Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.08104 · SciPost Physics

Quantitative functional renormalization for three-dimensional quantum Heisenberg models

Nils Niggemann, Johannes Reuther, Björn Sbierski

Published May 11, 2022• 31 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We employ a recently developed variant of the functional renormalization group method for spin systems, the so-called pseudo Majorana functional renormalization group, to investigate three-dimensional spin-1/2 Heisenberg models at finite temperatures. We study unfrustrated and frustrated Heisenberg systems on the simple cubic and pyrochlore lattices. Comparing our results with other quantum many-body techniques, we demonstrate a high quantitative accuracy of our method. Particularly, for the unfrustrated simple cubic lattice antiferromagnet ordering temperatures obtained from finite-size scaling of one-loop data deviate from error controlled quantum Monte Carlo results by \sim5\% ∼ 5 % and we confirm consistency of our data with established critical exponents \nu ν and \eta η of the three-dimensional Heisenberg universality class. As the PMFRG yields results in good agreement with QMC, but remains applicable when the system is frustrated, we next treat the pyrochlore Heisenberg antiferromagnet as a paradigmatic magnetically disordered system and find nearly perfect agreement of our two-loop static homogeneous susceptibility with other methods. We further investigate the broadening of pinch points in the spin structure factor as a result of quantum and thermal fluctuations and confirm a finite width in the extrapolated limit T\rightarrow0 T → 0 . While extensions towards higher loop orders \ell ℓ seem to systematically improve our approach for magnetically disordered systems we also discuss subtleties when increasing \ell ℓ in the presence of magnetic order. Overall, the pseudo Majorana functional renormalization group is established as a powerful many-body technique in quantum magnetism with a wealth of possible future applications.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.12.5.156

Related papers

Frustrated quantum spins at finite temperature: Pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group approach

Nils Niggemann, Björn Sbierski, Johannes Reuther

The pseudofermion functional renormalization group (PFFRG) method has proven to be a powerful numerical approach to treat frustrated quantum spin systems. In its usual implementation, however, the complex fermionic representation of spin operators introduces unphysical Hilbert-space sectors which render an application at finite temperatures inaccurate. In this work we formulate a general functional renormalization group approach based on Majorana fermions to overcome these difficulties. We, particularly, implement spin operators via an $\text{SO}(3)$ symmetric Majorana representation which does not introduce any unphysical states and, hence, remains applicable to quantum spin models at finite temperatures. We apply this scheme, dubbed pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group (PMFRG) method, to frustrated Heisenberg models on small spin clusters as well as square and triangular lattices. Computing the finite-temperature behavior of spin correlations and thermodynamic quantities such as free energy and heat capacity, we find good agreement with exact diagonalization and the high-temperature series expansion down to moderate temperatures. We observe a significantly enhanced accuracy of the PMFRG compared to the PFFRG at finite temperatures. More generally, we conclude that the development of functional renormalization group approaches with Majorana fermions considerably extends the scope of applicability of such methods.

arXiv:2012.14836•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 22, 2021•53 citations

Phase diagram of the XXZ pyrochlore model from pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group

Yannik Schaden, M. G. Gonzalez, Johannes Reuther

We calculate the magnetic phase diagram of the spin- 1 / 2 nearest neighbor XXZ pyrochlore model using the pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group in the temperature flow formalism. Our phase diagram as a function of temperature and coupling ratio, allowing both longitudinal and transverse couplings to be ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic, reveals a large nonmagnetic regime at low temperatures, which includes the quantum spin ice phase near the antiferromagnetic Ising model, as well as the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg and XY models. We are able to detect magnetic phase transitions via critical finite size scaling down to temperatures two orders of magnitude smaller than the spin interactions, demonstrating the remarkably good performance of our method upon approaching the ground state. Specifically, the low-temperature transition from the zero-flux quantum spin ice phase into the transverse ferromagnetic phase shows very good agreement with previous quantum Monte Carlo results. Comparing our findings with classical results, we identify a quantum order-by-disorder effect near the antiferromagnetic XY model. In magnetically disordered regimes, we find characteristic patterns of broadened pinch points in the spin structure factor and investigate their evolution when approaching magnetically ordered phases. We also compute linear responses to lattice symmetry breaking perturbations and identify a possible lattice nematic ground state of the antiferromagnetic XY model.

