Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.02253 · Physical Review A

Unveiling topological order through multipartite entanglement

Siddhartha Patra, Somnath Basu, Siddhartha Lal

Published May 19, 2022• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is well known that the topological entanglement entropy (${S}_{\mathrm{topo}}$) of a topologically ordered ground state in two spatial dimensions can be captured efficiently by measuring the tripartite quantum information (${I}^{3}$) of a specific annular arrangement of three subsystems. However, the nature of the general $N$-partite information (${I}^{N}$) and correlation of a topologically ordered ground state remains unknown. In this work, we study such ${I}^{N}$ measure and its nontrivial dependence on the arrangement of $N$ subsystems. For the collection of subsystems (CSS) forming a closed annular structure, the ${I}^{N}$ measure ($N\ensuremath{\ge}3$) is a topological invariant equal to the product of ${S}_{\mathrm{topo}}$ and the Euler characteristic of the CSS embedded on a planar manifold, $|{I}^{N}|=\ensuremath{\chi}{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}$. Importantly, we establish that ${I}^{N}$ is robust against several deformations of the annular CSS, such as the addition of holes within individual subsystems and handles between nearest-neighbor subsystems. While the addition of a handle between further neighbor subsystems causes ${I}^{N}$ to vanish, the multipartite information measures of the two smaller annular CSS emergent from this deformation again yield the same topological invariant. For a general CSS with multiple holes (${n}_{h}>1$), we find that the sum of the distinct, multipartite information measured on the annular CSS around those holes is given by the product of ${S}_{\mathrm{topo}}, \ensuremath{\chi}$ and ${n}_{h}, {\ensuremath{\sum}}_{{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{i}=1}^{{n}_{h}}|{I}_{{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{i}}^{{N}_{{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{i}}}|={n}_{h}\ensuremath{\chi}{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}$. This constrains the concomitant measurement of several multipartite information on any complicated CSS. The $N\text{th}$ order irreducible correlations for an annular CSS of $N$ subsystems is also found to be bounded from above by $|{I}^{N}|$, which shows the presence of correlations among subsystems arranged in the form of closed loops of all sizes. Thus, our results offer important insight into the nature of the many-particle entanglement and correlations within a topologically ordered state of matter.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.105.052428

Related papers

Information-theoretical analysis of topological entanglement entropy and multipartite correlations

Kohtaro Kato, Fabian Furrer, Mio Murao

A special feature of the ground state in a topologically ordered phase is the existence of large-scale correlations depending only on the topology of the regions. These correlations can be detected by the topological entanglement entropy or by a measure called irreducible correlation. We show that these two measures coincide for states obeying an area law and having zero correlation length. Moreover, we provide an operational meaning for these measures by proving its equivalence to the optimal rate of a particular class of secret sharing protocols. This establishes an information-theoretical approach to multipartite correlations in topologically ordered systems.

arXiv:1505.01917•Physical Review A•Feb 11, 2016•41 citations

Universal entanglement probes of topological order and locally-achiral manifolds

Yarden Sheffer

We consider the problem of identifying a topological order based on bulk entanglement of the ground-state wavefunction. Previous work showed that some universal information can be extracted from multi-entropy measures, a class of multipartite entanglement measures obtained by applying permutation operators exchanging the degrees of freedom between different replicas of the wavefunction. It remains an open question to what extent such entanglement measures can be used to extract any universal information from the ground state. Here we show that the topological partition function $Z(M)$ of a manifold $M$ can be extracted provided that $M$ satisfies a topological condition which we term ``local achirality". We show that locally-achiral manifolds can be used to extract universal properties of 2+1d topological phases that go beyond the $S$ and $T$ matrices. As a first step towards classifying locally-achiral manifolds, we show that, in four dimensions, such manifolds have vanishing Pontryagin number. We relate this property to the existence of beyond-cohomology time-reversal symmetry protected topological order (T-SPT) in four dimensions. Finally, we present an entanglement measure that detects this nontrivial T-SPT.

