Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2111.07768 · Physical Review Letters

Can Angular Oscillations Probe Superfluidity in Dipolar Supersolids?

Matthew A. Norcia, Elena Poli, Claudia Politi, Lauritz Klaus, Thomas Bland, Manfred J. Mark, Luis Santos, R. N. Bisset, Francesca Ferlaino

Published Jul 22, 2022• 43 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Angular oscillations can provide a useful probe of the superfluid properties of a system. Such measurements have recently been applied to dipolar supersolids, which exhibit both density modulation and phase coherence, and for which robust probes of superfluidity are particularly interesting. So far, these investigations have been confined to linear droplet arrays, which feature relatively simple excitation spectra, but limited sensitivity to the effects of superfluidity. Here, we explore angular oscillations in systems with 2D structure which, in principle, have greater sensitivity to superfluidity. In both experiment and simulation, we find that the interplay of superfluid and crystalline excitations leads to a frequency of angular oscillations that remains nearly unchanged even when the superfluidity of the system is altered dramatically. This indicates that angular oscillation measurements do not always provide a robust experimental probe of superfluidity with typical experimental protocols.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.129.040403

Related papers

Dipole-mode and scissors-mode oscillations of a dipolar supersolid

Luis E. Young-S., Sadhan K. Adhikari

We study dipole-mode and scissors-mode oscillations of a harmonically trapped dipolar supersolid, composed of dipolar droplets arranged on a one-dimensional (1D) or a 2D lattice, to establish the robustness of its crystalline structure under translation and rotation, using a beyond-mean-field model including a Lee-Huang-Yang interaction. The dipolar atoms are polarized in the $z$ direction with the supersolid crystalline structure lying in the $x\text{\ensuremath{-}}y$ plane. A stable dipole-mode oscillation is possible in the case of both quasi-1D and quasi-2D dipolar supersolids, whereas a sustained angular scissors-mode oscillation is possible only in the case of a quasi-1D dipolar supersolid between a maximum and a minimum of trap anisotropy in the $x\text{\ensuremath{-}}y$ plane. In both cases there is no visible deformation of the crystalline structure of the dipolar supersolid during the oscillation. The theoretical estimate of the scissors-mode-oscillation frequency is in good agreement with the present results and the agreement improves with an increase in the number of droplets in the supersolid and also with an increase in the confining trap frequencies. The results of this study can be tested experimentally with present knowhow.

arXiv:2305.06265•Physical Review A•May 30, 2023•4 citations

Superfluid properties of a honeycomb dipolar supersolid

Albert Gallemí, Luis Santos

Recent breakthrough experiments on dipolar condensates have reported the creation of supersolids, including two-dimensional arrays of quantum droplets. Droplet arrays are, however, not the only possible nontrivial density arrangement resulting from the interplay of mean-field instability and quantum stabilization. Several other possible density patterns may occur in trapped condensates at higher densities, including the so-called honeycomb supersolid, a phase that exists, as it is also the case of a triangular droplet supersolid, in the thermodynamic limit. We show that compared to droplet supersolids, honeycomb supersolids have a much-enhanced superfluid fraction while keeping a large density contrast, and constitute in this sense a much better dipolar supersolid. However, in contrast to droplet supersolids, quantized vortices cannot be created in a honeycomb supersolid without driving a transition into a so-called labyrinthic phase. We show that the reduced moment of inertia, and with it the superfluid fraction, can be however reliably probed by studying the dynamics following a scissorslike perturbation.

arXiv:2209.10450•Physical Review A•Dec 2, 2022•24 citations

Dynamical signatures of superfluidity and shear rigidity in different phases of a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate

Soumyadeep Halder, H. Ghosh, Axel Pelster +1 more

We show that a sudden change in the polarization direction of the magnetic dipole moments of the atoms in a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) can serve as a useful dynamical probe to sense its superfluid and solid-like properties. We find that for small angular deviation of the polarization direction, actuated for instance by modifying an external magnetic field, the superfluid state undergoes an undamped scissors mode oscillation, a characteristic signature of superfluidity. In contrast, both the droplet and supersolid states exhibit a scissors-mode oscillation, which is effectively damped due to multiple closely spaced frequency components. Notably, we find that this damping rate provides a qualitative measure for the rigidity of different phases of a dipolar BEC. Furthermore, there exists a maximum angular deviation of the polarization direction, beyond which the droplet and the supersolid states undergo a permanent deformation i.e., we find an analog of the usual elastic to plastic phase transition of solids. We characterize this transition numerically using the fidelity of the condensate wavefunction with the ground state as well as the droplet width and periodicity of the supersolid density of the condensate which are experimentally accessible. Thus, the dynamical protocol introduced here can be an important experimental benchmark to identify and characterize the superfluid and solid properties of different phases of dipolar BECs.

