Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2202.13963 · Physica Scripta

Detection of d 1 ⨂ d 2 dimensional bipartite entangled state: a graph theoretical approach

Rohit Kumar, Satyabrata Adhikari

Published Nov 11, 2022• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Braunstein et al have started the study of entanglement properties of the quantum states through graph theoretical approach. Their idea was to start from a simple unweighted graph G and then they have defined the quantum state from the Laplacian of the graph G . A lot of research had already been done using the similar idea. We ask here the opposite one i.e can we generate a graph from the density matrix? To investigate this question, we have constructed a unital map ϕ such that ϕ ( ρ ) = L ρ + ρ , where the quantum state is described by the density operator ρ . The entries of L ρ depends on the entries of the quantum state ρ and the entries are taken in such a way that L ρ satisfies all the properties of the Laplacian. This make possible to design a simple connected weighted graph from the Laplacian L ρ . We show that the constructed unital map ϕ characterize the quantum state with respect to its purity by showing that if the determinant of the matrix ϕ ( ρ ) − I is positive then the quantum state ρ represent a mixed state. Moreover, we study the positive partial transpose (PPT) criterion in terms of the spectrum of the density matrix under investigation and the spectrum of the Laplacian associated with the given density matrix. Furthermore, we derive the inequality between the minimum eigenvalue of the density matrix and the weight of the edges of the connected subgraph of a simple weighted graph to detect the entanglement of d 1 ⨂ d 2 dimensional bipartite quantum states. Lastly, we have illustrated our results with few examples.

DOI
10.1088/1402-4896/aca22c

Related papers

A combinatorial approach to multipartite quantum systems: basic formulation

Ali Saif M. Hassan, Pramod S. Joag

In this paper we give a method to associate a graph with an arbitrary density matrix referred to a standard orthonormal basis in the Hilbert space of a finite dimensional quantum system. We study related issues such as classification of pure and mixed states, Von Neumann entropy, separability of multipartite quantum states and quantum operations in terms of the graphs associated with quantum states. In order to address the separability and entanglement questions using graphs, we introduce a modified tensor product of weighted graphs, and establish its algebraic properties. In particular, we show that Werner's definition (Werner 1989 Phys. Rev. A 40 4277) of a separable state can be written in terms of graphs, for the states in a real or complex Hilbert space. We generalize the separability criterion (degree criterion) due to Braunstein et al (2006 Phys. Rev. A 73 012320) to a class of weighted graphs with real weights. We have given some criteria for the Laplacian associated with a weighted graph to be positive semidefinite.

arXiv:quant-ph/0602053•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 1, 2007•13 citations

Combinatorial structures in quantum correlation: A new perspective

Rohit kumar, Satyabrata Adhikari

Graph-theoretic structures play a central role in the description and analysis of quantum systems. In this work, we introduce a new class of quantum states, called $A_α$-graph states, which are constructed from either unweighted or weighted graphs by taking the normalised convex combination of the degree matrix $D$ and the adjacency matrix $A_G$ of a graph $G$. The constructed states are different from the standard graph states arising from stabiliser formalism. Our approach is also different from the approach used by Braunstein et al. This class of states depend on a tunable mixing parameter $α\in (0,1]$. We first establish the conditions under which the associated operator $ρ_α^{A_G}$ is positive semidefinite and hence represents a valid quantum state. We then derive a positive partial transposition (PPT) condition for $A_α$-graph states in terms of graph parameters. This PPT condition involves only the Frobenius norm of the adjacency matrix of the graph, the degrees of the vertices and the total number of vertices. For simple graphs, we obtain the range of the parameter $α$ for which the $A_α$-graph states represent a class of entangled states. We then develop a graph-theoretic formulation of a moments-based entanglement detection criterion, focusing on the recently proposed $p_3$-PPT criterion, which relies on the second and third moments of the partial transposition. Since the estimation of these moments is experimentally accessible via randomised measurements, swap operations, and machine-learning-based protocols, our approach provides a physically relevant framework for detecting entanglement in structured quantum states derived from graphs. This work bridges graph theory and moments-based entanglement detection, offering a new perspective on the role of combinatorial structures in quantum correlations.

quant-pharXiv:2512.15686•Annals of Physics•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Entanglement detection in triangle-free quantum states

Satvik Singh

We present an alternative approach to unveil a different kind of entanglement in bipartite quantum states whose diagonal zero patterns in suitable matrix representations admit a nice description in terms of triangle-free graphs. Upon application of a local averaging operation, the separability of such states transforms into a simple matrix positivity condition, the violation of which implies the presence of entanglement. We completely characterize the class of triangle-free graphs, which allows for nontrivial entanglement detection using the above test. Moreover, we develop a recipe to construct a plethora of unique classes of positive partial transpose (PPT) entangled states in arbitrary dimensions. Finally, we link the task of entanglement detection in general states to the well-known graph-theoretic problem of finding triangle-free-induced subgraphs in a given graph.

