Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2204.01756 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Quantum dimer model on fullerenes: Resonance, scarring, and confinement

R. Krishna Prahlaadh, R. Ganesh

Published Aug 30, 2022• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The earliest known examples of quantum superposition were found in organic chemistry---in molecules that ``resonate'' among multiple arrangements of $\ensuremath{\pi}$-bonds. Small molecules such as benzene resonate among a few bond arrangements. In contrast, a large system that stretches over a macroscopic lattice may resonate among an extensive number of configurations. This is analogous to a quantum spin liquid as described by Anderson's resonating valence bond picture. In this article, we study the intermediate case of somewhat large molecules, the ${\mathrm{C}}_{20}$ and ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ fullerenes. We build a minimal description in terms of quantum dimer models (QDMs), allowing for local resonance processes and repulsion between proximate $\ensuremath{\pi}$-bonds. This allows us to characterize ground states, e.g., with ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ forming a superposition of 5828 dimer covers. Despite the large number of contributing dimer covers, the ground state shows strong dimer-dimer correlations. Going beyond the ground state, the full spectrum of ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ shows many interesting features. When repulsive terms are neglected, the energy values are placed symmetrically about zero. This reflection symmetry originates from a chiral symmetry of the Hamiltonian, which in turn originates from the local bond geometry of ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$. This property also leads to a large number of protected zero-energy states. In general, the spectrum contains many scarlike states, corresponding to localized dimer-rearrangement dynamics. Resonance dynamics in QDMs can manifest in the behavior of defects, potentially binding defects via an effective attractive interaction. To test this notion, we introduce pairs of vacancies at all possible separations. Resonance energy reaches its lowest value when the vacancies are closest to one another. This suggests confinement of monomers, albeit within a finite cluster. We discuss qualitative pictures for understanding bonding in fullerenes, and we draw connections with results from quantum chemistry.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.106.054438

Related papers

Dimer Smectic in Extended Quantum Dimer Model -approach from pseudo S=1 Hamiltonian-

Kouki Nakata, Keisuke Totsuka

We extend Quantum Dimer Model (QDM) introduced by Rokhsar and Kivelson in such a way that the model includes resonance processes on larger loops. The strategy is to first construct a pseudo spin Hamiltonian which is defined not by the S =1/2 but by the S=1 representation and then establish the correspondence between the pseudo-spin-1 configurations and those of dimers. The standard QDM keeps only the lowest resonance processes for pairs of parallel dimers and its validity in describing the realistic spin systems is not obvious. Our extended QDM (EQDM) improves this point and contains a novel resonance term, which is equivalent to two successive actions of the familiar parallel dimer resonance. For a certain choice of the coupling constants, our model exhibits three exotic valence-bond phases (herringbone, checkerboard and 'dimer smectic') in the ground state, which meet at a triple point. The checkerboard phase has four-fold rotational symmetry, while the dimer smectic is characterized by partial ordering only in one of the two directions. In the dimer smectic phase, we investigate the dimer-dimer correlation by using an analogy to random walks.

arXiv:1004.1040•Apr 7, 2010•0 citations

Ground-state properties of the Hubbard model on a C60 cluster

R. T. Scalettar, Adriana Moreo, Elbio R. Dagotto +3 more

Using quantum Monte Carlo techniques, we study the one-band Hubbard model at half filling, on a ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ molecule. Spin-spin correlations are measured at couplings U/t=4 and 8, and results are compared with similar studies on square lattices. At the lowest temperatures accessible to our simulations, we find that the spin correlations on the ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ molecule tend to vanish at large distances, with a correlation length of 3--4 lattice spacings. Spin-wave calculations in the Heisenberg limit are also reported, in qualitative agreement with Monte Carlo simulations. These results suggest that the ground state of the half-filled Hubbard model on the ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ fullerene is spin disordered (defined as having a correlation length smaller than the cluster size), in contrast with the spin-density-wave state that exists on the two-dimensional square lattice. We believe that a ``dimer'' state may properly describe the undoped ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ molecule.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 1, 1993•20 citations

