Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2204.10874 · New Journal of Physics

Quantum–classical correspondence in spin–boson equilibrium states at arbitrary coupling

Federico Cerisola, Marco Berritta, Stefano Scali, S. A. R. Horsley, James D. Cresser, Janet Anders

Published May 1, 2024• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The equilibrium properties of nanoscale systems can deviate significantly from standard thermodynamics due to their coupling to an environment. We investigate this here for the θ -angled spin–boson model, where we first derive a compact and general form of the classical equilibrium state including environmental corrections to all orders. Secondly, for the quantum spin–boson model we prove, by carefully taking a large spin limit, that Bohr’s quantum–classical correspondence persists at all coupling strengths. This shows, for the first time, the validity of the quantum–classical correspondence for an open system and gives insight into the regimes where the quantum system is well-approximated by a classical one. Finally, we provide the first classification of the coupling parameter regimes for the spin–boson model, from weak to ultrastrong, both for the quantum case and the classical setting. Our results shed light on the interplay of quantum and mean force corrections in equilibrium states of the spin–boson model, and will help draw the quantum to classical boundary in a range of fields, such as magnetism and exciton dynamics.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/ad4818

Related papers

Equivalence between the second order steady state for the spin-boson model and its quantum mean force Gibbs state

Prem Kumar, K. P. Athulya, Sibasish Ghosh A

When the coupling of a quantum system to its environment is nonnegligible, its steady state is known to deviate from the textbook Gibbs state. The Bloch-Redfield quantum master equation, one of the most widely adopted equations for solving the open quantum dynamics, cannot predict all the deviations of the steady state of a quantum system from the Gibbs state. In this paper, for a generic spin-boson model, we use a higher-order quantum master equation (in system-environment coupling strength) to analytically calculate all the deviations of the steady state of the quantum system up to second order in coupling strength. We also show that this steady state is exactly identical to the corresponding generalized Gibbs state, the so-called quantum mean force Gibbs state, at arbitrary temperature. All these calculations are highly general, making them immediately applicable to a wide class of systems well modeled by the spin-Boson model, spanning a diverse range of topics, from nanomaterials to various condensed-phase processes, and quantum computing (e.g., environment-induced corrections to the steady state of a superconducting qubit). As an example, we use our results to study the dynamics and the steady state of a solid-state double-quantum-dot system under physically relevant choices of parameters.

arXiv:2411.08869•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 24, 2025•4 citations

Weak and Ultrastrong Coupling Limits of the Quantum Mean Force Gibbs State

James D. Cresser, Janet Anders

The Gibbs state is widely taken to be the equilibrium state of a system in contact with an environment at temperature T. However, non-negligible interactions between system and environment can give rise to an altered state. Here, we derive general expressions for this mean force Gibbs state, valid for any system that interacts with a bosonic reservoir. First, we derive the state in the weak coupling limit and find that, in general, it maintains coherences with respect to the bare system Hamiltonian. Second, we develop a new expansion method suited to investigate the ultrastrong coupling regime. This allows us to derive the explicit form for the mean force Gibbs state, and we find that it becomes diagonal in the basis set by the system-reservoir interaction instead of the system Hamiltonian. Several examples are discussed including a single qubit, a three-level V-system, and two coupled qubits all interacting with bosonic reservoirs. The results shed light on the presence of coherences in the strong coupling regime, and provide key tools for nanoscale thermodynamics investigations.

arXiv:2104.12606•Physical Review Letters•Dec 17, 2021•79 citations

The quantum HMF model: II. Bosons

Pierre-Henri Chavanis

We study the thermodynamics of quantum particles with long-range interactions at T = 0. Specifically, we generalize the Hamiltonian mean-field (HMF) model to the case of bosons. We consider the Hartree approximation that becomes exact in a proper thermodynamic limit with a coupling constant k ∼ 1/ N . The equilibrium configurations are solutions of the mean-field Schrödinger equation with a cosine interaction. We show that the homogeneous phase, which is unstable in the classical regime, becomes stable in the quantum regime. The homogeneous phase is stabilized by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. This takes place through a second-order phase transition where the control parameter is the normalized Planck constant. The homogeneous phase is unstable for and stable for . The inhomogeneous phase is stable for and disappears for . We point out analogies between the bosonic HMF model and the concept of boson stars in astrophysics. We also discuss the differences between bosons and fermions for what concerns the thermodynamic limit, the order of the phase transition and the form of the density profiles.

Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Aug 8, 2011•10 citations

Rigorous Born approximation and beyond for the spin-boson model

David Peter Divincenzo, Daniel Loss

Within the lowest-order Born approximation, we present an exact calculation of the time dynamics of the spin-boson model in the Ohmic regime. We observe non-Markovian effects at zero temperature that scale with the system-bath coupling strength and cause qualitative changes in the evolution of coherence at intermediate times of order of the oscillation period. These changes could significantly affect the performance of these systems as qubits. In the biased case, we find a prompt loss of coherence at these intermediate times, whose decay rate is set by $\sqrt{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, where $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is the coupling strength to the environment. We also explore the calculation of the next-order Born approximation: we show that, at the expense of very large computational complexity, interesting physical quantities can be rigorously computed at fourth order using computer algebra, presented completely in an accompanying MATHEMATICA file. We compute the $O(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ corrections to the long time behavior of the system density matrix; the result is identical to the reduced density matrix of the equilibrium state to the same order in $\ensuremath{\alpha}$. All these calculations indicate precision experimental tests that could confirm or refute the validity of the spin-boson model in a variety of systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0304118•Physical Review B•Jan 14, 2005•140 citations

Quantum-classical correspondence of non-Hermitian spin-orbit coupled bosonic junction

Xin Yan, Hongzheng Wu, Changwei Fan +5 more

Abstract We investigate the classical-quantum correspondence of non-Hermitian Spin-orbit (SO)-coupled bosonic junctions, where an effective decay term is introduced in one of the two wells. Starting from the normalized two-point functions, we analytically demonstrate that the mean-field system has a classical Hamiltonian structure, and we successfully derive a non-Hermitian discrete nonlinear Schrödinger (Gross–Pitaevskii) equation. We discover that near the symmetry-breaking phase transition point, the correspondence between classical (mean-field) and quantum dynamics is more likely to break down. Our numerical simulations of the full quantum model, limited to a finite number of particles due to computational constraints, reveal that when the effective spin–orbit coupling (SOC) strength takes half-integer values, atomic self-trapping in a non-lossy well consistently occurs regardless of the system parameters, and the corresponding quantum dynamics exhibit remarkable insensitivity to the number of particles in this scenario. Additionally, we reveal that in both the mean-field and many-particle models, the SOC effects can greatly promote the synchronous periodic oscillations between the spin-up and spin-down components, and this synchronous dynamic is closely related to symmetry.

arXiv:2410.13176•Physica Scripta•Apr 2, 2025•2 citations

Effective description of the short-time dynamics in open quantum systems

Matteo A. C. Rossi, Caterina Foti, Alessandro Cuccoli +3 more

We address the dynamics of a bosonic system coupled to either a bosonic or a magnetic environment and derive a set of sufficient conditions that allow one to describe the dynamics in terms of the effective interaction with a classical fluctuating field. We find that for short interaction times the dynamics of the open system is described by a Gaussian noise map for several different interaction models and independently on the temperature of the environment. In order to go beyond a qualitative understanding of the origin and physical meaning of the above short-time constraint, we take a general viewpoint and, based on an algebraic approach, suggest that any quantum environment can be described by classical fields whenever global symmetries lead to the definition of environmental operators that remain well defined when increasing the size, i.e., the number of dynamical variables, of the environment. In the case of the bosonic environment this statement is exactly demonstrated via a constructive procedure that explicitly shows why a large number of environmental dynamical variables and, necessarily, global symmetries, entail the set of conditions derived in the first part of the work.