quant-pharXiv:2606.18361•Jun 18, 2026•2 citations

Multipartite entanglement in two-dimensional chiral topological liquids

Yuhan Liu, Yuya Kusuki, Jonah Kudler-Flam +2 more

The multipartite entanglement structure for the ground states of two-dimensional (2D) topological phases is an interesting albeit not well-understood question. Utilizing the bulk-boundary correspondence, the calculation of tripartite entanglement in 2D topological phases can be reduced to that of the vertex state, defined by the boundary conditions at the interfaces between spatial regions. In this paper, we use the conformal interface technique to calculate entanglement measures in the vertex state, which include area-law terms, corner contributions, and topological pieces, and a possible additional order-one contribution. This explains our previous observation of the Markov gap $h=\frac{c}{3}ln2$ in the three-vertex state, and generalizes this result to the $p$-vertex state, general rational conformal field theories, and more choices of subsystems. Finally, we support our prediction by numerical evidence, finding precise agreement.

arXiv:2301.07130•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 6, 2024•25 citations

Genuine Multi-Entropy in the Toric Code

Sriram Akella, Norihiro Iizuka, Akihiro Miyata

We study genuine multi-entropy as a diagnostic of multipartite entanglement in the toric code, which provides a controlled setting for probing multipartite structures in topologically ordered states. Our main question is whether genuine multi-entropy captures information that is not reducible to conventional lower-party entropic data, such as topological entanglement entropy. We first analyze toric-code ground states that admit a stabilizer-state description, where the relevant quantities can be evaluated exactly. We conjecture that, for stabilizer states and $\mathtt{q}\ge4$, the $\mathtt{q}$-partite genuine multi-entropy at replica index $n<\mathtt{q}$ collapses to a linear combination of multi-entropies involving at most $\mathtt{q}-2$ parties. We establish this pattern explicitly for $\mathtt{q}=4$ in the toric code stabilizer sector: for $n=2,3$, the genuine multi-entropy is proportional to the tripartite information $I_3$ and, for the Kitaev-Preskill partition, contains no independent genuine four-partite information beyond that captured by the topological entanglement entropy. At $n=4$, however, this reduction breaks down: the genuine multi-entropy is no longer proportional to $I_3$, but remains a topological invariant of the toric-code stabilizer ground states under Kitaev-Preskill-preserving deformations that do not change whether the numbers of vertex- and plaquette-type junctions coincide. For generic non-stabilizer superpositions within the ground-state manifold and for coherent superpositions of local excitations, the low-$n$ reduction also fails. These results show that genuine multi-entropy probes multipartite entanglement structure beyond the tripartite information, and hence beyond the topological entanglement entropy in the Kitaev-Preskill partition, whereas for stabilizer states at low replica index it reduces to lower-partite entropic data.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2607.06050•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 8, 2026•1 citation

Equivalence of Topological Entanglement Entropy and Irreducible Correlation and Relationship to Secret Sharing

Kohtaro Kato, Fabian Furrer, Mio Murao

Topological entanglement entropy, which is defined as the conditional mutual information of a state for an annular region in a topologically ordered system, is widely used to detect characteristic topological correlations in topologically ordered phases. We investigate an information-theoretical meaning of the topological entanglement entropy by analyzing a multi-partite correlation measure called irreducible correlation. We prove that the topological entanglement entropy is equivalent to the irreducible correlation if the state has zero-correlation length. We further show that for zero-correlation length states the irreducible correlation is equal to the maximum communication rate of a particular class of secret sharing protocols. Therefore, we provide an operational interpretation of the topological entanglement entropy.

•May 8, 2015•1 citation

Entanglement entropy of gapped phases and topological order in three dimensions

Tarun Grover, Ari M. Turner, Ashvin Vishwanath

We discuss entanglement entropy of gapped ground states in different dimensions, obtained on partitioning space into two regions. For trivial phases without topological order, we argue that the entanglement entropy may be obtained by integrating an ``entropy density'' over the partition boundary that admits a gradient expansion in the curvature of the boundary. This constrains the expansion of entanglement entropy as a function of system size and points to an even-odd dependence on dimensionality. For example, in contrast to the familiar result in two dimensions, a size-independent constant contribution to the entanglement entropy can appear for trivial phases in any odd spatial dimension. We then discuss phases with topological entanglement entropy (TEE) that cannot be obtained by adding local contributions. We find that in three dimensions there is just one type of TEE, as in two dimensions, that depends linearly on the number of connected components of the boundary (the ``zeroth Betti number''). In $D>3$ dimensions, new types of TEE appear which depend on the higher Betti numbers of the boundary manifold. We construct generalized toric code models that exhibit these TEEs and discuss ways to extract TEE in $D\ensuremath{\ge}3$.