arXiv:2010.11891•Physical Review A•Mar 29, 2021•9 citations

Multipartite Separability of Laplacian Matrices of Graphs

Chai Wah Wu

Recently, Braunstein et al. introduced normalized Laplacian matrices of graphs as density matrices in quantum mechanics and studied the relationships between quantum physical properties and graph theoretical properties of the underlying graphs. We provide further results on the multipartite separability of Laplacian matrices of graphs. In particular, we identify complete bipartite graphs whose normalized Laplacian matrix is multipartite entangled under any vertex labeling. Furthermore, we give conditions on the vertex degrees such that there is a vertex labeling under which the normalized Laplacian matrix is entangled. These results address an open question raised in Braunstein et al. Finally, we show that the Laplacian matrix of any product of graphs (strong, Cartesian, tensor, lexicographical, etc.) is multipartite separable, extending analogous results for bipartite and tripartite separability.

arXiv:0809.0827•The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics•May 15, 2009•11 citations

The Tripartite Separability of Density Matrices of Graphs

Zhen Wang, Zhi‐Xi Wang

The density matrix of a graph is the combinatorial laplacian matrix of a graph normalized to have unit trace. In this paper we generalize the entanglement properties of mixed density matrices from combinatorial laplacian matrices of graphs discussed in Braunstein et al. [Annals of Combinatorics, 10 (2006) 291] to tripartite states. Then we prove that the degree condition defined in Braunstein et al. [Phys. Rev. A, 73 (2006) 012320] is sufficient and necessary for the tripartite separability of the density matrix of a nearest point graph.

arXiv:0705.2561•The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics•May 23, 2007•7 citations

Condition for zero and nonzero discord in graph Laplacian quantum states

Supriyo Dutta, Bibhas Adhikari, Subhashish Banerjee

This work is at the interface of graph theory and quantum mechanics. Quantum correlations epitomize the usefulness of quantum mechanics. Quantum discord is an interesting facet of bipartite quantum correlations. Earlier, it was shown that every combinatorial graph corresponds to quantum states whose characteristics are reflected in the structure of the underlined graph. A number of combinatorial relations between quantum discord and simple graphs were studied. To extend the scope of these studies, we need to generalize the earlier concepts applicable to simple graphs to weighted graphs, corresponding to a diverse class of quantum states. To this effect, we determine the class of quantum states whose density matrix representation can be derived from graph Laplacian matrices associated with a weighted directed graph and call them graph Laplacian quantum states. We find the graph theoretic conditions for zero and nonzero quantum discord for these states. We apply these results on some important pure two qubit states, as well as a number of mixed quantum states, such as the Werner, Isotropic, and [Formula: see text]-states. We also consider graph Laplacian states corresponding to simple graphs as a special case.