arXiv:1703.09236•Physical Review A•Sep 20, 2017•15 citations
Abstract The equilibrium properties of nanoscale systems can deviate significantly from standard thermodynamics due to their coupling to an environment. We investigate this here for the θ -angled spin–boson model, where we first derive a compact and general form of the classical equilibrium state including environmental corrections to all orders. Secondly, for the quantum spin–boson model we prove, by carefully taking a large spin limit, that Bohr’s quantum–classical correspondence persists at all coupling strengths. This shows, for the first time, the validity of the quantum–classical correspondence for an open system and gives insight into the regimes where the quantum system is well-approximated by a classical one. Finally, we provide the first classification of the coupling parameter regimes for the spin–boson model, from weak to ultrastrong, both for the quantum case and the classical setting. Our results shed light on the interplay of quantum and mean force corrections in equilibrium states of the spin–boson model, and will help draw the quantum to classical boundary in a range of fields, such as magnetism and exciton dynamics.
When the coupling of a quantum system to its environment is nonnegligible, its steady state is known to deviate from the textbook Gibbs state. The Bloch-Redfield quantum master equation, one of the most widely adopted equations for solving the open quantum dynamics, cannot predict all the deviations of the steady state of a quantum system from the Gibbs state. In this paper, for a generic spin-boson model, we use a higher-order quantum master equation (in system-environment coupling strength) to analytically calculate all the deviations of the steady state of the quantum system up to second order in coupling strength. We also show that this steady state is exactly identical to the corresponding generalized Gibbs state, the so-called quantum mean force Gibbs state, at arbitrary temperature. All these calculations are highly general, making them immediately applicable to a wide class of systems well modeled by the spin-Boson model, spanning a diverse range of topics, from nanomaterials to various condensed-phase processes, and quantum computing (e.g., environment-induced corrections to the steady state of a superconducting qubit). As an example, we use our results to study the dynamics and the steady state of a solid-state double-quantum-dot system under physically relevant choices of parameters.
The Gibbs state is widely taken to be the equilibrium state of a system in contact with an environment at temperature T. However, non-negligible interactions between system and environment can give rise to an altered state. Here, we derive general expressions for this mean force Gibbs state, valid for any system that interacts with a bosonic reservoir. First, we derive the state in the weak coupling limit and find that, in general, it maintains coherences with respect to the bare system Hamiltonian. Second, we develop a new expansion method suited to investigate the ultrastrong coupling regime. This allows us to derive the explicit form for the mean force Gibbs state, and we find that it becomes diagonal in the basis set by the system-reservoir interaction instead of the system Hamiltonian. Several examples are discussed including a single qubit, a three-level V-system, and two coupled qubits all interacting with bosonic reservoirs. The results shed light on the presence of coherences in the strong coupling regime, and provide key tools for nanoscale thermodynamics investigations.
We study the thermodynamics of quantum particles with long-range interactions at T = 0. Specifically, we generalize the Hamiltonian mean-field (HMF) model to the case of bosons. We consider the Hartree approximation that becomes exact in a proper thermodynamic limit with a coupling constant k ∼ 1/ N . The equilibrium configurations are solutions of the mean-field Schrödinger equation with a cosine interaction. We show that the homogeneous phase, which is unstable in the classical regime, becomes stable in the quantum regime. The homogeneous phase is stabilized by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. This takes place through a second-order phase transition where the control parameter is the normalized Planck constant. The homogeneous phase is unstable for and stable for . The inhomogeneous phase is stable for and disappears for . We point out analogies between the bosonic HMF model and the concept of boson stars in astrophysics. We also discuss the differences between bosons and fermions for what concerns the thermodynamic limit, the order of the phase transition and the form of the density profiles.
Within the lowest-order Born approximation, we present an exact calculation of the time dynamics of the spin-boson model in the Ohmic regime. We observe non-Markovian effects at zero temperature that scale with the system-bath coupling strength and cause qualitative changes in the evolution of coherence at intermediate times of order of the oscillation period. These changes could significantly affect the performance of these systems as qubits. In the biased case, we find a prompt loss of coherence at these intermediate times, whose decay rate is set by $\sqrt{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, where $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is the coupling strength to the environment. We also explore the calculation of the next-order Born approximation: we show that, at the expense of very large computational complexity, interesting physical quantities can be rigorously computed at fourth order using computer algebra, presented completely in an accompanying MATHEMATICA file. We compute the $O(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ corrections to the long time behavior of the system density matrix; the result is identical to the reduced density matrix of the equilibrium state to the same order in $\ensuremath{\alpha}$. All these calculations indicate precision experimental tests that could confirm or refute the validity of the spin-boson model in a variety of systems.
Abstract We investigate the classical-quantum correspondence of non-Hermitian Spin-orbit (SO)-coupled bosonic junctions, where an effective decay term is introduced in one of the two wells. Starting from the normalized two-point functions, we analytically demonstrate that the mean-field system has a classical Hamiltonian structure, and we successfully derive a non-Hermitian discrete nonlinear Schrödinger (Gross–Pitaevskii) equation. We discover that near the symmetry-breaking phase transition point, the correspondence between classical (mean-field) and quantum dynamics is more likely to break down. Our numerical simulations of the full quantum model, limited to a finite number of particles due to computational constraints, reveal that when the effective spin–orbit coupling (SOC) strength takes half-integer values, atomic self-trapping in a non-lossy well consistently occurs regardless of the system parameters, and the corresponding quantum dynamics exhibit remarkable insensitivity to the number of particles in this scenario. Additionally, we reveal that in both the mean-field and many-particle models, the SOC effects can greatly promote the synchronous periodic oscillations between the spin-up and spin-down components, and this synchronous dynamic is closely related to symmetry.
We address the dynamics of a bosonic system coupled to either a bosonic or a magnetic environment and derive a set of sufficient conditions that allow one to describe the dynamics in terms of the effective interaction with a classical fluctuating field. We find that for short interaction times the dynamics of the open system is described by a Gaussian noise map for several different interaction models and independently on the temperature of the environment. In order to go beyond a qualitative understanding of the origin and physical meaning of the above short-time constraint, we take a general viewpoint and, based on an algebraic approach, suggest that any quantum environment can be described by classical fields whenever global symmetries lead to the definition of environmental operators that remain well defined when increasing the size, i.e., the number of dynamical variables, of the environment. In the case of the bosonic environment this statement is exactly demonstrated via a constructive procedure that explicitly shows why a large number of environmental dynamical variables and, necessarily, global symmetries, entail the set of conditions derived in the first part of the work.