Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2201.05563 · Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

Approximating quantum thermodynamic properties using DFT

Krissia Zawadzki, Amy Skelt, Irene D’Amico

Published Apr 11, 2022• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The fabrication, utilisation, and efficiency of quantum technology devices rely on a good understanding of quantum thermodynamic properties. Many-body systems are often used as hardware for these quantum devices, but interactions between particles make the complexity of related calculations grow exponentially with the system size. Here we explore and systematically compare 'simple' and 'hybrid' approximations to the average work and entropy variation built on static density functional theory concepts. These approximations are computationally cheap and could be applied to large systems. We exemplify them considering driven one-dimensional Hubbard chains and show that, for 'simple' approximations and low to medium temperatures, it pays to consider a good estimate of the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian to approximate the driving Hamiltonian. Our results confirm that a 'hybrid' approach, requiring a very good approximation of the initial and, for the entropy, final states of the system, provides great improvements. This approach should be particularly efficient when many-body effects are not increased by the driving Hamiltonian.

DOI
10.1088/1361-648x/ac6648

Related papers

Quantum thermodynamic properties in many-body systems out-of-equilibrium

Amy Skelt

Relatively small many-body quantum systems are often used as hardware for quantum devices. Most of these devices will operate below the thermal limit where thermodynamics must be treated differently to account for quantum behaviours. It is therefore imperative that the thermodynamic properties of these systems are well understood, especially as they can limit the technologies but also help the fabrication and running of efficient quantum devices. \n \nIn this thesis we study quantum work and entropy production in closed many-body quantum systems out-of-equilibrium. We find that, for the systems studied, the largest average quantum work can be extracted in adiabatic weakly correlated regimes. These regimes are also seen to minimise the entropy produced, making them efficient regimes in which to operate devices based on these systems. \n \nAdiabatic evolutions are important for many quantum devices, and so it is important that they can be accurately characterised. The validity of current methods has been questioned recently, so in this thesis we propose the use of metrics as a good quantitative measure to characterise adiabaticity. We found that the density distance (a more accessible quantity than the wavefunction and its distance measures) alone can determine adiabaticity in a range of quantum systems, even at finite temperature. \n \nHowever, when calculating properties of many-body systems, there are many challenges often resulting in the need to approximate. In this thesis we propose a new style of approximation for quantum thermodynamic properties, taking inspiration from density functional theory (DFT). This new style uses the exact initial state of the system but approximates the dynamics and is seen to be computationally cheap but largely accurate. We test this with non-interacting and DFT approximated dynamics, finding that, surprisingly, the non-interacting dynamics give the most accurate results in most regimes, with the cheapest cost.

•Apr 1, 2020•0 citations

DFT-inspired methods for quantum thermodynamics

Marcela Herrera, Roberto M. Serra, Irene D’Amico

In the framework of quantum thermodynamics, we propose a method to quantitatively describe thermodynamic quantities for out-of-equilibrium interacting many-body systems. The method is articulated in various approximation protocols which allow to achieve increasing levels of accuracy, it is relatively simple to implement even for medium and large number of interactive particles, and uses tools and concepts from density functional theory. We test the method on the driven Hubbard dimer at half filling, and compare exact and approximate results. We show that the proposed method reproduces the average quantum work to high accuracy: for a very large region of parameter space (which cuts across all dynamical regimes) estimates are within 10% of the exact results.

arXiv:1703.02460•Scientific Reports•Jun 29, 2017•22 citations

Entropic Density Functional Theory

Ahmad Yousefi, Ariel Caticha

A formulation of density functional theory (DFT) is constructed as an application of the method of maximum entropy for an inhomogeneous fluid in thermal equilibrium. The use of entropy as a systematic method to generate optimal approximations is extended from the classical to the quantum domain. This process introduces a family of trial density operators that are parameterized by the particle density. The optimal density operator is that which maximizes the quantum entropy relative to the exact canonical density operator. This approach reproduces the variational principle of DFT and allows a simple proof of the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem at finite temperature. Finally, as an illustration, we discuss the Kohn-Sham approximation scheme at finite temperature.