arXiv:1108.4038•Physical Review B•Nov 23, 2011•146 citations
It is well known that the topological entanglement entropy (Stopo{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}Stopo​) of a topologically ordered ground state in two spatial dimensions can be captured efficiently by measuring the tripartite quantum information (I3{I}^{3}I3) of a specific annular arrangement of three subsystems. However, the nature of the general NNN-partite information (IN{I}^{N}IN) and correlation of a topologically ordered ground state remains unknown. In this work, we study such IN{I}^{N}IN measure and its nontrivial dependence on the arrangement of NNN subsystems. For the collection of subsystems (CSS) forming a closed annular structure, the IN{I}^{N}IN measure (N\ensuremath≥3N\ensuremath{\ge}3N\ensuremath≥3) is a topological invariant equal to the product of Stopo{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}Stopo​ and the Euler characteristic of the CSS embedded on a planar manifold, ∣IN∣=\ensuremathχStopo|{I}^{N}|=\ensuremath{\chi}{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}∣IN∣=\ensuremathχStopo​. Importantly, we establish that IN{I}^{N}IN is robust against several deformations of the annular CSS, such as the addition of holes within individual subsystems and handles between nearest-neighbor subsystems. While the addition of a handle between further neighbor subsystems causes IN{I}^{N}IN to vanish, the multipartite information measures of the two smaller annular CSS emergent from this deformation again yield the same topological invariant. For a general CSS with multiple holes (nh>1{n}_{h}>1nh​>1), we find that the sum of the distinct, multipartite information measured on the annular CSS around those holes is given by the product of Stopo,\ensuremathχ{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}, \ensuremath{\chi}Stopo​,\ensuremathχ and nh,\ensuremath∑\ensuremathμi=1nh∣I\ensuremathμiN\ensuremathμi∣=nh\ensuremathχStopo{n}_{h}, {\ensuremath{\sum}}_{{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{i}=1}^{{n}_{h}}|{I}_{{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{i}}^{{N}_{{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{i}}}|={n}_{h}\ensuremath{\chi}{S}_{\mathrm{topo}}nh​,\ensuremath∑\ensuremathμi​=1nh​​∣I\ensuremathμi​N\ensuremathμi​​​∣=nh​\ensuremathχStopo​. This constrains the concomitant measurement of several multipartite information on any complicated CSS. The NthN\text{th}Nth order irreducible correlations for an annular CSS of NNN subsystems is also found to be bounded from above by ∣IN∣|{I}^{N}|∣IN∣, which shows the presence of correlations among subsystems arranged in the form of closed loops of all sizes. Thus, our results offer important insight into the nature of the many-particle entanglement and correlations within a topologically ordered state of matter.
A special feature of the ground state in a topologically ordered phase is the existence of large-scale correlations depending only on the topology of the regions. These correlations can be detected by the topological entanglement entropy or by a measure called irreducible correlation. We show that these two measures coincide for states obeying an area law and having zero correlation length. Moreover, we provide an operational meaning for these measures by proving its equivalence to the optimal rate of a particular class of secret sharing protocols. This establishes an information-theoretical approach to multipartite correlations in topologically ordered systems.
We consider the problem of identifying a topological order based on bulk entanglement of the ground-state wavefunction. Previous work showed that some universal information can be extracted from multi-entropy measures, a class of multipartite entanglement measures obtained by applying permutation operators exchanging the degrees of freedom between different replicas of the wavefunction. It remains an open question to what extent such entanglement measures can be used to extract any universal information from the ground state. Here we show that the topological partition function Z(M)Z(M)Z(M) of a manifold MMM can be extracted provided that MMM satisfies a topological condition which we term ``local achirality". We show that locally-achiral manifolds can be used to extract universal properties of 2+1d topological phases that go beyond the SSS and TTT matrices. As a first step towards classifying locally-achiral manifolds, we show that, in four dimensions, such manifolds have vanishing Pontryagin number. We relate this property to the existence of beyond-cohomology time-reversal symmetry protected topological order (T-SPT) in four dimensions. Finally, we present an entanglement measure that detects this nontrivial T-SPT.
