Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2202.05378

Theory of perturbatively nonlinear quantum transport II: Hilbert space truncation, gauge invariance, and second order transport in a spatially uniform, time-varying electric field

Varga Bonbien, Aurélien Manchon

Published Feb 11, 2022• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This article is the second of a trilogy that addresses the perturbative response of general quantum systems, with possibly nontrivial ground state geometry, beyond linear order. Here, we establish concise, general formulae for second order response to a spatially uniform, time-varying electric field in the velocity gauge that are $\textit{manifestly}$ free of static limit spurious divergences. We first discuss general quantum evolution in a curved space, then detail how such a situation is a natural byproduct of Hilbert space truncation, and point out crucial subtleties associated with the resulting finite curvatures. We then present a geometric perspective of the two popular gauges often used in quantum transport theories, the velocity gauge and the length gauge, and discuss how they, taking truncation-induced curvature effects into account, naturally lead to the same results in spite of the truncation. We highlight subtle formal discrepancies in the literature. Finally, we provide a general scheme for removing static limit spurious divergences in the velocity gauge $\textit{without}$ frequency expansions and present concise and comprehensive Green's function formulae for responses up to second order. As an application of specific aspects of our theory, second order charge current responses in selected cases are analyzed in parts I and III.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2202.05378

Related papers

Theory of perturbatively nonlinear quantum transport I: general formulation and structure of the retarded correlator

Varga Bonbien, Aurélien Manchon

This article is the first of a trilogy that addresses various aspects of the perturbative response of general quantum systems, with possibly nontrivial ground state geometry, beyond linear order. Here, we use group theoretical considerations to investigate the structure of retarded correlators, and demonstrate how they decompose according to irreducible representations of a `time-reversal group' and relevant permutation groups, with the former probing dissipative and time-reversal properties, and the latter discerning configurational properties -- longitudinal, transverse and their generalizations. We establish second order fluctuation-dissipation and fluctuation-reaction theorems, and connect them to well-known second order transport effects such as the shift and injection currents. Exploiting the Schur-Weyl duality between irreducible representations of general linear groups and irreducible representations of permutation groups, we show how to decide which terms in the decomposition based on the latter can be supported by different crystals described via the 32 point groups, and perform the full point group classification for rank 3 and 4 polar and axial tensors. Our results provide a formal basis for the extraction of uniquely differing physical effects from retarded correlators. Applications to second order charge current responses in selected cases are given in part III.

arXiv:2202.05379•Feb 11, 2022•0 citations

Exploring many-body quantum geometry beyond the quantum metric with correlation functions: A time-dependent perspective

Yuntao Guan, Barry Bradlyn

The quantum geometric tensor and quantum Fisher information have recently been shown to provide a unified geometric description of the linear response of many-body systems. However, a similar geometric description of higher-order perturbative phenomena including nonlinear response in generic quantum systems is lacking. In this work, we develop a general framework for the time-dependent quantum geometry of many-body systems by treating external perturbing fields as coordinates on the space of density matrices. We use the Bures distance between the initial and time-evolved density matrix to define geometric quantities through a perturbative expansion. To lowest order, we derive a time-dependent generalization of the Bures metric related to the spectral density of linear response functions, unifying previous results for the quantum metric in various limits and providing a geometric interpretation of Fermi’s golden rule. At next order in the expansion, we define a time-dependent Bures-Levi-Civita connection for general many-body systems. We show that the connection is the sum of one contribution that is related to a second-order nonlinear response function, and a second contribution that captures the higher geometric structure of first-order perturbation theory. We show that in the quasistatic, zero-temperature limit for noninteracting fermions, this Bures connection reduces to the known expression for band-theoretic Christoffel symbols. Our work provides a systematic framework to explore many-body quantum geometry beyond the quantum metric and highlights how higher-order correlation functions can probe this geometry.

arXiv:2507.23028•Physical Review Research•Feb 27, 2026•4 citations

Nonequilibrium perturbation theory of the spinless Falicov-Kimball model: Second-order truncated expansion in U

