Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.06189 · Annalen der Physik

Non‐Uniqueness of Driving Fields Generating Non‐Linear Optical Response

Gerard McCaul, Alexander F. King, Denys I. Bondar

Published Aug 4, 2022• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In recent years, non‐linear optical phenomena have attracted much attention, with a particular focus on the engineering and exploitation of non‐linear responses. Comparatively little study has, however, been devoted to the driving fields that generate these responses. This work demonstrates that the relationship between a driving field and the optical response it induces is non‐unique. Using a generic model for a strongly interacting system, it is shown that multiple candidate driving field exists, which will all generate the same response. Consequently, it is possible to show that the optical response is not sufficient to determine the internal dynamics of the system, and that different solutions for the driving field will do different amounts of work on a system. Physically, the work done indicates the energy absorbed by the system from the field and will therefore correspond to modifying the absorption spectrum of the material. This non‐uniqueness phenomenon may be further utilized to engineer thermodynamically efficient system states without modifying its optical response.

DOI
10.1002/andp.202100523

Related papers

Designing media for the local control of nanoscale absorption, transmission, and energy transfer

Jamie M. Leeder, Matt M. Coles, Jack Ford +1 more

Interactions between light and molecular matter featuring photon absorption are commonly associated with excitation of individual chromophores. Subsequent relaxation is achieved through numerous mechanisms, such as scattering and energy transfer to neighbouring chromophores. The efficiency of such processes depends on many factors, including the intensity and wavelength of the optical input, the absorption cross-section of the molecule and the relative orientation of molecular components. New photonic materials are developed on the principle that such factors are controllable, duly tailoring the system to suit new technological applications. The parameters that determine the linear response in multicomponent materials are typically assessed within the theoretical framework of classical optics. However, with improved interest and capability in fabricating nanoscale structures (especially those that exhibit quantum effects), it is becoming increasingly relevant to develop theory that more faithfully represents how individual photons engage with matter. In such constructs, the interaction of materials with optical waves and photons is highly dependent on local molecular environment, therefore surrounding structures and ancillary species exert forms of influence on the photophysical processes inherent within dielectric media. At optical wavelengths where the secondary structure displays little intrinsic optical absorption, the role of such components is often interpreted as modifying the input through a corrective local index of refraction. Although expedient in the discussion of bulk properties of a macroscopic medium, it is reasonably supposed at a local chromophore-photon level that optical mechanisms operate in a different fashion. Using a fully quantized approach to the representation of local molecular electronic structure and electrodynamics, this research develops rigorous theory and a corresponding physical interpretation of how photon absorption, scattering and energy transfer are modified by vicinal, non-absorbing chromophores. The results provide insight into the mechanisms achieved within multi-chromophore systems, highlighting factors that assist in the optimization of optical characteristics in designer materials.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 2, 2014•0 citations

Engaging new dimensions in nonlinear optical spectroscopy using auxiliary beams of light

Jack Ford, David S. Bradshaw, Davıd L. Andrews

By applying a sufficiently intense beam of off-resonant light, simultaneously with a conventional excitation source beam, the efficiencies of one- and two-photon absorption processes may be significantly modified. The nonlinear mechanism that is responsible, known as laser modified absorption, is fully described by a quantum electrodynamical analysis. The origin of the process, which involves stimulated forward Rayleigh-scattering of the auxiliary beam, relates to higher order terms which are secured by a time-dependent perturbation treatment. These terms, usually inconsequential when a single beam of light is present, become prominent under the secondary optical stimulus – even with levels of intensity that are moderate by today’s standards. Distinctive kinds of behaviour may be observed for chromophores fixed in a static arrangement, or for solution- or gas-phase molecules whose response is tempered by a rotational average of orientations. In each case the results exhibit an interplay of factors involving the beam polarisations and the molecular electronic response. Special attention is given to interesting metastable states that are symmetry forbidden by one- or two-photon absorption. Such states may be accessible, and thus become populated, on input of the auxiliary beam. For example, in the one-photon absorption case, terms arise that are more usually associated with three-photon processes, corresponding to very different selection rules. Other kinds of metastable state also arise in the two-photon process, and measuring the effect of applying the stimulus beam to absorbances of such character adds a new dimension to the information content of the associated spectroscopy. Finally, based on these novel forms of optical nonlinearity, there may be new possibilities for quantum non-demolition measurements.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 1, 2014•0 citations

How to Make Distinct Dynamical Systems Appear Spectrally Identical

Andre G. Campos, Denys I. Bondar, Renán Cabrera +1 more

We show that a laser pulse can always be found that induces a desired optical response from an arbitrary dynamical system. As illustrations, driving fields are computed to induce the same optical response from a variety of distinct systems (open and closed, quantum and classical). As a result, the observed induced dipolar spectra without detailed information on the driving field are not sufficient to characterize atomic and molecular systems. The formulation may also be applied to design materials with specified optical characteristics. These findings reveal unexplored flexibilities of nonlinear optics.

