Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.00394 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Secret Key Agreement via Secure Omniscience

Praneeth Kumar Vippathalla, Chung Chan, Navin Kashyap, Qiaoqiao Zhou

Published Oct 24, 2023• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we explore the connection between secret key agreement and secure omniscience within the setting of the multiterminal source model with an eavesdropper having side information. While the secret key agreement problem considers the generation of a maximum-rate secret key through public discussion, the secure omniscience problem is concerned with communication protocols for omniscience that minimize the rate of information leakage to the eavesdropper. The starting point of our work is a lower bound on the minimum leakage rate for omniscience,$R_{ \text {L}}$, in terms of the wiretap secret key capacity,$C_{ \text {W}}$. Our interest is in identifying broad classes of sources for which this lower bound is met with equality, in which case we say that there is a duality between secure omniscience and secret key agreement. We show that this duality holds in the case of certain finite linear source (FLS) models, such as two-terminal FLS models and pairwise independent network models on trees with a linear eavesdropper. Duality also holds for any FLS model in which$C_{ \text {W}}$is achieved by a perfect linear secret key agreement scheme. We conjecture that the duality in fact holds unconditionally for any FLS model. On the negative side, we give an example of a (non-FLS) source model for which duality does not hold if we limit ourselves to communication-for-omniscience protocols with at most two (interactive) communications. We also address the secure function computation problem and explore the connection between the minimum leakage rate for computing a function and the wiretap secret key capacity.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2023.3327151

Related papers

Secret Key Agreement and Secure Omniscience of Tree-PIN Source with Linear Wiretapper

Praneeth Kumar Vippathalla, Chung Chan, Navin Kashyap +1 more

In this paper, we obtain a single-letter characterization of the wiretap secret key capacity for a large class of multiterminal source models (namely, tree-PIN models) with a linear wiretapper that can observe arbitrary linear combinations of the source. For this class of sources, we also show a duality between the problems of wiretap secret key agreement and secure omniscience, which suggests that such duality potentially holds for more general sources.

arXiv:2102.01771•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jul 12, 2021•5 citations

Secure Information Exchange for Omniscience

Chung Chan, Navin Kashyap, Praneeth Kumar Vippathalla +1 more

We consider the problem of exchanging sensitive information in public and provide a general formulation that can unify and extend various existing scenarios of information exchange, such as the problems of private information extraction and information bottleneck. The formulation also gives rise to a new scenario called secure omniscience (SO), where users want to exchange all their private information with minimum leakage to a wiretapper with side information. Single-letter lower and upper bounds are obtained for the minimum leakage, and the bounds are shown to be tight under the finite linear source model with two users. The bounds are derived in terms of the solutions of the closely related problems of communication for omniscience (CO) and secret key agreement (SKA). However, we find examples where the bounds are not tight, and so the connections to CO and SKA are not precise. In particular, it is possible that any optimal CO scheme that minimizes communication does not minimize leakage, and any optimal SO scheme that minimizes leakage does not attain the capacity for SKA. Nevertheless, we identify a useful notion of information alignment that can modify an optimal CO scheme to reduce leakage for SO.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2020•2 citations

Secret Key Generation in the Multiterminal Source Model : Communication and Other Aspects

Manuj Mukherjee

This dissertation is primarily concerned with the communication required to achieve secret key (SK) capacity in a multiterminal source model. The multiterminal source model introduced by Csiszar and Narayan consists of a group of remotely located terminals with access to correlated sources and a noiseless public channel. The terminals wish to secure their communication by agreeing upon a group secret key. The key agreement protocol involves communicating over the public channel, and agreeing upon an SK secured from eavesdroppers listening to the public communication. The SK capacity, i.e., the maximum rate of an SK that can be agreed upon by the terminals, has been characterized by Csiszar and Narayan. Their capacity-achieving key generation protocol involved terminals communicating to attain omniscience, i.e., every terminal gets to recover the sources of the other terminals. While this is a very general protocol, it often requires larger rates of public communication than is necessary to achieve SK capacity. The primary focus of this dissertation is to characterize the communication complexity, i.e., the minimum rate of public discussion needed to achieve SK capacity. A lower bound to communication complexity is derived for a general multiterminal source, although it turns out to be loose in general. While the minimum rate of communication for omniscience is always an upper bound to the communication complexity, we derive tighter upper bounds to communication complexity for a special class of multiterminal sources, namely, the hypergraphical sources. This upper bound yield a complete characterization of hypergraphical sources where communication for omniscience is a rate-optimal protocol for SK generation, i.e., the communication complexity equals the minimum rate of communication for omniscience. Another aspect of the public communication touched upon by this dissertation is the necessity of omnivocality, i.e., all terminals communicating, to achieve the SK capacity. It is well known that in two-terminal sources, only one terminal communicating success to generate a maximum rate secret key. However, we are able to show that for three or more terminals, omnivocality is indeed required to achieve SK capacity if a certain condition is met. For the specific case of three terminals, we show that this condition is also necessary to ensure omnivocality is essential in generating a SK of maximal rate. However, this condition is no longer necessary when there are four or more terminals. A certain notion of common information, namely, the Wyner common information, plays a central role in the communication complexity problem. This dissertation thus includes a study of multiparty versions of the two widely used notions of common information, namely, Wyner common information and Gacs-Korner (GK) common information. While evaluating these quantities is difficult in general, we are able to derive explicit expressions for both types of common information in the case of hypergraphical sources. We also study fault-tolerant SK…

