Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.07028 · Physica Scripta

Realistic photon-number resolution in generalized Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment

V Ye Len, M M Byelova, V. A. Uzunova, А. А. Семенов

Published Sep 8, 2022• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We consider realistic photodetection in a generalization of the Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment to the multimode case. The basic layout of this experiment underlies boson sampling—a promising model of nonuniversal quantum computations. Peculiarities of photocounting probabilities in such an experiment witness important nonclassical properties of electromagnetic field related to indistinguishability of boson particles. In practice, these probabilities are changed from their theoretical values due to the imperfect ability of realistic detectors to distinguish numbers of bunched photons. We derive analytical expressions for photocounting distributions in the generalized Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment for the case of realistic photon-number resolving (PNR) detectors. It is shown that probabilities of properly postselected events are proportional to probabilities obtained for perfect PNR detectors. Our results are illustrated with examples of arrays of on/off detectors and detectors affected by a finite dead time.

DOI
10.1088/1402-4896/ac9095

Related papers

Realistic photon-number resolution in Gaussian boson sampling

I. S. Yeremenko, M. A. Dmytruk, А. А. Семенов

Gaussian boson sampling (GBS) is a model of nonuniversal quantum computation that claims to demonstrate quantum supremacy with current technologies. This model entails sampling photocounting events from a multimode Gaussian state at the outputs of a linear interferometer. In this scheme, collision events—those with more than one photon for each mode—are infrequent. However, they are still used for validation purposes. Therefore, the limitation of realistic detectors to perfectly resolve adjacent photon numbers becomes pivotal. We derive a photocounting probability distribution in GBS schemes which is applicable for use with general detectors and photocounting techniques. This probability distribution is expressed in terms of functionals of the field-quadrature covariance matrix, e.g., Hafnian and Torontonian in the well-known special cases of photon-number-resolving and on-off detectors, respectively. Based on our results, we consider a GBS validation technique involving detectors with realistic photon-number resolution. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2403.03184•Physical Review A•Oct 18, 2024•0 citations

Beyond coincidence in Hong-Ou-Mandel interferometry

Hannah Scott, Dominic Branford, Niclas Westerberg +2 more

The Hong-Ou-Mandel effect provides a mechanism to determine the distinguishability of a photon pair by measuring the bunching rates of two photons interfering at a beam splitter. Of particular interest is the distinguishability in time, which can be used to probe a time delay. Photon detectors themselves give some timing information, however, while that resolution may dwarf that of an interferometric technique, typical analyses reduce the interference to a binary event, neglecting temporal information in the detector. By modeling detectors with number and temporal resolution we demonstrate a greater precision than coincidence rates or temporal data alone afford. Moreover, the additional information can allow simultaneous estimation of a time delay alongside calibration parameters, opening up the possibility of calibration-free protocols and approaching the precision of the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound.

arXiv:2005.14696•Physical Review A•Sep 10, 2020•21 citations

Theory framework of multiplexed photon-number-resolving detectors

Xiaobin Zhao, Hezheng Qin, Hong X. Tang +2 more

Photon counting is a fundamental component in quantum optics and quantum information. However, implementing ideal photon-number-resolving (PNR) detectors remains experimentally challenging. Multiplexed PNR detection offers a scalable and practical alternative by distributing photons across multiple modes and detecting their presence using simple ON-OFF detectors, thereby enabling approximate photon-number resolution. In this work, we establish a theoretical model for such detectors and prove that the estimation error in terms of photon number moments decreases inverse proportionally to the number of detectors. Thanks to the enhanced PNR capability, multiplexed PNR detector provides an advantage in cat-state breeding protocols. Assuming a two-photon subtraction case, $7$dB of squeezing, and an array of 20 detectors of efficiency $95\%$, our calculation predicts fidelity $\sim0.88$ with a success probability $\sim 3.8\%$, representing orders-of-magnitude improvement over previous works. Similar enhancement also extends to cat-state generation with the generalized photon number subtraction. With experimentally feasible parameters, our results suggest that megahertz-rate cat-state generation is achievable using an on-chip array of \emph{tens} of ON-OFF detectors.

arXiv:2507.05554•Physical Review A•Jan 9, 2026•0 citations

The Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment: from photon indistinguishability to continuous-variable quantum computing

Nicolas Fabre, Maria I. Amanti, F. Baboux +3 more

Abstract We extensively discuss the Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment by taking an original phase-space-based perspective. For this, we analyze time and frequency variables as quantum continuous variables in perfect analogy with position and momentum of massive particles or with the electromagnetic field’s quadratures. We discuss how this experiment can be used to directly measure the time-frequency Wigner function and implement logical gates in these variables. We also briefly discuss the quantum/classical aspects of this experiment providing a general expression for intensity correlations that make explicit the differences between a classical Hong–Ou–Mandel-like dip and a quantum one. Throughout the manuscript, we will often focus and refer to a particular system based on AlGaAs waveguides emitting photon pairs via spontaneous parametric down conversion, but our results can be extended to other analogous experimental systems and to various degrees of freedom. Graphical Abstract The Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment is a landmark in quantum optics, showing the bunching of indistinguishable bunch. In the present contribution, we give another perspective to this experiment based on a phase space representation of the continuous degrees of freedom of the single photons sent into the input arms of such interferometer. We show that the coincidence detection in the output ports of an Hong– Ou–Mandel interferometer is a direct measurement of the Wigner function of the produced photons in a given region of space, and we discuss how continuous degrees of freedom of single photons can be used in continuous variables quantum protocols, as quantum error correction and metrology. Our results open the perspective of broadening even more the applications of single photon-based quantum information-related protocols.

