Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.08401 · Physical Review Research

Quantum hardware calculations of periodic systems with partition-measurement symmetry verification: Simplified models of hydrogen chain and iron crystals

Kentaro Yamamoto, David Zsolt Manrique, Irfan T. Khan, Hideaki Sawada, David Muñoz Ramo

Published Aug 9, 2022• 32 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Running quantum algorithms on real hardware is essential for understanding their strengths and limitations, especially in the noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) era. Herein we focus on the practical aspect of quantum computational calculations of solid-state crystalline materials based on theory developed in our group by using real quantum hardware with a noise mitigation technique referred to as partition-measurement symmetry verification, which performs postselection of shot counts based on ${Z}_{2}$ and ${U}_{1}$ symmetry verification. We select two periodic systems with different levels of complexity for these calculations. One of them is the distorted hydrogen chain as an example of very simple systems, and the other one is iron crystal in the bcc and fcc phases as it is considered to be inaccessible by using classical computational wave-function methods. The ground-state energies are evaluated based on the translational quantum subspace expansion method for the hydrogen chain, and periodic boundary condition adapted variational quantum eigensolver for our iron models. By applying these techniques for the simplest two-qubit iron model systems, the correlation energies obtained by the hardware calculations agree with those of the state-vector simulations within $\ensuremath{\sim}5$ kJ/mol. Although the quantum computational resources used for those experiments are still limited, the techniques applied to obtain our simplified models will be applicable in essentially the same manner to more complicated cases as quantum hardware matures.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.4.033110

Related papers

Momentum-Space Unitary Coupled Cluster and Translational Quantum Subspace Expansion for Periodic Systems on Quantum Computers

David Zsolt Manrique, Irfan T. Khan, Kentaro Yamamoto +2 more

We demonstrate the use of the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) to simulate solid state crystalline materials. We adapt the Unitary Coupled Cluster ansatz to periodic boundary conditions in real space and momentum space representations and directly map complex cluster operators to a quantum circuit ansatz to take advantage of the reduced number of excitation operators and Hamiltonian terms due to momentum conservation. To further reduce required quantum resources, such as the number of UCCSD amplitudes, circuit depth, required number of qubits and number of measurement circuits, we investigate a translational Quantum Subspace Expansion method (TransQSE) for the localized representation of the periodic Hamiltonian. Additionally, we also demonstrate an extension of the point group symmetry based qubit tapering method to periodic systems. We compare accuracy and computational costs for a range of geometries for 1D chains of dimerized hydrogen, helium and lithium hydride with increasing number of momentum space grid points and also demonstrate VQE calculations for 2D and 3D hydrogen and helium lattices. Our presented strategies enable the use of near-term quantum hardware to perform solid state simulation with variational quantum algorithms.

arXiv:2008.08694•Aug 19, 2020•35 citations

Benchmarking the Variational Quantum Eigensolver using different quantum hardware

Amine Bentellis, Andrea Matic-Flierl, Christian B. Mendl +1 more

The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is a promising quantum algorithm for applications in chemistry within the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. The ability for a quantum computer to simulate electronic structures with high accuracy would have a profound impact on material and biochemical science with potential applications e.g., to the development of new drugs. However, considering the variety of quantum hardware architectures, it is still uncertain which hardware concept is most suited to execute the VQE for e.g., the simulation of molecules. Aspects to consider here are the required connectivity of the quantum circuit used, the size and the depth and thus the susceptibility to noise effects. Besides theo-retical considerations, empirical studies using available quantum hardware may help to clarify the question of which hardware technology might be better suited for a certain given application and algorithm. Going one step into this direction, within this work, we present results using the VQE for the simulation of the hydrogen molecule, comparing superconducting and ion trap quantum computers. The experiments are carried out with a standardized setup of ansatz and optimizer, selected to reduce the number of required iterations. The findings are analyzed considering different quantum processor types, calibration data as well as the depth and gate counts of the circuits required for the different hardware concepts after transpilation.

arXiv:2305.07092•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•15 citations

Benchmarking Quantum Material Simulations on NISQ Processors: Accuracy, Error Mitigation, and Algorithm Scaling Across 28 Prototypical Systems Using Qiskit