arXiv:1611.02699•Physical Review Letters•Feb 24, 2017•28 citations

Non-Equilibrium Phenomena in Strongly Correlated Systems

Giacomo Mazza

Correlated systems are a wide class of materials in which the strong electron-electron repulsion is the origin of very fascinating and unusual properties, among which metal-to-insulator transitions and high temperature superconductivity are the most striking examples. In the recent years, the fast development of non-adiabatic probing techniques opened new interesting perspectives for the investigation of such materials in non-equilibrium conditions. In this thesis, we discuss the theoretical description of few relevant cases which represent different examples of non-equilibrium phenomena in correlated materials. In particular, we will focus on the dynamics following a sudden excitation and the coupling to an external driving field. As a first example we consider the dynamics across a phase transition, namely we explore the possibility of driving a phase transition as the result of a sudden excitation, as e.g. the coupling with a short light pulse. We consider systems showing different equilibrium phases and study the conditions under which the off-equilibrium dynamics may lead to non-trivial dynamical phase transitions. A different case is represented by the dynamics induced by a driving electric field. This problem is particularly relevant for the possible applications of correlated materials in electronic devices. Here we consider the paradigmatic case of a correlated material coupled to external sources which impose a finite bias across the system. We analyze the formation and the properties of the non-equilibrium stationary states in which a finite current flows through the system. This allows us to study the non-linear response properties of a correlated system. In this context, a particularly relevant aspect is the problem of the dielectric breakdown of a Mott insulator, namely the formation of conducting states in the Mott insulating phase. In this thesis we explore different mechanisms leading to such possibility. First we discuss a quantum tunneling mechanism of carriers driven across the insulating gap by the effect of strong electric-fields. Eventually, we discuss the possibility of a resistive transition from an insulating to a metallic state induced by the application of an external electric-field.

•Sep 21, 2015•0 citations

Travelling Wave Bistability

J. A. Goldstone, E. Garmire

In the majority of optically bistable systems discussed to date, the bistability results from nonuniqueness in the boundary conditions coupled with a unique wave equation. We describe here optical bistability which occurs with unique boundary conditions but a non-unique wave equation, due to bistability in the susceptibility tensor.

Topical Meeting on Optical Bistability (OB)•Jan 1, 1983•0 citations

Linear response as a singular limit for a periodically driven closed quantum system

Angelo Russomanno, Alessandro Silva, Giuseppe E. Santoro

We address the issue of the validity of linear response theory for a closed quantum system subject to a periodic external driving. Linear response theory (LRT) predicts energy absorption at frequencies of the external driving where the imaginary part of the appropriate response function is different from zero. Here we show that, for a fairly general nonlinear many-body system on a lattice subject to an extensive perturbation, this approximation should be expected to be valid only up to a time t * depending on the strength of the driving, beyond which the true coherent Schrödinger evolution departs from the linear response prediction and the system stops absorbing energy from the driving. We exemplify this phenomenon in detail with the example of a quantum Ising chain subject to a time-periodic modulation of the transverse field, by comparing an exact Floquet analysis with the standard results of LRT. In this context, we also show that if the perturbation is just local, the system is expected in the thermodynamic limit to keep absorbing energy, and LRT works at all times. We finally argue more generally the validity of the scenario presented for closed quantum many-body lattice systems with a bound on the energy-per-site spectrum, discussing the experimental relevance of our findings in the context of cold atoms in optical lattices and ultra-fast spectroscopy experiments.

