Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2201.04667

Classical and Quantum Measurement Theory

Morgan, Peter

Published Jan 12, 2022• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Classical and quantum measurement theories are usually held to be different because the algebra of classical measurements is commutative, however the Poisson bracket allows noncommutativity to be added naturally. After we introduce noncommutativity into classical measurement theory, we can also add quantum noise, differentiated from thermal noise by Poincaré invariance. With these two changes, the extended classical and quantum measurement theories are equally capable, so we may speak of a single "measurement theory". The reconciliation of general relativity and quantum theory has been long delayed because classical and quantum systems have been thought to be very different, however this unification allows us to discuss a unified measurement theory for geometry in physics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2201.04667

Related papers

Incompatible observables in classical physics: A closer look at measurement in Hamiltonian mechanics

David Theurel

Quantum theory famously entails the existence of incompatible measurements, pairs of system observables which cannot be simultaneously measured to arbitrary precision. Incompatibility is widely regarded to be a uniquely quantum phenomenon, linked to failure to commute of quantum operators. Even in the face of deep parallels between quantum commutators and classical Poisson brackets, no connection has been established between the Poisson algebra and any intrinsic limitations to classical measurement. Here I examine measurement in classical Hamiltonian physics as a process involving the joint evolution of an object-system and a finite-temperature measuring apparatus. Instead of the ideal measurement capable of extracting information without disturbing the system, I find a Heisenberg-like precision-disturbance relation: Measuring an observable leaves all Poisson-commuting observables undisturbed but inevitably disturbs all non-Poisson-commuting observables. In this classical uncertainty relation the role of h-bar is played by an apparatus-specific quantity, q-bar. While this is not a universal constant, the analysis suggests that q-bar takes a finite positive value for any apparatus that can be built. (Specifically: q-bar vanishes in the model only in the unreachable limit of zero absolute temperature.) I show that a classical version of Ozawa's model of quantum measurement [Ozawa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 385 (1988)0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.60.385], originally proposed as a means to violate Heisenberg's relation, does not violate the classical relation. If this result were to generalize to all models of measurement, then incompatibility would prove to be a feature not only of quantum, but of classical physics too. Put differently: The approach presented here points the way to studying the (Bayesian) epistemology of classical physics, which was until now assumed to be trivial. It now seems possible that it is nontrivial and bears a resemblance to the quantum formalism. The present findings may be of interest to researchers working on foundations of quantum mechanics, particularly for ψ-epistemic interpretations. More practically, there may be applications in the fields of precision measurement, nanoengineering, and molecular machines.

arXiv:2104.02064•Physical review. E•Aug 19, 2024•1 citation

Quantum measurement theory

Kurt A. Jacobs

Introduction and overview Much that is studied in quantum measurement theory, and thus in this book, is very different from that studied in its classical counterpart, Bayesian inference. While quantum measurement theory is in one sense a minimal extension of the latter to quantum states, quantum measurements cause dynamical changes that never need appear in a classical theory. This has a multitude of ramifications, many of which you will find in this book. One such consequence is a limit to the information that can be obtained about the state of a quantum system, and this results in relationships between information gained and dynamics induced that do not exist in classical systems. Because of the limits to information extraction, choosing the right kinds of measurements becomes important in a way that it never was for classical systems. Finding the best measurements for a given purpose, and working out how to realize these measurements, is often nontrivial. The relationship between information and disturbance impacts the control of quantum systems using measurements and feedback, and we discuss this application in Chapter 5. The ability to extract information about quantum systems is also important in using quantum systems to make precise measurements of classical quantities such as time, acceleration, and the strengths of electric and magnetic fields. This subject is referred to as quantum metrology, and we discuss it in Chapter 6.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 14, 2014•10 citations

Algebra of quantum mechanics via classical phonons. II: Klein-Gordon dynamics, the Heisenberg formalism, the Dirac canonical commutation rule and the Poincare algebra through the continuous Poisson bracket formalism