Volodymyr Turkowski, James K. Freericks

We perform a perturbative analysis for the nonequilibrium Green's functions of the spinless Falicov-Kimball model in the presence of an arbitrary external time-dependent but spatially uniform electric field. The conduction-electron self-energy is found from a strictly truncated second-order perturbative expansion in the local electron-electron repulsion $U$. We examine the current at half-filling and compare to both the semiclassical Boltzmann equation and exact numerical solutions for the contour-ordered Green's functions from a transient-response formalism (in infinite dimensions) on the Kadanoff-Baym-Keldysh contour. We find that a strictly truncated perturbation theory in the two-time formalism cannot reach the long-time limit of the steady state; instead, it illustrates pathological behavior for times larger than approximately $2∕U$.

arXiv:cond-mat/0610640•Physical Review B•Mar 13, 2007•19 citations

Illustrating gauge invariance in quantum mechanics through the free electron in a uniform time-varying electric field

C. Leubner

The nature of gauge transformations and gauge invariance in quantum mechanics about which there exists so much confusion in the literature is simply and pedagogically illuminated by first carefully investigating in various gauges the elementary problem of a free electron subject to a spatially uniform time-dependent electric field, and by then utilizing the findings from this particular example to clarify some general misconceptions.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1981•9 citations

Gauge invariance and Ward identities in nonlinear response theory

Habib Rostami, Mikhail I. Katsnelson, Giovanni Vignale +1 more

We present a formal analysis of nonlinear response functions in terms of correlation functions in real- and imaginary-time domains. In particular, we show that causal nonlinear response functions, expressed in terms of nested commutators in real time, can be obtained from the analytic continuation of time-ordered response functions, which are more easily amenable to diagrammatic calculation. This generalizes the well-known result of linear response theory. We then use gauge invariance arguments to derive exact relations between second-order response functions in density and current channels. These identities, which are non-perturbative in the strength of inter-particle interactions, allow us to establish exact connections between nonlinear optics calculations done in different electromagnetic gauges.

arXiv:2102.04425•Annals of Physics•May 26, 2021•43 citations

Nonlinear response of Bloch electrons in infinite dimensions

Volodymyr Turkowski, James K. Freericks

The nonlinear response of noninteracting (Bloch) electrons is examined within a nonequilibrium formalism on the infinite-dimensional hypercubic lattice. We examine the effects of a spatially uniform, but time-varying electric field (ignoring magnetic-field effects). The electronic Green's functions, Wigner density of states, and time-varying current are all determined and analyzed. We study both constant and pulsed electric fields, focusing on the transient response region and on local properties. These noninteracting Green's functions are an important input into nonequilibrium dynamical mean field theory for the nonlinear response of strongly correlated electrons.

