Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.02701 · Physical Review Letters

Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution with Random Postselection

Feihu Xu, Yuzhe Zhang, Qiang Zhang, Jian-Wei Pan

Published Mar 18, 2022• 63 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Device-independent quantum key distribution (QKD) can permit the superior security even with unknown devices. In practice, however, the realization of device-independent QKD is technically challenging because of its low noise tolerance. In the photonic setup, due to the limited detection efficiency, a large amount of the data generates from no-detection events which contain few correlations but contribute high errors. Here, we propose the device-independent QKD protocol with random postselection, where the secret keys are extracted only from the postselected subset of outcomes. This could not open the detection loophole as long as the entropy of the postselected subset is evaluated from the information of the entire set of data, including both detection and no-detection events. This postselection has the advantage to significantly reduce the error events, thus relaxing the threshold of required detection efficiency. In the model of collective attacks, our protocol can tolerate detector efficiency as low as 68.5%, which goes beyond standard security proofs. The results make a concrete step for the implementation of device-independent QKD in practice.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.128.110506

Related papers

High-speed device-independent quantum key distribution against collective attacks

Qiang Zhang, Wen‐Zhao Liu, Yuzhe Zhang +6 more

Abstract The security of quantum key distribution (QKD) usually relies on that the users’s devices are well characterized according to the security models made in the security proofs. In contrast,device-independent QKD an entanglement-based protocol permits the security even without any knowledge of the underlying devices. Despite its beauty in theory, device-independent QKD is elusive to realize with current technology. This is because a faithful realization requires ahigh-quality violation of Bell inequality without the fair-sampling assumption. Particularly, in a photonic realization, a rather high detection efficiency is needed where the threshold values depend on the security proofs; this efficiency is far beyond the current reach. Here, both theoretical and experimental innovations yield the realization of device-independent QKD based on a photonic setup. On the theory side, to relax the threshold efficiency for practical deviceindependent QKD, we exploit the random post-selection combined with adding noise for preprocessing, and compute the entropy with complete nonlocal correlations. On the experiment side, we develop a high-quality polarization-entangled photonic source and achieve state-of-theart (heralded) detection efficiency of 87.49%, which outperforms previous experiments and satisfies the threshold efficiency for the first time. Together, we demonstrate device-independent QKD at a secret key rate of 466 bits/s over 20 m standard fiber in the asymptotic limit against collective attacks. Besides, we show the feasibility of generating secret keys at a fiber length of 220 meters. Importantly, our photonic implementation can generate entangled photons at a high rate and in the telecom wavelength, which is desirable for high-speed key generation over long distances. The results not only prove the feasibility of device-independent QKD with realistic devices, but also push the security of communication to an unprecedented level.

•Oct 27, 2021•8 citations

Towards Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution with Photonic Devices

Corentin Lanore, Xavier Valcarce, Jean Etesse +2 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols enable two distant parties to communicate with information-theoretically proven secrecy. However, these protocols are generally vulnerable to potential mismatches between the physical modeling and the implementation of their quantum operations, thereby opening opportunities for side channel attacks. Device-Independent (DI) QKD addresses this problem by reducing the degree of device modeling to a black-box setting. The stronger security obtained in this way comes at the cost of a reduced noise tolerance, rendering experimental demonstrations more challenging: so far, only one experiment based on trapped ions was able to successfully generate a secret key. Photonic platforms have however long been preferred for QKD thanks to their suitability to optical fiber transmission, high repetition rates, readily available hardware, and potential for circuit integration. In this work, we assess the feasibility of DIQKD on a photonic circuit recently identified by machine learning techniques. For this, we introduce an efficient converging hierarchy of semi-definite programs (SDP) to bound the conditional von Neumann entropy and develop a finite-statistics analysis that takes into account full outcome statistics. Our analysis shows that the proposed optical circuit is sufficiently resistant to noise to make an experimental realization realistic.

quant-pharXiv:2601.14373•Jan 22, 2026•1 citation

Toward a Photonic Demonstration of Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution

Wen‐Zhao Liu, Yuzhe Zhang, Yi-Zheng Zhen +6 more

The security of quantum key distribution (QKD) usually relies on that the users' devices are well characterized according to the security models made in the security proofs. In contrast, device-independent QKD-an entanglement-based protocol-permits the security even without any knowledge of the underlying quantum devices. Despite its beauty in theory, device-independent QKD is elusive to realize with current technologies. Especially in photonic implementations, the requirements for detection efficiency are far beyond the performance of any reported device-independent experiments. In this Letter, we report a proof-of-principle experiment of device-independent QKD based on a photonic setup in the asymptotic limit. On the theoretical side, we enhance the loss tolerance for real device imperfections by combining different approaches, namely, random postselection, noisy preprocessing, and developed numerical methods to estimate the key rate via the von Neumann entropy. On the experimental side, we develop a high-quality polarization-entangled photon source achieving a state-of-the-art (heralded) detection efficiency about 87.5%. Although our experiment does not include random basis switching, the achieved efficiency outperforms previous photonic experiments involving loophole-free Bell tests. Together, we show that the measured quantum correlations are strong enough to ensure a positive key rate under the fiber length up to 220 m. Our photonic platform can generate entangled photons at a high rate and in the telecom wavelength, which is desirable for high-speed generation over long distances. The results present an important step toward a full demonstration of photonic device-independent QKD.

arXiv:2110.01480•Physical Review Letters•Jul 27, 2022•162 citations

Device-independent quantum secret sharing with advanced random key generation basis

Qi Zhang, Jia‐Wei Ying, Wang Zhong-jian +9 more

Quantum secret sharing (QSS) enables a dealer to securely distribute keys to multiple players. Device-independent (DI) QSS can resist all possible attacks from practical imperfect devices and provide QSS the highest level of security in theory. However, DI QSS requires high-performance devices, especially for low-noise channels, which is a big challenge to demonstrate experimentally. We propose a DI QSS protocol with the advanced random key generation basis strategy, which combines the random key generation basis with the noise preprocessing and postselection strategies. We develop the methods to numerically simulate the key generation rate in an acceptable time. Our DI QSS protocol has some advantages. First, it can increase the noise tolerance threshold from an initial 7.147% to 9.231% (29.16% growth) and reduce the global detection efficiency threshold from 96.32% to 93.41%. The maximal distance between any two users increases to 1.43 km, which is about 5.5 times the initial value. Second, by randomly selecting two basis combinations to generate the key, our DI QSS protocol can reduce the entanglement resource consumption. Our protocol has potential for the experimental demonstration of DI QSS and application in the future.

arXiv:2410.04003•Physical Review A•Jan 2, 2025•49 citations

Device-independent quantum key distribution with single-photon sources (Conference Presentation)

Alejandro Máttar, Daniel Cavalcanti, Jan Kołodyński +3 more

The concept of the Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution (DI-QKD) constitutes the minimalist paradigm for quantum cryptography, in which the security of the distributed secret key is fully assured by the statistical properties of the data being shared between the parties that perform a quantum-based protocol. In particular, the secrecy of the distributed key is ultimately guaranteed not only thanks to the quantum nature of the underlying scheme, but also without making any assumptions about the operation of the devices being employed. Such a conservative approach is possible thanks to the non-local correlations exhibited within the shared data, i.e., the correlations of genuine quantum origin that, due to violation of a particular Bell inequality, cannot be explained by any form of common randomness pre-available to the parties. Such violation, however, must be revealed without performing any post-selection on the data, what would then open the so-called detection loophole and jeopardize the security of the protocol. In spite of the tremendous advances recently made to achieve higher detection efficiencies in Bell-violation experiments, DI-QKD remains a very experimentally difficult task due to the exponential increase of loss in the channel, e.g., implemented with optical fibres, with the distance separating the parties involved. Here, we describe a new and plausible solution to overcome the crucial problem of channel loss in the frame of DI-QKD optical implementations. In particular, we propose a novel protocol inspired by the entanglement swapping schemes, which by the usage of the state-of-the-art (e.g., quantum-dot-based or heralded) single-photon sources has potential, for the first time, to be implementable with current photonic and linear optics technologies. While allowing for any transmission losses that only decrease the rate of the key distribution without creating vulnerability, it tolerates overall detection efficiency at the 90% level even when requiring strict device-independence. We compare our scheme against protocols that involve sources based on spontaneous parametric down-conversion (SPDC), in order to explicitly show and explain why such SPDC-based proposals—even when enhanced by the entanglement swapping or qubit amplification techniques—are then largely outperformed when physical imperfections are rigorously taken into account.