Emmanuel Giner

In the first part of this series we have shown how the Schrodinger equation for a single particle and the corresponding non relativistic quantum observables can be obtained from a purely classical phonon model through the Newtonian equations of motion. In this work we focus instead on how the classical Hamiltonian formalism applied to the same phonon system allows to recover the feature of relativistic quantum mechanics for a single spinless particle. Using the classical nature of the phonon model, we naturally define continuous Poisson brackets between classical observables, which allows to recover the dynamics of such observables, i.e. the Ehrenfest relations associated to real-valued Klein-Gordon fields. The Poisson brackets also permits to obtain the generic form of constants of motions, thus generalizing the concept of inner products and momentum on Klein-Gordon fields. We then connect the formalism of real-valued classical functionals with that of hermitian operators and complex-valued wave functions. This is done through the introduction of a non-local complex-valued change of variables which allows to rewrite the real-valued Klein-Gordon equation in a form akin to the Schrodinger equation, and the classical observables as quantum expectation values. Then, we show how this change of variables allows to rewrite the classical Poisson brackets as commutators of hermitian operators. This points out the strict equivalence between the Heisenberg formalism and the formalism of classical Poisson bracket. Eventually, we illustrate how the Poisson brackets allows to recover the transformations of Poincare group in 1+1 dimension together with its algebra. The latter makes the link between the Lorentz invariant inner product of Mostafazadeh and the Casimir invariant associated to the mass of particle.

quant-pharXiv:2607.03909•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations

Quantum mechanics on non commutative spaces and squeezed states: a functional approach

Musongela Lubo

We review here the quantum mechanics of some noncommutative theories in which no state saturates simultaneously all the non trivial Heisenberg uncertainty relations. We show how the difference of structure between the Poisson brackets and the commutators in these theories generically leads to a harmonic oscillator whose positions and momenta mean values are not strictly equal to the ones predicted by classical mechanics. This raises the question of the nature of quasi classical states in these models. We propose an extension based on a variational principle. The action considered is the sum of the absolute values of the expressions associated to the non trivial Heisenberg uncertainty relations. We first verify that our proposal works in the usual theory i.e we recover the known Gaussian functions. Besides them, we find other states which can be expressed as products of Gaussians with specific hyper geometrics. We illustrate our construction in two models defined on a four dimensional phase space: a model endowed with a minimal length uncertainty and the non commutative plane. Our proposal leads to second order partial differential equations. We find analytical solutions in specific cases. We briefly discuss how our proposal may be applied to the fuzzy sphere and analyze its shortcomings.

arXiv:hep-th/0304039•Apr 4, 2003•7 citations

Quantum-classical interactions and measurement: a consistent description using statistical ensembles on configuration space

Marcel Reginatto, Michael J. W. Hall

We provide an overview of a canonical formalism that describes mixed quantum-classical systems in terms of statistical ensembles on configuration space, and discuss applications to measurement theory. It is shown that the formalism allows a general description of the measurement of a quantum system by a classical apparatus without running into inconsistencies. An example of classical and quantum particles interacting gravitationally is also given.

arXiv:0905.2948•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2009•24 citations

Measurement in classical and quantum physics

Alexey A. Kryukov

It was recently shown that quantum and classical mechanics are related in a deeper and more intimate way than previously thought possible. A geometric framework for both theories that allowed going back and forth between quantum and classical processes was discovered. The quantum-mechanical experiments were presented in a new and illuminating fashion, paving a way to resolve the paradoxes of quantum theory. The downside of the theory is a relatively involved machinery of functional analysis and differential geometry used to derive the results. At the same time, the main conclusions are fundamentally simple and can be presented without complicated math. The goal of this paper is to provide such a ``no math" presentation of the theory.

