Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.07520 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Uncertainties in quantum measurements: a quantum tomography

A. P. Balachandran, F Calderón, V. P. Nair, Aleksandr Pinzul, A. F. Reyes-Lega, Sachindeo Vaidya

Published Apr 25, 2022• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The observables associated with a quantum system S form a non-commutative algebra A S . It is assumed that a density matrix ρ can be determined from the expectation values of observables. But A S admits inner automorphisms a ↦ u a u − 1 , a , u ∈ A S , u * u = u u * = 1 , so that its individual elements can be identified only up to unitary transformations. So since Tr ρ ( uau *) = Tr( u * ρu ) a , only the spectrum of ρ , or its characteristic polynomial, can be determined in quantum mechanics. In local quantum field theory, ρ cannot be determined at all, as we shall explain. However, abelian algebras do not have inner automorphisms, so the measurement apparatus can determine mean values of observables in abelian algebras A M ⊂ A S ( M for measurement, S for system). We study the uncertainties in extending ρ | A M to ρ | A S (the determination of which means measurement of A S ) and devise a protocol to determine ρ

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/ac6a2c

Related papers

Priority Choice Experimental Two-Qubit Tomography: Measuring One by One All Elements of Density Matrices

Karol Bartkiewicz, Antonín Černoch, Karel Lemr +1 more

In standard optical tomographic methods, the off-diagonal elements of a density matrix ρ are measured indirectly. Thus, the reconstruction of ρ, even if it is based on linear inversion, typically magnifies small errors in the experimental data. Recently, an optimal tomography solution measuring all the elements of ρ one-by-one without error magnification has been theoretically proposed. We implemented this method for two-qubit polarization states. For comparison, we also experimentally implemented other well-known tomographic protocols, either based solely on local measurements (of, e.g., the Pauli operators and James-Kwiat-Munro-White projectors) or with mutually unbiased bases requiring both local and global measurements. We reconstructed seventeen separable, partially and maximally entangled two-qubit polarization states. Our experiments show that our method has the highest stability against errors in comparison to other quantum tomographies. In particular, we demonstrate that each optimally-reconstructed state is embedded in an uncertainty circle of the smallest radius, both in terms of trace distance and disturbance. We explain how to experimentally estimate uncertainty radii for all the implemented tomographies and show that, for each reconstructed state, the relevant uncertainty circles intersect indicating the approximate location of the corresponding physical density matrix.

arXiv:1506.01317•Scientific Reports•Jan 21, 2016•28 citations

A new approach to measurement in quantum tomography

Artur Czerwiński

In this article we propose a new approach to quantum measurement in reference to the stroboscopic tomography. Generally, in the stroboscopic approach it is assumed that the information about the quantum system is encoded in the mean values of certain Hermitian operators $Q_1, ..., Q_r$ and each of them can be measured more than once. The main goal of the stroboscopic tomography is to determine when one can reconstruct the initial density matrix $ρ(0)$ on the basis of the measurement results $\langle Q_i \rangle_{t_j}$. In this paper we propose to treat every complex matrix as a measurable operator. This generalized approach to quantum measurement may bring some improvement into the models of stroboscopic tomography.

arXiv:1504.01326•Apr 2, 2015•2 citations

An Overview on Single Apparatus Quantum Measurements

Bahar Mehmani, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

Given the state of a quantum system, one can calculate the expectation value of any observable of the system. However, the inverse problem of determining the state by performing different measurements is not a trivial task. In various experimental setups it is reasonably straightforward to reconstruct the state of a quantum system employing linear tomographic technique. In this way the elements of the density matrix can be linearly related to a set of measured quantities. But since different observables of a quantum system are not commuting with each other, one often has to perform series of successive measurements of observables which cannot be done simultaneously. Simultaneous measurement of observables cost less time and energy and is more beneficial. In this paper we review the strategy of quantum state tomography with simultaneous measurement of commuting observables. This can be done by introducing an assistant system of which the state is known. We show that the interaction between the assistant and the system of interest within different frame works allows the reconstruction of the state of the system. Specifically, we consider a two-level system and reconstruct its initial state by introducing an assistant which can be either another two-level system or a single cavity mode of the electromagnetic field.

arXiv:1007.3635•Journal of Computational and Theoretical Nanoscience•Mar 23, 2011•4 citations

