Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2202.10471 · Physical Review A

Classical versus quantum: Comparing tensor-network-based quantum circuits on Large Hadron Collider data

Jack Y. Araz, Michael Spannowsky

Published Dec 19, 2022• 44 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Tensor networks (TN) are approximations of high-dimensional tensors designed to represent locally entangled quantum many-body systems efficiently. This paper provides a comprehensive comparison between classical TNs and TN-inspired quantum circuits in the context of machine learning on highly complex, simulated Large Hadron Collider data. We show that classical TNs require exponentially large bond dimensions and higher Hilbert-space mapping to perform comparably to their quantum counterparts. While such an expansion in the dimensionality allows better performance, we observe that, with increased dimensionality, classical TNs lead to a highly flat loss landscape, rendering the usage of gradient-based optimization methods highly challenging. Furthermore, by employing quantitative metrics, such as the Fisher information and effective dimensions, we show that classical TNs require a more extensive training sample to represent the data as efficiently as TN-inspired quantum circuits. We also engage with the idea of hybrid classical-quantum TNs and show possible architectures to employ a larger phase space from the data. We offer our results using three main TN Ans\"atze: Tree tensor networks, matrix product states, and multiscale entanglement renormalization Ans\"atze.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.106.062423

Related papers

Tensor Networks and Quantum-Inspired Machine Learning

Hamid D. Ismail

This chapter presents tensor networks as a unifying framework for quantum-inspired machine learning and for the analysis of near-term quantum learning models. Motivated by the challenge of high dimensionality, this chapter shows how tensor networks exploit locality, low-rank structure, and controlled correlations to represent high-order data efficiently while avoiding the exponential scaling of naïve tensor representations. Fundamental concepts including tensors, tensor contraction, and graphical network representations are introduced, followed by the development of key architectures such as Matrix Product States (Tensor Trains) and the Multi-scale Entanglement Renormalization Ansatz. Their roles in controlling expressivity, entanglement, and computational cost are emphasized throughout. This chapter further demonstrates the close correspondence between tensor networks and quantum circuits, showing how shallow quantum models can be interpreted as low-bond-dimension tensor networks and how this perspective clarifies classical simulability, representational capacity, and noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ)-era limitations. Hybrid quantum-tensor network architectures are presented as a practical route for combining classical compression and representation learning with targeted quantum processing. Applications in natural language processing, biological sequence learning, and image and signal processing illustrate how tensor network methods serve as both efficient classical models and structured surrogates for quantum learning systems. Hands-on Qiskit and PennyLane examples connect these ideas to executable machine learning workflows.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Decomposition of matrix product states into shallow quantum circuits

Manuel S. Rudolph, Jing Chen, Jacob A. Miller +2 more

Abstract Tensor networks (TNs) are a family of computational methods built on graph-structured factorizations of large tensors, which have long represented state-of-the-art methods for the approximate simulation of complex quantum systems on classical computers. The rapid pace of recent advancements in numerical computation, notably the rise of GPU and TPU hardware accelerators, have allowed TN algorithms to scale to even larger quantum simulation problems, and to be employed more broadly for solving machine learning tasks. The ‘quantum-inspired’ nature of TNs permits them to be mapped to parametrized quantum circuits (PQCs), a fact which has inspired recent proposals for enhancing the performance of TN algorithms using near-term quantum devices, as well as enabling joint quantum–classical training frameworks that benefit from the distinct strengths of TN and PQC models. However, the success of any such methods depends on efficient and accurate methods for approximating TN states using realistic quantum circuits, which remains an unresolved question. This work compares a range of novel and previously-developed algorithmic protocols for decomposing matrix product states (MPS) of arbitrary bond dimension into low-depth quantum circuits consisting of stacked linear layers of two-qubit unitaries. These protocols are formed from different combinations of a preexisting analytical decomposition method together with constrained optimization of circuit unitaries, with initialization by the former method helping to avoid poor-quality local minima in the latter optimization process. While all of these protocols have efficient classical runtimes, our experimental results reveal one particular protocol employing sequential growth and optimization of the quantum circuit to outperform all others, with even greater benefits in the setting of limited computational resources. Given these promising results, we expect our proposed decomposition protocol to form a useful ingredient within any joint application of TNs and PQCs, further unlocking the rich and complementary benefits of classical and quantum computation.

