Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2201.03620 · Entropy

A Classical Formulation of Quantum Theory?

William F. Braasch, William K. Wootters

Published Jan 17, 2022• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We explore a particular way of reformulating quantum theory in classical terms, starting with phase space rather than Hilbert space, and with actual probability distributions rather than quasiprobabilities. The classical picture we start with is epistemically restricted, in the spirit of a model introduced by Spekkens. We obtain quantum theory only by combining a collection of restricted classical pictures. Our main challenge in this paper is to find a simple way of characterizing the allowed sets of classical pictures. We present one promising approach to this problem and show how it works out for the case of a single qubit.

DOI
10.3390/e24010137

Related papers

Quantum predictions arising from epistemically restricted classical predictions

William F. Braasch, William K. Wootters

Spekkens has introduced an epistemically restricted classical theory of discrete systems, based on discrete phase space. The theory manifests a number of quantum-like properties but cannot fully imitate quantum theory because it is noncontextual. In this paper we start with a theory resembling Spekkens's model: we imagine a classical observer describing an experiment in terms of discrete phase space, and for each aspect of the experiment -- the state preparation, the transformations, and the measurement -- there is an epistemic restriction limiting the form of the probability distribution the classical observer may use. We show that for a certain class of systems, one can obtain the correct quantum mechanical prediction for the experiment by combining the (typically weaker) predictions of all the conceivable classical observers. The rule for effecting this combination is highly nonclassical: the ``nonrandom part of the quantum prediction is obtained by summing the ``nonrandom parts of the classical predictions.

•Jul 6, 2021•0 citations

A quantum prediction as a collection of epistemically restricted classical predictions

William F. Braasch Jr., William K. Wootters

Spekkens has introduced an epistemically restricted classical theory of discrete systems, based on discrete phase space. The theory manifests a number of quantum-like properties but cannot fully imitate quantum theory because it is noncontextual. In this paper we show how, for a certain class of quantum systems, the quantum description of an experiment can be decomposed into classical descriptions that are epistemically restricted, though in a different sense than in Spekkens' work. For each aspect of the experiment—the preparation, the transformations, and the measurement—the epistemic restriction limits the form of the probability distribution an imagined classical observer may use. There are also global constraints that the whole collection of classical descriptions must satisfy. Each classical description generates its own prediction regarding the outcome of the experiment. One recovers the quantum prediction via a simple but highly nonclassical rule: the "nonrandom part" of the predicted quantum probabilities is obtained by summing the nonrandom parts of the classically predicted probabilities. By "nonrandom part" we mean the deviation from complete randomness, that is, from what one would expect upon measuring the fully mixed state.

arXiv:2107.02728•Quantum•Feb 21, 2022•3 citations

Quantum mechanics from an epistemic state space

Per Östborn

We derive the Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics from epistemic principles. A key assumption is that a physical theory that relies on entities or distinctions that are unknowable in principle gives rise to wrong predictions. An epistemic formalism is developed, where concepts like individual and collective knowledge are used, and knowledge may be actual or potential. The physical state $S$ corresponds to the collective potential knowledge. The state $S$ is a subset of a state space $\mathcal{S}=\{Z\}$, such that $S$ always contains several elements $Z$, which correspond to unattainable states of complete potential knowledge of the world. The evolution of $S$ cannot be determined in terms of the individual evolution of the elements $Z$, unlike the evolution of an ensemble in classical phase space. The evolution of $S$ is described in terms of sequential time $n\in \mathbf{\mathbb{N}}$, which is updated according to $n\rightarrow n+1$ each time potential knowledge changes. In certain experimental contexts $C$, there is initial knowledge at time $n$ that a given series of properties $P,P',\ldots$ will be observed within a given time frame, meaning that a series of values $p,p',\ldots$ of these properties will become known. At time $n$, it is just known that these values belong to predefined, finite sets $\{p\},\{p'\},\ldots$. In such a context $C$, it is possible to define a complex Hilbert space $\mathcal{H}_{C}$ on top of $\mathcal{S}$, in which the elements are contextual state vectors $\bar{S}_{C}$. Born's rule to calculate the probabilities to find the values $p,p',\ldots$ is derived as the only generally applicable such rule. Also, we can associate a self-adjoint operator $\bar{P}$ with eigenvalues $\{p\}$ to each property $P$ observed within $C$. These operators obey $[\bar{P},\bar{P}']=0$ if and only if the precise values of $P$ and $P'$ are simultaneoulsy knowable.

arXiv:1703.08543•Mar 24, 2017•7 citations

Epistemic restrictions in Hilbert space quantum mechanics

Robert B. Griffiths

A resolution of the quantum measurement problem(s) using the consistent histories interpretation yields in a rather natural way a restriction on what an observer can know about a quantum system, one that is also consistent with some results in quantum information theory. This analysis provides a quantum mechanical understanding of some recent work that shows that certain kinds of quantum behavior are exhibited by a fully classical model if by hypothesis an observer's knowledge of its state is appropriately limited.

arXiv:1308.4176•Physical Review A•Oct 31, 2013•4 citations

Phase-space distributions and the classical component of quantum observables

Alfredo Luis

We analyze the relation between the classical part of quantum observables and the distributions representing quantum states and observables on the classical phase space. We determine in which conditions such a relation can be established, and the proper phase-space distribution required for this purpose.