arXiv:2412.14773•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 24, 2025•4 citations

Pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization for frustrated XXZ spin- 1 2 models with field or magnetization along the spin- Z direction at finite temperature

Frederic Bippus, Benedikt Schneider, Björn Sbierski

The numerical study of high-dimensional frustrated quantum magnets remains a challenging problem. Here we present an extension of the pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group to spin-1/2 XXZ-type Hamiltonians with field or magnetization along spin- Z direction at finite temperature. We consider a U(1) symmetry-adapted fermionic spin representation and derive the diagrammatic framework and its renormalization group flow equations. We discuss benchmark results and application to two antiferromagnetic triangular lattice materials recently studied in experiments with applied magnetic fields: First, we numerically reproduce the magnetization data measured for CeMgAl 11 O 19 confirming model parameters previously estimated from inelastic neutron spectrum in high fields. Second, we showcase the accuracy of our method by studying the thermal phase transition into the spin solid up-up-down phase of Na 2 BaCo ( PO 4 ) 2 in good agreement with experiment.

arXiv:2411.18198•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 13, 2025•9 citations

Phase diagram of the antiferromagnetic J 1 − J 2 spin-1 pyrochlore Heisenberg model

Imre Hagymási, Nils Niggemann, Johannes Reuther

We study the phase diagram of the antiferromagnetic ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice with $S=1$ spins at zero and finite temperatures. We use a combination of complementary state-of-the-art quantum many-body approaches such as density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), density-matrix purification, and pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group (PMFRG). We present an efficient approach to preserve the applicability of the PMFRG for spin-1 systems at finite temperatures despite the inevitable presence of unphysical spin states. The good performance of our methods is first demonstrated for the nearest-neighbor pyrochlore Heisenberg model where the finite-temperature behavior of the specific heat and uniform susceptibility show excellent agreement within PMFRG and density-matrix purification. Including an antiferromagnetic second-neighbor coupling we find that the nonmagnetic ground-state phase of the nearest-neighbor model extents up to ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\sim}0.02$ within DMRG, beyond which magnetic $\mathbit{k}=0$ long-range order sets in. Our PMFRG calculations find the phase transition in a similar regime ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\sim}0.035(8)$ which, together with the DMRG result, provides a strong argument for the existence of a small but finite nonmagnetic ground-state phase in the spin-1 pyrochlore Heisenberg model. We also discuss the origin of discrepancies between different versions of the functional renormalization group concerning the location of this phase transition.

arXiv:2405.12745•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 9, 2024•5 citations

Temperature flow in pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization for quantum spins

Benedikt Schneider, Johannes Reuther, M. G. Gonzalez +2 more

We implement the temperature flow scheme first proposed by Honerkamp and Salmhofer [Phys. Rev. B 64, 184516 (2001)] into the pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group method for quantum spin systems. Since the renormalization group parameter in this approach is a physical quantity, the temperature $T$, the numerical efficiency increases significantly compared to more conventional renormalization group parameters, especially when computing finite-temperature phase diagrams. We first apply this method to determine the finite-temperature phase diagram of the ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model on the simple cubic lattice, where our findings support claims of a vanishingly small nonmagnetic phase around the high frustration point ${J}_{2}=0.25{J}_{1}$. Perhaps most importantly, we find the temperature flow scheme to be advantageous in detecting finite-temperature phase transitions as, by construction, a phase transition is never encountered at an artificial, unphysical cutoff parameter. Finally, we apply the temperature flow scheme to the dipolar XXZ model on the square lattice, where we find a rich phase diagram with a large nonmagnetic regime down to the lowest accessible temperatures. Wherever a comparison with error-controlled (quantum) Monte Carlo methods is applicable, we find excellent quantitative agreement with less than $5%$ deviation from the numerically exact results.