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

On the Optimality of Secret Key Agreement via Omniscience

Chung Chan, Manuj Mukherjee, Navin Kashyap +1 more

For the multiterminal secret key agreement problem under a private source model, it is known that the maximum key rate, i.e., the secrecy capacity, can be achieved through communication for omniscience, but the omniscience strategy can be strictly suboptimal in terms of minimizing the public discussion rate. While a single-letter characterization is not known for the minimum discussion rate needed for achieving the secrecy capacity, we derive single-letter lower bounds that yield some simple conditions for omniscience to be discussion-rate optimal. These conditions turn out to be enough to deduce the optimality of omniscience for a large class of sources, including the hypergraphical sources. We also extend our results to more general class of multiterminal sources with helpers and silent users.

arXiv:1702.07429•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Feb 5, 2018•21 citations

Perfect secrecy, perfect omniscience and steiner tree packing

Sirin Nitinawarat, Alexander Barg, Prakash Narayan +2 more

We investigate perfect secret key generation for a ¿pairwise independent network¿ model in which every pair of terminals observes correlated sources that are independent of sources observed by all other pairs of terminals. The terminals are then allowed to communicate interactively in multiple rounds over a public noiseless channel of unlimited capacity. This communication is observed by all the terminals as well as by an eavesdropper. The objective is to generate a perfect secret key shared by a given set of terminals at the largest rate possible. All the terminals cooperate in generating the secret key, with perfect secrecy being required from the eavesdropper. For this model, we introduce the concept of communication for perfect omniscience using which we first obtain a single-letter characterization of the perfect secret key capacity. Moreover, this perfect secret key capacity is shown to be achieved by linear noninteractive communication, and coincides with the (standard) secret key capacity. Our second contribution, exploiting the notion of communication for perfect omniscience, is a new nonasymptotic and computable upper bound for the combinatorial problem of maximal Steiner tree packing in a multigraph. Thus, our work establishes certain connections among perfect secrecy generation and communication for perfect omniscience for the pairwise independent network model, and Steiner tree packing.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2009•4 citations

One-Shot Perfect Secret Key Agreement for Finite Linear Sources

Chung Chan, Navin Kashyap, Praneeth Kumar Vippathalla +1 more

We consider a non-asymptotic (one-shot) version of the multiterminal secret key agreement problem on a finite linear source model. In this model, the observation of each terminal is a linear function of an underlying random vector composed of finitely many i.i.d. uniform random variables. By restricting the public discussion to be a linear function of the terminals' observations, we obtain a characterization of the communication complexity (minimum number of symbols of public discussion) of generating a secret key of maximum length. More precisely, we show that the minimum discussion can be achieved by a non-interactive protocol in which each terminal first does a linear processing of its own private observations, following which the terminals all execute a discussion-optimal communication-for-omniscience protocol. The secret key can be chosen to be a linear function of the vector of all observations.