•Feb 24, 2000•0 citations
Classical and quantum measurement theories are usually held to be different because the algebra of classical measurements is commutative, however the Poisson bracket allows noncommutativity to be added naturally. After we introduce noncommutativity into classical measurement theory, we can also add quantum noise, differentiated from thermal noise by Poincaré invariance. With these two changes, the extended classical and quantum measurement theories are equally capable, so we may speak of a single "measurement theory". The reconciliation of general relativity and quantum theory has been long delayed because classical and quantum systems have been thought to be very different, however this unification allows us to discuss a unified measurement theory for geometry in physics.
Quantum theory famously entails the existence of incompatible measurements, pairs of system observables which cannot be simultaneously measured to arbitrary precision. Incompatibility is widely regarded to be a uniquely quantum phenomenon, linked to failure to commute of quantum operators. Even in the face of deep parallels between quantum commutators and classical Poisson brackets, no connection has been established between the Poisson algebra and any intrinsic limitations to classical measurement. Here I examine measurement in classical Hamiltonian physics as a process involving the joint evolution of an object-system and a finite-temperature measuring apparatus. Instead of the ideal measurement capable of extracting information without disturbing the system, I find a Heisenberg-like precision-disturbance relation: Measuring an observable leaves all Poisson-commuting observables undisturbed but inevitably disturbs all non-Poisson-commuting observables. In this classical uncertainty relation the role of h-bar is played by an apparatus-specific quantity, q-bar. While this is not a universal constant, the analysis suggests that q-bar takes a finite positive value for any apparatus that can be built. (Specifically: q-bar vanishes in the model only in the unreachable limit of zero absolute temperature.) I show that a classical version of Ozawa's model of quantum measurement [Ozawa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 385 (1988)0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.60.385], originally proposed as a means to violate Heisenberg's relation, does not violate the classical relation. If this result were to generalize to all models of measurement, then incompatibility would prove to be a feature not only of quantum, but of classical physics too. Put differently: The approach presented here points the way to studying the (Bayesian) epistemology of classical physics, which was until now assumed to be trivial. It now seems possible that it is nontrivial and bears a resemblance to the quantum formalism. The present findings may be of interest to researchers working on foundations of quantum mechanics, particularly for ψ-epistemic interpretations. More practically, there may be applications in the fields of precision measurement, nanoengineering, and molecular machines.
Introduction and overview Much that is studied in quantum measurement theory, and thus in this book, is very different from that studied in its classical counterpart, Bayesian inference. While quantum measurement theory is in one sense a minimal extension of the latter to quantum states, quantum measurements cause dynamical changes that never need appear in a classical theory. This has a multitude of ramifications, many of which you will find in this book. One such consequence is a limit to the information that can be obtained about the state of a quantum system, and this results in relationships between information gained and dynamics induced that do not exist in classical systems. Because of the limits to information extraction, choosing the right kinds of measurements becomes important in a way that it never was for classical systems. Finding the best measurements for a given purpose, and working out how to realize these measurements, is often nontrivial. The relationship between information and disturbance impacts the control of quantum systems using measurements and feedback, and we discuss this application in Chapter 5. The ability to extract information about quantum systems is also important in using quantum systems to make precise measurements of classical quantities such as time, acceleration, and the strengths of electric and magnetic fields. This subject is referred to as quantum metrology, and we discuss it in Chapter 6.
In the first part of this series we have shown how the Schrodinger equation for a single particle and the corresponding non relativistic quantum observables can be obtained from a purely classical phonon model through the Newtonian equations of motion. In this work we focus instead on how the classical Hamiltonian formalism applied to the same phonon system allows to recover the feature of relativistic quantum mechanics for a single spinless particle. Using the classical nature of the phonon model, we naturally define continuous Poisson brackets between classical observables, which allows to recover the dynamics of such observables, i.e. the Ehrenfest relations associated to real-valued Klein-Gordon fields. The Poisson brackets also permits to obtain the generic form of constants of motions, thus generalizing the concept of inner products and momentum on Klein-Gordon fields. We then connect the formalism of real-valued classical functionals with that of hermitian operators and complex-valued wave functions. This is done through the introduction of a non-local complex-valued change of variables which allows to rewrite the real-valued Klein-Gordon equation in a form akin to the Schrodinger equation, and the classical observables as quantum expectation values. Then, we show how this change of variables allows to rewrite the classical Poisson brackets as commutators of hermitian operators. This points out the strict equivalence between the Heisenberg formalism and the formalism of classical Poisson bracket. Eventually, we illustrate how the Poisson brackets allows to recover the transformations of Poincare group in 1+1 dimension together with its algebra. The latter makes the link between the Lorentz invariant inner product of Mostafazadeh and the Casimir invariant associated to the mass of particle.
We review here the quantum mechanics of some noncommutative theories in which no state saturates simultaneously all the non trivial Heisenberg uncertainty relations. We show how the difference of structure between the Poisson brackets and the commutators in these theories generically leads to a harmonic oscillator whose positions and momenta mean values are not strictly equal to the ones predicted by classical mechanics. This raises the question of the nature of quasi classical states in these models. We propose an extension based on a variational principle. The action considered is the sum of the absolute values of the expressions associated to the non trivial Heisenberg uncertainty relations. We first verify that our proposal works in the usual theory i.e we recover the known Gaussian functions. Besides them, we find other states which can be expressed as products of Gaussians with specific hyper geometrics. We illustrate our construction in two models defined on a four dimensional phase space: a model endowed with a minimal length uncertainty and the non commutative plane. Our proposal leads to second order partial differential equations. We find analytical solutions in specific cases. We briefly discuss how our proposal may be applied to the fuzzy sphere and analyze its shortcomings.
It was recently shown that quantum and classical mechanics are related in a deeper and more intimate way than previously thought possible. A geometric framework for both theories that allowed going back and forth between quantum and classical processes was discovered. The quantum-mechanical experiments were presented in a new and illuminating fashion, paving a way to resolve the paradoxes of quantum theory. The downside of the theory is a relatively involved machinery of functional analysis and differential geometry used to derive the results. At the same time, the main conclusions are fundamentally simple and can be presented without complicated math. The goal of this paper is to provide such a ``no math" presentation of the theory.