Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.11646 · npj Quantum Information

Contextuality in infinite one-dimensional translation-invariant local Hamiltonians

Kaiyan Yang, Xiao Zeng, Yujing Luo, Guowu Yang, Lan Shu, Miguel Navascués, Zizhu Wang

Published Jul 26, 2022• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In recent years there has been a growing interest in treating many-body systems as Bell scenarios, where lattice sites play the role of distant parties and only near-neighbor statistics are accessible. We investigate contextuality arising from three Bell scenarios in infinite, translation-invariant 1D models: nearest-neighbor with two dichotomic observables per site; nearest- and next-to-nearest neighbor with two dichotomic observables per site, and nearest-neighbor with three dichotomic observables per site. For the first scenario, we give strong evidence that it cannot exhibit contextuality, not even in non-signaling physical theories beyond quantum mechanics. For the second one, we identify several low-dimensional models that reach the ultimate quantum limits, paving the way for self-testing ground states of quantum many-body systems. For the last scenario, which generalizes the Heisenberg model, we give strong evidence that, in order to exhibit contextuality, the dimension of the local quantum system must be at least 3.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-022-00598-0

Related papers

Contextuality as a Diagnostic of Translation-Symmetry Breaking in Translation-Invariant 1D Hamiltonians

Xiao Zeng, Kaiyan Yang, Lingxia Zhang +1 more

Bell- and contextuality-type inequalities have become practical probes of many-body quantum correlations, often involving only few-body correlators and quantities with a direct Hamiltonian interpretation such as an energy density. Here we investigate the mechanism by which translation-invariant Hamiltonians generated from representative families of contextuality witnesses organize their ground-state structure in infinite one-dimensional systems. For the witness families considered, maximal quantum violation is realized by ground-state sectors with commensurate enlarged unit cells: the Hamiltonians are invariant under one-site translations, while the optimal ground states are $p$-periodic with $p>1$. At the corresponding classical-bound points, the ground-state sectors are highly degenerate and support many commensurate periods. Along the interpolation paths analyzed in this work, entering the contextual regime is accompanied by the lifting of this classical period degeneracy in favor of a quantum-selected period. We also identify finite periodic-boundary-condition benchmarks at the selected periods: for each model studied, the finite-ring witness reproduces the same classical bound and quantum value as the corresponding infinite-chain witness, and in several cases the resulting finite inequalities are tight. These reductions turn the infinite-chain contextuality certification into compact energy-estimation benchmarks requiring only local correlator measurements. We establish the mechanism analytically in representative two- and three-body witness models and corroborate it more broadly using translation-invariant semidefinite-program relaxations together with variational matrix-product-state calculations.

quant-pharXiv:2606.19033•Jun 18, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement and Nonlocality in Infinite 1D Systems

Zizhu Wang, Sukhwinder Singh, Miguel Navascués

We consider the problem of detecting entanglement and nonlocality in one-dimensional (1D) infinite, translation-invariant (TI) systems when just near-neighbor information is available. This issue is deeper than one might think a priori, since, as we show, there exist instances of local separable states (classical boxes) which admit only entangled (nonclassical) TI extensions. We provide a simple characterization of the set of local states of multiseparable TI spin chains and construct a family of linear witnesses which can detect entanglement in infinite TI states from the nearest-neighbor reduced density matrix. Similarly, we prove that the set of classical TI boxes forms a polytope and devise a general procedure to generate all Bell inequalities which characterize it. Using an algorithm based on matrix product states, we show how some of them can be violated by distant parties conducting identical measurements on an infinite TI quantum state. All our results can be easily adapted to detect entanglement and nonlocality in large (finite, not TI) 1D condensed matter systems.