Physical Review A•Jun 20, 2003•5 citations

Framed Hilbert space: hanging the quasi-probability pictures of quantum theory

Christopher Ferrie, Joseph Emerson

Building on earlier work, we further develop a formalism based on the mathematical theory of frames that defines a set of possible phase-space or quasi-probability representations of finite-dimensional quantum systems. We prove that an alternate approach to defining a set of quasi-probability representations, based on a more natural generalization of a classical representation, is equivalent to our earlier approach based on frames, and therefore is also subject to our no-go theorem for a non-negative representation. Furthermore, we clarify the relationship between the contextuality of quantum theory and the necessity of negativity in quasi-probability representations and discuss their relevance as criteria for non-classicality. We also provide a comprehensive overview of known quasi-probability representations and their expression within the frame formalism.

arXiv:0903.4843•New Journal of Physics•Jun 22, 2009•109 citations
We explore a particular way of reformulating quantum theory in classical terms, starting with phase space rather than Hilbert space, and with actual probability distributions rather than quasiprobabilities. The classical picture we start with is epistemically restricted, in the spirit of a model introduced by Spekkens. We obtain quantum theory only by combining a collection of restricted classical pictures. Our main challenge in this paper is to find a simple way of characterizing the allowed sets of classical pictures. We present one promising approach to this problem and show how it works out for the case of a single qubit.
Spekkens has introduced an epistemically restricted classical theory of discrete systems, based on discrete phase space. The theory manifests a number of quantum-like properties but cannot fully imitate quantum theory because it is noncontextual. In this paper we start with a theory resembling Spekkens's model: we imagine a classical observer describing an experiment in terms of discrete phase space, and for each aspect of the experiment -- the state preparation, the transformations, and the measurement -- there is an epistemic restriction limiting the form of the probability distribution the classical observer may use. We show that for a certain class of systems, one can obtain the correct quantum mechanical prediction for the experiment by combining the (typically weaker) predictions of all the conceivable classical observers. The rule for effecting this combination is highly nonclassical: the ``nonrandom part of the quantum prediction is obtained by summing the ``nonrandom parts of the classical predictions.
Spekkens has introduced an epistemically restricted classical theory of discrete systems, based on discrete phase space. The theory manifests a number of quantum-like properties but cannot fully imitate quantum theory because it is noncontextual. In this paper we show how, for a certain class of quantum systems, the quantum description of an experiment can be decomposed into classical descriptions that are epistemically restricted, though in a different sense than in Spekkens' work. For each aspect of the experiment—the preparation, the transformations, and the measurement—the epistemic restriction limits the form of the probability distribution an imagined classical observer may use. There are also global constraints that the whole collection of classical descriptions must satisfy. Each classical description generates its own prediction regarding the outcome of the experiment. One recovers the quantum prediction via a simple but highly nonclassical rule: the "nonrandom part" of the predicted quantum probabilities is obtained by summing the nonrandom parts of the classically predicted probabilities. By "nonrandom part" we mean the deviation from complete randomness, that is, from what one would expect upon measuring the fully mixed state.
We derive the Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics from epistemic principles. A key assumption is that a physical theory that relies on entities or distinctions that are unknowable in principle gives rise to wrong predictions. An epistemic formalism is developed, where concepts like individual and collective knowledge are used, and knowledge may be actual or potential. The physical state SSS corresponds to the collective potential knowledge. The state SSS is a subset of a state space S={Z}\mathcal{S}=\{Z\}S={Z}, such that SSS always contains several elements ZZZ, which correspond to unattainable states of complete potential knowledge of the world. The evolution of SSS cannot be determined in terms of the individual evolution of the elements ZZZ, unlike the evolution of an ensemble in classical phase space. The evolution of SSS is described in terms of sequential time n∈Nn\in \mathbf{\mathbb{N}}n∈N, which is updated according to n→n+1n\rightarrow n+1n→n+1 each time potential knowledge changes. In certain experimental contexts CCC, there is initial knowledge at time nnn that a given series of properties P,P′,…P,P',\ldotsP,P′,… will be observed within a given time frame, meaning that a series of values p,p′,…p,p',\ldotsp,p′,… of these properties will become known. At time nnn, it is just known that these values belong to predefined, finite sets {p},{p′},…\{p\},\{p'\},\ldots{p},{p′},…. In such a context CCC, it is possible to define a complex Hilbert space HC\mathcal{H}_{C}HC​ on top of S\mathcal{S}S, in which the elements are contextual state vectors SˉC\bar{S}_{C}SˉC​. Born's rule to calculate the probabilities to find the values p,p′,…p,p',\ldotsp,p′,… is derived as the only generally applicable such rule. Also, we can associate a self-adjoint operator Pˉ\bar{P}Pˉ with eigenvalues {p}\{p\}{p} to each property PPP observed within CCC. These operators obey [Pˉ,Pˉ′]=0[\bar{P},\bar{P}']=0[Pˉ,Pˉ′]=0 if and only if the precise values of PPP and P′P'P′ are simultaneoulsy knowable.
A resolution of the quantum measurement problem(s) using the consistent histories interpretation yields in a rather natural way a restriction on what an observer can know about a quantum system, one that is also consistent with some results in quantum information theory. This analysis provides a quantum mechanical understanding of some recent work that shows that certain kinds of quantum behavior are exhibited by a fully classical model if by hypothesis an observer's knowledge of its state is appropriately limited.
Building on earlier work, we further develop a formalism based on the mathematical theory of frames that defines a set of possible phase-space or quasi-probability representations of finite-dimensional quantum systems. We prove that an alternate approach to defining a set of quasi-probability representations, based on a more natural generalization of a classical representation, is equivalent to our earlier approach based on frames, and therefore is also subject to our no-go theorem for a non-negative representation. Furthermore, we clarify the relationship between the contextuality of quantum theory and the necessity of negativity in quasi-probability representations and discuss their relevance as criteria for non-classicality. We also provide a comprehensive overview of known quasi-probability representations and their expression within the frame formalism.