Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2203.09545 · Physical Review Letters

Third Law of Thermodynamics and the Scaling of Quantum Computers

Lorenzo Buffoni, Stefano Gherardini, Emmanuel Zambrini Cruzeiro, Yasser Omar

Published Oct 3, 2022• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The third law of thermodynamics, also known as the Nernst unattainability principle, puts a fundamental bound on how close a system, whether classical or quantum, can be cooled to a temperature near to absolute zero. On the other hand, a fundamental assumption of quantum computing is to start each computation from a register of qubits initialized in a pure state, i.e., at zero temperature. These conflicting aspects, at the interface between quantum computing and thermodynamics, are often overlooked or, at best, addressed only at a single-qubit level. In this Letter, we argue how the existence of a small but finite effective temperature, which makes the initial state a mixed state, poses a real challenge to the fidelity constraints required for the scaling of quantum computers. Our theoretical results, carried out for a generic quantum circuit with N-qubit input states, are validated by test runs performed on a real quantum processor.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.129.150602

Related papers

Fundamental limits for cooling of linear quantum refrigerators

Nahuel Freitas, Juan Pablo Paz

We study the asymptotic dynamics of arbitrary linear quantum open systems that are periodically driven while coupled with generic bosonic reservoirs. We obtain exact results for the heat flowing from each reservoir, and these results are valid beyond the weak-coupling or Markovian approximations. We prove the validity of the dynamical third law of thermodynamics (Nernst unattainability principle), showing that the ultimate limit for cooling is imposed by a fundamental heating mechanism that dominates at low temperatures, namely the nonresonant creation of excitation pairs in the reservoirs induced by the driving field. This quantum effect, which is missed in the weak-coupling approximation, restores the unattainability principle, the validity of which was recently challenged.

arXiv:1607.04234•Physical review. E•Jan 23, 2017•54 citations

Quantum refrigerator in the quest for the absolute zero temperature

Yair Rezek, Ronnie Kosloff

One of the formulations of the third laws of thermodynamics is that a processes become more isentropic as one approaches the absolute zero temperatures. We examine this prediction by studying an operating model of a quantum refrigerator pumping heat from a cold to a hot reservoir. The working medium consists of a gas of noninteracting harmonic oscillators. The model can be solved in closed form in the quasi-static limit or numerically for general conditions. It is found that the isentropic limit for Tc → 0 is approached only on the expansion segment of the refrigeration cycle. The scaling of the cooling rate with temperature is shown to be consistent with the second law of thermodynamics. This scaling is also consistent with the unattainability principle which is an alternative formulation of the third law of thermodynamics.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jan 11, 2008•0 citations

Dynamic Cooling on Contemporary Quantum Computers

Lindsay Bassman Oftelie, Antonella De Pasquale, Michele Campisi

We study the problem of dynamic cooling whereby a target qubit is cooled at the expense of heating up N − 1 further identical qubits by means of a global unitary operation. A standard back-of-the-envelope high-temperature estimate establishes that the target qubit temperature can be dynamically cooled by at most a factor of 1 / N . Here we provide the exact expression for the minimum temperature to which the target qubit can be cooled and reveal that there is a crossover from the high initial temperature regime, where the scaling is 1 / N , to a low initial temperature regime, where a much faster scaling of 1 / N occurs. This slow, 1 / N scaling, which was relevant for early high-temperature NMR quantum computers, is the reason dynamic cooling was dismissed as ineffectual around 20 years ago; the fact that current low-temperature quantum computers fall in the fast, 1 / N scaling regime, reinstates the appeal of dynamic cooling today. We further show that the associated work cost of cooling is exponentially more advantageous in the low-temperature regime. We discuss the implementation of dynamic cooling in terms of quantum circuits and examine the effects of hardware noise. We successfully demonstrate dynamic cooling in a three-qubit system on a real quantum processor. Since the circuit size grows quickly with N , scaling dynamic cooling to larger systems on noisy devices poses a challenge. We therefore propose a suboptimal cooling algorithm, whereby relinquishing a small amount of cooling capability results in a drastically reduced circuit complexity, greatly facilitating the implementation of dynamic cooling on near-future quantum computers. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2401.09134•PRX Quantum•Jul 16, 2024•24 citations