arXiv:2312.14838•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 3, 2024•13 citations

Generalizations of Pseudo Majorana Functional Renormalization Group and its Application to Highly Frustrated Spin Systems

Schaden-Thillmann, Yannik

Spin systems are known for their purely interacting nature, causing them to lack a canonical perturbative limit, which usually helps to understand the fundamental physics of a system. A method that has proven effective for the description of strongly correlated systems is Functional Renormalization Group (FRG), which can be thought of as an alternative to the path integral formalism as an approach to many-body quantum mechanics. The basic concept is to cure infrared divergences by introducing a cutoff to correlation functions. Continuously lowering the infrared cutoff and hence allowing the system to occupy lower-lying energy states is called the FRG flow and is formulated in terms of differential equations. The solutions to these equations are functions which describe effective interactions between particles and hence contain information about particle correlations and thermodynamic quantities. Formulating FRG in terms of spins turns out to be a subtle endeavor, though, as the spin algebra relations are relatively complicated compared to, for example, the canonical anti-commutation relations of fermions. In order to use the advantages of FRG for spin systems, one can map spins onto fermionic operators, which leads to pseudo-fermion FRG (PFFRG), developed by Reuther and Wölfle.[198] Alter- natively, one can express spins in terms of Majorana operators, leading to pseudo- Majorana FRG (PMFRG), which has been developed by Niggemann, Sbierski, and Reuther.[163] PMFRG is particularly powerful at finite temperatures, where useful properties of Majorana operators render the method more accurate than PFFRG. In contrast to many other methods, PFFRG and PMFRG are applicable to any spin system, even frustrated ones. In this work, PMFRG is being generalized and applied to highly frustrated spin systems. In particular, spin representations in terms of Majorana operators for spins with arbitrary large spin magnitude S are being investigated and classified thoroughly, which closes a gap in the literature about the second quantization of spin operators. Moreover, it is presented how to generalize PMFRG for Heisenberg models with full SU(2) symmetry to XXZ models exhibiting only a U(1) symmetry. This opens up a wide range of interesting applications for PMFRG. An example is the XXZ model on the pyrochlore lattice, which is known to exhibit conventional long-range order but also exotic spin liquid ground states in the so-called spin ice phase. PMFRG is applied to this model, and the results are being compared to experiments. Furthermore, the entire phase diagram of the XXZ model is being mapped out. Also, the capability of PMFRG to reproduce low-energy field theory predictions and to determine critical exponents is being tested.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
We employ a recently developed variant of the functional renormalization group method for spin systems, the so-called pseudo Majorana functional renormalization group, to investigate three-dimensional spin-1/2 Heisenberg models at finite temperatures. We study unfrustrated and frustrated Heisenberg systems on the simple cubic and pyrochlore lattices. Comparing our results with other quantum many-body techniques, we demonstrate a high quantitative accuracy of our method. Particularly, for the unfrustrated simple cubic lattice antiferromagnet ordering temperatures obtained from finite-size scaling of one-loop data deviate from error controlled quantum Monte Carlo results by \sim5% ∼ 5 % and we confirm consistency of our data with established critical exponents \nu ν and \eta η of the three-dimensional Heisenberg universality class. As the PMFRG yields results in good agreement with QMC, but remains applicable when the system is frustrated, we next treat the pyrochlore Heisenberg antiferromagnet as a paradigmatic magnetically disordered system and find nearly perfect agreement of our two-loop static homogeneous susceptibility with other methods. We further investigate the broadening of pinch points in the spin structure factor as a result of quantum and thermal fluctuations and confirm a finite width in the extrapolated limit T\rightarrow0 T → 0 . While extensions towards higher loop orders \ell ℓ seem to systematically improve our approach for magnetically disordered systems we also discuss subtleties when increasing \ell ℓ in the presence of magnetic order. Overall, the pseudo Majorana functional renormalization group is established as a powerful many-body technique in quantum magnetism with a wealth of possible future applications.
