Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.09483

Evaluating NISQ Devices with Quadratic Nonresidues

Thomas G. Draper

Published Oct 18, 2021• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a new method for evaluating NISQ devices. This paper has three distinct parts. First, we present a new quantum algorithm that solves a two hundred year old problem of finding quadratic nonresidues (QNR) in polynomial time. We show that QNR is in Exact Quantum Polynomial time, while it is still unknown whether QNR is in P. Second, we present a challenge to create a probability distribution over the quadratic nonresidues. Due to the theoretical complexity gap, a quantum computer can achieve a higher success rate than any known method on a classical computer. A device beating the classical bound indicates quantum advantage or a mathematical breakthrough. Third, we derive a simple circuit for the smallest instance of the quadratic nonresidue test and run it on a variety of currently available NISQ devices. We then present a comparative statistical evaluation of the NISQ devices tested.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2110.09483

Related papers

Quantum Computers Can Find Quadratic Nonresidues in Deterministic Polynomial Time

Thomas G. Draper

An integer $a$ is a quadratic nonresidue for a prime $p$ if $x^2 \equiv a \bmod p$ has no solution. Quadratic nonresidues may be found by probabilistic methods in polynomial time. However, without assuming the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, no deterministic polynomial-time algorithm is known. We present a quantum algorithm which generates a random quadratic nonresidue in deterministic polynomial time.

arXiv:2106.03991•Jun 7, 2021•1 citation

The complexity of NISQ

Sitan Chen, Jordan S. Cotler, Hsin-Yuan Huang +1 more

The recent proliferation of NISQ devices has made it imperative to understand their power. In this work, we define and study the complexity class NISQ, which encapsulates problems that can be efficiently solved by a classical computer with access to noisy quantum circuits. We establish super-polynomial separations in the complexity among classical computation, NISQ, and fault-tolerant quantum computation to solve some problems based on modifications of Simon's problems. We then consider the power of NISQ for three well-studied problems. For unstructured search, we prove that NISQ cannot achieve a Grover-like quadratic speedup over classical computers. For the Bernstein-Vazirani problem, we show that NISQ only needs a number of queries logarithmic in what is required for classical computers. Finally, for a quantum state learning problem, we prove that NISQ is exponentially weaker than classical computers with access to noiseless constant-depth quantum circuits.

arXiv:2210.07234•Nature Communications•Sep 26, 2023•151 citations

CutQC: using small Quantum computers for large Quantum circuit evaluations

Wei Tang, Teague Tomesh, Martin Suchara +2 more

Quantum computing (QC) is a new paradigm offering the potential of exponential speedups over classical computing for certain computational problems. Each additional qubit doubles the size of the computational state space available to a QC algorithm. This exponential scaling underlies QC’s power, but today’s Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices face significant engineering challenges in scalability. The set of quantum circuits that can be reliably run on NISQ devices is limited by their noisy operations and low qubit counts. This paper introduces CutQC, a scalable hybrid computing approach that combines classical computers and quantum computers to enable evaluation of quantum circuits that cannot be run on classical or quantum computers alone. CutQC cuts large quantum circuits into smaller subcircuits, allowing them to be executed on smaller quantum devices. Classical postprocessing can then reconstruct the output of the original circuit. This approach offers significant runtime speedup compared with the only viable current alternative—purely classical simulations—and demonstrates evaluation of quantum circuits that are larger than the limit of QC or classical simulation. Furthermore, in real-system runs, CutQC achieves much higher quantum circuit evaluation fidelity using small prototype quantum computers than the state-of-the-art large NISQ devices achieve. Overall, this hybrid approach allows users to leverage classical and quantum computing resources to evaluate quantum programs far beyond the reach of either one alone.

arXiv:2012.02333•International Conference on Architectural Support for Programming Languages and Operating Systems (ASPLOS)•Apr 11, 2021•220 citations