arXiv:2207.10602•Entropy•Dec 21, 2023•6 citations

Enhancing density functional theory using the variational quantum eigensolver

Evan Sheridan, Lana Mineh, Raul A. Santos +1 more

Quantum computers open up new avenues for modelling the physical properties of materials and molecules. Density Functional Theory (DFT) is the gold standard classical algorithm for predicting these properties, but relies on approximations of the unknown universal functional, limiting its general applicability for many fundamental and technologically relevant systems. In this work we develop a hybrid quantum/classical algorithm called quantum enhanced DFT (QEDFT) that systematically constructs quantum approximations of the universal functional using data obtained from a quantum computer. We benchmark the QEDFT algorithm on the Fermi-Hubbard model, both numerically and on data from experiments on real quantum hardware. We find that QEDFT surpasses the quality of groundstate results obtained from Hartree-Fock DFT, as well as from direct application of conventional quantum algorithms such as VQE. Furthermore, we demonstrate that QEDFT works even when only noisy, low-depth quantum computation is available, by benchmarking the algorithm on data obtained from Google's quantum computer. We further show how QEDFT also captures quintessential properties of strongly correlated Mott physics for large Fermi-Hubbard systems using functionals generated on much smaller system sizes. Our results indicate that QEDFT can be applied to realistic materials and molecular systems, and has the potential to outperform the direct application of either DFT or VQE alone, without the requirement of large scale or fully fault-tolerant quantum computers.

arXiv:2402.18534•Feb 28, 2024•7 citations

Quantum phase transitions in one-dimensional nanostructures: a comparison between DFT and DMRG methodologies

T. Pauletti, M. Sanino, L. Gimenes +2 more

Abstract Context: In the realm of quantum chemistry, the accurate prediction of electronic structure and properties of nanostructures remains a formidable challenge. Density Functional Theory (DFT) and Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) have emerged as two powerful computational methods for addressing electronic correlation effects in diverse molecular systems. We compare ground-state energies (e0), density profiles (n) and average entanglement entropies ($\bar S$) in metals, insulators and at the transition from metal to insulator, in homogeneous, superlattices and harmonically confined chains described by the fermionic one-dimensional Hubbard model. While for the homogeneous systems there is a clear hierarchy between the deviations, $D%(\bar S)<D%(e_0)< \bar D%(n)$, and all the deviations decrease with the chain size; for superlattices and harmonical confinement the relation among the deviations is less trivial and strongly dependent on the superlattice structure and the confinement strength considered. For the superlattices, in general increasing the number of impurities in the unit cell represents less precision on the DFT calculations. For the confined chains, DFT performs better for metallic phases, while the highest deviations appear for the Mott and band-insulator phases. This work provides a comprehensive comparative analysis of these methodologies, shedding light on their respective strengths, limitations, and applications. Methods: The DFT calculations were performed using the standard Kohn-Sham scheme within the BALDA approach. It integrated the numerical Bethe-Ansatz (BA) solution of the Hubbard model as the homogeneous density functional within a local-density approximation (LDA) for the exchange-correlation energy. The DMRG algorithms were implemented using the ITensor library, which is based on the Matrix Product States (MPS) ansatz. The calculations were performed until the energy reaches convergence of at least 10-8.