arXiv:1306.2805•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Sep 13, 2013•33 citations
Abstract In recent years, non‐linear optical phenomena have attracted much attention, with a particular focus on the engineering and exploitation of non‐linear responses. Comparatively little study has, however, been devoted to the driving fields that generate these responses. This work demonstrates that the relationship between a driving field and the optical response it induces is non‐unique. Using a generic model for a strongly interacting system, it is shown that multiple candidate driving field exists, which will all generate the same response. Consequently, it is possible to show that the optical response is not sufficient to determine the internal dynamics of the system, and that different solutions for the driving field will do different amounts of work on a system. Physically, the work done indicates the energy absorbed by the system from the field and will therefore correspond to modifying the absorption spectrum of the material. This non‐uniqueness phenomenon may be further utilized to engineer thermodynamically efficient system states without modifying its optical response.
Interactions between light and molecular matter featuring photon absorption are commonly associated with excitation of individual chromophores. Subsequent relaxation is achieved through numerous mechanisms, such as scattering and energy transfer to neighbouring chromophores. The efficiency of such processes depends on many factors, including the intensity and wavelength of the optical input, the absorption cross-section of the molecule and the relative orientation of molecular components. New photonic materials are developed on the principle that such factors are controllable, duly tailoring the system to suit new technological applications. The parameters that determine the linear response in multicomponent materials are typically assessed within the theoretical framework of classical optics. However, with improved interest and capability in fabricating nanoscale structures (especially those that exhibit quantum effects), it is becoming increasingly relevant to develop theory that more faithfully represents how individual photons engage with matter. In such constructs, the interaction of materials with optical waves and photons is highly dependent on local molecular environment, therefore surrounding structures and ancillary species exert forms of influence on the photophysical processes inherent within dielectric media. At optical wavelengths where the secondary structure displays little intrinsic optical absorption, the role of such components is often interpreted as modifying the input through a corrective local index of refraction. Although expedient in the discussion of bulk properties of a macroscopic medium, it is reasonably supposed at a local chromophore-photon level that optical mechanisms operate in a different fashion. Using a fully quantized approach to the representation of local molecular electronic structure and electrodynamics, this research develops rigorous theory and a corresponding physical interpretation of how photon absorption, scattering and energy transfer are modified by vicinal, non-absorbing chromophores. The results provide insight into the mechanisms achieved within multi-chromophore systems, highlighting factors that assist in the optimization of optical characteristics in designer materials.
By applying a sufficiently intense beam of off-resonant light, simultaneously with a conventional excitation source beam, the efficiencies of one- and two-photon absorption processes may be significantly modified. The nonlinear mechanism that is responsible, known as laser modified absorption, is fully described by a quantum electrodynamical analysis. The origin of the process, which involves stimulated forward Rayleigh-scattering of the auxiliary beam, relates to higher order terms which are secured by a time-dependent perturbation treatment. These terms, usually inconsequential when a single beam of light is present, become prominent under the secondary optical stimulus – even with levels of intensity that are moderate by today’s standards. Distinctive kinds of behaviour may be observed for chromophores fixed in a static arrangement, or for solution- or gas-phase molecules whose response is tempered by a rotational average of orientations. In each case the results exhibit an interplay of factors involving the beam polarisations and the molecular electronic response. Special attention is given to interesting metastable states that are symmetry forbidden by one- or two-photon absorption. Such states may be accessible, and thus become populated, on input of the auxiliary beam. For example, in the one-photon absorption case, terms arise that are more usually associated with three-photon processes, corresponding to very different selection rules. Other kinds of metastable state also arise in the two-photon process, and measuring the effect of applying the stimulus beam to absorbances of such character adds a new dimension to the information content of the associated spectroscopy. Finally, based on these novel forms of optical nonlinearity, there may be new possibilities for quantum non-demolition measurements.
We show that a laser pulse can always be found that induces a desired optical response from an arbitrary dynamical system. As illustrations, driving fields are computed to induce the same optical response from a variety of distinct systems (open and closed, quantum and classical). As a result, the observed induced dipolar spectra without detailed information on the driving field are not sufficient to characterize atomic and molecular systems. The formulation may also be applied to design materials with specified optical characteristics. These findings reveal unexplored flexibilities of nonlinear optics.
Correlated systems are a wide class of materials in which the strong electron-electron repulsion is the origin of very fascinating and unusual properties, among which metal-to-insulator transitions and high temperature superconductivity are the most striking examples. In the recent years, the fast development of non-adiabatic probing techniques opened new interesting perspectives for the investigation of such materials in non-equilibrium conditions. In this thesis, we discuss the theoretical description of few relevant cases which represent different examples of non-equilibrium phenomena in correlated materials. In particular, we will focus on the dynamics following a sudden excitation and the coupling to an external driving field. As a first example we consider the dynamics across a phase transition, namely we explore the possibility of driving a phase transition as the result of a sudden excitation, as e.g. the coupling with a short light pulse. We consider systems showing different equilibrium phases and study the conditions under which the off-equilibrium dynamics may lead to non-trivial dynamical phase transitions. A different case is represented by the dynamics induced by a driving electric field. This problem is particularly relevant for the possible applications of correlated materials in electronic devices. Here we consider the paradigmatic case of a correlated material coupled to external sources which impose a finite bias across the system. We analyze the formation and the properties of the non-equilibrium stationary states in which a finite current flows through the system. This allows us to study the non-linear response properties of a correlated system. In this context, a particularly relevant aspect is the problem of the dielectric breakdown of a Mott insulator, namely the formation of conducting states in the Mott insulating phase. In this thesis we explore different mechanisms leading to such possibility. First we discuss a quantum tunneling mechanism of carriers driven across the insulating gap by the effect of strong electric-fields. Eventually, we discuss the possibility of a resistive transition from an insulating to a metallic state induced by the application of an external electric-field.
We address the issue of the validity of linear response theory for a closed quantum system subject to a periodic external driving. Linear response theory (LRT) predicts energy absorption at frequencies of the external driving where the imaginary part of the appropriate response function is different from zero. Here we show that, for a fairly general nonlinear many-body system on a lattice subject to an extensive perturbation, this approximation should be expected to be valid only up to a time t * depending on the strength of the driving, beyond which the true coherent Schrödinger evolution departs from the linear response prediction and the system stops absorbing energy from the driving. We exemplify this phenomenon in detail with the example of a quantum Ising chain subject to a time-periodic modulation of the transverse field, by comparing an exact Floquet analysis with the standard results of LRT. In this context, we also show that if the perturbation is just local, the system is expected in the thermodynamic limit to keep absorbing energy, and LRT works at all times. We finally argue more generally the validity of the scenario presented for closed quantum many-body lattice systems with a bound on the energy-per-site spectrum, discussing the experimental relevance of our findings in the context of cold atoms in optical lattices and ultra-fast spectroscopy experiments.