Quantum refrigerators in quest of the absolute zero

Ronnie Kosloff, Eitan Geva, Jeffrey M. Gordon

The second and third laws of thermodynamics can be used to establish a fundamental bound for the maximum possible cooling rate in approaching the absolute zero of temperature. In modeling the behavior of the molecular refrigerators geared toward attaining ultralow temperatures, only quantum mechanical, as opposed to classical physics, models can be admissible. As a simple model, we analyze a three-level quantum refrigerator, and in particular its irreversible thermodynamic performance as absolute zero is approached.

Journal of Applied Physics•Jun 1, 2000•86 citations

Efficiently Cooling Quantum Systems with Finite Resources: Insights from Thermodynamic Geometry

Philip Taranto, Patryk Lipka-Bartosik, Nayeli A. Rodríguez-Briones +4 more

Landauer's limit on heat dissipation during information erasure is critical as devices shrink, requiring optimal pure-state preparation to minimize errors. However, Nernst's third law states this demands infinite resources in energy, time, or control complexity. We address the challenge of cooling quantum systems with finite resources. Using Markovian collision models, we explore resource trade-offs and present efficient cooling protocols (that are optimal for qubits) for coherent and incoherent control. Leveraging thermodynamic length, we derive bounds on heat dissipation for swap-based strategies and discuss the limitations of preparing pure states efficiently.

arXiv:2404.06649•Physical Review Letters•Feb 18, 2025•17 citations

The quantum refrigerator: The quest for absolute zero

Y. Rezek, P. Salamon, K. H. Hoffmann +1 more

The emergence of the laws of thermodynamics from the laws of quantum mechanics is an unresolved issue. The generation of the third law of thermodynamics from quantum dynamics is analysed. The scaling of the optimal cooling power of a reciprocating quantum refrigerator is sought as a function of the cold bath temperature as T c →0. The working medium consists of noninteracting particles in a harmonic potential. Two closed-form solutions of the refrigeration cycle are analyzed, and compared to a numerical optimization scheme, focusing on cooling toward zero temperature. The optimal cycle is characterized by linear relations between the heat extracted from the cold bath, the energy level spacing of the working medium and the temperature. The scaling of the optimal cooling rate is found to be proportional to T c 3/2 giving a dynamical interpretation to the third law of thermodynamics.

