Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2203.10318 · Physical Review Research

Exact rate analysis for quantum repeaters with imperfect memories and entanglement swapping as soon as possible

Lars Kamin, Evgeny V Shchukin, Frank Schmidt, Peter van Loock

Published May 10, 2023• 49 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present an exact rate analysis for a secret key that can be shared among two parties employing a linear quantum repeater chain. One of our main motivations is to address the question whether simply placing quantum memories along a quantum communication channel can be beneficial in a realistic setting. The underlying model assumes deterministic entanglement swapping of single-spin quantum memories and it excludes probabilistic entanglement distillation, and thus two-way classical communication, on higher nesting levels. Within this framework, we identify the essential properties of any optimal repeater scheme: entanglement distribution in parallel, entanglement swapping as soon and parallel quantum storage as little as possible. While these features are obvious or trivial for the simplest repeater with one middle station, for more stations they cannot always be combined. We propose an optimal scheme including channel loss and memory dephasing, proving its optimality for the case of two stations and conjecturing it for the general case. In an even more realistic setting, we consider additional tools and parameters such as memory cutoffs, multiplexing, initial state and swapping gate fidelities, and finite link coupling efficiencies in order to identify potential regimes in memory-assisted quantum key distribution beyond one middle station that exceed the rates of the smallest quantum repeaters as well as those obtainable in all-optical schemes unassisted by stationary memory qubits and two-way classical communication. Our analytical treatment enables us to determine simultaneous trade-offs between various parameters, their scaling, and their influence on the performance ordering among different types of protocols, comparing two-photon interference after dual-rail qubit transmission with one-photon interference of single-rail qubits or, similarly, optical interference of coherent states. We find that for experimental parameter values that are highly demanding but not impossible (up to 10 s coherence time, about 80% link coupling, and state or gate infidelities in the regime of 1%--2%), one secret bit can be shared per second at a total channel loss budget of 157.6 dB, i.e. a total distance of 800 km for a fiber attenuation length of 22 km with repeater stations placed at every 100 km---a clear improvement over realistic twin-field or, much more pronouncedly, ideal point-to-point quantum key distribution at GHz clock rates.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.5.023086

Related papers

Complete analysis of a realistic fiber-based quantum repeater scheme

Adam Kinos, Andreas Walther, Stefan Kröll +1 more

We present a quantum repeater protocol for distributing entanglement over long distances, where a dedicated communication stage enables trial rates not limited by the travel time between repeater nodes. To accomplish this, each node contains several qubits that can couple to one single-photon emitter. Photons from the emitters in neighboring nodes generate heralded entanglement between qubits in these nodes. The protocol leaves the emitters disentangled from the rest of the system immediately after emitting the photons, thus allowing them to be reused to entangle other qubits without waiting for the repeater link round-trip time. This time multiplexing increases the protocol trial rate by up to an order of magnitude. The protocol is then combined with conventional deterministic entanglement swapping and heralded entanglement purification to extend the entanglement distance and reduce the entanglement error, respectively. We perform a complete protocol analysis by considering all relevant error sources, such as initialization, two-qubit gate, and qubit measurement errors, as well as the exponential decoherence of the qubits with time. The latter is particularly important since we analyze the protocol performance for a broad range of experimental parameters and obtain secret key rates ranging from 1 to 1000 Hz at a distance of 1000 km. Our results suggest that it is important to reach a qubit memory coherence time of around 1 s, and two-qubit gate and measurement errors on the order of 10 − 3 to obtain reasonable secret key rates over distances longer than achievable with direct transmission. While this work focuses on optimizing secret key rates, the protocol can also be used for Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen pair generation and is thus also relevant for, e.g., distributed quantum computing.