arXiv:1608.03485•Physical Review Letters•Jun 8, 2017•31 citations

Entanglement and Nonlocality of 1D Macroscopic Systems

Zizhu Wang, Sukhwinder Singh, Miguel Navascués

We consider the problem of certifying entanglement and nonlocality in one-dimensional macroscopic systems when just averaged near-neighbor correlators are available. We map this question to the characterization of the set of all quantum states (distributions) which admit a separable (classical) Translation-Invariant (TI) extension to infinitely many sites. We advance the first problem by constructing a family of witnesses which can detect entanglement in infinite TI states from the nearest-neighbor reduced density matrix. Along the way, we identify a set of separable twoqubit states which only admit entangled TI extensions. For nonlocality detection, we show that the set of classical TI boxes forms a polytope and devise a general procedure to generate all Bell inequalities which characterize it. Through a Matrix Product State-based method, we show how some of them can be violated by distant parties conducting identical measurements on an infinite TI quantum state.

•Aug 11, 2016•0 citations

Cost of locally approximating high-dimensional ground states of contextual quantum models

Kaiyan Yang, Yanzheng Zhu, Xiao Zeng +3 more

Contextuality, one of the strongest forms of quantum correlations, delineates the boundary between the quantum world and the classical one. Recent advances show that some translation-invariant contextuality witnesses are maximally violated by ground states and local observables of infinite one-dimensional translation-invariant Hamiltonians. However, these models all have local Hilbert space dimension larger than two, making the study of their ground states behavior difficult on current qubit-based platforms. In this work, we focus on the cost of simulating their 3-site reduced density matrices using qubit-based parameterized quantum circuits. The local approximations are purified then encoded into permutation-symmetric qubit states. By developing a universal set of permutation-symmetry preserving qubit-based gates, we assess the accuracy of simulating the purified local ground states against fixed classical and quantum resources. Results reveal that more contextual ground states with lower energy density are easier to simulate under identical resources. The authors encode qutrit contextual-Hamiltonian ground states into permutation-symmetric qubits with symmetry-preserving gates and use parameterized quantum circuits to variationally simulate their purified 3-site reduced states. They find that stronger contextuality reduces simulation cost, although all contextual states cost more than non-contextual ones.

arXiv:2405.04884•Communications Physics•May 17, 2025•2 citations

Trade-off relations between Bell nonlocality and local Kochen–Specker contextuality in generalized Bell scenarios

Lucas Emanuel Antunes Porto, Gabriel Ruffolo, Rafael Rabelo +2 more

Abstract The relations between Bell nonlocality and Kochen–Specker contextuality have been subject of research from many different perspectives in the last decades. Recently, some interesting results on these relations have been explored in the so-called generalized Bell scenarios, that is, scenarios where Bell spatial separation (or agency independence) coexist with (at least one of the) parties’ ability to perform compatible measurements at each round of the experiment. When this party has an n-cycle compatiblity setup, it was first claimed that Bell nonlocality could not be concomitantly observed with contextuality at this party’s local experiment. However, by a more natural reading of the definition of locality, it turns out that both Bell nonlocality and local contextuality can, in fact, be jointly present. In spite of it, in this work we prove that in the simplest of those scenarios there cannot be arbitrary amounts of both of these two resources together. That is, in these cases we show that the violation of any Bell inequality limits the possible violations of any local noncontextuality inequality. We also explore this trade-off relation using quantifiers of nonlocality and contextuality, discussing how such a relation can be understood in terms of a ‘global’ notion of contextuality, and we study possible extensions of this result to other scenarios.

arXiv:2405.02964•New Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 2024•2 citations

Symmetrized Block-Product Periodic Marginals in Infinite Translation-Invariant Quantum Chains