The European Physical Journal D•Oct 1, 2022•12 citations

Clearer visibility of the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect with a correlation function based on rates rather than intensities

Krzysztof Rosołek, Kamil Kostrzewa, Arijit Dutta +3 more

We test ideas put forward, e.g., by \ifmmode \dot{Z}\else \.{Z}\fi{}ukowski et al. [M. \ifmmode \dot{Z}\else \.{Z}\fi{}ukowski et al., Phys. Rev. A 95, 042113 (2017)], which suggest that using rates in quantum optics can lead to better indicators of nonclassicality for states of quantum optical fields with undefined photon numbers. By rate we mean the ratio of registered photons in a given detector to the total number of detected photons in all detectors in a run of the experiment. For the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect for parametric down-conversion fields, we show that by using two detector correlation functions, which are defined in terms of averages of products of measured rates, rather than usual intensities, one can observe nonclassical visibilities beyond $1/2$ for significantly higher pump rates. At such rates we already have the partially stimulated emission, which leads to significant amplitudes for multiple pairs production, still the approach allows us to clearly see the nonclassical dip. We consider both the perfect and imperfect detection efficiency.

arXiv:1601.07817•Physical Review A•Apr 17, 2017•4 citations

Partial indistinguishability theory for multiphoton experiments in multiport devices

V. S. Shchesnovich

We generalize an approach for description of multiphoton experiments with multiport unitary linear optical devices, started in Phys. Rev. A 89, 022333 (2014) with single photons in mixed spectral states, to arbitrary (multiphoton) input and arbitrary photon detectors. We show that output probabilities are always given in terms of the matrix permanents of the Hadamard product of a matrix built from the network matrix and matrices built from the spectral state of photons and spectral sensitivities of detectors. Moreover, in the case of input with up to one photon per mode, the output probabilities are given by a sum (or integral) with each term being the absolute value squared of such a matrix permanent. We conjecture that, for an arbitrary multiphoton input, zero output probability of an output configuration is always the result of an exact cancellation of quantum transition amplitudes of completely indistinguishable photons (a subset of all input photons) and, moreover, is independent of coherence between only partially indistinguishable photons. The conjecture is supported by examples. Furthermore, we propose a measure of partial indistinguishability of photons which generalizes Mandel's observation, and find the law of degradation of quantum coherence in a realistic boson-sampling device with increase of the total number of photons and/or their ``classicality parameter.''