arXiv:2512.24108•Physical Review A•Jul 1, 2026•1 citation

Evidence of superfluidity in a dipolar supersolid

Giulio Biagioni

The elusive supersolid, an exotic quantum phase that combines the properties of a crystalline solid and those of a superfluid, has been recently discovered in a system of Bose-condensed strongly magnetic atoms. In this paper, I report on an experiment that directly demonstrates the superfluid behavior of the dipolar supersolid measuring its anomalous response to a rotational excitation. I complement the illustration of the experimental results with a review and an original interpretation of a seminal model due to Leggett.

•Jan 1, 2021•1 citation

Excitation spectrum of a double supersolid in a trapped dipolar Bose mixture

Daniel Scheiermann, Albert Gallemí, Luis Santos

Dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates are excellent platforms for studying supersolidity, characterized by coexisting density modulation and superfluidity. The realization of dipolar mixtures opens intriguing new scenarios, most remarkably the possibility of realizing a double supersolid, composed of two interacting superfluids. We analyze the complex excitation spectrum of a miscible trapped dipolar Bose mixture, showing that it provides key insights about the double-supersolid regime. We show that this regime may be readily probed experimentally by monitoring the appearance of a doublet of superfluid compressional modes, linked to the different superfluid character of each component. Additionally, the dipolar supersolid mixture exhibits a nontrivial spin nature of the dipolar rotons, the Higgs excitation, and the low-lying Goldstone modes. Interestingly, the analysis of the lowest-lying modes allows for monitoring the transition of just one of the components into the incoherent-droplet regime, whereas the other remains coherent, highlighting their disparate superfluid properties.

arXiv:2412.05215•Physical Review A•Mar 13, 2025•4 citations

Transient Supersolid Properties in an Array of Dipolar Quantum Droplets

Fabian Böttcher, Jan-Niklas Schmidt, Matthias Wenzel +4 more

We study theoretically and experimentally the emergence of supersolid properties in a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate.The theory reveals a ground state phase diagram with three distinct regimes-a regular Bose-Einstein condensate and incoherent and coherent arrays of quantum droplets.The coherent droplets are connected by a background condensate, which leads-in addition to the periodic density modulation-to a robust phase coherence throughout the whole system.We further theoretically demonstrate that we are able to dynamically approach the ground state in our experiment and that its lifetime is limited only by three-body losses.Experimentally we probe and confirm the signatures of the phase diagram by observing the in situ density modulation as well as the phase coherence using matter wave interference.