Xiao Zeng, Kaiyan Yang, Lingxia Zhang +1 more

We study local marginals in one-dimensional translation-invariant quantum systems that may hide finite-period structure. Given an $n$-site reduced density matrix, we ask whether it can be obtained by repeating a finite $p$-site block state along the chain and averaging over the $p$ lattice translations. This defines a symmetrized block-product periodic marginal problem, which provides a route both to diagnosing hidden periodic order from local data and to upper bounding ground-state energy densities of infinite translation-invariant local Hamiltonians. We develop two complementary methods. The first is a semidefinite-programming relaxation based on block permutation symmetry and positive partial transpose constraints, which outer-approximates the convex hull of such marginals and yields certified infeasibility tests. The second is a symmetrized matrix product state ansatz, which constructs explicit block-product periodic states and gives variational upper bounds. We benchmark the framework on the Majumdar-Ghosh model, transverse-field Ising, XX, XXZ, and contextuality-related spin models. The results show that the method captures the expected finite-period structure in exactly solvable cases and gives systematically improving variational energies as the period and bond dimension increase. We also formulate a periodic-NPA relaxation for translation-invariant contextuality witnesses and recover the known quantum limits in the tested examples.

quant-pharXiv:2608.10365•Aug 12, 2026•0 citations
Abstract In recent years there has been a growing interest in treating many-body systems as Bell scenarios, where lattice sites play the role of distant parties and only near-neighbor statistics are accessible. We investigate contextuality arising from three Bell scenarios in infinite, translation-invariant 1D models: nearest-neighbor with two dichotomic observables per site; nearest- and next-to-nearest neighbor with two dichotomic observables per site, and nearest-neighbor with three dichotomic observables per site. For the first scenario, we give strong evidence that it cannot exhibit contextuality, not even in non-signaling physical theories beyond quantum mechanics. For the second one, we identify several low-dimensional models that reach the ultimate quantum limits, paving the way for self-testing ground states of quantum many-body systems. For the last scenario, which generalizes the Heisenberg model, we give strong evidence that, in order to exhibit contextuality, the dimension of the local quantum system must be at least 3.
Bell- and contextuality-type inequalities have become practical probes of many-body quantum correlations, often involving only few-body correlators and quantities with a direct Hamiltonian interpretation such as an energy density. Here we investigate the mechanism by which translation-invariant Hamiltonians generated from representative families of contextuality witnesses organize their ground-state structure in infinite one-dimensional systems. For the witness families considered, maximal quantum violation is realized by ground-state sectors with commensurate enlarged unit cells: the Hamiltonians are invariant under one-site translations, while the optimal ground states are ppp-periodic with p>1p>1p>1. At the corresponding classical-bound points, the ground-state sectors are highly degenerate and support many commensurate periods. Along the interpolation paths analyzed in this work, entering the contextual regime is accompanied by the lifting of this classical period degeneracy in favor of a quantum-selected period. We also identify finite periodic-boundary-condition benchmarks at the selected periods: for each model studied, the finite-ring witness reproduces the same classical bound and quantum value as the corresponding infinite-chain witness, and in several cases the resulting finite inequalities are tight. These reductions turn the infinite-chain contextuality certification into compact energy-estimation benchmarks requiring only local correlator measurements. We establish the mechanism analytically in representative two- and three-body witness models and corroborate it more broadly using translation-invariant semidefinite-program relaxations together with variational matrix-product-state calculations.
We consider the problem of detecting entanglement and nonlocality in one-dimensional (1D) infinite, translation-invariant (TI) systems when just near-neighbor information is available. This issue is deeper than one might think a priori, since, as we show, there exist instances of local separable states (classical boxes) which admit only entangled (nonclassical) TI extensions. We provide a simple characterization of the set of local states of multiseparable TI spin chains and construct a family of linear witnesses which can detect entanglement in infinite TI states from the nearest-neighbor reduced density matrix. Similarly, we prove that the set of classical TI boxes forms a polytope and devise a general procedure to generate all Bell inequalities which characterize it. Using an algorithm based on matrix product states, we show how some of them can be violated by distant parties conducting identical measurements on an infinite TI quantum state. All our results can be easily adapted to detect entanglement and nonlocality in large (finite, not TI) 1D condensed matter systems.