Measuring non-Hermitian operators via weak values

Arun Kumar Pati, Uttam Singh, Urbasi Sinha

In quantum theory, a physical observable is represented by a Hermitian operator as it admits real eigenvalues. This stems from the fact that any measuring apparatus that is supposed to measure a physical observable will always yield a real number. However, the reality of an eigenvalue of some operator does not mean that it is necessarily Hermitian. There are examples of non-Hermitian operators that may admit real eigenvalues under some symmetry conditions. In general, given a non-Hermitian operator, its average value in a quantum state is a complex number and there are only very limited methods available to measure it. Following standard quantum mechanics, we provide an experimentally feasible protocol to measure the expectation value of any non-Hermitian operator via weak measurements. The average of a non-Hermitian operator in a pure state is a complex multiple of the weak value of the positive-semidefinite part of the non-Hermitian operator. We also prove an uncertainty relation for any two non-Hermitian operators and show that the fidelity of a quantum state under a quantum channel can be measured using the average of the corresponding Kraus operators. The importance of our method is shown in testing the stronger uncertainty relation, verifying the Ramanujan formula, and measuring the product of noncommuting projectors.

arXiv:1406.3007•Physical Review A•Nov 25, 2015•75 citations

Group Theoretical Quantum Tomography

Gianni Cassinelli, Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Ernesto De Vito +1 more

. The paper is devoted to the mathematical foundation of the quantum tomography using the theory of square-integrable representations of unimodular Lie groups. 1. introduction In Quantum Mechanics a physical system is associated with a Hilbert space H: the states are described by positive trace-class trace-one operators T on H, the physical quantities by self-adjoint operators A on H and the physical content of the theory is given by the expectation values Tr (AT ). The state T is completely determined by Tr (Q n T ) for Q n running on a suitable set fQ n g of observables and, for arbitrary operator A, Tr (AT ) can be computed in terms of Tr (Q n T ). In order to implement this scheme one has to estimate Tr (Q n T ) experimentally, facing the problems arising from statistical errors and instrumental noise. Moreover, the number of experimental data is clearly nite, while A and T are operators on an innite dimensional Hilbert space and the set fQ n g is innite. The problem of determ...

•Jan 1, 2000•26 citations

Quantum measurement trees, II: quantum observables as ortho-measurable functions and density matrices as ortho-probability measures

Peter J. Hammond

Given a quantum state in the finite-dimensional Hilbert space Cn, the range of possible values of a quantum observable is usually identified with the discrete spectrum of eigenvalues of a corresponding Hermitian matrix. Here any such observable is identified with (i) an 'ortho-measurable' function defined on the Boolean 'ortho-algebra' generated by the eigenspaces that form an orthogonal decomposition of Cn, and (ii) a 'numerically identified' orthogonal decomposition of Cn. The latter means that each subspace of the orthogonal decomposition can be uniquely identified by its own attached real number, just as each eigenspace of a Hermitian matrix can be uniquely identified by the corresponding eigenvalue. Furthermore, any density matrix on Cn is identified with a Bayesian prior 'ortho-probability' measure defined on the linear subspaces that make up the Boolean ortho-algebra induced by its eigenspaces. Then any pure quantum state is identified with a degenerate density matrix, and any mixed state with a probability measure on a set of orthogonal pure states. Finally, given any quantum observable, the relevant Bayesian posterior probabilities of measured outcomes can be found by the usual trace formula that extends Born's rule. This article is part of the theme issue 'Quantum theory and topology in models of decision making (Part 2)'.

