Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.02342 · Linear Algebra and its Applications

Monotonicity versions of Epstein's Concavity Theorem and related inequalities

Eric A. Carlen, Haonan Zhang

Published Sep 7, 2022• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many trace inequalities can be expressed either as concavity/convexity theorems or as monotonicity theorems. A classic example is the joint convexity of the quantum relative entropy which is equivalent to the Data Processing Inequality. The latter says that quantum operations can never increase the relative entropy. The monotonicity versions often have many advantages, and often have direct physical application, as in the example just mentioned. Moreover, the monotonicity results are often valid for a larger class of maps than, say, quantum operations (which are completely positive). In this paper we prove several new monotonicity results, the first of which is a monotonicity theorem that has as a simple corollary a celebrated concavity theorem of Epstein. Our starting points are the monotonicity versions of the Lieb Concavity and the Lieb Convexity Theorems. We also give two new proofs of these in their general forms using interpolation. We then prove our new monotonicity theorems by several duality arguments.

DOI
10.1016/j.laa.2022.09.001

Related papers

Quantum Stein's lemma revisited, inequalities for quantum entropies, and a concavity theorem of Lieb

Igor Bjelaković, Rainer Siegmund‐Schultze

We derive the monotonicity of the quantum relative entropy by an elementary operational argument based on Stein's lemma in quantum hypothesis testing. For the latter we present an elementary and short proof that requires the law of large numbers only. Joint convexity of the quantum relative entropy is proven too, resulting in a self-contained elementary version of Tropp's approach to Lieb's concavity theorem, according to which the map tr(exp(h+log a)) is concave in a on positive operators for self-adjoint h.

arXiv:quant-ph/0307170•Jul 24, 2003•29 citations

Inequalities for Quantum Entropy: A Review with Conditions for Equality

Mary Beth Ruskai

This paper presents self-contained proofs of the strong subadditivity inequality for quantum entropy and some related inequalities for the quantum relative entropy, most notably its convexity and its monotonicity under stochastic maps. Moreover, the approach presented here, which is based on Klein's inequality and one of Lieb's less well-known concave trace functions, allows one to obtain conditions for equality. Using the fact that the Holevo bound on the accessible information in a quantum ensemble can be obtained as a consequence of the monotonicity of relative entropy, we show that equality can be attained for that bound only when the states in the ensemble commute. The paper concludes with an Appendix giving a short description of Epstein's elegant proof of the relevant concavity theorem of Lieb.

•May 13, 2002•166 citations

Equality cases in monotonicity of quasi-entropies, Lieb’s concavity and Ando’s convexity

Fumio Hiai

We revisit and improve joint concavity/convexity and monotonicity properties of quasi-entropies due to Petz in a new fashion. Then we characterize equality cases in the monotonicity inequalities (the data-processing inequalities) of quasi-entropies in several ways as follows: Let Φ:B(H)→B(K) be a trace-preserving map such that Φ* is a Schwarz map. When f is an operator monotone or operator convex function on [0, ∞), we present several equivalent conditions for the equality SfK(Φ(ρ)‖Φ(σ))=SfΦ*(K)(ρ‖σ) to hold for given positive operators ρ, σ on H and K∈B(K). The conditions include equality cases in the monotonicity versions of Lieb’s concavity and Ando’s convexity theorems. Specializing the map Φ we have equivalent conditions for equality cases in Lieb’s concavity and Ando’s convexity. Similar equality conditions are discussed also for monotone metrics and χ2-divergences. We further consider some types of linear preserver problems for those quantum information quantities.

arXiv:2304.04361•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 2023•1 citation

Carlen-Frank-Lieb conjecture and monotonicity of $\alpha-z$ R\'enyi relative entropy