We consider the problem of certifying entanglement and nonlocality in one-dimensional macroscopic systems when just averaged near-neighbor correlators are available. We map this question to the characterization of the set of all quantum states (distributions) which admit a separable (classical) Translation-Invariant (TI) extension to infinitely many sites. We advance the first problem by constructing a family of witnesses which can detect entanglement in infinite TI states from the nearest-neighbor reduced density matrix. Along the way, we identify a set of separable twoqubit states which only admit entangled TI extensions. For nonlocality detection, we show that the set of classical TI boxes forms a polytope and devise a general procedure to generate all Bell inequalities which characterize it. Through a Matrix Product State-based method, we show how some of them can be violated by distant parties conducting identical measurements on an infinite TI quantum state.
Contextuality, one of the strongest forms of quantum correlations, delineates the boundary between the quantum world and the classical one. Recent advances show that some translation-invariant contextuality witnesses are maximally violated by ground states and local observables of infinite one-dimensional translation-invariant Hamiltonians. However, these models all have local Hilbert space dimension larger than two, making the study of their ground states behavior difficult on current qubit-based platforms. In this work, we focus on the cost of simulating their 3-site reduced density matrices using qubit-based parameterized quantum circuits. The local approximations are purified then encoded into permutation-symmetric qubit states. By developing a universal set of permutation-symmetry preserving qubit-based gates, we assess the accuracy of simulating the purified local ground states against fixed classical and quantum resources. Results reveal that more contextual ground states with lower energy density are easier to simulate under identical resources. The authors encode qutrit contextual-Hamiltonian ground states into permutation-symmetric qubits with symmetry-preserving gates and use parameterized quantum circuits to variationally simulate their purified 3-site reduced states. They find that stronger contextuality reduces simulation cost, although all contextual states cost more than non-contextual ones.
Abstract The relations between Bell nonlocality and Kochen–Specker contextuality have been subject of research from many different perspectives in the last decades. Recently, some interesting results on these relations have been explored in the so-called generalized Bell scenarios, that is, scenarios where Bell spatial separation (or agency independence) coexist with (at least one of the) parties’ ability to perform compatible measurements at each round of the experiment. When this party has an n-cycle compatiblity setup, it was first claimed that Bell nonlocality could not be concomitantly observed with contextuality at this party’s local experiment. However, by a more natural reading of the definition of locality, it turns out that both Bell nonlocality and local contextuality can, in fact, be jointly present. In spite of it, in this work we prove that in the simplest of those scenarios there cannot be arbitrary amounts of both of these two resources together. That is, in these cases we show that the violation of any Bell inequality limits the possible violations of any local noncontextuality inequality. We also explore this trade-off relation using quantifiers of nonlocality and contextuality, discussing how such a relation can be understood in terms of a ‘global’ notion of contextuality, and we study possible extensions of this result to other scenarios.
We study local marginals in one-dimensional translation-invariant quantum systems that may hide finite-period structure. Given an nnn-site reduced density matrix, we ask whether it can be obtained by repeating a finite ppp-site block state along the chain and averaging over the ppp lattice translations. This defines a symmetrized block-product periodic marginal problem, which provides a route both to diagnosing hidden periodic order from local data and to upper bounding ground-state energy densities of infinite translation-invariant local Hamiltonians. We develop two complementary methods. The first is a semidefinite-programming relaxation based on block permutation symmetry and positive partial transpose constraints, which outer-approximates the convex hull of such marginals and yields certified infeasibility tests. The second is a symmetrized matrix product state ansatz, which constructs explicit block-product periodic states and gives variational upper bounds. We benchmark the framework on the Majumdar-Ghosh model, transverse-field Ising, XX, XXZ, and contextuality-related spin models. The results show that the method captures the expected finite-period structure in exactly solvable cases and gives systematically improving variational energies as the period and bond dimension increase. We also formulate a periodic-NPA relaxation for translation-invariant contextuality witnesses and recover the known quantum limits in the tested examples.