arXiv:2402.12463•Journal of Molecular Modeling•Jul 16, 2024•2 citations

Thermal-density-functional-theory approach to quantum thermodynamics

Antonio Palamara, Francesco Plastina, A. Sindona +1 more

Understanding the thermodynamic properties of many-body quantum systems and their emergence from microscopic laws is a topic of great significance due to its profound fundamental implications and extensive practical applications. Recent advances in experimental techniques for controlling and preparing these systems have increased interest in this area, as they have the potential to drive the development of quantum technologies. In this study, we present a density-functional-theory approach to extract detailed information about the statistics of work and the irreversible entropy associated with quantum quenches at finite temperature. Specifically, we demonstrate that these quantities can be expressed as functionals of thermal and out-of-equilibrium densities, which may serve as fundamental variables for understanding finite-temperature many-body processes. We, then, apply our method to the case of the inhomogeneous Hubbard model, showing that our density-functional-theory-based approach can be usefully employed to unveil the distinctive roles of interaction and external potential on the thermodynamic properties of such a system. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2409.02559•Physical Review A•Dec 2, 2024•5 citations
The fabrication, utilisation, and efficiency of quantum technology devices rely on a good understanding of quantum thermodynamic properties. Many-body systems are often used as hardware for these quantum devices, but interactions between particles make the complexity of related calculations grow exponentially with the system size. Here we explore and systematically compare 'simple' and 'hybrid' approximations to the average work and entropy variation built on static density functional theory concepts. These approximations are computationally cheap and could be applied to large systems. We exemplify them considering driven one-dimensional Hubbard chains and show that, for 'simple' approximations and low to medium temperatures, it pays to consider a good estimate of the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian to approximate the driving Hamiltonian. Our results confirm that a 'hybrid' approach, requiring a very good approximation of the initial and, for the entropy, final states of the system, provides great improvements. This approach should be particularly efficient when many-body effects are not increased by the driving Hamiltonian.
Relatively small many-body quantum systems are often used as hardware for quantum devices. Most of these devices will operate below the thermal limit where thermodynamics must be treated differently to account for quantum behaviours. It is therefore imperative that the thermodynamic properties of these systems are well understood, especially as they can limit the technologies but also help the fabrication and running of efficient quantum devices. \n \nIn this thesis we study quantum work and entropy production in closed many-body quantum systems out-of-equilibrium. We find that, for the systems studied, the largest average quantum work can be extracted in adiabatic weakly correlated regimes. These regimes are also seen to minimise the entropy produced, making them efficient regimes in which to operate devices based on these systems. \n \nAdiabatic evolutions are important for many quantum devices, and so it is important that they can be accurately characterised. The validity of current methods has been questioned recently, so in this thesis we propose the use of metrics as a good quantitative measure to characterise adiabaticity. We found that the density distance (a more accessible quantity than the wavefunction and its distance measures) alone can determine adiabaticity in a range of quantum systems, even at finite temperature. \n \nHowever, when calculating properties of many-body systems, there are many challenges often resulting in the need to approximate. In this thesis we propose a new style of approximation for quantum thermodynamic properties, taking inspiration from density functional theory (DFT). This new style uses the exact initial state of the system but approximates the dynamics and is seen to be computationally cheap but largely accurate. We test this with non-interacting and DFT approximated dynamics, finding that, surprisingly, the non-interacting dynamics give the most accurate results in most regimes, with the cheapest cost.
In the framework of quantum thermodynamics, we propose a method to quantitatively describe thermodynamic quantities for out-of-equilibrium interacting many-body systems. The method is articulated in various approximation protocols which allow to achieve increasing levels of accuracy, it is relatively simple to implement even for medium and large number of interactive particles, and uses tools and concepts from density functional theory. We test the method on the driven Hubbard dimer at half filling, and compare exact and approximate results. We show that the proposed method reproduces the average quantum work to high accuracy: for a very large region of parameter space (which cuts across all dynamical regimes) estimates are within 10% of the exact results.
