Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2201.13041

A new realization of the long-range entanglement: fractality replacing the topological order

Wei Wang

Published Jan 31, 2022• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The essence of the famed long-range entanglement as revealed in topologically ordered state is the paradoxical coexistence of short-range correlation and nonlocal information that cannot be removed through constant-depth local quantum circuits. Its realization in different quantum states is a focus research topic in both quantum computation and quantum matter. However, the proved realizations are subject to the paradigm of topological order (including its extensions), i.e. via a quantum code structure with macroscopic code distance. Here, we broaden the knowledge of long-range entangled states by rigorously proving the coexistence in a new concrete state. The state describes qudits on the newly experimentally discovered fractal lattice geometry (1.58D) on which the quantum code structure has been shown not to exist, i.e., there is no topological order. Our result might reveal a new paradigm for the realization of the long-range entanglement in many-body quantum states, and might stimulate new studies connecting quantum information and quantum matter.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2201.13041

Related papers

A long-range entangled state beyond the paradigm of topological order

Wei Wang

Abstract The nature of the famed long-range entanglement of quantum many-body systems is the paradoxical coexistence of short-range correlation and nonlocal information which cannot be encoded through constant-depth local quantum circuits. This coexistence is only proved in topologically ordered states and their extensions in 2D or higher dimensions, and is in charge of their fundamental importance in fault-tolerant quantum computation. Here, we broaden the knowledge of long-range entangled states beyond the manifold-topology picture by proving the coexistence in a new concrete example in addition to those well-known ones like the toric-code ground state. The new long-range entangled state reveals an intrinsically different paradigm, it describes quantum matter on the newly experimentally realized fractal lattice geometry in 1.58D where the topological framework is negated, but a self-similarity structure shapes how the nonlocal information is encoded. The new paradigm portrays an exotic quantum order and uncovers the potential of fractional-dimension quantum states in studies relevant to quantum computation.

•May 17, 2022•0 citations

Topological Order: From Long-Range Entangled Quantum Matter to a Unified Origin of Light and Electrons

Xiao-Gang Wen

We review the progress in the last 20–30 years, during which we discovered that there are many new phases of matter that are beyond the traditional Landau symmetry breaking theory. We discuss new “topological” phenomena, such as topological degeneracy that reveals the existence of those new phases—topologically ordered phases. Just like zero viscosity defines the superfluid order, the new “topological” phenomena define the topological order at macroscopic level. More recently, we found that at the microscopical level, topological order is due to long-range quantum entanglements. Long-range quantum entanglements lead to many amazing emergent phenomena, such as fractional charges and fractional statistics. Long-range quantum entanglements can even provide a unified origin of light and electrons; light is a fluctuation of long-range entanglements, and electrons are defects in long-range entanglements.

arXiv:1210.1281•ISRN Condensed Matter Physics•Mar 27, 2013•218 citations

Universal representation of the long-range entanglement in the family of Toric Code states

Mohammad Hossein Zarei, Mohsen Rahmani Haghighi

Abstract Toric Code, a cornerstone of the topological order, admits numerous realizations on different planar graphs. We prove that all these realizations share a single, universal entanglement structure in a sense that any Toric Code state can be generated by applying a fixed set of non-local unitaries between similar quasi-one-dimensional quantum ladders. In particular, we consider Toric Code states corresponding to various planar graphs and apply non-local dientanglers to qubits corresponding to non-contractible cycles that satisfy a topological constraint. We demonstrate that, independent of the geometry of the underlying graph, disentanglers convert Toric Code states into a tensor product of Kitaev's Ladder states. This exact and graph-independent construction reveals that the long-range entanglement characterizing the Toric Code's topological phase has a precise decomposable structure in a sense that it arises entirely from a specific pattern of entanglement between lower-dimensional subsystems. This structural insight opens new avenues for classification and simulation of topological orders.

arXiv:2509.03422•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 29, 2026•0 citations

Long-Range Entanglement from Measuring Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases

Nathanan Tantivasadakarn, Ryan Thorngren, Ashvin Vishwanath +1 more

A fundamental distinction between many-body quantum states are those with short- and long-range entanglement (SRE and LRE). The latter cannot be created by finite-depth circuits, underscoring the nonlocal nature of Schrödinger cat states, topological order, and quantum criticality. Remarkably, examples are known where LRE is obtained by performing single-site measurements on SRE, such as the toric code from measuring a sublattice of a 2D cluster state. However, a systematic understanding of when and how measurements of SRE give rise to LRE is still lacking. Here, we establish that LRE appears upon performing measurements on symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases—of which the cluster state is one example. For instance, we show how to implement the Kramers-Wannier transformation by adding a cluster SPT to an input state followed by measurement. This transformation naturally relates states with SRE and LRE. An application is the realization of double-semion order when the input state is the Z 2 Levin-Gu SPT. Similarly, the addition of fermionic SPTs and measurement leads to an implementation of the Jordan-Wigner transformation of a general state. More generally, we argue that a large class of SPT phases protected by G × H symmetry gives rise to anomalous LRE upon measuring G -charges, and we prove that this persists for generic points in the SPT phase under certain conditions. Our work introduces a new practical tool for using SPT phases as resources for creating LRE, and we uncover the classification result that all states related by sequentially gauging Abelian groups or by Jordan-Wigner transformation are in the same equivalence class, once we augment finite-depth circuits with single-site measurements. In particular, any topological or fracton order with a solvable finite gauge group can be obtained from a product state in this way. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2112.01519•Physical Review X•Jun 7, 2024•241 citations

Extensive long-range magic in non-Abelian topological orders

Yuzhen Zhang, Isaac H. Kim, Yimu Bao +1 more

We show that the low-energy states of non-Abelian topological orders possess extensive magic which is long-ranged, and cannot be eliminated by a constant-depth local unitary circuit. This refines conventional notions of complexity beyond the linear circuit depth which is required to prepare any topological phase, and provides a new resource-theoretic characterization of topological orders. A central technical result is a no-go theorem establishing that stabilizer states--even up to constant-depth local unitarie--cannot approximate low-energy states of non-Abelian string-net models which satisfy the entanglement bootstrap axioms. Moreover, we show that stabilizer-realizable Abelian string-net phases have mutual braiding phases quantized by the on-site qudit dimension, and that any violation of this condition necessarily implies extensive long-range magic. Extending to higher spatial dimensions, we argue that any state obeying an entanglement area law and hosting excitations with nontrivial fusion spaces must exhibit extensive long-range magic. This applies, in particular, to ground-states and low-energy states of higher-dimensional quantum double models.

quant-pharXiv:2605.15150•May 15, 2026•9 citations

Entanglement Spectroscopy and probing the Li-Haldane Conjecture in Topological Quantum Matter

Torsten V. Zache, Christian Kokail, Bhuvanesh Sundar +1 more

Topological phases are characterized by their entanglement properties, which is manifest in a direct relation between entanglement spectra and edge states discovered by Li and Haldane. We propose to leverage the power of synthetic quantum systems for measuring entanglement via the Entanglement Hamiltonian to probe this relationship experimentally. This is made possible by exploiting the quasi-local structure of Entanglement Hamiltonians. The feasibility of this proposal is illustrated for two paradigmatic examples realizable with current technology, an integer quantum Hall state of non-interacting fermions on a 2D lattice and a symmetry protected topological state of interacting fermions on a 1D chain. Our results pave the road towards an experimental identification of topological order in strongly correlated quantum many-body systems.