The pseudofermion functional renormalization group (PFFRG) method has proven to be a powerful numerical approach to treat frustrated quantum spin systems. In its usual implementation, however, the complex fermionic representation of spin operators introduces unphysical Hilbert-space sectors which render an application at finite temperatures inaccurate. In this work we formulate a general functional renormalization group approach based on Majorana fermions to overcome these difficulties. We, particularly, implement spin operators via an SO(3)\text{SO}(3)SO(3) symmetric Majorana representation which does not introduce any unphysical states and, hence, remains applicable to quantum spin models at finite temperatures. We apply this scheme, dubbed pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group (PMFRG) method, to frustrated Heisenberg models on small spin clusters as well as square and triangular lattices. Computing the finite-temperature behavior of spin correlations and thermodynamic quantities such as free energy and heat capacity, we find good agreement with exact diagonalization and the high-temperature series expansion down to moderate temperatures. We observe a significantly enhanced accuracy of the PMFRG compared to the PFFRG at finite temperatures. More generally, we conclude that the development of functional renormalization group approaches with Majorana fermions considerably extends the scope of applicability of such methods.
We calculate the magnetic phase diagram of the spin- 1 / 2 nearest neighbor XXZ pyrochlore model using the pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group in the temperature flow formalism. Our phase diagram as a function of temperature and coupling ratio, allowing both longitudinal and transverse couplings to be ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic, reveals a large nonmagnetic regime at low temperatures, which includes the quantum spin ice phase near the antiferromagnetic Ising model, as well as the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg and XY models. We are able to detect magnetic phase transitions via critical finite size scaling down to temperatures two orders of magnitude smaller than the spin interactions, demonstrating the remarkably good performance of our method upon approaching the ground state. Specifically, the low-temperature transition from the zero-flux quantum spin ice phase into the transverse ferromagnetic phase shows very good agreement with previous quantum Monte Carlo results. Comparing our findings with classical results, we identify a quantum order-by-disorder effect near the antiferromagnetic XY model. In magnetically disordered regimes, we find characteristic patterns of broadened pinch points in the spin structure factor and investigate their evolution when approaching magnetically ordered phases. We also compute linear responses to lattice symmetry breaking perturbations and identify a possible lattice nematic ground state of the antiferromagnetic XY model.
The numerical study of high-dimensional frustrated quantum magnets remains a challenging problem. Here we present an extension of the pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group to spin-1/2 XXZ-type Hamiltonians with field or magnetization along spin- Z direction at finite temperature. We consider a U(1) symmetry-adapted fermionic spin representation and derive the diagrammatic framework and its renormalization group flow equations. We discuss benchmark results and application to two antiferromagnetic triangular lattice materials recently studied in experiments with applied magnetic fields: First, we numerically reproduce the magnetization data measured for CeMgAl 11 O 19 confirming model parameters previously estimated from inelastic neutron spectrum in high fields. Second, we showcase the accuracy of our method by studying the thermal phase transition into the spin solid up-up-down phase of Na 2 BaCo ( PO 4 ) 2 in good agreement with experiment.
We study the phase diagram of the antiferromagnetic ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model on the pyrochlore lattice with S=1S=1S=1 spins at zero and finite temperatures. We use a combination of complementary state-of-the-art quantum many-body approaches such as density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), density-matrix purification, and pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group (PMFRG). We present an efficient approach to preserve the applicability of the PMFRG for spin-1 systems at finite temperatures despite the inevitable presence of unphysical spin states. The good performance of our methods is first demonstrated for the nearest-neighbor pyrochlore Heisenberg model where the finite-temperature behavior of the specific heat and uniform susceptibility show excellent agreement within PMFRG and density-matrix purification. Including an antiferromagnetic second-neighbor coupling we find that the nonmagnetic ground-state phase of the nearest-neighbor model extents up to ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\sim}0.02$ within DMRG, beyond which magnetic $\mathbit{k}=0$ long-range order sets in. Our PMFRG calculations find the phase transition in a similar regime ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\sim}0.035(8)$ which, together with the DMRG result, provides a strong argument for the existence of a small but finite nonmagnetic ground-state phase in the spin-1 pyrochlore Heisenberg model. We also discuss the origin of discrepancies between different versions of the functional renormalization group concerning the location of this phase transition.