Quantum Monte Carlo studies of spinons in one-dimensional spin systems

Ying Tang, Anders W. Sandvik

Observing constituent particles with fractional quantum numbers in confined and deconfined states is an interesting and challenging problem in quantum many-body physics. Here, we further explore a computational scheme [Y. Tang and A. W. Sandvik, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 157201 (2011)] based on valence-bond quantum Monte Carlo simulations of quantum spin systems. Using several different one-dimensional models, we characterize $S=\frac{1}{2}$ spinon excitations using the intrinsic spinon size $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and confinement length $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ (the size of a bound state). The spinons have finite size in valence-bond-solid states, infinite size in the critical region (with overlaps characterized by power laws), and become ill defined (completely unlocalizable) in the N\'eel state (which we stabilize in one dimension by introducing long-range interactions). We also verify that pairs of spinons are deconfined in uniform spin chains but become confined upon introducing a pattern of alternating coupling strengths (dimerization) or coupling two chains (forming a ladder). In the dimerized system, an individual spinon can be small when the confinement length is large; this is the case when the imposed dimerization is weak but the ground state of the corresponding uniform chain is a spontaneously formed valence-bond solid (where the spinons are deconfined). Based on our numerical results, we argue that a system with $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\ll}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ is associated with weak repulsive short-range spinon-spinon interactions. In principle, both the length scales $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ can still be individually tuned from small to infinite (with $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\le}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$) by varying model parameters. In contrast, in the ladder system the two lengths are always similar, and this is the case also in the weakly dimerized systems when the corresponding uniform chain is in the critical phase. In these systems, the effective spinon-spinon interactions are purely attractive and there is only a single large length scale close to criticality, which is reflected in the standard spin correlations as well as in the spinon characteristics.

arXiv:1404.6697•Physical Review B•Nov 23, 2015•25 citations

Quantum dimer models emerging from large-spin ultracold atoms

Bhuvanesh Sundar, Todd C. Rutkowski, Erich J. Mueller +1 more

We propose an experimental protocol for using cold atoms to create and probe quantum dimer models, thereby exploring the Pauling-Anderson vision of a macroscopic collection of resonating bonds. This process can allow the study of exotic crystalline phases, fractionalization, topological spin liquids, and the relationship between resonating dimers and superconductivity subjects which have been challenging to address in solid-state experiments. Our key technical development is considering the action of an off-resonant photoassociation laser on large spin atoms localized at the sites of a deep optical lattice. The resulting superexchange interaction favors nearest-neighbor singlets. We derive an effective Hamiltonian in terms of these dimer degrees of freedom, finding that it is similar to well-known quantum dimer models, which boast a rich variety of valence bond crystal and spin liquid phases. We numerically study the ground state, explain how to tune the parameters, and develop a protocol to directly measure the dimers and their resonating patterns.

arXiv:1702.05514•Physical Review A•Apr 23, 2019•5 citations

Multicolored quantum dimer models, resonating valence-bond states, color visons, and the triangular-lattice t2g spin-orbital system

Bruce Normand

The spin-orbital model for triply degenerate ${t}_{2g}$ electrons on a triangular lattice has been shown to be dominated by dimers. The phase diagram contains both strongly resonating, compound spin-orbital dimer states and quasistatic, spin-singlet valence-bond (VB) states. To elucidate the nature of the true ground state in these different regimes, the model is mapped to a number of quantum dimer models (QDMs), each of which has three dimer colors. The generic multicolored QDM, illustrated for the two- and three-color cases, possesses a topological color structure, ``color vison'' excitations, and broad regions of resonating VB phases. The specific models are analyzed to gain further insight into the likely ground states in the superexchange and direct-exchange limits of the electronic Hamiltonian, and they suggest a strong tendency toward VB order in all cases.

arXiv:1009.5140•Physical Review B•Feb 17, 2011•22 citations

Properties of resonating-valence-bond spin liquids and critical dimer models

Ying Tang, Anders W. Sandvik, Christopher L. Henley

We use Monte Carlo simulations to study properties of Anderson's resonating-valence-bond (RVB) spin-liquid state on the square lattice (i.e., the equal superposition of all pairing of spins into nearest-neighbor singlet pairs) and compare with the classical dimer model (CDM). The latter system also corresponds to the ground state of the Rokhsar-Kivelson quantum dimer model at its critical point. We find that, although spin-spin correlations decay exponentially in the RVB, four-spin valence-bond-solid correlations are critical, qualitatively like the well-known dimer-dimer correlations of the CDM, but decaying more slowly (as $1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ with $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\approx}1.20$, compared with $\ensuremath{\alpha}=2$ for the CDM). We also compute the distribution of monomer (defect) pair separations, which decay by a larger exponent in the RVB than in the CDM. We further study both models in their different winding-number sectors and evaluate the relative weights of different sectors. Like the CDM, all the observed RVB behaviors can be understood in the framework of a mapping to a ``height'' model characterized by a gradient-squared stiffness constant $K$. Four independent measurements consistently show a value ${K}_{\mathrm{RVB}}\ensuremath{\approx}1.6{K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}$, with the same kinds of numerical evaluations of ${K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}$ giving results in agreement with the rigorously known value ${K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}=\ensuremath{\pi}/16$. The background of a nonzero winding-number gradient $W/L$ introduces spatial anisotropies and an increase in the effective $K$, both of which can be understood as a consequence of anharmonic terms in the height-model free energy, which are of relevance to the recently proposed scenario of ``Cantor deconfinement'' in extended quantum dimer models. In addition to the standard case of short bonds only, we also studied ensembles in which fourth-neighbor (bipartite) bonds are allowed at a density controlled by a tunable fugacity, resulting (as expected) in a smooth reduction of $K$.

