This paper is on developing some computer-assisted proof methods involving non-classical inequalities for Shannon entropy. Two areas of the applications of information inequalities are studied: Secret sharing schemes and hat guessing games. In the former a random secret value is transformed into shares distributed among several participants in such a way that only the qualified groups of participants can recover the secret value. In the latter each participant is assigned a hat colour and they try to guess theirs while seeing only some of the others'. The aim is to maximize the probability that every player guesses correctly, the optimal probability depends on the underlying sight graph. We use for both problems the method of non-Shannon-type information inequalities going back to Z. Zhang and R. W. Yeung. We employ the linear programming technique that allows to apply new information inequalities indirectly, without even writing them down explicitly. To reduce the complexity of the problems of linear programming involved in the bounds we extensively use symmetry considerations. Using these tools, we improve lower bounds on the ratio of key size to secret size for the former problem and an upper bound for one of the ten vertex graphs related to an open question by Riis for the latter problem.
We present a new improvement in the linear programming technique to derive lower bounds on the information ratio of secret sharing schemes. We obtain non-Shannon-type bounds without using information inequalities explicitly. Our new technique makes it possible to determine the optimal information ratio of linear secret sharing schemes for all access structures on 5 participants and all graph-based access structures on 6 participants. In addition, new lower bounds are presented also for some small matroid ports and, in particular, the optimal information ratios of the linear secret sharing schemes for the ports of the Vamos matroid are determined.
We discuss linear programming techniques that help to deduce corollaries of non-classical inequalities for Shannon's entropy. We focus on direct applications of the copy lemma. These applications involve implicitly some (known or unknown) non-classical universal inequalities for Shannon's entropy, though we do not derive these inequalities explicitly. To reduce the computational complexity of these problems, we extensively use symmetry considerations. We present two examples of use of these techniques: we provide a reduced size formal inference of the best known bound for the Ingleton score (originally proven by Dougherty et al. with explicitly derived non-Shannon type inequalities), and improve the lower bound for the optimal information ratio of the secret sharing scheme for an access structure based on the Vámos matroid.
The known secret-sharing schemes for most access structures are not efficient; even for a one-bit secret the length of the shares in the schemes is 2O(n), wherenis the number of participants in the access structure. It is a long standing open problem to improve these schemes or prove that they cannot be improved. The best known lower bound is by Csirmaz, who proved that there exist access structures withnparticipants such that the size of the share of at least one party isn/logntimes the secret size. Csirmaz's proof uses Shannon information inequalities, which were the only information inequalities known when Csirmaz published his result. On the negative side, Csirmaz proved that by only using Shannon information inequalities one cannot prove a lower bound of ω(n) on the share size. In the last decade, a sequence of non-Shannon information inequalities were discovered. In fact, it was proved that there are infinity many independent information inequalities even in four variables. This raises the hope that these inequalities can help in improving the lower bounds beyondn. However, we show that any information inequality with four or five variables cannot prove a lower bound of ω(n) on the share size. In addition, we show that the same negative result holds for all information inequalities with more than five variables that are known to date.
/spl acute/A secret sharing scheme permits a secret to be shared among participants in such a way that only qualified subsets of participants can recover the secret, but any nonqualified subset has absolutely no information on the secret. We derive new limitations on the information rate of secret sharing schemes, that measures how much information is being distributed as shares as compared to the size of the secret key, and the average information rate, that is the ratio between the secret size and the arithmetic mean of the size of the shares. By applying the substitution technique, we are able to construct many new examples of access structures where the information rate is bounded away from 1. The substitution technique is a method used to obtain a new access structure by replacing a participant in a previous structure with a new access structure.>
In a secret sharing scheme, a secret s is divided into multiple shares and distributed among n participants. As more shares are collected, the mutual information between the secret and the shares increases monotonically. In the perfect case, the best known explicit lower bound on the share size is given by
k2k−1⋅H(s), where H(s) is the entropy of the secret and k is the largest integer such that n ≥ 2k+k−2. This paper considers the non-perfect case, in which each share reveals at most a
L1 fraction of the secret's entropy, for an integer L > 1. A prior result in this setting provides a lower bound of
kL2k−1⋅H(s), under the condition n ≥ 2k+k+L−3. We provide a new lower bound that approaches the perfect-case bound, namely
k2k−2+1/L⋅H(s), which holds under the condition n ≥ 2k+k+2L−4. The proof generalizes perfect-case techniques by increasing the number of participants by 2(L−1). These results refine our understanding of the trade-off between share size and information leakage in non-perfect secret sharing. In particular, we construct non-perfect access structures that nearly attain the perfect lower bound with fewer participants than previous non-perfect bounds, thus complementing and extending prior work.