arXiv:1901.07982•Physical Review X•Mar 22, 2019•461 citations
Angular oscillations can provide a useful probe of the superfluid properties of a system. Such measurements have recently been applied to dipolar supersolids, which exhibit both density modulation and phase coherence, and for which robust probes of superfluidity are particularly interesting. So far, these investigations have been confined to linear droplet arrays, which feature relatively simple excitation spectra, but limited sensitivity to the effects of superfluidity. Here, we explore angular oscillations in systems with 2D structure which, in principle, have greater sensitivity to superfluidity. In both experiment and simulation, we find that the interplay of superfluid and crystalline excitations leads to a frequency of angular oscillations that remains nearly unchanged even when the superfluidity of the system is altered dramatically. This indicates that angular oscillation measurements do not always provide a robust experimental probe of superfluidity with typical experimental protocols.
We study dipole-mode and scissors-mode oscillations of a harmonically trapped dipolar supersolid, composed of dipolar droplets arranged on a one-dimensional (1D) or a 2D lattice, to establish the robustness of its crystalline structure under translation and rotation, using a beyond-mean-field model including a Lee-Huang-Yang interaction. The dipolar atoms are polarized in the zzz direction with the supersolid crystalline structure lying in the $x\text{\ensuremath{-}}y$ plane. A stable dipole-mode oscillation is possible in the case of both quasi-1D and quasi-2D dipolar supersolids, whereas a sustained angular scissors-mode oscillation is possible only in the case of a quasi-1D dipolar supersolid between a maximum and a minimum of trap anisotropy in the $x\text{\ensuremath{-}}y$ plane. In both cases there is no visible deformation of the crystalline structure of the dipolar supersolid during the oscillation. The theoretical estimate of the scissors-mode-oscillation frequency is in good agreement with the present results and the agreement improves with an increase in the number of droplets in the supersolid and also with an increase in the confining trap frequencies. The results of this study can be tested experimentally with present knowhow.
Recent breakthrough experiments on dipolar condensates have reported the creation of supersolids, including two-dimensional arrays of quantum droplets. Droplet arrays are, however, not the only possible nontrivial density arrangement resulting from the interplay of mean-field instability and quantum stabilization. Several other possible density patterns may occur in trapped condensates at higher densities, including the so-called honeycomb supersolid, a phase that exists, as it is also the case of a triangular droplet supersolid, in the thermodynamic limit. We show that compared to droplet supersolids, honeycomb supersolids have a much-enhanced superfluid fraction while keeping a large density contrast, and constitute in this sense a much better dipolar supersolid. However, in contrast to droplet supersolids, quantized vortices cannot be created in a honeycomb supersolid without driving a transition into a so-called labyrinthic phase. We show that the reduced moment of inertia, and with it the superfluid fraction, can be however reliably probed by studying the dynamics following a scissorslike perturbation.
We show that a sudden change in the polarization direction of the magnetic dipole moments of the atoms in a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) can serve as a useful dynamical probe to sense its superfluid and solid-like properties. We find that for small angular deviation of the polarization direction, actuated for instance by modifying an external magnetic field, the superfluid state undergoes an undamped scissors mode oscillation, a characteristic signature of superfluidity. In contrast, both the droplet and supersolid states exhibit a scissors-mode oscillation, which is effectively damped due to multiple closely spaced frequency components. Notably, we find that this damping rate provides a qualitative measure for the rigidity of different phases of a dipolar BEC. Furthermore, there exists a maximum angular deviation of the polarization direction, beyond which the droplet and the supersolid states undergo a permanent deformation i.e., we find an analog of the usual elastic to plastic phase transition of solids. We characterize this transition numerically using the fidelity of the condensate wavefunction with the ground state as well as the droplet width and periodicity of the supersolid density of the condensate which are experimentally accessible. Thus, the dynamical protocol introduced here can be an important experimental benchmark to identify and characterize the superfluid and solid properties of different phases of dipolar BECs.
The elusive supersolid, an exotic quantum phase that combines the properties of a crystalline solid and those of a superfluid, has been recently discovered in a system of Bose-condensed strongly magnetic atoms. In this paper, I report on an experiment that directly demonstrates the superfluid behavior of the dipolar supersolid measuring its anomalous response to a rotational excitation. I complement the illustration of the experimental results with a review and an original interpretation of a seminal model due to Leggett.
Dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates are excellent platforms for studying supersolidity, characterized by coexisting density modulation and superfluidity. The realization of dipolar mixtures opens intriguing new scenarios, most remarkably the possibility of realizing a double supersolid, composed of two interacting superfluids. We analyze the complex excitation spectrum of a miscible trapped dipolar Bose mixture, showing that it provides key insights about the double-supersolid regime. We show that this regime may be readily probed experimentally by monitoring the appearance of a doublet of superfluid compressional modes, linked to the different superfluid character of each component. Additionally, the dipolar supersolid mixture exhibits a nontrivial spin nature of the dipolar rotons, the Higgs excitation, and the low-lying Goldstone modes. Interestingly, the analysis of the lowest-lying modes allows for monitoring the transition of just one of the components into the incoherent-droplet regime, whereas the other remains coherent, highlighting their disparate superfluid properties.
We study theoretically and experimentally the emergence of supersolid properties in a dipolar Bose-Einstein condensate.The theory reveals a ground state phase diagram with three distinct regimes-a regular Bose-Einstein condensate and incoherent and coherent arrays of quantum droplets.The coherent droplets are connected by a background condensate, which leads-in addition to the periodic density modulation-to a robust phase coherence throughout the whole system.We further theoretically demonstrate that we are able to dynamically approach the ground state in our experiment and that its lifetime is limited only by three-body losses.Experimentally we probe and confirm the signatures of the phase diagram by observing the in situ density modulation as well as the phase coherence using matter wave interference.