Perspectives on Quantum Sensing and Computation for Particle Physics

Alba Cervera-Lierta

<!--HTML-->A universal fault-tolerant quantum computer that can solve efficiently problems such as integer factorization and unstructured database search requires millions of qubits with low error rates and long coherence times. While the experimental advancement towards realizing such devices will potentially take decades of research, noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers already exist. These computers are composed of hundreds of noisy qubits, i.e. qubits that are not error-corrected, and therefore perform imperfect operations in a limited coherence time. In the search for quantum advantage with these devices, algorithms have been proposed for applications in various disciplines spanning physics, machine learning, quantum chemistry and combinatorial optimization. The goal of such algorithms is to leverage the limited available resources to perform classically challenging tasks. In this talk, I provide an overview of NISQ algorithms, their limitations and potential advantages.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Variational Quantum Algorithms for Solving Vehicle Routing Problem

Muhammad Alsaiyari, Muhamad Felemban

Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is considered one of the most challenging problems with application in several domains, including transportation and logistics distribution. VRP is known to be NP-Hard problem. Several algorithms have been proposed to solve VRP in polynomial time. However, these algorithms are inefficient if the VRP instance increases. Recently, researchers investigated how quantum computing can be used to solve VRP. In particular, two promising variational quantum algorithms have been studied, i.e., Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA). In this paper, we implement both algorithms on IBM Qiskit and compare their evaluation in solving several instances of VRP. We observe that current Noisy-Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices cannot solve VRP instances beyond 5 nodes and 2 vehicles. Furthermore, we observe that classical optimizers still provide better results. However, we believe that with the rapid advancement of quantum computing manufacturing, VQE and QAOA can provide better performance as compared to classical computing,

International Conference on Smart Computing and Application (ICSCA)•Feb 5, 2023•10 citations

NP-hard but no longer hard to solve? Using quantum computing to tackle optimization problems

Rhonda Au-Yeung, Nicholas Chancellor, Pascal Halffmann

In the last decade, public and industrial research funding has moved quantum computing from the early promises of Shor’s algorithm through experiments to the era of noisy intermediate scale quantum devices (NISQ) for solving real-world problems. It is likely that quantum methods can efficiently solve certain (NP-) hard optimization problems where classical approaches fail. In our perspective, we examine the field of quantum optimization, that is, solving optimization problems using quantum computers. We provide an entry point to quantum optimization for researchers from each topic, optimization or quantum computing, by demonstrating advances and obstacles with a suitable use case. We give an overview on problem formulation, available algorithms, and benchmarking. Although we show a proof-of-concept rather than a full benchmark between classical and quantum methods, this gives an idea of the current quality and capabilities of quantum computers for optimization problems. All observations are incorporated in a discussion on some recent quantum optimization breakthroughs, current status, and future directions.