arXiv:1010.6146•Physical Review B•Nov 21, 2011•73 citations
The earliest known examples of quantum superposition were found in organic chemistry---in molecules that ``resonate'' among multiple arrangements of \ensuremathπ\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremathπ-bonds. Small molecules such as benzene resonate among a few bond arrangements. In contrast, a large system that stretches over a macroscopic lattice may resonate among an extensive number of configurations. This is analogous to a quantum spin liquid as described by Anderson's resonating valence bond picture. In this article, we study the intermediate case of somewhat large molecules, the C20{\mathrm{C}}_{20}C20​ and C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ fullerenes. We build a minimal description in terms of quantum dimer models (QDMs), allowing for local resonance processes and repulsion between proximate \ensuremathπ\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremathπ-bonds. This allows us to characterize ground states, e.g., with C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ forming a superposition of 5828 dimer covers. Despite the large number of contributing dimer covers, the ground state shows strong dimer-dimer correlations. Going beyond the ground state, the full spectrum of C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ shows many interesting features. When repulsive terms are neglected, the energy values are placed symmetrically about zero. This reflection symmetry originates from a chiral symmetry of the Hamiltonian, which in turn originates from the local bond geometry of C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​. This property also leads to a large number of protected zero-energy states. In general, the spectrum contains many scarlike states, corresponding to localized dimer-rearrangement dynamics. Resonance dynamics in QDMs can manifest in the behavior of defects, potentially binding defects via an effective attractive interaction. To test this notion, we introduce pairs of vacancies at all possible separations. Resonance energy reaches its lowest value when the vacancies are closest to one another. This suggests confinement of monomers, albeit within a finite cluster. We discuss qualitative pictures for understanding bonding in fullerenes, and we draw connections with results from quantum chemistry.
We extend Quantum Dimer Model (QDM) introduced by Rokhsar and Kivelson in such a way that the model includes resonance processes on larger loops. The strategy is to first construct a pseudo spin Hamiltonian which is defined not by the S =1/2 but by the S=1 representation and then establish the correspondence between the pseudo-spin-1 configurations and those of dimers. The standard QDM keeps only the lowest resonance processes for pairs of parallel dimers and its validity in describing the realistic spin systems is not obvious. Our extended QDM (EQDM) improves this point and contains a novel resonance term, which is equivalent to two successive actions of the familiar parallel dimer resonance. For a certain choice of the coupling constants, our model exhibits three exotic valence-bond phases (herringbone, checkerboard and 'dimer smectic') in the ground state, which meet at a triple point. The checkerboard phase has four-fold rotational symmetry, while the dimer smectic is characterized by partial ordering only in one of the two directions. In the dimer smectic phase, we investigate the dimer-dimer correlation by using an analogy to random walks.
Using quantum Monte Carlo techniques, we study the one-band Hubbard model at half filling, on a C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ molecule. Spin-spin correlations are measured at couplings U/t=4 and 8, and results are compared with similar studies on square lattices. At the lowest temperatures accessible to our simulations, we find that the spin correlations on the C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ molecule tend to vanish at large distances, with a correlation length of 3--4 lattice spacings. Spin-wave calculations in the Heisenberg limit are also reported, in qualitative agreement with Monte Carlo simulations. These results suggest that the ground state of the half-filled Hubbard model on the C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ fullerene is spin disordered (defined as having a correlation length smaller than the cluster size), in contrast with the spin-density-wave state that exists on the two-dimensional square lattice. We believe that a ``dimer'' state may properly describe the undoped C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​ molecule.
Observing constituent particles with fractional quantum numbers in confined and deconfined states is an interesting and challenging problem in quantum many-body physics. Here, we further explore a computational scheme [Y. Tang and A. W. Sandvik, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 157201 (2011)] based on valence-bond quantum Monte Carlo simulations of quantum spin systems. Using several different one-dimensional models, we characterize S=12S=\frac{1}{2}S=21​ spinon excitations using the intrinsic spinon size $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and confinement length $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ (the size of a bound state). The spinons have finite size in valence-bond-solid states, infinite size in the critical region (with overlaps characterized by power laws), and become ill defined (completely unlocalizable) in the N\'eel state (which we stabilize in one dimension by introducing long-range