S. N. PRAJAPATI

Abstract Quantum computers promise to solve electronic structure, lattice dynamics, and strongly correlated problems beyond classical reach. However, near-term noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) processors require systematic benchmarking to establish where variational algorithms with error mitigation can achieve chemical accuracy and cor rectly predict physical phenomena. Here we present 28 quantum material simula tions implemented with Qiskit, spanning molecular hydrogen (H 2 ) through the iron molybdenum cofactor (FeMoco), one-dimensional Hubbard chains, Kitaev honeycomb spin liquids, topological insulators (SSH model), BCS superconductors, and disordered Anderson insulators. Using the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) with UCCSD ansatz, we achieve chemical accuracy (±1.6 mHa) for H 2 across the full dissociation curve and recover exact ground-state energies for H4 within 9 mHa after zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) — reducing raw VQE errors from 152 mHa to 9 mHa. We accu rately identify the transverse-field Ising quantum critical point (h c = J) with 4 qubits, resolve Majorana Dirac dispersions in the Kitaev spin liquid, and reproduce the Mott transition in the Fermi-Hubbard model at U c = 6t. Resource estimation for FeMoco reveals O(N 2.5 ) scaling, projecting chemical accuracy with ∼200 logical qubits. Across all benchmarks, we quantify the accuracy-circuit depth tradeoff, demonstrating that depth-6 VQE ans¨atze achieve chemical accuracy for small molecules while depth-10 is required for correlated lattices. These results establish a comprehensive benchmark suite for evaluating quantum hardware, error mitigation protocols, and variational al gorithms for materials science on NISQ processors.

•Apr 29, 2026•0 citations

Band structure of two-dimensional graphene and of one-dimensional nanoribbons via variational quantum algorithms: from energies to wavefunction quality

Raúl Medrano Millán, Rodrigo Gil-Merino y Rubio, J. Borge +1 more

Simulating quantum many-body systems classically encounters exponential bottlenecks, which quantum devices circumvent by natively encoding wavefunctions. In the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, however, hardware noise constrains simulation accuracy. As a stepping stone toward strongly correlated materials, we compute the band structure of 2D monolayer graphene and 1D nanoribbons (zigzag and armchair) using a single variational workflow in the $p_z$ tight-binding approximation. Non-interacting ground states also provide essential initial reference states for subspace and warm-started variational methods to solve interacting spectra. By mapping the Bloch Hamiltonian to Pauli operators, we extract the ground band via the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and excited subbands via Variational Quantum Deflation (VQD), validating our approach from ideal simulations to execution on physical IBM Quantum processors. In ideal simulations, the workflow reproduces exact diagonalization results with high precision, whereas hardware noise introduces energy deviations of a few hundredths of the hopping parameter. While qubit counts scale logarithmically with ribbon width, fixed-depth ansatz accuracy degrades with Hilbert space dimension. Crucially, deepening the ansatz improves ideal simulation accuracy by over three orders of magnitude but worsens energy estimates under noise, proving that practical circuit depth is bounded by hardware noise rather than expressivity. Finally, we complement energy evaluations with a wavefunction-level diagnostic measuring subspace containment. This diagnostic captures degenerate manifolds and exposes optimization failure modes disguised by energy agreement alone. Operating directly on NISQ hardware, this validated workflow establishes a controlled baseline for studying topological and strongly correlated phases in realistic materials.

arXiv:2611.04975•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Symmetry-Preserving Variational Quantum Simulation of the Heisenberg Spin Chain on Noisy Quantum Hardware

Rudraksh Sharma

Variational quantum algorithms are among the most promising approaches for simulating interacting quantum many-body systems on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. However, the practical success of variational quantum eigensolvers (VQE) critically depends on the structure of the chosen variational ansatz. In this work, we investigate the ground-state properties of the one-dimensional antiferromagnetic Heisenberg spin-1/2 chain using both generic hardware-efficient ansatz and physics-informed, symmetry-preserving variational circuits. We benchmark variational results against exact diagonalization and noiseless simulations, and subsequently validate the approach on real IQM Garnet quantum hardware. Our results demonstrate that incorporating physical symmetries into the circuit design leads to significantly improved energy estimates, enhanced robustness against hardware noise, and clearer convergence behavior when compared to hardware-efficient ansatz under identical resource constraints. These findings highlight the importance of problem specific ansatz construction for reliable quantum simulations in the NISQ era.

quant-pharXiv:2512.23009•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations

Simulating Periodic Systems on a Quantum Computer Using Molecular Orbitals

Jie Liu, Lingyun Wan, Zhenyu Li +1 more

The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is one of the most appealing quantum algorithms to simulate electronic structure properties of molecules on near-term noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. In this work, we generalize the VQE algorithm for simulating periodic systems. However, the numerical study of a one-dimensional (1D) infinite hydrogen chain using existing VQE algorithms shows a remarkable deviation of the ground-state energy with respect to the exact full configuration interaction (FCI) result. Here, we present two schemes to improve the accuracy of quantum simulations for periodic systems. The first one is a modified VQE algorithm, which introduces a unitary transformation of Hartree-Fock orbitals to avoid the complex wave function. The second one is combining VQE with the quantum subspace expansion approach (VQE/QSE). Numerical benchmark calculations demonstrate that both of the two schemes provide an accurate description of the potential energy curve of the 1D hydrogen chain. In addition, excited states computed with the VQE/QSE approach also agree very well with FCI results.

arXiv:2008.02946•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Oct 19, 2020•55 citations
Running quantum algorithms on real hardware is essential for understanding their strengths and limitations, especially in the noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) era. Herein we focus on the practical aspect of quantum computational calculations of solid-state crystalline materials based on theory developed in our group by using real quantum hardware with a noise mitigation technique referred to as partition-measurement symmetry verification, which performs postselection of shot counts based on Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ and U1{U}_{1}U1​ symmetry verification. We select two periodic systems with different levels of complexity for these calculations. One of them is the distorted hydrogen chain as an example of very simple systems, and the other one is iron crystal in the bcc and fcc phases as it is considered to be inaccessible by using classical computational wave-function methods. The ground-state energies are evaluated based on the translational quantum subspace expansion method for the hydrogen chain, and periodic boundary condition adapted variational quantum eigensolver for our iron models. By applying these techniques for the simplest two-qubit iron model systems, the correlation energies obtained by the hardware calculations agree with those of the state-vector simulations within \ensuremath∼5\ensuremath{\sim}5\ensuremath∼5 kJ/mol. Although the quantum computational resources used for those experiments are still limited, the techniques applied to obtain our simplified models will be applicable in essentially the same manner to more complicated cases as quantum hardware matures.
We demonstrate the use of the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) to simulate solid state crystalline materials. We adapt the Unitary Coupled Cluster ansatz to periodic boundary conditions in real space and momentum space representations and directly map complex cluster operators to a quantum circuit ansatz to take advantage of the reduced number of excitation operators and Hamiltonian terms due to momentum conservation. To further reduce required quantum resources, such as the number of UCCSD amplitudes, circuit depth, required number of qubits and number of measurement circuits, we investigate a translational Quantum Subspace Expansion method (TransQSE) for the localized representation of the periodic Hamiltonian. Additionally, we also demonstrate an extension of the point group symmetry based qubit tapering method to periodic systems. We compare accuracy and computational costs for a range of geometries for 1D chains of dimerized hydrogen, helium and lithium hydride with increasing number of momentum space grid points and also demonstrate VQE calculations for 2D and 3D hydrogen and helium lattices. Our presented strategies enable the use of near-term quantum hardware to perform solid state simulation with variational quantum algorithms.
The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is a promising quantum algorithm for applications in chemistry within the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. The ability for a quantum computer to simulate electronic structures with high accuracy would have a profound impact on material and biochemical science with potential applications e.g., to the development of new drugs. However, considering the variety of quantum hardware architectures, it is still uncertain which hardware concept is most suited to execute the VQE for e.g., the simulation of molecules. Aspects to consider here are the required connectivity of the quantum circuit used, the size and the depth and thus the susceptibility to noise effects. Besides theo-retical considerations, empirical studies using available quantum hardware may help to clarify the question of which hardware technology might be better suited for a certain given application and algorithm. Going one step into this direction, within this work, we present results using the VQE for the simulation of the hydrogen molecule, comparing superconducting and ion trap quantum computers. The experiments are carried out with a standardized setup of ansatz and optimizer, selected to reduce the number of required iterations. The findings are analyzed considering different quantum processor types, calibration data as well as the depth and gate counts of the circuits required for the different hardware concepts after transpilation.