arXiv:2212.10990•Frontiers in Quantum Science and Technology•Feb 23, 2023•60 citations
We propose a new method for evaluating NISQ devices. This paper has three distinct parts. First, we present a new quantum algorithm that solves a two hundred year old problem of finding quadratic nonresidues (QNR) in polynomial time. We show that QNR is in Exact Quantum Polynomial time, while it is still unknown whether QNR is in P. Second, we present a challenge to create a probability distribution over the quadratic nonresidues. Due to the theoretical complexity gap, a quantum computer can achieve a higher success rate than any known method on a classical computer. A device beating the classical bound indicates quantum advantage or a mathematical breakthrough. Third, we derive a simple circuit for the smallest instance of the quadratic nonresidue test and run it on a variety of currently available NISQ devices. We then present a comparative statistical evaluation of the NISQ devices tested.
An integer aaa is a quadratic nonresidue for a prime ppp if x2≡a mod px^2 \equiv a \bmod px2≡amodp has no solution. Quadratic nonresidues may be found by probabilistic methods in polynomial time. However, without assuming the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, no deterministic polynomial-time algorithm is known. We present a quantum algorithm which generates a random quadratic nonresidue in deterministic polynomial time.
The recent proliferation of NISQ devices has made it imperative to understand their power. In this work, we define and study the complexity class NISQ, which encapsulates problems that can be efficiently solved by a classical computer with access to noisy quantum circuits. We establish super-polynomial separations in the complexity among classical computation, NISQ, and fault-tolerant quantum computation to solve some problems based on modifications of Simon's problems. We then consider the power of NISQ for three well-studied problems. For unstructured search, we prove that NISQ cannot achieve a Grover-like quadratic speedup over classical computers. For the Bernstein-Vazirani problem, we show that NISQ only needs a number of queries logarithmic in what is required for classical computers. Finally, for a quantum state learning problem, we prove that NISQ is exponentially weaker than classical computers with access to noiseless constant-depth quantum circuits.
Quantum computing (QC) is a new paradigm offering the potential of exponential speedups over classical computing for certain computational problems. Each additional qubit doubles the size of the computational state space available to a QC algorithm. This exponential scaling underlies QC’s power, but today’s Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices face significant engineering challenges in scalability. The set of quantum circuits that can be reliably run on NISQ devices is limited by their noisy operations and low qubit counts. This paper introduces CutQC, a scalable hybrid computing approach that combines classical computers and quantum computers to enable evaluation of quantum circuits that cannot be run on classical or quantum computers alone. CutQC cuts large quantum circuits into smaller subcircuits, allowing them to be executed on smaller quantum devices. Classical postprocessing can then reconstruct the output of the original circuit. This approach offers significant runtime speedup compared with the only viable current alternative—purely classical simulations—and demonstrates evaluation of quantum circuits that are larger than the limit of QC or classical simulation. Furthermore, in real-system runs, CutQC achieves much higher quantum circuit evaluation fidelity using small prototype quantum computers than the state-of-the-art large NISQ devices achieve. Overall, this hybrid approach allows users to leverage classical and quantum computing resources to evaluate quantum programs far beyond the reach of either one alone.
<!--HTML-->A universal fault-tolerant quantum computer that can solve efficiently problems such as integer factorization and unstructured database search requires millions of qubits with low error rates and long coherence times. While the experimental advancement towards realizing such devices will potentially take decades of research, noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers already exist. These computers are composed of hundreds of noisy qubits, i.e. qubits that are not error-corrected, and therefore perform imperfect operations in a limited coherence time. In the search for quantum advantage with these devices, algorithms have been proposed for applications in various disciplines spanning physics, machine learning, quantum chemistry and combinatorial optimization. The goal of such algorithms is to leverage the limited available resources to perform classically challenging tasks. In this talk, I provide an overview of NISQ algorithms, their limitations and potential advantages.
Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is considered one of the most challenging problems with application in several domains, including transportation and logistics distribution. VRP is known to be NP-Hard problem. Several algorithms have been proposed to solve VRP in polynomial time. However, these algorithms are inefficient if the VRP instance increases. Recently, researchers investigated how quantum computing can be used to solve VRP. In particular, two promising variational quantum algorithms have been studied, i.e., Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA). In this paper, we implement both algorithms on IBM Qiskit and compare their evaluation in solving several instances of VRP. We observe that current Noisy-Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices cannot solve VRP instances beyond 5 nodes and 2 vehicles. Furthermore, we observe that classical optimizers still provide better results. However, we believe that with the rapid advancement of quantum computing manufacturing, VQE and QAOA can provide better performance as compared to classical computing,
In the last decade, public and industrial research funding has moved quantum computing from the early promises of Shor’s algorithm through experiments to the era of noisy intermediate scale quantum devices (NISQ) for solving real-world problems. It is likely that quantum methods can efficiently solve certain (NP-) hard optimization problems where classical approaches fail. In our perspective, we examine the field of quantum optimization, that is, solving optimization problems using quantum computers. We provide an entry point to quantum optimization for researchers from each topic, optimization or quantum computing, by demonstrating advances and obstacles with a suitable use case. We give an overview on problem formulation, available algorithms, and benchmarking. Although we show a proof-of-concept rather than a full benchmark between classical and quantum methods, this gives an idea of the current quality and capabilities of quantum computers for optimization problems. All observations are incorporated in a discussion on some recent quantum optimization breakthroughs, current status, and future directions.