A formulation of density functional theory (DFT) is constructed as an application of the method of maximum entropy for an inhomogeneous fluid in thermal equilibrium. The use of entropy as a systematic method to generate optimal approximations is extended from the classical to the quantum domain. This process introduces a family of trial density operators that are parameterized by the particle density. The optimal density operator is that which maximizes the quantum entropy relative to the exact canonical density operator. This approach reproduces the variational principle of DFT and allows a simple proof of the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem at finite temperature. Finally, as an illustration, we discuss the Kohn-Sham approximation scheme at finite temperature.
Quantum computers open up new avenues for modelling the physical properties of materials and molecules. Density Functional Theory (DFT) is the gold standard classical algorithm for predicting these properties, but relies on approximations of the unknown universal functional, limiting its general applicability for many fundamental and technologically relevant systems. In this work we develop a hybrid quantum/classical algorithm called quantum enhanced DFT (QEDFT) that systematically constructs quantum approximations of the universal functional using data obtained from a quantum computer. We benchmark the QEDFT algorithm on the Fermi-Hubbard model, both numerically and on data from experiments on real quantum hardware. We find that QEDFT surpasses the quality of groundstate results obtained from Hartree-Fock DFT, as well as from direct application of conventional quantum algorithms such as VQE. Furthermore, we demonstrate that QEDFT works even when only noisy, low-depth quantum computation is available, by benchmarking the algorithm on data obtained from Google's quantum computer. We further show how QEDFT also captures quintessential properties of strongly correlated Mott physics for large Fermi-Hubbard systems using functionals generated on much smaller system sizes. Our results indicate that QEDFT can be applied to realistic materials and molecular systems, and has the potential to outperform the direct application of either DFT or VQE alone, without the requirement of large scale or fully fault-tolerant quantum computers.
Abstract Context: In the realm of quantum chemistry, the accurate prediction of electronic structure and properties of nanostructures remains a formidable challenge. Density Functional Theory (DFT) and Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) have emerged as two powerful computational methods for addressing electronic correlation effects in diverse molecular systems. We compare ground-state energies (e0), density profiles (n) and average entanglement entropies (Sˉ\bar SSˉ) in metals, insulators and at the transition from metal to insulator, in homogeneous, superlattices and harmonically confined chains described by the fermionic one-dimensional Hubbard model. While for the homogeneous systems there is a clear hierarchy between the deviations, DD%(\bar S)<D%(e_0)< \bar D%(n)D, and all the deviations decrease with the chain size; for superlattices and harmonical confinement the relation among the deviations is less trivial and strongly dependent on the superlattice structure and the confinement strength considered. For the superlattices, in general increasing the number of impurities in the unit cell represents less precision on the DFT calculations. For the confined chains, DFT performs better for metallic phases, while the highest deviations appear for the Mott and band-insulator phases. This work provides a comprehensive comparative analysis of these methodologies, shedding light on their respective strengths, limitations, and applications. Methods: The DFT calculations were performed using the standard Kohn-Sham scheme within the BALDA approach. It integrated the numerical Bethe-Ansatz (BA) solution of the Hubbard model as the homogeneous density functional within a local-density approximation (LDA) for the exchange-correlation energy. The DMRG algorithms were implemented using the ITensor library, which is based on the Matrix Product States (MPS) ansatz. The calculations were performed until the energy reaches convergence of at least 10-8.
Understanding the thermodynamic properties of many-body quantum systems and their emergence from microscopic laws is a topic of great significance due to its profound fundamental implications and extensive practical applications. Recent advances in experimental techniques for controlling and preparing these systems have increased interest in this area, as they have the potential to drive the development of quantum technologies. In this study, we present a density-functional-theory approach to extract detailed information about the statistics of work and the irreversible entropy associated with quantum quenches at finite temperature. Specifically, we demonstrate that these quantities can be expressed as functionals of thermal and out-of-equilibrium densities, which may serve as fundamental variables for understanding finite-temperature many-body processes. We, then, apply our method to the case of the inhomogeneous Hubbard model, showing that our density-functional-theory-based approach can be usefully employed to unveil the distinctive roles of interaction and external potential on the thermodynamic properties of such a system. Published by the American Physical Society 2024