The multipartite entanglement structure for the ground states of two-dimensional (2D) topological phases is an interesting albeit not well-understood question. Utilizing the bulk-boundary correspondence, the calculation of tripartite entanglement in 2D topological phases can be reduced to that of the vertex state, defined by the boundary conditions at the interfaces between spatial regions. In this paper, we use the conformal interface technique to calculate entanglement measures in the vertex state, which include area-law terms, corner contributions, and topological pieces, and a possible additional order-one contribution. This explains our previous observation of the Markov gap h=c3ln2h=\frac{c}{3}ln2h=3c​ln2 in the three-vertex state, and generalizes this result to the ppp-vertex state, general rational conformal field theories, and more choices of subsystems. Finally, we support our prediction by numerical evidence, finding precise agreement.
We study genuine multi-entropy as a diagnostic of multipartite entanglement in the toric code, which provides a controlled setting for probing multipartite structures in topologically ordered states. Our main question is whether genuine multi-entropy captures information that is not reducible to conventional lower-party entropic data, such as topological entanglement entropy. We first analyze toric-code ground states that admit a stabilizer-state description, where the relevant quantities can be evaluated exactly. We conjecture that, for stabilizer states and q≥4\mathtt{q}\ge4q≥4, the q\mathtt{q}q-partite genuine multi-entropy at replica index n<qn<\mathtt{q}n<q collapses to a linear combination of multi-entropies involving at most q−2\mathtt{q}-2q−2 parties. We establish this pattern explicitly for q=4\mathtt{q}=4q=4 in the toric code stabilizer sector: for n=2,3n=2,3n=2,3, the genuine multi-entropy is proportional to the tripartite information I3I_3I3​ and, for the Kitaev-Preskill partition, contains no independent genuine four-partite information beyond that captured by the topological entanglement entropy. At n=4n=4n=4, however, this reduction breaks down: the genuine multi-entropy is no longer proportional to I3I_3I3​, but remains a topological invariant of the toric-code stabilizer ground states under Kitaev-Preskill-preserving deformations that do not change whether the numbers of vertex- and plaquette-type junctions coincide. For generic non-stabilizer superpositions within the ground-state manifold and for coherent superpositions of local excitations, the low-nnn reduction also fails. These results show that genuine multi-entropy probes multipartite entanglement structure beyond the tripartite information, and hence beyond the topological entanglement entropy in the Kitaev-Preskill partition, whereas for stabilizer states at low replica index it reduces to lower-partite entropic data.
Topological entanglement entropy, which is defined as the conditional mutual information of a state for an annular region in a topologically ordered system, is widely used to detect characteristic topological correlations in topologically ordered phases. We investigate an information-theoretical meaning of the topological entanglement entropy by analyzing a multi-partite correlation measure called irreducible correlation. We prove that the topological entanglement entropy is equivalent to the irreducible correlation if the state has zero-correlation length. We further show that for zero-correlation length states the irreducible correlation is equal to the maximum communication rate of a particular class of secret sharing protocols. Therefore, we provide an operational interpretation of the topological entanglement entropy.
We discuss entanglement entropy of gapped ground states in different dimensions, obtained on partitioning space into two regions. For trivial phases without topological order, we argue that the entanglement entropy may be obtained by integrating an ``entropy density'' over the partition boundary that admits a gradient expansion in the curvature of the boundary. This constrains the expansion of entanglement entropy as a function of system size and points to an even-odd dependence on dimensionality. For example, in contrast to the familiar result in two dimensions, a size-independent constant contribution to the entanglement entropy can appear for trivial phases in any odd spatial dimension. We then discuss phases with topological entanglement entropy (TEE) that cannot be obtained by adding local contributions. We find that in three dimensions there is just one type of TEE, as in two dimensions, that depends linearly on the number of connected components of the boundary (the ``zeroth Betti number''). In D>3D>3D>3 dimensions, new types of TEE appear which depend on the higher Betti numbers of the boundary manifold. We construct generalized toric code models that exhibit these TEEs and discuss ways to extract TEE in $D\ensuremath{\ge}3$.