arXiv:2110.03913•Quantum•Apr 27, 2022•33 citations
The essence of the famed long-range entanglement as revealed in topologically ordered state is the paradoxical coexistence of short-range correlation and nonlocal information that cannot be removed through constant-depth local quantum circuits. Its realization in different quantum states is a focus research topic in both quantum computation and quantum matter. However, the proved realizations are subject to the paradigm of topological order (including its extensions), i.e. via a quantum code structure with macroscopic code distance. Here, we broaden the knowledge of long-range entangled states by rigorously proving the coexistence in a new concrete state. The state describes qudits on the newly experimentally discovered fractal lattice geometry (1.58D) on which the quantum code structure has been shown not to exist, i.e., there is no topological order. Our result might reveal a new paradigm for the realization of the long-range entanglement in many-body quantum states, and might stimulate new studies connecting quantum information and quantum matter.
Abstract The nature of the famed long-range entanglement of quantum many-body systems is the paradoxical coexistence of short-range correlation and nonlocal information which cannot be encoded through constant-depth local quantum circuits. This coexistence is only proved in topologically ordered states and their extensions in 2D or higher dimensions, and is in charge of their fundamental importance in fault-tolerant quantum computation. Here, we broaden the knowledge of long-range entangled states beyond the manifold-topology picture by proving the coexistence in a new concrete example in addition to those well-known ones like the toric-code ground state. The new long-range entangled state reveals an intrinsically different paradigm, it describes quantum matter on the newly experimentally realized fractal lattice geometry in 1.58D where the topological framework is negated, but a self-similarity structure shapes how the nonlocal information is encoded. The new paradigm portrays an exotic quantum order and uncovers the potential of fractional-dimension quantum states in studies relevant to quantum computation.
We review the progress in the last 20–30 years, during which we discovered that there are many new phases of matter that are beyond the traditional Landau symmetry breaking theory. We discuss new “topological” phenomena, such as topological degeneracy that reveals the existence of those new phases—topologically ordered phases. Just like zero viscosity defines the superfluid order, the new “topological” phenomena define the topological order at macroscopic level. More recently, we found that at the microscopical level, topological order is due to long-range quantum entanglements. Long-range quantum entanglements lead to many amazing emergent phenomena, such as fractional charges and fractional statistics. Long-range quantum entanglements can even provide a unified origin of light and electrons; light is a fluctuation of long-range entanglements, and electrons are defects in long-range entanglements.
Abstract Toric Code, a cornerstone of the topological order, admits numerous realizations on different planar graphs. We prove that all these realizations share a single, universal entanglement structure in a sense that any Toric Code state can be generated by applying a fixed set of non-local unitaries between similar quasi-one-dimensional quantum ladders. In particular, we consider Toric Code states corresponding to various planar graphs and apply non-local dientanglers to qubits corresponding to non-contractible cycles that satisfy a topological constraint. We demonstrate that, independent of the geometry of the underlying graph, disentanglers convert Toric Code states into a tensor product of Kitaev's Ladder states. This exact and graph-independent construction reveals that the long-range entanglement characterizing the Toric Code's topological phase has a precise decomposable structure in a sense that it arises entirely from a specific pattern of entanglement between lower-dimensional subsystems. This structural insight opens new avenues for classification and simulation of topological orders.
A fundamental distinction between many-body quantum states are those with short- and long-range entanglement (SRE and LRE). The latter cannot be created by finite-depth circuits, underscoring the nonlocal nature of Schrödinger cat states, topological order, and quantum criticality. Remarkably, examples are known where LRE is obtained by performing single-site measurements on SRE, such as the toric code from measuring a sublattice of a 2D cluster state. However, a systematic understanding of when and how measurements of SRE give rise to LRE is still lacking. Here, we establish that LRE appears upon performing measurements on symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases—of which the cluster state is one example. For instance, we show how to implement the Kramers-Wannier transformation by adding a cluster SPT to an input state followed by measurement. This transformation naturally relates states with SRE and LRE. An application is the realization of double-semion order when the input state is the Z 2 Levin-Gu SPT. Similarly, the addition of fermionic SPTs and measurement leads to an implementation of the Jordan-Wigner transformation of a general state. More generally, we argue that a large class of SPT phases protected by G × H symmetry gives rise to anomalous LRE upon measuring G -charges, and we prove that this persists for generic points in the SPT phase under certain conditions. Our work introduces a new practical tool for using SPT phases as resources for creating LRE, and we uncover the classification result that all states related by sequentially gauging Abelian groups or by Jordan-Wigner transformation are in the same equivalence class, once we augment finite-depth circuits with single-site measurements. In particular, any topological or fracton order with a solvable finite gauge group can be obtained from a product state in this way. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We show that the low-energy states of non-Abelian topological orders possess extensive magic which is long-ranged, and cannot be eliminated by a constant-depth local unitary circuit. This refines conventional notions of complexity beyond the linear circuit depth which is required to prepare any topological phase, and provides a new resource-theoretic characterization of topological orders. A central technical result is a no-go theorem establishing that stabilizer states--even up to constant-depth local unitarie--cannot approximate low-energy states of non-Abelian string-net models which satisfy the entanglement bootstrap axioms. Moreover, we show that stabilizer-realizable Abelian string-net phases have mutual braiding phases quantized by the on-site qudit dimension, and that any violation of this condition necessarily implies extensive long-range magic. Extending to higher spatial dimensions, we argue that any state obeying an entanglement area law and hosting excitations with nontrivial fusion spaces must exhibit extensive long-range magic. This applies, in particular, to ground-states and low-energy states of higher-dimensional quantum double models.
Topological phases are characterized by their entanglement properties, which is manifest in a direct relation between entanglement spectra and edge states discovered by Li and Haldane. We propose to leverage the power of synthetic quantum systems for measuring entanglement via the Entanglement Hamiltonian to probe this relationship experimentally. This is made possible by exploiting the quasi-local structure of Entanglement Hamiltonians. The feasibility of this proposal is illustrated for two paradigmatic examples realizable with current technology, an integer quantum Hall state of non-interacting fermions on a 2D lattice and a symmetry protected topological state of interacting fermions on a 1D chain. Our results pave the road towards an experimental identification of topological order in strongly correlated quantum many-body systems.