arXiv:2309.04151•Physical Review Research•Aug 5, 2025•5 citations

Rate-loss analysis of an efficient quantum repeater architecture

Saikat Guha, Hari Krovi, Christopher A. Fuchs +4 more

We analyze an entanglement-based quantum key distribution (QKD) architecture that uses a linear chain of quantum repeaters employing photon-pair sources, spectral-multiplexing, linear-optic Bell-state measurements, multimode quantum memories, and classical-only error correction. Assuming perfect sources, we find an exact expression for the secret-key rate, and an analytical description of how errors propagate through the repeater chain, as a function of various loss-and-noise parameters of the devices. We show via an explicit analytical calculation, which separately addresses the effects of the principle nonidealities, that this scheme achieves a secret-key rate that surpasses the Takeoka-Guha-Wilde bound---a recently found fundamental limit to the rate-vs-loss scaling achievable by any QKD protocol over a direct optical link---thereby providing one of the first rigorous proofs of the efficacy of a repeater protocol. We explicitly calculate the end-to-end shared noisy quantum state generated by the repeater chain, which could be useful for analyzing the performance of other non-QKD quantum protocols that require establishing long-distance entanglement. We evaluate that shared state's fidelity and the achievable entanglement-distillation rate, as a function of the number of repeater nodes, total range, and various loss-and-noise parameters of the system. We extend our theoretical analysis to encompass sources with nonzero two-pair-emission probability, using an efficient exact numerical evaluation of the quantum state propagation and measurements. We expect our results to spur formal rate-loss analysis of other repeater protocols and also to provide useful abstractions to seed analyses of quantum networks of complex topologies.

arXiv:1404.7183•Physical Review A•Aug 31, 2015•142 citations

Rate analysis for a hybrid quantum repeater

Nadja K. Bernardes, Ludmiła Praxmeyer, Peter van Loock

We present a detailed rate analysis for a hybrid quantum repeater assuming perfect memories and using optimal probabilistic entanglement generation and deterministic swapping routines. The hybrid quantum repeater protocol is based on atomic qubit-entanglement distribution through optical coherent-state communication. An exact, analytical formula for the rates of entanglement generation in quantum repeaters is derived, including a study on the impacts of entanglement purification and multiplexing strategies. More specifically, we consider scenarios with as little purification as possible and we show that for sufficiently low local losses, such purifications are still more powerful than multiplexing. In a possible experimental scenario, our hybrid system can create near-maximally entangled ($F=0.98$) pairs over a distance of 1280 km at rates of the order of 100 Hz.

arXiv:1010.0106•Physical Review A•Jan 27, 2011•86 citations

Memory-assisted long-distance phase-matching quantum key distribution

Frank L. Schmidt, Peter van Loock

We propose a scheme that generalizes the loss scaling properties of twin-field or phase-matching quantum key distribution (QKD) related to a channel of transmission ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}$ from $\sqrt{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$ to $\sqrt[2n]{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$ by employing $n\ensuremath{-}1$ memory stations with spin qubits and $n$ beam-splitter stations including optical detectors. Our scheme's resource states are similar to the coherent-state-based light-matter entangled states of a previous hybrid quantum repeater, but unlike the latter our scheme avoids the necessity of employing $2n\ensuremath{-}1$ memory stations and writing the transmitted optical states into the matter memory qubits. The full scaling advantage of this memory-assisted phase-matching QKD (MA-PM QKD) is obtainable with threshold detectors in a scenario with only channel loss. We mainly focus on the obtainable secret-key rates per channel use for up to $n=4$ including memory dephasing and for $n=2$ (i.e., $\sqrt[4]{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$-MA-PM QKD assisted by a single memory station) for error models including dark counts, memory dephasing and depolarization, and phase mismatch. By combining the twin-field concept of interfering phase-sensitive optical states with that of storing quantum states up to a cutoff memory time, distances well beyond 700 km with rates well above ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}$ can be reached for realistic, high-quality quantum memories (up to 1-s coherence time) and modest detector efficiencies. Similarly, the standard single-node quantum repeater, scaling as $\sqrt{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$, can be beaten when approaching perfect detectors and exceeding spin coherence times of 5 s; beating ideal twin-field QKD requires 1 s. As for further experimental simplifications, our treatment includes the notion of weak nonlinearities for the light-matter states, a discussion on the possibility of replacing the threshold by homodyne detectors, and a comparison between sequential and parallel entanglement distributions.