arXiv:cond-mat/0408455•Physical Review B•Feb 4, 2005•69 citations
This article is the second of a trilogy that addresses the perturbative response of general quantum systems, with possibly nontrivial ground state geometry, beyond linear order. Here, we establish concise, general formulae for second order response to a spatially uniform, time-varying electric field in the velocity gauge that are manifestly\textit{manifestly}manifestly free of static limit spurious divergences. We first discuss general quantum evolution in a curved space, then detail how such a situation is a natural byproduct of Hilbert space truncation, and point out crucial subtleties associated with the resulting finite curvatures. We then present a geometric perspective of the two popular gauges often used in quantum transport theories, the velocity gauge and the length gauge, and discuss how they, taking truncation-induced curvature effects into account, naturally lead to the same results in spite of the truncation. We highlight subtle formal discrepancies in the literature. Finally, we provide a general scheme for removing static limit spurious divergences in the velocity gauge without\textit{without}without frequency expansions and present concise and comprehensive Green's function formulae for responses up to second order. As an application of specific aspects of our theory, second order charge current responses in selected cases are analyzed in parts I and III.
This article is the first of a trilogy that addresses various aspects of the perturbative response of general quantum systems, with possibly nontrivial ground state geometry, beyond linear order. Here, we use group theoretical considerations to investigate the structure of retarded correlators, and demonstrate how they decompose according to irreducible representations of a `time-reversal group' and relevant permutation groups, with the former probing dissipative and time-reversal properties, and the latter discerning configurational properties -- longitudinal, transverse and their generalizations. We establish second order fluctuation-dissipation and fluctuation-reaction theorems, and connect them to well-known second order transport effects such as the shift and injection currents. Exploiting the Schur-Weyl duality between irreducible representations of general linear groups and irreducible representations of permutation groups, we show how to decide which terms in the decomposition based on the latter can be supported by different crystals described via the 32 point groups, and perform the full point group classification for rank 3 and 4 polar and axial tensors. Our results provide a formal basis for the extraction of uniquely differing physical effects from retarded correlators. Applications to second order charge current responses in selected cases are given in part III.
The quantum geometric tensor and quantum Fisher information have recently been shown to provide a unified geometric description of the linear response of many-body systems. However, a similar geometric description of higher-order perturbative phenomena including nonlinear response in generic quantum systems is lacking. In this work, we develop a general framework for the time-dependent quantum geometry of many-body systems by treating external perturbing fields as coordinates on the space of density matrices. We use the Bures distance between the initial and time-evolved density matrix to define geometric quantities through a perturbative expansion. To lowest order, we derive a time-dependent generalization of the Bures metric related to the spectral density of linear response functions, unifying previous results for the quantum metric in various limits and providing a geometric interpretation of Fermi’s golden rule. At next order in the expansion, we define a time-dependent Bures-Levi-Civita connection for general many-body systems. We show that the connection is the sum of one contribution that is related to a second-order nonlinear response function, and a second contribution that captures the higher geometric structure of first-order perturbation theory. We show that in the quasistatic, zero-temperature limit for noninteracting fermions, this Bures connection reduces to the known expression for band-theoretic Christoffel symbols. Our work provides a systematic framework to explore many-body quantum geometry beyond the quantum metric and highlights how higher-order correlation functions can probe this geometry.
We perform a perturbative analysis for the nonequilibrium Green's functions of the spinless Falicov-Kimball model in the presence of an arbitrary external time-dependent but spatially uniform electric field. The conduction-electron self-energy is found from a strictly truncated second-order perturbative expansion in the local electron-electron repulsion UUU. We examine the current at half-filling and compare to both the semiclassical Boltzmann equation and exact numerical solutions for the contour-ordered Green's functions from a transient-response formalism (in infinite dimensions) on the Kadanoff-Baym-Keldysh contour. We find that a strictly truncated perturbation theory in the two-time formalism cannot reach the long-time limit of the steady state; instead, it illustrates pathological behavior for times larger than approximately 2∕U2∕U2∕U.
We present a formal analysis of nonlinear response functions in terms of correlation functions in real- and imaginary-time domains. In particular, we show that causal nonlinear response functions, expressed in terms of nested commutators in real time, can be obtained from the analytic continuation of time-ordered response functions, which are more easily amenable to diagrammatic calculation. This generalizes the well-known result of linear response theory. We then use gauge invariance arguments to derive exact relations between second-order response functions in density and current channels. These identities, which are non-perturbative in the strength of inter-particle interactions, allow us to establish exact connections between nonlinear optics calculations done in different electromagnetic gauges.
The nonlinear response of noninteracting (Bloch) electrons is examined within a nonequilibrium formalism on the infinite-dimensional hypercubic lattice. We examine the effects of a spatially uniform, but time-varying electric field (ignoring magnetic-field effects). The electronic Green's functions, Wigner density of states, and time-varying current are all determined and analyzed. We study both constant and pulsed electric fields, focusing on the transient response region and on local properties. These noninteracting Green's functions are an important input into nonequilibrium dynamical mean field theory for the nonlinear response of strongly correlated electrons.