•Jun 8, 2017•3 citations

Detector-device-independent quantum key distribution

Charles Ci Wen Lim, Boris A. Korzh, Anthony Martin +3 more

Recently, a quantum key distribution (QKD) scheme based on entanglement swapping, called measurement-device-independent QKD (mdiQKD), was proposed to bypass all measurement side-channel attacks. While mdiQKD is conceptually elegant and offers a supreme level of security, the experimental complexity is challenging for practical systems. For instance, it requires interference between two widely separated independent single-photon sources, and the secret key rates are dependent on detecting two photons—one from each source. Here, we demonstrate a proof-of-principle experiment of a QKD scheme that removes the need for a two-photon system and instead uses the idea of a two-qubit single-photon to significantly simplify the implementation and improve the efficiency of mdiQKD in several aspects.

arXiv:1410.1850•Applied Physics Letters•Dec 1, 2014•32 citations
Device-independent quantum key distribution (QKD) can permit the superior security even with unknown devices. In practice, however, the realization of device-independent QKD is technically challenging because of its low noise tolerance. In the photonic setup, due to the limited detection efficiency, a large amount of the data generates from no-detection events which contain few correlations but contribute high errors. Here, we propose the device-independent QKD protocol with random postselection, where the secret keys are extracted only from the postselected subset of outcomes. This could not open the detection loophole as long as the entropy of the postselected subset is evaluated from the information of the entire set of data, including both detection and no-detection events. This postselection has the advantage to significantly reduce the error events, thus relaxing the threshold of required detection efficiency. In the model of collective attacks, our protocol can tolerate detector efficiency as low as 68.5%, which goes beyond standard security proofs. The results make a concrete step for the implementation of device-independent QKD in practice.
Abstract The security of quantum key distribution (QKD) usually relies on that the users’s devices are well characterized according to the security models made in the security proofs. In contrast,device-independent QKD an entanglement-based protocol permits the security even without any knowledge of the underlying devices. Despite its beauty in theory, device-independent QKD is elusive to realize with current technology. This is because a faithful realization requires ahigh-quality violation of Bell inequality without the fair-sampling assumption. Particularly, in a photonic realization, a rather high detection efficiency is needed where the threshold values depend on the security proofs; this efficiency is far beyond the current reach. Here, both theoretical and experimental innovations yield the realization of device-independent QKD based on a photonic setup. On the theory side, to relax the threshold efficiency for practical deviceindependent QKD, we exploit the random post-selection combined with adding noise for preprocessing, and compute the entropy with complete nonlocal correlations. On the experiment side, we develop a high-quality polarization-entangled photonic source and achieve state-of-theart (heralded) detection efficiency of 87.49%, which outperforms previous experiments and satisfies the threshold efficiency for the first time. Together, we demonstrate device-independent QKD at a secret key rate of 466 bits/s over 20 m standard fiber in the asymptotic limit against collective attacks. Besides, we show the feasibility of generating secret keys at a fiber length of 220 meters. Importantly, our photonic implementation can generate entangled photons at a high rate and in the telecom wavelength, which is desirable for high-speed key generation over long distances. The results not only prove the feasibility of device-independent QKD with realistic devices, but also push the security of communication to an unprecedented level.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols enable two distant parties to communicate with information-theoretically proven secrecy. However, these protocols are generally vulnerable to potential mismatches between the physical modeling and the implementation of their quantum operations, thereby opening opportunities for side channel attacks. Device-Independent (DI) QKD addresses this problem by reducing the degree of device modeling to a black-box setting. The stronger security obtained in this way comes at the cost of a reduced noise tolerance, rendering experimental demonstrations more challenging: so far, only one experiment based on trapped ions was able to successfully generate a secret key. Photonic platforms have however long been preferred for QKD thanks to their suitability to optical fiber transmission, high repetition rates, readily available hardware, and potential for circuit integration. In this work, we assess the feasibility of DIQKD on a photonic circuit recently identified by machine learning techniques. For this, we introduce an efficient converging hierarchy of semi-definite programs (SDP) to bound the conditional von Neumann entropy and develop a finite-statistics analysis that takes into account full outcome statistics. Our analysis shows that the proposed optical circuit is sufficiently resistant to noise to make an experimental realization realistic.