arXiv:2209.00595•Quantum Science and Technology•Oct 19, 2023•110 citations

Transforming two-dimensional tensor networks into quantum circuits for supervised learning

Zhihui Song, Jinchen Xu, Xin Zhou +2 more

Abstract There have been numerous quantum neural networks reported, but they struggle to match traditional neural networks in accuracy. Given the huge improvement of the neural network models’ accuracy by two-dimensional tensor network (TN) states in classical tensor network machine learning (TNML), it is promising to explore whether its application in quantum machine learning can extend the performance boundary of the models. Here, we transform two-dimensional TNs into quantum circuits for supervised learning. Specifically, we encode two-dimensional TNs into quantum circuits through rigorous mathematical proofs for constructing model ansätze, including string-bond states, entangled-plaquette states and isometric TN states. In addition, we propose adaptive data encoding methods and combine with TNs. We construct a tensor-network-inspired quantum circuit (TNQC) supervised learning framework for transferring TNML from classical to quantum, and build several novel two-dimensional TN-inspired quantum classifiers based on this framework. Finally, we propose a parallel quantum machine learning method for multi-class classification to construct 2D TNQC-based multi-class classifiers. Classical simulation results on the MNIST benchmark dataset show that our proposed models achieve the state-of-the-art accuracy performance, significantly outperforming other quantum classifiers on both binary and multi-class classification tasks, and beat simple convolutional classifiers on a fair track with identical inputs. The noise resilience of the models makes them successfully run and work in a real quantum computer.

Machine Learning Science and Technology•Mar 1, 2024•3 citations

Tensor networks for quantum machine learning

Hans-Martin Rieser, Frank Köster, Arne Raulf

Once developed for quantum theory, tensor networks (TNs) have been established as a successful machine learning (ML) paradigm. Now, they have been ported back to the quantum realm in the emerging field of quantum ML to assess problems that classical computers are unable to solve efficiently. Their nature at the interface between physics and ML makes TNs easily deployable on quantum computers. In this review article, we shed light on one of the major architectures considered to be predestined for variational quantum ML. In particular, we discuss how layouts like matrix product state, projected entangled pair states, tree tensor networks and multi-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz can be mapped to a quantum computer, how they can be used for ML and data encoding and which implementation techniques improve their performance.

arXiv:2303.11735•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jul 1, 2023•60 citations

Quantum-Train with Tensor Network Mapping Model and Distributed Circuit Ansatz

Chen-Yu Liu, Chu-Hsuan Abraham Lin, Kuan‐Cheng Chen

In the Quantum-Train (QT) framework, mapping quantum state measurements to classical neural network weights is a critical challenge that affects the scalability and efficiency of hybrid quantum-classical models. The traditional QT framework employs a multi-layer perceptron (MLP) for this task, but it struggles with scalability and interpretability. To address these issues, we propose replacing the MLP with a tensor network-based model and introducing a distributed circuit ansatz designed for large-scale quantum machine learning with multiple small quantum processing unit nodes. This approach enhances scalability, efficiently represents high-dimensional data, and maintains a compact model structure. Our enhanced QT framework retains the benefits of reduced parameter count and independence from quantum resources during inference. Experimental results on benchmark datasets demonstrate that the tensor network-based QT framework achieves competitive performance with improved efficiency and generalization, offering a practical solution for scalable hybrid quantum-classical machine learning.

arXiv:2409.06992•IEEE International Conference on Acoustics Speech and Signal Processing•Mar 12, 2025•15 citations

Hybrid Tensor Networks: The Integration of Quantum and Classical Machine Learning