arXiv:1901.05817•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jul 1, 2019•2 citations
In this paper, we explore the connection between secret key agreement and secure omniscience within the setting of the multiterminal source model with an eavesdropper having side information. While the secret key agreement problem considers the generation of a maximum-rate secret key through public discussion, the secure omniscience problem is concerned with communication protocols for omniscience that minimize the rate of information leakage to the eavesdropper. The starting point of our work is a lower bound on the minimum leakage rate for omniscience,RLR_{ \text {L}}RL​, in terms of the wiretap secret key capacity,CWC_{ \text {W}}CW​. Our interest is in identifying broad classes of sources for which this lower bound is met with equality, in which case we say that there is a duality between secure omniscience and secret key agreement. We show that this duality holds in the case of certain finite linear source (FLS) models, such as two-terminal FLS models and pairwise independent network models on trees with a linear eavesdropper. Duality also holds for any FLS model in whichCWC_{ \text {W}}CW​is achieved by a perfect linear secret key agreement scheme. We conjecture that the duality in fact holds unconditionally for any FLS model. On the negative side, we give an example of a (non-FLS) source model for which duality does not hold if we limit ourselves to communication-for-omniscience protocols with at most two (interactive) communications. We also address the secure function computation problem and explore the connection between the minimum leakage rate for computing a function and the wiretap secret key capacity.
We consider the problem of exchanging sensitive information in public and provide a general formulation that can unify and extend various existing scenarios of information exchange, such as the problems of private information extraction and information bottleneck. The formulation also gives rise to a new scenario called secure omniscience (SO), where users want to exchange all their private information with minimum leakage to a wiretapper with side information. Single-letter lower and upper bounds are obtained for the minimum leakage, and the bounds are shown to be tight under the finite linear source model with two users. The bounds are derived in terms of the solutions of the closely related problems of communication for omniscience (CO) and secret key agreement (SKA). However, we find examples where the bounds are not tight, and so the connections to CO and SKA are not precise. In particular, it is possible that any optimal CO scheme that minimizes communication does not minimize leakage, and any optimal SO scheme that minimizes leakage does not attain the capacity for SKA. Nevertheless, we identify a useful notion of information alignment that can modify an optimal CO scheme to reduce leakage for SO.
This dissertation is primarily concerned with the communication required to achieve secret key (SK) capacity in a multiterminal source model. The multiterminal source model introduced by Csiszar and Narayan consists of a group of remotely located terminals with access to correlated sources and a noiseless public channel. The terminals wish to secure their communication by agreeing upon a group secret key. The key agreement protocol involves communicating over the public channel, and agreeing upon an SK secured from eavesdroppers listening to the public communication. The SK capacity, i.e., the maximum rate of an SK that can be agreed upon by the terminals, has been characterized by Csiszar and Narayan. Their capacity-achieving key generation protocol involved terminals communicating to attain omniscience, i.e., every terminal gets to recover the sources of the other terminals. While this is a very general protocol, it often requires larger rates of public communication than is necessary to achieve SK capacity. The primary focus of this dissertation is to characterize the communication complexity, i.e., the minimum rate of public discussion needed to achieve SK capacity. A lower bound to communication complexity is derived for a general multiterminal source, although it turns out to be loose in general. While the minimum rate of communication for omniscience is always an upper bound to the communication complexity, we derive tighter upper bounds to communication complexity for a special class of multiterminal sources, namely, the hypergraphical sources. This upper bound yield a complete characterization of hypergraphical sources where communication for omniscience is a rate-optimal protocol for SK generation, i.e., the communication complexity equals the minimum rate of communication for omniscience. Another aspect of the public communication touched upon by this dissertation is the necessity of omnivocality, i.e., all terminals communicating, to achieve the SK capacity. It is well known that in two-terminal sources, only one terminal communicating success to generate a maximum rate secret key. However, we are able to show that for three or more terminals, omnivocality is indeed required to achieve SK capacity if a certain condition is met. For the specific case of three terminals, we show that this condition is also necessary to ensure omnivocality is essential in generating a SK of maximal rate. However, this condition is no longer necessary when there are four or more terminals. A certain notion of common information, namely, the Wyner common information, plays a central role in the communication complexity problem. This dissertation thus includes a study of multiparty versions of the two widely used notions of common information, namely, Wyner common information and Gacs-Korner (GK) common information. While evaluating these quantities is difficult in general, we are able to derive explicit expressions for both types of common information in the case of hypergraphical sources. We also study fault-tolerant SK…
For the multiterminal secret key agreement problem under a private source model, it is known that the maximum key rate, i.e., the secrecy capacity, can be achieved through communication for omniscience, but the omniscience strategy can be strictly suboptimal in terms of minimizing the public discussion rate. While a single-letter characterization is not known for the minimum discussion rate needed for achieving the secrecy capacity, we derive single-letter lower bounds that yield some simple conditions for omniscience to be discussion-rate optimal. These conditions turn out to be enough to deduce the optimality of omniscience for a large class of sources, including the hypergraphical sources. We also extend our results to more general class of multiterminal sources with helpers and silent users.
We investigate perfect secret key generation for a ¿pairwise independent network¿ model in which every pair of terminals observes correlated sources that are independent of sources observed by all other pairs of terminals. The terminals are then allowed to communicate interactively in multiple rounds over a public noiseless channel of unlimited capacity. This communication is observed by all the terminals as well as by an eavesdropper. The objective is to generate a perfect secret key shared by a given set of terminals at the largest rate possible. All the terminals cooperate in generating the secret key, with perfect secrecy being required from the eavesdropper. For this model, we introduce the concept of communication for perfect omniscience using which we first obtain a single-letter characterization of the perfect secret key capacity. Moreover, this perfect secret key capacity is shown to be achieved by linear noninteractive communication, and coincides with the (standard) secret key capacity. Our second contribution, exploiting the notion of communication for perfect omniscience, is a new nonasymptotic and computable upper bound for the combinatorial problem of maximal Steiner tree packing in a multigraph. Thus, our work establishes certain connections among perfect secrecy generation and communication for perfect omniscience for the pairwise independent network model, and Steiner tree packing.
We consider a non-asymptotic (one-shot) version of the multiterminal secret key agreement problem on a finite linear source model. In this model, the observation of each terminal is a linear function of an underlying random vector composed of finitely many i.i.d. uniform random variables. By restricting the public discussion to be a linear function of the terminals' observations, we obtain a characterization of the communication complexity (minimum number of symbols of public discussion) of generating a secret key of maximum length. More precisely, we show that the minimum discussion can be achieved by a non-interactive protocol in which each terminal first does a linear processing of its own private observations, following which the terminals all execute a discussion-optimal communication-for-omniscience protocol. The secret key can be chosen to be a linear function of the vector of all observations.