The security of quantum key distribution (QKD) usually relies on that the users' devices are well characterized according to the security models made in the security proofs. In contrast, device-independent QKD-an entanglement-based protocol-permits the security even without any knowledge of the underlying quantum devices. Despite its beauty in theory, device-independent QKD is elusive to realize with current technologies. Especially in photonic implementations, the requirements for detection efficiency are far beyond the performance of any reported device-independent experiments. In this Letter, we report a proof-of-principle experiment of device-independent QKD based on a photonic setup in the asymptotic limit. On the theoretical side, we enhance the loss tolerance for real device imperfections by combining different approaches, namely, random postselection, noisy preprocessing, and developed numerical methods to estimate the key rate via the von Neumann entropy. On the experimental side, we develop a high-quality polarization-entangled photon source achieving a state-of-the-art (heralded) detection efficiency about 87.5%. Although our experiment does not include random basis switching, the achieved efficiency outperforms previous photonic experiments involving loophole-free Bell tests. Together, we show that the measured quantum correlations are strong enough to ensure a positive key rate under the fiber length up to 220 m. Our photonic platform can generate entangled photons at a high rate and in the telecom wavelength, which is desirable for high-speed generation over long distances. The results present an important step toward a full demonstration of photonic device-independent QKD.
Quantum secret sharing (QSS) enables a dealer to securely distribute keys to multiple players. Device-independent (DI) QSS can resist all possible attacks from practical imperfect devices and provide QSS the highest level of security in theory. However, DI QSS requires high-performance devices, especially for low-noise channels, which is a big challenge to demonstrate experimentally. We propose a DI QSS protocol with the advanced random key generation basis strategy, which combines the random key generation basis with the noise preprocessing and postselection strategies. We develop the methods to numerically simulate the key generation rate in an acceptable time. Our DI QSS protocol has some advantages. First, it can increase the noise tolerance threshold from an initial 7.147% to 9.231% (29.16% growth) and reduce the global detection efficiency threshold from 96.32% to 93.41%. The maximal distance between any two users increases to 1.43 km, which is about 5.5 times the initial value. Second, by randomly selecting two basis combinations to generate the key, our DI QSS protocol can reduce the entanglement resource consumption. Our protocol has potential for the experimental demonstration of DI QSS and application in the future.
The concept of the Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution (DI-QKD) constitutes the minimalist paradigm for quantum cryptography, in which the security of the distributed secret key is fully assured by the statistical properties of the data being shared between the parties that perform a quantum-based protocol. In particular, the secrecy of the distributed key is ultimately guaranteed not only thanks to the quantum nature of the underlying scheme, but also without making any assumptions about the operation of the devices being employed. Such a conservative approach is possible thanks to the non-local correlations exhibited within the shared data, i.e., the correlations of genuine quantum origin that, due to violation of a particular Bell inequality, cannot be explained by any form of common randomness pre-available to the parties. Such violation, however, must be revealed without performing any post-selection on the data, what would then open the so-called detection loophole and jeopardize the security of the protocol. In spite of the tremendous advances recently made to achieve higher detection efficiencies in Bell-violation experiments, DI-QKD remains a very experimentally difficult task due to the exponential increase of loss in the channel, e.g., implemented with optical fibres, with the distance separating the parties involved. Here, we describe a new and plausible solution to overcome the crucial problem of channel loss in the frame of DI-QKD optical implementations. In particular, we propose a novel protocol inspired by the entanglement swapping schemes, which by the usage of the state-of-the-art (e.g., quantum-dot-based or heralded) single-photon sources has potential, for the first time, to be implementable with current photonic and linear optics technologies. While allowing for any transmission losses that only decrease the rate of the key distribution without creating vulnerability, it tolerates overall detection efficiency at the 90% level even when requiring strict device-independence. We compare our scheme against protocols that involve sources based on spontaneous parametric down-conversion (SPDC), in order to explicitly show and explain why such SPDC-based proposals—even when enhanced by the entanglement swapping or qubit amplification techniques—are then largely outperformed when physical imperfections are rigorously taken into account.
Recently, a quantum key distribution (QKD) scheme based on entanglement swapping, called measurement-device-independent QKD (mdiQKD), was proposed to bypass all measurement side-channel attacks. While mdiQKD is conceptually elegant and offers a supreme level of security, the experimental complexity is challenging for practical systems. For instance, it requires interference between two widely separated independent single-photon sources, and the secret key rates are dependent on detecting two photons—one from each source. Here, we demonstrate a proof-of-principle experiment of a QKD scheme that removes the need for a two-photon system and instead uses the idea of a two-qubit single-photon to significantly simplify the implementation and improve the efficiency of mdiQKD in several aspects.