Jiaqi Yao

Tensor networks can compactly represent high-dimensional data in the form of low-rank tensor decompositions, which helps capture complex structures and correlations within the data. However, their inherently multilinear nature limits their potential as universal approximators. To address this limitation, tensor networks are combined with classical neural network layers, introducing nonlinear elements to enhance the model’s expressive power. The Hybrid Tensor Networks (HTN) system encompasses two prevalent tensor network configurations, Matrix Product States and Tree Tensor Networks, which facilitates the adaptable design of models customized for particular machine learning applications. This framework has been validated on classification and image reconstruction tasks, demonstrating its potential to handle complex data structures and its applicability within the machine learning field. Employing this approach, the goal is to establish a foundation for future research on hybrid quantum-classical models, thereby opening up avenues for the realm of quantum machine learning.

International Conference on Computer, Vision and Intelligent Technology (ICCVIT)•Nov 24, 2024•1 citation
Tensor networks (TN) are approximations of high-dimensional tensors designed to represent locally entangled quantum many-body systems efficiently. This paper provides a comprehensive comparison between classical TNs and TN-inspired quantum circuits in the context of machine learning on highly complex, simulated Large Hadron Collider data. We show that classical TNs require exponentially large bond dimensions and higher Hilbert-space mapping to perform comparably to their quantum counterparts. While such an expansion in the dimensionality allows better performance, we observe that, with increased dimensionality, classical TNs lead to a highly flat loss landscape, rendering the usage of gradient-based optimization methods highly challenging. Furthermore, by employing quantitative metrics, such as the Fisher information and effective dimensions, we show that classical TNs require a more extensive training sample to represent the data as efficiently as TN-inspired quantum circuits. We also engage with the idea of hybrid classical-quantum TNs and show possible architectures to employ a larger phase space from the data. We offer our results using three main TN Ans"atze: Tree tensor networks, matrix product states, and multiscale entanglement renormalization Ans"atze.
This chapter presents tensor networks as a unifying framework for quantum-inspired machine learning and for the analysis of near-term quantum learning models. Motivated by the challenge of high dimensionality, this chapter shows how tensor networks exploit locality, low-rank structure, and controlled correlations to represent high-order data efficiently while avoiding the exponential scaling of naïve tensor representations. Fundamental concepts including tensors, tensor contraction, and graphical network representations are introduced, followed by the development of key architectures such as Matrix Product States (Tensor Trains) and the Multi-scale Entanglement Renormalization Ansatz. Their roles in controlling expressivity, entanglement, and computational cost are emphasized throughout. This chapter further demonstrates the close correspondence between tensor networks and quantum circuits, showing how shallow quantum models can be interpreted as low-bond-dimension tensor networks and how this perspective clarifies classical simulability, representational capacity, and noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ)-era limitations. Hybrid quantum-tensor network architectures are presented as a practical route for combining classical compression and representation learning with targeted quantum processing. Applications in natural language processing, biological sequence learning, and image and signal processing illustrate how tensor network methods serve as both efficient classical models and structured surrogates for quantum learning systems. Hands-on Qiskit and PennyLane examples connect these ideas to executable machine learning workflows.
Abstract Tensor networks (TNs) are a family of computational methods built on graph-structured factorizations of large tensors, which have long represented state-of-the-art methods for the approximate simulation of complex quantum systems on classical computers. The rapid pace of recent advancements in numerical computation, notably the rise of GPU and TPU hardware accelerators, have allowed TN algorithms to scale to even larger quantum simulation problems, and to be employed more broadly for solving machine learning tasks. The ‘quantum-inspired’ nature of TNs permits them to be mapped to parametrized quantum circuits (PQCs), a fact which has inspired recent proposals for enhancing the performance of TN algorithms using near-term quantum devices, as well as enabling joint quantum–classical training frameworks that benefit from the distinct strengths of TN and PQC models. However, the success of any such methods depends on efficient and accurate methods for approximating TN states using realistic quantum circuits, which remains an unresolved question. This work compares a range of novel and previously-developed algorithmic protocols for decomposing matrix product states (MPS) of arbitrary bond dimension into low-depth quantum circuits consisting of stacked linear layers of two-qubit unitaries. These protocols are formed from different combinations of a preexisting analytical decomposition method together with constrained optimization of circuit unitaries, with initialization by the former method helping to avoid poor-quality local minima in the latter optimization process. While all of these protocols have efficient classical runtimes, our experimental results reveal one particular protocol employing sequential growth and optimization of the quantum circuit to outperform all others, with even greater benefits in the setting of limited computational resources. Given these promising results, we expect our proposed decomposition protocol to form a useful ingredient within any joint application of TNs and PQCs, further unlocking the rich and complementary benefits of classical and quantum computation.
