between one and two dimensions. Using mean-field theory as well as Metropolis Monte Carlo and Wang-Landau simulations, we locate quantitatively the boundaries of four ordered phases. Each becomes an effective Ising model with unique effective couplings at large interchain coupling. Away from this limit, we demonstrate nontrivial critical behavior, including tricritical points that separate first- and second-order phase transitions. Finally, we present evidence that this model belongs to the two-dimensional Ising universality class.
Baxter has solved a restricted class of square lattice gas models with nearest-neighbor exclusion (thus "hard squares") and next-nearest-neighbor interactions. Arguments are presented which demonstrate that the subspace spanned by his exact solution contains the line of tricritical points and the associated surface of first-order transitions of hard squares with attractive next-nearest-neighbor interactions. The tricritical exponents so identified confirm those obtained by Nienhuis for a dilute Ising model.
By using extensive tensor network calculations, we map out the phase diagram of the frustrated J_{1}-J_{2} Ising model on the square lattice. In particular, we focus on the cases with controversy in the phase diagram, especially the stripe transition in the regime g=|J_{2}/J_{1}|>1/2 (J_{2}>0,J_{1}<0). While recent studies claimed that the phase transition is of first order when 1/2<g<g^{*} (with the smallest g^{*} being 0.67), our simulations suggest that if there is such a first-order region, it is smaller than those found in earlier studies by other methods. Combining with the analysis of critical properties, we provide evidence that the classical J_{1}-J_{2} model evolves continuously from two decoupled Ising models (g→∞ with central charge c=1) to a point belonging to the tricritical Ising universality class (with c=0.7) as g decreases to g^{*}≃0.54.
The phase diagram of a two-dimensional frustrated Ising model with both anti-ferromagnetic and ferromagnetic couplings is studied using tensor network renormalization group techniques. This model can be seen as two antiferromagnetic Ising replicas coupled by nonlocal spin-spin interactions, designed in such a way that the continuum limit matches that of the still-debated J_{1}-J_{2} model and induces a marginal critical behavior. Our model has the advantage of having more symmetries than the J_{1}-J_{2} model and of allowing a more straightforward implementation of tensor network renormalization group algorithms. We demonstrate the existence of two transition lines, featuring both first- and second-order regimes. In the latter, the central charge and the critical exponents are shown to be compatible with the Ashkin-Teller universality class. This picture is consistent with that given by Monte Carlo simulations of the J_{1}-J_{2} model but not with recent studies with tensor network techniques.