arXiv:1910.03333•Physical Review A•Oct 26, 2020•19 citations

Quantum repeaters using a heralded scheme with remote swapping and two-photon interference

Yi Zhong, Chang Li, 颜辉 Yan Hui

Abstract Efficient long-distance entanglement distribution is a key requirement for a global quantum internet. Quantum repeaters overcome photon loss in optical fibers, offering a route to long-distance entanglement distribution. Here, we study heralded quantum repeater architectures that are based on two-photon interference and integrate local or remote swapping. We derive an analytical expression for the entanglement distribution time as a function of transmission distance for both heralded local-swapping and remote-swapping schemes. This expression provides physical insight into how repeaters overcome channel loss in long-haul fibers. Considering a realistic quantum memory, we present theoretical curves showing the effect of finite memory lifetime on the entanglement distribution time. By comparing optimal distribution times over distances up to thousands of kilometers, we determine the optimal nesting architectures for the single-repeater channel in each scheme and compare the optimal distribution rates and entanglement fidelities of these schemes at various distances. Finally, by examining the limiting cases of zero channel loss, zero device loss, and lossless repeater systems, we find fundamental performance bounds for quantum repeaters. These results provide practical design principles for scalable quantum repeater networks and pave the way toward continent-scale quantum communication.

Chinese Physics B•Oct 28, 2026•0 citations

Long-distance quantum key distribution with imperfect devices

Nicoló Lo Piparo, Mohsen Razavi

Quantum key distribution over probabilistic quantum repeaters is addressed. We compare, under practical assumptions, two such schemes in terms of their secret key generation rates per quantum memory. The two schemes under investigation are the one proposed by Duan et al. [Nature (London) 414, 413 (2001)] and that of Sangouard et al. [Phys. Rev. A 76, 050301 (2007)]. We consider various sources of imperfection in both protocols, such as nonzero double-photon probabilities at the sources, dark counts in detectors, and inefficiencies in the channel, photodetectors, and memories. We also consider memory decay and dephasing processes in our analysis. For the latter system, we determine the maximum value of the double-photon probability beyond which secret key distillation is not possible. We also find crossover distances for one nesting level to its subsequent one. We finally compare the two protocols in terms of their achievable secret key generation rates at their optimal settings. Our results specify regimes of operation where one system outperforms the other.