arXiv:2509.22617•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 11, 2025•2 citations
Abstract The observables associated with a quantum system S form a non-commutative algebra A S . It is assumed that a density matrix ρ can be determined from the expectation values of observables. But A S admits inner automorphisms a ↦ u a u − 1 , a , u ∈ A S , u * u = u u * = 1 , so that its individual elements can be identified only up to unitary transformations. So since Tr ρ ( uau *) = Tr( u * ρu ) a , only the spectrum of ρ , or its characteristic polynomial, can be determined in quantum mechanics. In local quantum field theory, ρ cannot be determined at all, as we shall explain. However, abelian algebras do not have inner automorphisms, so the measurement apparatus can determine mean values of observables in abelian algebras A M ⊂ A S ( M for measurement, S for system). We study the uncertainties in extending ρ | A M to ρ | A S (the determination of which means measurement of A S ) and devise a protocol to determine ρ
In standard optical tomographic methods, the off-diagonal elements of a density matrix ρ are measured indirectly. Thus, the reconstruction of ρ, even if it is based on linear inversion, typically magnifies small errors in the experimental data. Recently, an optimal tomography solution measuring all the elements of ρ one-by-one without error magnification has been theoretically proposed. We implemented this method for two-qubit polarization states. For comparison, we also experimentally implemented other well-known tomographic protocols, either based solely on local measurements (of, e.g., the Pauli operators and James-Kwiat-Munro-White projectors) or with mutually unbiased bases requiring both local and global measurements. We reconstructed seventeen separable, partially and maximally entangled two-qubit polarization states. Our experiments show that our method has the highest stability against errors in comparison to other quantum tomographies. In particular, we demonstrate that each optimally-reconstructed state is embedded in an uncertainty circle of the smallest radius, both in terms of trace distance and disturbance. We explain how to experimentally estimate uncertainty radii for all the implemented tomographies and show that, for each reconstructed state, the relevant uncertainty circles intersect indicating the approximate location of the corresponding physical density matrix.
In this article we propose a new approach to quantum measurement in reference to the stroboscopic tomography. Generally, in the stroboscopic approach it is assumed that the information about the quantum system is encoded in the mean values of certain Hermitian operators Q1,...,QrQ_1, ..., Q_rQ1​,...,Qr​ and each of them can be measured more than once. The main goal of the stroboscopic tomography is to determine when one can reconstruct the initial density matrix ρ(0)ρ(0)ρ(0) on the basis of the measurement results ⟨Qi⟩tj\langle Q_i \rangle_{t_j}⟨Qi​⟩tj​​. In this paper we propose to treat every complex matrix as a measurable operator. This generalized approach to quantum measurement may bring some improvement into the models of stroboscopic tomography.
Given the state of a quantum system, one can calculate the expectation value of any observable of the system. However, the inverse problem of determining the state by performing different measurements is not a trivial task. In various experimental setups it is reasonably straightforward to reconstruct the state of a quantum system employing linear tomographic technique. In this way the elements of the density matrix can be linearly related to a set of measured quantities. But since different observables of a quantum system are not commuting with each other, one often has to perform series of successive measurements of observables which cannot be done simultaneously. Simultaneous measurement of observables cost less time and energy and is more beneficial. In this paper we review the strategy of quantum state tomography with simultaneous measurement of commuting observables. This can be done by introducing an assistant system of which the state is known. We show that the interaction between the assistant and the system of interest within different frame works allows the reconstruction of the state of the system. Specifically, we consider a two-level system and reconstruct its initial state by introducing an assistant which can be either another two-level system or a single cavity mode of the electromagnetic field.
In quantum theory, a physical observable is represented by a Hermitian operator as it admits real eigenvalues. This stems from the fact that any measuring apparatus that is supposed to measure a physical observable will always yield a real number. However, the reality of an eigenvalue of some operator does not mean that it is necessarily Hermitian. There are examples of non-Hermitian operators that may admit real eigenvalues under some symmetry conditions. In general, given a non-Hermitian operator, its average value in a quantum state is a complex number and there are only very limited methods available to measure it. Following standard quantum mechanics, we provide an experimentally feasible protocol to measure the expectation value of any non-Hermitian operator via weak measurements. The average of a non-Hermitian operator in a pure state is a complex multiple of the weak value of the positive-semidefinite part of the non-Hermitian operator. We also prove an uncertainty relation for any two non-Hermitian operators and show that the fidelity of a quantum state under a quantum channel can be measured using the average of the corresponding Kraus operators. The importance of our method is shown in testing the stronger uncertainty relation, verifying the Ramanujan formula, and measuring the product of noncommuting projectors.
. The paper is devoted to the mathematical foundation of the quantum tomography using the theory of square-integrable representations of unimodular Lie groups. 1. introduction In Quantum Mechanics a physical system is associated with a Hilbert space H: the states are described by positive trace-class trace-one operators T on H, the physical quantities by self-adjoint operators A on H and the physical content of the theory is given by the expectation values Tr (AT ). The state T is completely determined by Tr (Q n T ) for Q n running on a suitable set fQ n g of observables and, for arbitrary operator A, Tr (AT ) can be computed in terms of Tr (Q n T ). In order to implement this scheme one has to estimate Tr (Q n T ) experimentally, facing the problems arising from statistical errors and instrumental noise. Moreover, the number of experimental data is clearly nite, while A and T are operators on an innite dimensional Hilbert space and the set fQ n g is innite. The problem of determ...
Given a quantum state in the finite-dimensional Hilbert space Cn, the range of possible values of a quantum observable is usually identified with the discrete spectrum of eigenvalues of a corresponding Hermitian matrix. Here any such observable is identified with (i) an 'ortho-measurable' function defined on the Boolean 'ortho-algebra' generated by the eigenspaces that form an orthogonal decomposition of Cn, and (ii) a 'numerically identified' orthogonal decomposition of Cn. The latter means that each subspace of the orthogonal decomposition can be uniquely identified by its own attached real number, just as each eigenspace of a Hermitian matrix can be uniquely identified by the corresponding eigenvalue. Furthermore, any density matrix on Cn is identified with a Bayesian prior 'ortho-probability' measure defined on the linear subspaces that make up the Boolean ortho-algebra induced by its eigenspaces. Then any pure quantum state is identified with a degenerate density matrix, and any mixed state with a probability measure on a set of orthogonal pure states. Finally, given any quantum observable, the relevant Bayesian posterior probabilities of measured outcomes can be found by the usual trace formula that extends Born's rule. This article is part of the theme issue 'Quantum theory and topology in models of decision making (Part 2)'.