Haonan Zhang

In this paper we study the joint convexity/concavity of the trace functions \[ \Psi_{p,q,s}(A,B)=\text{Tr}(B^{\frac{q}{2}}K^*A^{p}KB^{\frac{q}{2}})^s,~~p,q,s\in \mathbb{R}, \] where $A$ and $B$ are positive definite matrices and $K$ is any fixed invertible matrix. We will give full range of $(p,q,s)\in\mathbb{R}^3$ for $\Psi_{p,q,s}$ to be jointly convex/concave for all $K$. As a consequence, we confirm a conjecture of Carlen, Frank and Lieb. In particular, we confirm a weaker conjecture of Audenaert and Datta and obtain the full range of $(\alpha,z)$ for $\alpha$-$z$ Renyi relative entropies to be monotone under completely positive trace preserving maps. We also give simpler proofs of many known results, including the concavity of $\Psi_{p,0,1/p}$ for $0<p<1$ which was first proved by Epstein using complex analysis. The key is to reduce the problem to the joint convexity/concavity of the trace functions \[ \Psi_{p,1-p,1}(A,B)=\text{Tr} K^*A^{p}KB^{1-p},~~-1\le p\le 1, \] using a variational method.

•Nov 3, 2018•2 citations

From joint convexity of quantum relative entropy to a concavity theorem of Lieb

Joel A. Tropp

This paper provides a succinct proof of a 1973 theorem of Lieb that establishes the concavity of a certain trace function. The development relies on a deep result from quantum information theory, the joint convexity of quantum relative entropy, as well as a recent argument due to Carlen and Lieb.

arXiv:1101.1070•Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society•Aug 4, 2011•38 citations

A UNIFIED TREATMENT OF CONVEXITY OF RELATIVE ENTROPY AND RELATED TRACE FUNCTIONS, WITH CONDITIONS FOR EQUALITY

Anna Jenčová, Mary Beth Ruskai

We consider a generalization of relative entropy derived from the Wigner–Yanase–Dyson entropy and give a simple, self-contained proof that it is convex. Moreover, special cases yield the joint convexity of relative entropy, and for Tr K* ApK B1-pLieb's joint concavity in (A, B) for 0 < p < 1 and Ando's joint convexity for 1 < p ≤ 2. This approach allows us to obtain conditions for equality in these cases, as well as conditions for equality in a number of inequalities which follow from them. These include the monotonicity under partial traces, and some Minkowski type matrix inequalities proved by Carlen and Lieb for [Formula: see text]. In all cases, the equality conditions are independent of p; for extensions to three spaces they are identical to the conditions for equality in the strong subadditivity of relative entropy.