arXiv:1210.8042•Physical Review A•Jul 30, 2013•21 citations
We present an exact rate analysis for a secret key that can be shared among two parties employing a linear quantum repeater chain. One of our main motivations is to address the question whether simply placing quantum memories along a quantum communication channel can be beneficial in a realistic setting. The underlying model assumes deterministic entanglement swapping of single-spin quantum memories and it excludes probabilistic entanglement distillation, and thus two-way classical communication, on higher nesting levels. Within this framework, we identify the essential properties of any optimal repeater scheme: entanglement distribution in parallel, entanglement swapping as soon and parallel quantum storage as little as possible. While these features are obvious or trivial for the simplest repeater with one middle station, for more stations they cannot always be combined. We propose an optimal scheme including channel loss and memory dephasing, proving its optimality for the case of two stations and conjecturing it for the general case. In an even more realistic setting, we consider additional tools and parameters such as memory cutoffs, multiplexing, initial state and swapping gate fidelities, and finite link coupling efficiencies in order to identify potential regimes in memory-assisted quantum key distribution beyond one middle station that exceed the rates of the smallest quantum repeaters as well as those obtainable in all-optical schemes unassisted by stationary memory qubits and two-way classical communication. Our analytical treatment enables us to determine simultaneous trade-offs between various parameters, their scaling, and their influence on the performance ordering among different types of protocols, comparing two-photon interference after dual-rail qubit transmission with one-photon interference of single-rail qubits or, similarly, optical interference of coherent states. We find that for experimental parameter values that are highly demanding but not impossible (up to 10 s coherence time, about 80% link coupling, and state or gate infidelities in the regime of 1%--2%), one secret bit can be shared per second at a total channel loss budget of 157.6 dB, i.e. a total distance of 800 km for a fiber attenuation length of 22 km with repeater stations placed at every 100 km---a clear improvement over realistic twin-field or, much more pronouncedly, ideal point-to-point quantum key distribution at GHz clock rates.
We present a quantum repeater protocol for distributing entanglement over long distances, where a dedicated communication stage enables trial rates not limited by the travel time between repeater nodes. To accomplish this, each node contains several qubits that can couple to one single-photon emitter. Photons from the emitters in neighboring nodes generate heralded entanglement between qubits in these nodes. The protocol leaves the emitters disentangled from the rest of the system immediately after emitting the photons, thus allowing them to be reused to entangle other qubits without waiting for the repeater link round-trip time. This time multiplexing increases the protocol trial rate by up to an order of magnitude. The protocol is then combined with conventional deterministic entanglement swapping and heralded entanglement purification to extend the entanglement distance and reduce the entanglement error, respectively. We perform a complete protocol analysis by considering all relevant error sources, such as initialization, two-qubit gate, and qubit measurement errors, as well as the exponential decoherence of the qubits with time. The latter is particularly important since we analyze the protocol performance for a broad range of experimental parameters and obtain secret key rates ranging from 1 to 1000 Hz at a distance of 1000 km. Our results suggest that it is important to reach a qubit memory coherence time of around 1 s, and two-qubit gate and measurement errors on the order of 10 − 3 to obtain reasonable secret key rates over distances longer than achievable with direct transmission. While this work focuses on optimizing secret key rates, the protocol can also be used for Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen pair generation and is thus also relevant for, e.g., distributed quantum computing.
We analyze an entanglement-based quantum key distribution (QKD) architecture that uses a linear chain of quantum repeaters employing photon-pair sources, spectral-multiplexing, linear-optic Bell-state measurements, multimode quantum memories, and classical-only error correction. Assuming perfect sources, we find an exact expression for the secret-key rate, and an analytical description of how errors propagate through the repeater chain, as a function of various loss-and-noise parameters of the devices. We show via an explicit analytical calculation, which separately addresses the effects of the principle nonidealities, that this scheme achieves a secret-key rate that surpasses the Takeoka-Guha-Wilde bound---a recently found fundamental limit to the rate-vs-loss scaling achievable by any QKD protocol over a direct optical link---thereby providing one of the first rigorous proofs of the efficacy of a repeater protocol. We explicitly calculate the end-to-end shared noisy quantum state generated by the repeater chain, which could be useful for analyzing the performance of other non-QKD quantum protocols that require establishing long-distance entanglement. We evaluate that shared state's fidelity and the achievable entanglement-distillation rate, as a function of the number of repeater nodes, total range, and various loss-and-noise parameters of the system. We extend our theoretical analysis to encompass sources with nonzero two-pair-emission probability, using an efficient exact numerical evaluation of the quantum state propagation and measurements. We expect our results to spur formal rate-loss analysis of other repeater protocols and also to provide useful abstractions to seed analyses of quantum networks of complex topologies.