We implement the temperature flow scheme first proposed by Honerkamp and Salmhofer [Phys. Rev. B 64, 184516 (2001)] into the pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group method for quantum spin systems. Since the renormalization group parameter in this approach is a physical quantity, the temperature TTT, the numerical efficiency increases significantly compared to more conventional renormalization group parameters, especially when computing finite-temperature phase diagrams. We first apply this method to determine the finite-temperature phase diagram of the ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model on the simple cubic lattice, where our findings support claims of a vanishingly small nonmagnetic phase around the high frustration point J2=0.25J1{J}_{2}=0.25{J}_{1}J2​=0.25J1​. Perhaps most importantly, we find the temperature flow scheme to be advantageous in detecting finite-temperature phase transitions as, by construction, a phase transition is never encountered at an artificial, unphysical cutoff parameter. Finally, we apply the temperature flow scheme to the dipolar XXZ model on the square lattice, where we find a rich phase diagram with a large nonmagnetic regime down to the lowest accessible temperatures. Wherever a comparison with error-controlled (quantum) Monte Carlo methods is applicable, we find excellent quantitative agreement with less than 55%5 deviation from the numerically exact results.
Spin systems are known for their purely interacting nature, causing them to lack a canonical perturbative limit, which usually helps to understand the fundamental physics of a system. A method that has proven effective for the description of strongly correlated systems is Functional Renormalization Group (FRG), which can be thought of as an alternative to the path integral formalism as an approach to many-body quantum mechanics. The basic concept is to cure infrared divergences by introducing a cutoff to correlation functions. Continuously lowering the infrared cutoff and hence allowing the system to occupy lower-lying energy states is called the FRG flow and is formulated in terms of differential equations. The solutions to these equations are functions which describe effective interactions between particles and hence contain information about particle correlations and thermodynamic quantities. Formulating FRG in terms of spins turns out to be a subtle endeavor, though, as the spin algebra relations are relatively complicated compared to, for example, the canonical anti-commutation relations of fermions. In order to use the advantages of FRG for spin systems, one can map spins onto fermionic operators, which leads to pseudo-fermion FRG (PFFRG), developed by Reuther and Wölfle.[198] Alter- natively, one can express spins in terms of Majorana operators, leading to pseudo- Majorana FRG (PMFRG), which has been developed by Niggemann, Sbierski, and Reuther.[163] PMFRG is particularly powerful at finite temperatures, where useful properties of Majorana operators render the method more accurate than PFFRG. In contrast to many other methods, PFFRG and PMFRG are applicable to any spin system, even frustrated ones. In this work, PMFRG is being generalized and applied to highly frustrated spin systems. In particular, spin representations in terms of Majorana operators for spins with arbitrary large spin magnitude S are being investigated and classified thoroughly, which closes a gap in the literature about the second quantization of spin operators. Moreover, it is presented how to generalize PMFRG for Heisenberg models with full SU(2) symmetry to XXZ models exhibiting only a U(1) symmetry. This opens up a wide range of interesting applications for PMFRG. An example is the XXZ model on the pyrochlore lattice, which is known to exhibit conventional long-range order but also exotic spin liquid ground states in the so-called spin ice phase. PMFRG is applied to this model, and the results are being compared to experiments. Furthermore, the entire phase diagram of the XXZ model is being mapped out. Also, the capability of PMFRG to reproduce low-energy field theory predictions and to determine critical exponents is being tested.