Abstract Quantum computers promise to solve electronic structure, lattice dynamics, and strongly correlated problems beyond classical reach. However, near-term noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) processors require systematic benchmarking to establish where variational algorithms with error mitigation can achieve chemical accuracy and cor rectly predict physical phenomena. Here we present 28 quantum material simula tions implemented with Qiskit, spanning molecular hydrogen (H 2 ) through the iron molybdenum cofactor (FeMoco), one-dimensional Hubbard chains, Kitaev honeycomb spin liquids, topological insulators (SSH model), BCS superconductors, and disordered Anderson insulators. Using the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) with UCCSD ansatz, we achieve chemical accuracy (±1.6 mHa) for H 2 across the full dissociation curve and recover exact ground-state energies for H4 within 9 mHa after zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) — reducing raw VQE errors from 152 mHa to 9 mHa. We accu rately identify the transverse-field Ising quantum critical point (h c = J) with 4 qubits, resolve Majorana Dirac dispersions in the Kitaev spin liquid, and reproduce the Mott transition in the Fermi-Hubbard model at U c = 6t. Resource estimation for FeMoco reveals O(N 2.5 ) scaling, projecting chemical accuracy with ∼200 logical qubits. Across all benchmarks, we quantify the accuracy-circuit depth tradeoff, demonstrating that depth-6 VQE ans¨atze achieve chemical accuracy for small molecules while depth-10 is required for correlated lattices. These results establish a comprehensive benchmark suite for evaluating quantum hardware, error mitigation protocols, and variational al gorithms for materials science on NISQ processors.
Simulating quantum many-body systems classically encounters exponential bottlenecks, which quantum devices circumvent by natively encoding wavefunctions. In the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, however, hardware noise constrains simulation accuracy. As a stepping stone toward strongly correlated materials, we compute the band structure of 2D monolayer graphene and 1D nanoribbons (zigzag and armchair) using a single variational workflow in the pzp_zpz​ tight-binding approximation. Non-interacting ground states also provide essential initial reference states for subspace and warm-started variational methods to solve interacting spectra. By mapping the Bloch Hamiltonian to Pauli operators, we extract the ground band via the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and excited subbands via Variational Quantum Deflation (VQD), validating our approach from ideal simulations to execution on physical IBM Quantum processors. In ideal simulations, the workflow reproduces exact diagonalization results with high precision, whereas hardware noise introduces energy deviations of a few hundredths of the hopping parameter. While qubit counts scale logarithmically with ribbon width, fixed-depth ansatz accuracy degrades with Hilbert space dimension. Crucially, deepening the ansatz improves ideal simulation accuracy by over three orders of magnitude but worsens energy estimates under noise, proving that practical circuit depth is bounded by hardware noise rather than expressivity. Finally, we complement energy evaluations with a wavefunction-level diagnostic measuring subspace containment. This diagnostic captures degenerate manifolds and exposes optimization failure modes disguised by energy agreement alone. Operating directly on NISQ hardware, this validated workflow establishes a controlled baseline for studying topological and strongly correlated phases in realistic materials.
Variational quantum algorithms are among the most promising approaches for simulating interacting quantum many-body systems on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. However, the practical success of variational quantum eigensolvers (VQE) critically depends on the structure of the chosen variational ansatz. In this work, we investigate the ground-state properties of the one-dimensional antiferromagnetic Heisenberg spin-1/2 chain using both generic hardware-efficient ansatz and physics-informed, symmetry-preserving variational circuits. We benchmark variational results against exact diagonalization and noiseless simulations, and subsequently validate the approach on real IQM Garnet quantum hardware. Our results demonstrate that incorporating physical symmetries into the circuit design leads to significantly improved energy estimates, enhanced robustness against hardware noise, and clearer convergence behavior when compared to hardware-efficient ansatz under identical resource constraints. These findings highlight the importance of problem specific ansatz construction for reliable quantum simulations in the NISQ era.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is one of the most appealing quantum algorithms to simulate electronic structure properties of molecules on near-term noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. In this work, we generalize the VQE algorithm for simulating periodic systems. However, the numerical study of a one-dimensional (1D) infinite hydrogen chain using existing VQE algorithms shows a remarkable deviation of the ground-state energy with respect to the exact full configuration interaction (FCI) result. Here, we present two schemes to improve the accuracy of quantum simulations for periodic systems. The first one is a modified VQE algorithm, which introduces a unitary transformation of Hartree-Fock orbitals to avoid the complex wave function. The second one is combining VQE with the quantum subspace expansion approach (VQE/QSE). Numerical benchmark calculations demonstrate that both of the two schemes provide an accurate description of the potential energy curve of the 1D hydrogen chain. In addition, excited states computed with the VQE/QSE approach also agree very well with FCI results.