We present a detailed rate analysis for a hybrid quantum repeater assuming perfect memories and using optimal probabilistic entanglement generation and deterministic swapping routines. The hybrid quantum repeater protocol is based on atomic qubit-entanglement distribution through optical coherent-state communication. An exact, analytical formula for the rates of entanglement generation in quantum repeaters is derived, including a study on the impacts of entanglement purification and multiplexing strategies. More specifically, we consider scenarios with as little purification as possible and we show that for sufficiently low local losses, such purifications are still more powerful than multiplexing. In a possible experimental scenario, our hybrid system can create near-maximally entangled (F=0.98F=0.98F=0.98) pairs over a distance of 1280 km at rates of the order of 100 Hz.
We propose a scheme that generalizes the loss scaling properties of twin-field or phase-matching quantum key distribution (QKD) related to a channel of transmission ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}$ from $\sqrt{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$ to $\sqrt[2n]{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$ by employing $n\ensuremath{-}1$ memory stations with spin qubits and nnn beam-splitter stations including optical detectors. Our scheme's resource states are similar to the coherent-state-based light-matter entangled states of a previous hybrid quantum repeater, but unlike the latter our scheme avoids the necessity of employing $2n\ensuremath{-}1$ memory stations and writing the transmitted optical states into the matter memory qubits. The full scaling advantage of this memory-assisted phase-matching QKD (MA-PM QKD) is obtainable with threshold detectors in a scenario with only channel loss. We mainly focus on the obtainable secret-key rates per channel use for up to n=4n=4n=4 including memory dephasing and for n=2n=2n=2 (i.e., $\sqrt[4]{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$-MA-PM QKD assisted by a single memory station) for error models including dark counts, memory dephasing and depolarization, and phase mismatch. By combining the twin-field concept of interfering phase-sensitive optical states with that of storing quantum states up to a cutoff memory time, distances well beyond 700 km with rates well above ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}$ can be reached for realistic, high-quality quantum memories (up to 1-s coherence time) and modest detector efficiencies. Similarly, the standard single-node quantum repeater, scaling as $\sqrt{{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{total}}}$, can be beaten when approaching perfect detectors and exceeding spin coherence times of 5 s; beating ideal twin-field QKD requires 1 s. As for further experimental simplifications, our treatment includes the notion of weak nonlinearities for the light-matter states, a discussion on the possibility of replacing the threshold by homodyne detectors, and a comparison between sequential and parallel entanglement distributions.
Abstract Efficient long-distance entanglement distribution is a key requirement for a global quantum internet. Quantum repeaters overcome photon loss in optical fibers, offering a route to long-distance entanglement distribution. Here, we study heralded quantum repeater architectures that are based on two-photon interference and integrate local or remote swapping. We derive an analytical expression for the entanglement distribution time as a function of transmission distance for both heralded local-swapping and remote-swapping schemes. This expression provides physical insight into how repeaters overcome channel loss in long-haul fibers. Considering a realistic quantum memory, we present theoretical curves showing the effect of finite memory lifetime on the entanglement distribution time. By comparing optimal distribution times over distances up to thousands of kilometers, we determine the optimal nesting architectures for the single-repeater channel in each scheme and compare the optimal distribution rates and entanglement fidelities of these schemes at various distances. Finally, by examining the limiting cases of zero channel loss, zero device loss, and lossless repeater systems, we find fundamental performance bounds for quantum repeaters. These results provide practical design principles for scalable quantum repeater networks and pave the way toward continent-scale quantum communication.
Quantum key distribution over probabilistic quantum repeaters is addressed. We compare, under practical assumptions, two such schemes in terms of their secret key generation rates per quantum memory. The two schemes under investigation are the one proposed by Duan et al. [Nature (London) 414, 413 (2001)] and that of Sangouard et al. [Phys. Rev. A 76, 050301 (2007)]. We consider various sources of imperfection in both protocols, such as nonzero double-photon probabilities at the sources, dark counts in detectors, and inefficiencies in the channel, photodetectors, and memories. We also consider memory decay and dephasing processes in our analysis. For the latter system, we determine the maximum value of the double-photon probability beyond which secret key distillation is not possible. We also find crossover distances for one nesting level to its subsequent one. We finally compare the two protocols in terms of their achievable secret key generation rates at their optimal settings. Our results specify regimes of operation where one system outperforms the other.