arXiv:1410.1506•Physical Review A•Jan 29, 2015•122 citations
Abstract We consider realistic photodetection in a generalization of the Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment to the multimode case. The basic layout of this experiment underlies boson sampling—a promising model of nonuniversal quantum computations. Peculiarities of photocounting probabilities in such an experiment witness important nonclassical properties of electromagnetic field related to indistinguishability of boson particles. In practice, these probabilities are changed from their theoretical values due to the imperfect ability of realistic detectors to distinguish numbers of bunched photons. We derive analytical expressions for photocounting distributions in the generalized Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment for the case of realistic photon-number resolving (PNR) detectors. It is shown that probabilities of properly postselected events are proportional to probabilities obtained for perfect PNR detectors. Our results are illustrated with examples of arrays of on/off detectors and detectors affected by a finite dead time.
Gaussian boson sampling (GBS) is a model of nonuniversal quantum computation that claims to demonstrate quantum supremacy with current technologies. This model entails sampling photocounting events from a multimode Gaussian state at the outputs of a linear interferometer. In this scheme, collision events—those with more than one photon for each mode—are infrequent. However, they are still used for validation purposes. Therefore, the limitation of realistic detectors to perfectly resolve adjacent photon numbers becomes pivotal. We derive a photocounting probability distribution in GBS schemes which is applicable for use with general detectors and photocounting techniques. This probability distribution is expressed in terms of functionals of the field-quadrature covariance matrix, e.g., Hafnian and Torontonian in the well-known special cases of photon-number-resolving and on-off detectors, respectively. Based on our results, we consider a GBS validation technique involving detectors with realistic photon-number resolution. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The Hong-Ou-Mandel effect provides a mechanism to determine the distinguishability of a photon pair by measuring the bunching rates of two photons interfering at a beam splitter. Of particular interest is the distinguishability in time, which can be used to probe a time delay. Photon detectors themselves give some timing information, however, while that resolution may dwarf that of an interferometric technique, typical analyses reduce the interference to a binary event, neglecting temporal information in the detector. By modeling detectors with number and temporal resolution we demonstrate a greater precision than coincidence rates or temporal data alone afford. Moreover, the additional information can allow simultaneous estimation of a time delay alongside calibration parameters, opening up the possibility of calibration-free protocols and approaching the precision of the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound.
Photon counting is a fundamental component in quantum optics and quantum information. However, implementing ideal photon-number-resolving (PNR) detectors remains experimentally challenging. Multiplexed PNR detection offers a scalable and practical alternative by distributing photons across multiple modes and detecting their presence using simple ON-OFF detectors, thereby enabling approximate photon-number resolution. In this work, we establish a theoretical model for such detectors and prove that the estimation error in terms of photon number moments decreases inverse proportionally to the number of detectors. Thanks to the enhanced PNR capability, multiplexed PNR detector provides an advantage in cat-state breeding protocols. Assuming a two-photon subtraction case, 777dB of squeezing, and an array of 20 detectors of efficiency 95%95\%95%, our calculation predicts fidelity ∼0.88\sim0.88∼0.88 with a success probability ∼3.8%\sim 3.8\%∼3.8%, representing orders-of-magnitude improvement over previous works. Similar enhancement also extends to cat-state generation with the generalized photon number subtraction. With experimentally feasible parameters, our results suggest that megahertz-rate cat-state generation is achievable using an on-chip array of \emph{tens} of ON-OFF detectors.
Abstract We extensively discuss the Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment by taking an original phase-space-based perspective. For this, we analyze time and frequency variables as quantum continuous variables in perfect analogy with position and momentum of massive particles or with the electromagnetic field’s quadratures. We discuss how this experiment can be used to directly measure the time-frequency Wigner function and implement logical gates in these variables. We also briefly discuss the quantum/classical aspects of this experiment providing a general expression for intensity correlations that make explicit the differences between a classical Hong–Ou–Mandel-like dip and a quantum one. Throughout the manuscript, we will often focus and refer to a particular system based on AlGaAs waveguides emitting photon pairs via spontaneous parametric down conversion, but our results can be extended to other analogous experimental systems and to various degrees of freedom. Graphical Abstract The Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment is a landmark in quantum optics, showing the bunching of indistinguishable bunch. In the present contribution, we give another perspective to this experiment based on a phase space representation of the continuous degrees of freedom of the single photons sent into the input arms of such interferometer. We show that the coincidence detection in the output ports of an Hong– Ou–Mandel interferometer is a direct measurement of the Wigner function of the produced photons in a given region of space, and we discuss how continuous degrees of freedom of single photons can be used in continuous variables quantum protocols, as quantum error correction and metrology. Our results open the perspective of broadening even more the applications of single photon-based quantum information-related protocols.
We test ideas put forward, e.g., by \ifmmode \dot{Z}\else \.{Z}\fi{}ukowski et al. [M. \ifmmode \dot{Z}\else \.{Z}\fi{}ukowski et al., Phys. Rev. A 95, 042113 (2017)], which suggest that using rates in quantum optics can lead to better indicators of nonclassicality for states of quantum optical fields with undefined photon numbers. By rate we mean the ratio of registered photons in a given detector to the total number of detected photons in all detectors in a run of the experiment. For the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect for parametric down-conversion fields, we show that by using two detector correlation functions, which are defined in terms of averages of products of measured rates, rather than usual intensities, one can observe nonclassical visibilities beyond 1/21/21/2 for significantly higher pump rates. At such rates we already have the partially stimulated emission, which leads to significant amplitudes for multiple pairs production, still the approach allows us to clearly see the nonclassical dip. We consider both the perfect and imperfect detection efficiency.
We generalize an approach for description of multiphoton experiments with multiport unitary linear optical devices, started in Phys. Rev. A 89, 022333 (2014) with single photons in mixed spectral states, to arbitrary (multiphoton) input and arbitrary photon detectors. We show that output probabilities are always given in terms of the matrix permanents of the Hadamard product of a matrix built from the network matrix and matrices built from the spectral state of photons and spectral sensitivities of detectors. Moreover, in the case of input with up to one photon per mode, the output probabilities are given by a sum (or integral) with each term being the absolute value squared of such a matrix permanent. We conjecture that, for an arbitrary multiphoton input, zero output probability of an output configuration is always the result of an exact cancellation of quantum transition amplitudes of completely indistinguishable photons (a subset of all input photons) and, moreover, is independent of coherence between only partially indistinguishable photons. The conjecture is supported by examples. Furthermore, we propose a measure of partial indistinguishability of photons which generalizes Mandel's observation, and find the law of degradation of quantum coherence in a realistic boson-sampling device with increase of the total number of photons and/or their ``classicality parameter.''