arXiv:0903.2895•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 2010•59 citations
Many trace inequalities can be expressed either as concavity/convexity theorems or as monotonicity theorems. A classic example is the joint convexity of the quantum relative entropy which is equivalent to the Data Processing Inequality. The latter says that quantum operations can never increase the relative entropy. The monotonicity versions often have many advantages, and often have direct physical application, as in the example just mentioned. Moreover, the monotonicity results are often valid for a larger class of maps than, say, quantum operations (which are completely positive). In this paper we prove several new monotonicity results, the first of which is a monotonicity theorem that has as a simple corollary a celebrated concavity theorem of Epstein. Our starting points are the monotonicity versions of the Lieb Concavity and the Lieb Convexity Theorems. We also give two new proofs of these in their general forms using interpolation. We then prove our new monotonicity theorems by several duality arguments.
We derive the monotonicity of the quantum relative entropy by an elementary operational argument based on Stein's lemma in quantum hypothesis testing. For the latter we present an elementary and short proof that requires the law of large numbers only. Joint convexity of the quantum relative entropy is proven too, resulting in a self-contained elementary version of Tropp's approach to Lieb's concavity theorem, according to which the map tr(exp(h+log a)) is concave in a on positive operators for self-adjoint h.
This paper presents self-contained proofs of the strong subadditivity inequality for quantum entropy and some related inequalities for the quantum relative entropy, most notably its convexity and its monotonicity under stochastic maps. Moreover, the approach presented here, which is based on Klein's inequality and one of Lieb's less well-known concave trace functions, allows one to obtain conditions for equality. Using the fact that the Holevo bound on the accessible information in a quantum ensemble can be obtained as a consequence of the monotonicity of relative entropy, we show that equality can be attained for that bound only when the states in the ensemble commute. The paper concludes with an Appendix giving a short description of Epstein's elegant proof of the relevant concavity theorem of Lieb.
We revisit and improve joint concavity/convexity and monotonicity properties of quasi-entropies due to Petz in a new fashion. Then we characterize equality cases in the monotonicity inequalities (the data-processing inequalities) of quasi-entropies in several ways as follows: Let Φ:B(H)→B(K) be a trace-preserving map such that Φ* is a Schwarz map. When f is an operator monotone or operator convex function on [0, ∞), we present several equivalent conditions for the equality SfK(Φ(ρ)‖Φ(σ))=SfΦ*(K)(ρ‖σ) to hold for given positive operators ρ, σ on H and K∈B(K). The conditions include equality cases in the monotonicity versions of Lieb’s concavity and Ando’s convexity theorems. Specializing the map Φ we have equivalent conditions for equality cases in Lieb’s concavity and Ando’s convexity. Similar equality conditions are discussed also for monotone metrics and χ2-divergences. We further consider some types of linear preserver problems for those quantum information quantities.
Carlen-Frank-Lieb conjecture and monotonicity of α−z\alpha-zα−z R\'enyi relative entropy
In this paper we study the joint convexity/concavity of the trace functions Ψp,q,s(A,B)=Tr(Bq2K∗ApKBq2)s,  p,q,s∈R, \Psi_{p,q,s}(A,B)=\text{Tr}(B^{\frac{q}{2}}K^*A^{p}KB^{\frac{q}{2}})^s,~~p,q,s\in \mathbb{R}, Ψp,q,s​(A,B)=Tr(B2q​K∗ApKB2q​)s,  p,q,s∈R, where AAA and BBB are positive definite matrices and KKK is any fixed invertible matrix. We will give full range of (p,q,s)∈R3(p,q,s)\in\mathbb{R}^3(p,q,s)∈R3 for Ψp,q,s\Psi_{p,q,s}Ψp,q,s​ to be jointly convex/concave for all KKK. As a consequence, we confirm a conjecture of Carlen, Frank and Lieb. In particular, we confirm a weaker conjecture of Audenaert and Datta and obtain the full range of (α,z)(\alpha,z)(α,z) for α\alphaα-zzz Renyi relative entropies to be monotone under completely positive trace preserving maps. We also give simpler proofs of many known results, including the concavity of Ψp,0,1/p\Psi_{p,0,1/p}Ψp,0,1/p​ for 0<p<10<p<10<p<1 which was first proved by Epstein using complex analysis. The key is to reduce the problem to the joint convexity/concavity of the trace functions Ψp,1−p,1(A,B)=TrK∗ApKB1−p,  −1≤p≤1, \Psi_{p,1-p,1}(A,B)=\text{Tr} K^*A^{p}KB^{1-p},~~-1\le p\le 1, Ψp,1−p,1​(A,B)=TrK∗ApKB1−p,  −1≤p≤1, using a variational method.
We consider a generalization of relative entropy derived from the Wigner–Yanase–Dyson entropy and give a simple, self-contained proof that it is convex. Moreover, special cases yield the joint convexity of relative entropy, and for Tr K* ApK B1-pLieb's joint concavity in (A, B) for 0 < p < 1 and Ando's joint convexity for 1 < p ≤ 2. This approach allows us to obtain conditions for equality in these cases, as well as conditions for equality in a number of inequalities which follow from them. These include the monotonicity under partial traces, and some Minkowski type matrix inequalities proved by Carlen and Lieb for [Formula: see text]. In all cases, the equality conditions are independent of p; for extensions to three spaces they are identical to the conditions for equality in the strong subadditivity of relative entropy.