arXiv:1705.00808•International Journal of Quantum Information•Mar 1, 2019•7 citations
Abstract Braunstein et al have started the study of entanglement properties of the quantum states through graph theoretical approach. Their idea was to start from a simple unweighted graph G and then they have defined the quantum state from the Laplacian of the graph G . A lot of research had already been done using the similar idea. We ask here the opposite one i.e can we generate a graph from the density matrix? To investigate this question, we have constructed a unital map ϕ such that ϕ ( ρ ) = L ρ + ρ , where the quantum state is described by the density operator ρ . The entries of L ρ depends on the entries of the quantum state ρ and the entries are taken in such a way that L ρ satisfies all the properties of the Laplacian. This make possible to design a simple connected weighted graph from the Laplacian L ρ . We show that the constructed unital map ϕ characterize the quantum state with respect to its purity by showing that if the determinant of the matrix ϕ ( ρ ) − I is positive then the quantum state ρ represent a mixed state. Moreover, we study the positive partial transpose (PPT) criterion in terms of the spectrum of the density matrix under investigation and the spectrum of the Laplacian associated with the given density matrix. Furthermore, we derive the inequality between the minimum eigenvalue of the density matrix and the weight of the edges of the connected subgraph of a simple weighted graph to detect the entanglement of d 1 ⨂ d 2 dimensional bipartite quantum states. Lastly, we have illustrated our results with few examples.
In this paper we give a method to associate a graph with an arbitrary density matrix referred to a standard orthonormal basis in the Hilbert space of a finite dimensional quantum system. We study related issues such as classification of pure and mixed states, Von Neumann entropy, separability of multipartite quantum states and quantum operations in terms of the graphs associated with quantum states. In order to address the separability and entanglement questions using graphs, we introduce a modified tensor product of weighted graphs, and establish its algebraic properties. In particular, we show that Werner's definition (Werner 1989 Phys. Rev. A 40 4277) of a separable state can be written in terms of graphs, for the states in a real or complex Hilbert space. We generalize the separability criterion (degree criterion) due to Braunstein et al (2006 Phys. Rev. A 73 012320) to a class of weighted graphs with real weights. We have given some criteria for the Laplacian associated with a weighted graph to be positive semidefinite.
Graph-theoretic structures play a central role in the description and analysis of quantum systems. In this work, we introduce a new class of quantum states, called AαA_αAα​-graph states, which are constructed from either unweighted or weighted graphs by taking the normalised convex combination of the degree matrix DDD and the adjacency matrix AGA_GAG​ of a graph GGG. The constructed states are different from the standard graph states arising from stabiliser formalism. Our approach is also different from the approach used by Braunstein et al. This class of states depend on a tunable mixing parameter α∈(0,1]α\in (0,1]α∈(0,1]. We first establish the conditions under which the associated operator ραAGρ_α^{A_G}ραAG​​ is positive semidefinite and hence represents a valid quantum state. We then derive a positive partial transposition (PPT) condition for AαA_αAα​-graph states in terms of graph parameters. This PPT condition involves only the Frobenius norm of the adjacency matrix of the graph, the degrees of the vertices and the total number of vertices. For simple graphs, we obtain the range of the parameter ααα for which the AαA_αAα​-graph states represent a class of entangled states. We then develop a graph-theoretic formulation of a moments-based entanglement detection criterion, focusing on the recently proposed p3p_3p3​-PPT criterion, which relies on the second and third moments of the partial transposition. Since the estimation of these moments is experimentally accessible via randomised measurements, swap operations, and machine-learning-based protocols, our approach provides a physically relevant framework for detecting entanglement in structured quantum states derived from graphs. This work bridges graph theory and moments-based entanglement detection, offering a new perspective on the role of combinatorial structures in quantum correlations.
We present an alternative approach to unveil a different kind of entanglement in bipartite quantum states whose diagonal zero patterns in suitable matrix representations admit a nice description in terms of triangle-free graphs. Upon application of a local averaging operation, the separability of such states transforms into a simple matrix positivity condition, the violation of which implies the presence of entanglement. We completely characterize the class of triangle-free graphs, which allows for nontrivial entanglement detection using the above test. Moreover, we develop a recipe to construct a plethora of unique classes of positive partial transpose (PPT) entangled states in arbitrary dimensions. Finally, we link the task of entanglement detection in general states to the well-known graph-theoretic problem of finding triangle-free-induced subgraphs in a given graph.
Recently, Braunstein et al. introduced normalized Laplacian matrices of graphs as density matrices in quantum mechanics and studied the relationships between quantum physical properties and graph theoretical properties of the underlying graphs. We provide further results on the multipartite separability of Laplacian matrices of graphs. In particular, we identify complete bipartite graphs whose normalized Laplacian matrix is multipartite entangled under any vertex labeling. Furthermore, we give conditions on the vertex degrees such that there is a vertex labeling under which the normalized Laplacian matrix is entangled. These results address an open question raised in Braunstein et al. Finally, we show that the Laplacian matrix of any product of graphs (strong, Cartesian, tensor, lexicographical, etc.) is multipartite separable, extending analogous results for bipartite and tripartite separability.
The density matrix of a graph is the combinatorial laplacian matrix of a graph normalized to have unit trace. In this paper we generalize the entanglement properties of mixed density matrices from combinatorial laplacian matrices of graphs discussed in Braunstein et al. [Annals of Combinatorics, 10 (2006) 291] to tripartite states. Then we prove that the degree condition defined in Braunstein et al. [Phys. Rev. A, 73 (2006) 012320] is sufficient and necessary for the tripartite separability of the density matrix of a nearest point graph.
This work is at the interface of graph theory and quantum mechanics. Quantum correlations epitomize the usefulness of quantum mechanics. Quantum discord is an interesting facet of bipartite quantum correlations. Earlier, it was shown that every combinatorial graph corresponds to quantum states whose characteristics are reflected in the structure of the underlined graph. A number of combinatorial relations between quantum discord and simple graphs were studied. To extend the scope of these studies, we need to generalize the earlier concepts applicable to simple graphs to weighted graphs, corresponding to a diverse class of quantum states. To this effect, we determine the class of quantum states whose density matrix representation can be derived from graph Laplacian matrices associated with a weighted directed graph and call them graph Laplacian quantum states. We find the graph theoretic conditions for zero and nonzero quantum discord for these states. We apply these results on some important pure two qubit states, as well as a number of mixed quantum states, such as the Werner, Isotropic, and [Formula: see text]-states. We also consider graph Laplacian states corresponding to simple graphs as a special case.