Abstract There have been numerous quantum neural networks reported, but they struggle to match traditional neural networks in accuracy. Given the huge improvement of the neural network models’ accuracy by two-dimensional tensor network (TN) states in classical tensor network machine learning (TNML), it is promising to explore whether its application in quantum machine learning can extend the performance boundary of the models. Here, we transform two-dimensional TNs into quantum circuits for supervised learning. Specifically, we encode two-dimensional TNs into quantum circuits through rigorous mathematical proofs for constructing model ansätze, including string-bond states, entangled-plaquette states and isometric TN states. In addition, we propose adaptive data encoding methods and combine with TNs. We construct a tensor-network-inspired quantum circuit (TNQC) supervised learning framework for transferring TNML from classical to quantum, and build several novel two-dimensional TN-inspired quantum classifiers based on this framework. Finally, we propose a parallel quantum machine learning method for multi-class classification to construct 2D TNQC-based multi-class classifiers. Classical simulation results on the MNIST benchmark dataset show that our proposed models achieve the state-of-the-art accuracy performance, significantly outperforming other quantum classifiers on both binary and multi-class classification tasks, and beat simple convolutional classifiers on a fair track with identical inputs. The noise resilience of the models makes them successfully run and work in a real quantum computer.
Once developed for quantum theory, tensor networks (TNs) have been established as a successful machine learning (ML) paradigm. Now, they have been ported back to the quantum realm in the emerging field of quantum ML to assess problems that classical computers are unable to solve efficiently. Their nature at the interface between physics and ML makes TNs easily deployable on quantum computers. In this review article, we shed light on one of the major architectures considered to be predestined for variational quantum ML. In particular, we discuss how layouts like matrix product state, projected entangled pair states, tree tensor networks and multi-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz can be mapped to a quantum computer, how they can be used for ML and data encoding and which implementation techniques improve their performance.
In the Quantum-Train (QT) framework, mapping quantum state measurements to classical neural network weights is a critical challenge that affects the scalability and efficiency of hybrid quantum-classical models. The traditional QT framework employs a multi-layer perceptron (MLP) for this task, but it struggles with scalability and interpretability. To address these issues, we propose replacing the MLP with a tensor network-based model and introducing a distributed circuit ansatz designed for large-scale quantum machine learning with multiple small quantum processing unit nodes. This approach enhances scalability, efficiently represents high-dimensional data, and maintains a compact model structure. Our enhanced QT framework retains the benefits of reduced parameter count and independence from quantum resources during inference. Experimental results on benchmark datasets demonstrate that the tensor network-based QT framework achieves competitive performance with improved efficiency and generalization, offering a practical solution for scalable hybrid quantum-classical machine learning.
Tensor networks can compactly represent high-dimensional data in the form of low-rank tensor decompositions, which helps capture complex structures and correlations within the data. However, their inherently multilinear nature limits their potential as universal approximators. To address this limitation, tensor networks are combined with classical neural network layers, introducing nonlinear elements to enhance the model’s expressive power. The Hybrid Tensor Networks (HTN) system encompasses two prevalent tensor network configurations, Matrix Product States and Tree Tensor Networks, which facilitates the adaptable design of models customized for particular machine learning applications. This framework has been validated on classification and image reconstruction tasks, demonstrating its potential to handle complex data structures and its applicability within the machine learning field. Employing this approach, the goal is to establish a foundation for future research on hybrid quantum-classical models, thereby opening up avenues for the realm of quantum machine learning.