arXiv:0808.0229•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Feb 1, 2009•100 citations
The third law of thermodynamics, also known as the Nernst unattainability principle, puts a fundamental bound on how close a system, whether classical or quantum, can be cooled to a temperature near to absolute zero. On the other hand, a fundamental assumption of quantum computing is to start each computation from a register of qubits initialized in a pure state, i.e., at zero temperature. These conflicting aspects, at the interface between quantum computing and thermodynamics, are often overlooked or, at best, addressed only at a single-qubit level. In this Letter, we argue how the existence of a small but finite effective temperature, which makes the initial state a mixed state, poses a real challenge to the fidelity constraints required for the scaling of quantum computers. Our theoretical results, carried out for a generic quantum circuit with N-qubit input states, are validated by test runs performed on a real quantum processor.
We study the asymptotic dynamics of arbitrary linear quantum open systems that are periodically driven while coupled with generic bosonic reservoirs. We obtain exact results for the heat flowing from each reservoir, and these results are valid beyond the weak-coupling or Markovian approximations. We prove the validity of the dynamical third law of thermodynamics (Nernst unattainability principle), showing that the ultimate limit for cooling is imposed by a fundamental heating mechanism that dominates at low temperatures, namely the nonresonant creation of excitation pairs in the reservoirs induced by the driving field. This quantum effect, which is missed in the weak-coupling approximation, restores the unattainability principle, the validity of which was recently challenged.
One of the formulations of the third laws of thermodynamics is that a processes become more isentropic as one approaches the absolute zero temperatures. We examine this prediction by studying an operating model of a quantum refrigerator pumping heat from a cold to a hot reservoir. The working medium consists of a gas of noninteracting harmonic oscillators. The model can be solved in closed form in the quasi-static limit or numerically for general conditions. It is found that the isentropic limit for Tc → 0 is approached only on the expansion segment of the refrigeration cycle. The scaling of the cooling rate with temperature is shown to be consistent with the second law of thermodynamics. This scaling is also consistent with the unattainability principle which is an alternative formulation of the third law of thermodynamics.
We study the problem of dynamic cooling whereby a target qubit is cooled at the expense of heating up N − 1 further identical qubits by means of a global unitary operation. A standard back-of-the-envelope high-temperature estimate establishes that the target qubit temperature can be dynamically cooled by at most a factor of 1 / N . Here we provide the exact expression for the minimum temperature to which the target qubit can be cooled and reveal that there is a crossover from the high initial temperature regime, where the scaling is 1 / N , to a low initial temperature regime, where a much faster scaling of 1 / N occurs. This slow, 1 / N scaling, which was relevant for early high-temperature NMR quantum computers, is the reason dynamic cooling was dismissed as ineffectual around 20 years ago; the fact that current low-temperature quantum computers fall in the fast, 1 / N scaling regime, reinstates the appeal of dynamic cooling today. We further show that the associated work cost of cooling is exponentially more advantageous in the low-temperature regime. We discuss the implementation of dynamic cooling in terms of quantum circuits and examine the effects of hardware noise. We successfully demonstrate dynamic cooling in a three-qubit system on a real quantum processor. Since the circuit size grows quickly with N , scaling dynamic cooling to larger systems on noisy devices poses a challenge. We therefore propose a suboptimal cooling algorithm, whereby relinquishing a small amount of cooling capability results in a drastically reduced circuit complexity, greatly facilitating the implementation of dynamic cooling on near-future quantum computers. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The second and third laws of thermodynamics can be used to establish a fundamental bound for the maximum possible cooling rate in approaching the absolute zero of temperature. In modeling the behavior of the molecular refrigerators geared toward attaining ultralow temperatures, only quantum mechanical, as opposed to classical physics, models can be admissible. As a simple model, we analyze a three-level quantum refrigerator, and in particular its irreversible thermodynamic performance as absolute zero is approached.
Landauer's limit on heat dissipation during information erasure is critical as devices shrink, requiring optimal pure-state preparation to minimize errors. However, Nernst's third law states this demands infinite resources in energy, time, or control complexity. We address the challenge of cooling quantum systems with finite resources. Using Markovian collision models, we explore resource trade-offs and present efficient cooling protocols (that are optimal for qubits) for coherent and incoherent control. Leveraging thermodynamic length, we derive bounds on heat dissipation for swap-based strategies and discuss the limitations of preparing pure states efficiently.
The emergence of the laws of thermodynamics from the laws of quantum mechanics is an unresolved issue. The generation of the third law of thermodynamics from quantum dynamics is analysed. The scaling of the optimal cooling power of a reciprocating quantum refrigerator is sought as a function of the cold bath temperature as T c →0. The working medium consists of noninteracting particles in a harmonic potential. Two closed-form solutions of the refrigeration cycle are analyzed, and compared to a numerical optimization scheme, focusing on cooling toward zero temperature. The optimal cycle is characterized by linear relations between the heat extracted from the cold bath, the energy level spacing of the working medium and the temperature. The scaling of the optimal cooling rate is found to be proportional to T c 3/2 giving a dynamical interpretation to the third law of thermodynamics.