interactions). We also verify that pairs of spinons are deconfined in uniform spin chains but become confined upon introducing a pattern of alternating coupling strengths (dimerization) or coupling two chains (forming a ladder). In the dimerized system, an individual spinon can be small when the confinement length is large; this is the case when the imposed dimerization is weak but the ground state of the corresponding uniform chain is a spontaneously formed valence-bond solid (where the spinons are deconfined). Based on our numerical results, we argue that a system with $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\ll}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ is associated with weak repulsive short-range spinon-spinon interactions. In principle, both the length scales $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ can still be individually tuned from small to infinite (with $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\le}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$) by varying model parameters. In contrast, in the ladder system the two lengths are always similar, and this is the case also in the weakly dimerized systems when the corresponding uniform chain is in the critical phase. In these systems, the effective spinon-spinon interactions are purely attractive and there is only a single large length scale close to criticality, which is reflected in the standard spin correlations as well as in the spinon characteristics.
We propose an experimental protocol for using cold atoms to create and probe quantum dimer models, thereby exploring the Pauling-Anderson vision of a macroscopic collection of resonating bonds. This process can allow the study of exotic crystalline phases, fractionalization, topological spin liquids, and the relationship between resonating dimers and superconductivity subjects which have been challenging to address in solid-state experiments. Our key technical development is considering the action of an off-resonant photoassociation laser on large spin atoms localized at the sites of a deep optical lattice. The resulting superexchange interaction favors nearest-neighbor singlets. We derive an effective Hamiltonian in terms of these dimer degrees of freedom, finding that it is similar to well-known quantum dimer models, which boast a rich variety of valence bond crystal and spin liquid phases. We numerically study the ground state, explain how to tune the parameters, and develop a protocol to directly measure the dimers and their resonating patterns.
The spin-orbital model for triply degenerate t2g{t}_{2g}t2g​ electrons on a triangular lattice has been shown to be dominated by dimers. The phase diagram contains both strongly resonating, compound spin-orbital dimer states and quasistatic, spin-singlet valence-bond (VB) states. To elucidate the nature of the true ground state in these different regimes, the model is mapped to a number of quantum dimer models (QDMs), each of which has three dimer colors. The generic multicolored QDM, illustrated for the two- and three-color cases, possesses a topological color structure, ``color vison'' excitations, and broad regions of resonating VB phases. The specific models are analyzed to gain further insight into the likely ground states in the superexchange and direct-exchange limits of the electronic Hamiltonian, and they suggest a strong tendency toward VB order in all cases.
We use Monte Carlo simulations to study properties of Anderson's resonating-valence-bond (RVB) spin-liquid state on the square lattice (i.e., the equal superposition of all pairing of spins into nearest-neighbor singlet pairs) and compare with the classical dimer model (CDM). The latter system also corresponds to the ground state of the Rokhsar-Kivelson quantum dimer model at its critical point. We find that, although spin-spin correlations decay exponentially in the RVB, four-spin valence-bond-solid correlations are critical, qualitatively like the well-known dimer-dimer correlations of the CDM, but decaying more slowly (as $1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ with $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\approx}1.20$, compared with $\ensuremath{\alpha}=2$ for the CDM). We also compute the distribution of monomer (defect) pair separations, which decay by a larger exponent in the RVB than in the CDM. We further study both models in their different winding-number sectors and evaluate the relative weights of different sectors. Like the CDM, all the observed RVB behaviors can be understood in the framework of a mapping to a ``height'' model characterized by a gradient-squared stiffness constant KKK. Four independent measurements consistently show a value ${K}_{\mathrm{RVB}}\ensuremath{\approx}1.6{K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}$, with the same kinds of numerical evaluations of KCDM{K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}KCDM​ giving results in agreement with the rigorously known value ${K}_{\mathrm{CDM}}=\ensuremath{\pi}/16$. The background of a nonzero winding-number gradient W/LW/LW/L introduces spatial anisotropies and an increase in the effective KKK, both of which can be understood as a consequence of anharmonic terms in the height-model free energy, which are of relevance to the recently proposed scenario of ``Cantor deconfinement'' in extended quantum dimer models. In addition to the standard case of short bonds only, we also studied ensembles in which fourth-neighbor (bipartite) bonds are allowed at a density controlled by a tunable fugacity, resulting (as expected) in a smooth reduction of KKK.