Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.01690 · Physical Review Applied

High-Quality Thermal Gibbs Sampling with Quantum Annealing Hardware

Jon Nelson, Marc Vuffray, Andrey Y. Lokhov, Tameem Albash, Carleton Coffrin

Published Apr 25, 2022• 40 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum annealing (QA) was originally intended for accelerating the solution of combinatorial optimization tasks that have natural encodings as Ising models. However, recent experiments on QA-hardware platforms have demonstrated that, in the operating regime corresponding to weak interactions, the QA hardware behaves like a noisy Gibbs sampler at a hardware-specific effective temperature. This work builds on those insights and identifies a class of small hardware-native Ising models that are robust to noise effects and proposes a procedure for executing these models on QA hardware to maximize Gibbs-sampling performance. The experimental results indicate that the proposed protocol results in high-quality Gibbs samples from a hardware-specific effective temperature. Furthermore, we show that this effective temperature can be adjusted by modulating the annealing time and energy scale. The procedure proposed in this work provides an approach to using QA hardware for Ising-model sampling presenting potential opportunities for applications in machine learning and physics simulation.

DOI
10.1103/physrevapplied.17.044046

Related papers

Boltzmann sampling by diabatic quantum annealing

Ju-Yeon Gyhm, Gilhan Kim, Hyukjoon Kwon +1 more

Boltzmann sampling is a central component of many computational frameworks, including numerous algorithms in machine learning. Although quantum annealers have been investigated as potential fast Boltzmann samplers, their dependence on environmental noise makes precise control of the effective temperature difficult, introducing uncertainty into the sampling process. As an alternative, we propose diabatic quantum annealing-a faster, purely unitary process-as a controllable Boltzmann sampler in which the effective temperature is determined by the annealing rate. Using the ferromagnetic Ising model and the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model as test cases, we demonstrate that this method achieves rapid and accurate sampling in the high-temperature regime.

arXiv:2409.18126•Physical review. E•Apr 17, 2026•6 citations

Classical Thermometry of Quantum Annealers

George Grattan, Pratik Sathe, Cristiano Nisoli

Quantum annealers are emerging as programmable, dynamical experimental platforms for probing strongly correlated spin systems. Yet key thermal assumptions, chiefly a Gibbs-distributed output ensemble, remain unverified in the large-scale regime. Here, we experimentally and quantitatively assess Gibbs sampling fidelity across system sizes spanning over three orders of magnitude. We explore a wide parameter space of coupling strengths, system sizes, annealing times, and D-wave hardware architectures. We find that the naively assumed scaling law for the effective temperature requires a non-negligible, coupling-independent offset that is robust across machines and parameter regimes, quantifying residual non-thermal effects that still conform to an effective Gibbs description. These non-idealities are further reflected in a systematic discrepancy between the physical temperature inferred from the sampled ensemble and the nominal cryogenic temperature of the device. Our results systematically assess the viability of quantum annealers as experimental platforms for probing classical thermodynamics, correct previous assumptions, and provide a physically grounded thermometry framework to benchmark these machines for future thermodynamic experiments.

quant-pharXiv:2512.03162•Dec 4, 2025•3 citations

Assessment of image generation by quantum annealer

Takehito Sato, Masayuki Ohzeki, Kazuyuki Tanaka

Quantum annealing was originally proposed as an approach for solving combinatorial optimization problems using quantum effects. D-Wave Systems has released a production model of quantum annealing hardware. However, the inherent noise and various environmental factors in the hardware hamper the determination of optimal solutions. In addition, the freezing effect in regions with weak quantum fluctuations generates outputs approximately following a Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution at an extremely low temperature. Thus, a quantum annealer may also serve as a fast sampler for the Ising spin-glass problem, and several studies have investigated Boltzmann machine learning using a quantum annealer. Previous developments have focused on comparing the performance in the standard distance of the resulting distributions between conventional methods in classical computers and sampling by a quantum annealer. In this study, we focused on the performance of a quantum annealer as a generative model from a different aspect. To evaluate its performance, we prepared a discriminator given by a neural network trained on an a priori dataset. The evaluation results show a higher performance of quantum annealer compared with the classical approach for Boltzmann machine learning in training of the generative model. However the generation of the data suffers from the remanent quantum fluctuation in the quantum annealer. The quality of the generated images from the quantum annealer gets worse than the ideal case of the quantum annealing and the classical Monte-Carlo sampling.

arXiv:2103.08373•Scientific Reports•Jun 29, 2021•31 citations

On Quantum Annealing Without a Physical Quantum Annealer

Ameya Bhave, Ajinkya Borle

Quantum annealing is an emerging metaheuristic used for solving combinatorial optimisation problems. However, hardware based physical quantum annealers are primarily limited to a single vendor. As an alternative, we can discretise the quantum annealing process (discretised quantum annealing or DiQA) and use it on gate-model quantum computers. In this work, we first benchmark DiQA against simulated annealing for a similar number of steps. We then propose and evaluate a hybrid quantum classical heuristic: Quantum Accelerated Simulated Annealing (QASA), where the traditional classical annealing procedure can be sped up with the use of (relatively) low depth DiQA circuits. This is done by (i) running a partial annealing scheme with a fraction of the depth of the complete circuit (ii) sampling the results from the circuit and fitting a Gibbs distribution on it and (iii) Using the inverse temperature of the Gibbs distribution and the best sample to initialise simulated annealing (SA). Our simulation results show QASA performing comparably to SA but for a reduced amount of steps. With the promising results of our work, we hope to generate interest for potential future work in the area of fixed-parameter quantum optimisation.

arXiv:2307.09695•Jul 19, 2023•0 citations

On quantum annealing without a physical quantum annealer

Ameya Bhave, Ajinkya Borle

Quantum annealing is an emerging metaheuristic used for solving combinatorial optimisation problems. However, hardware based physical quantum annealers are primarily limited to a single vendor. As an alternative, we can discretise the quantum annealing process (discretised quantum annealing or DiQA) and use it on gate-model quantum computers. In this work, we first benchmark DiQA against simulated annealing for a similar number of steps. We then propose and evaluate a hybrid quantumclassical heuristic: Quantum Accelerated Simulated Annealing (QASA), where the traditional classical annealing procedure can be sped up with the use of (relatively) low depth DiQA circuits. This is done by (i) running a partial annealing scheme with a fraction of the depth of the complete circuit (ii) sampling the results from the circuit and fitting a Gibbs distribution on it and (iii) Using the inverse temperature of the Gibbs distribution and the best sample to initialise simulated annealing (SA). Our simulation results show QASA performing comparably to SA but for a reduced amount of steps.With the promising results of our work, we hope to generate interest for potential future work in the area of fixed-parameter quantum optimisation.

IET conference proceedings.•Dec 18, 2023•0 citations

Quantum Annealing for Combinatorial Optimization: Foundations, Architectures, Benchmarks, and Emerging Directions

Rudraksh Sharma, Ravi Katukam, Arjun Nagulapally

Critical decision-making issues in science, engineering, and industry are based on combinatorial optimization; however, its application is inherently limited by the NP-hard nature of the problem. A specialized paradigm of analogue quantum computing, quantum annealing (QA), has been proposed to solve these problems by encoding optimization problems into physical energy landscapes and solving them by quantum tunnelling systematically through exploration of solution space. This is a critical review that summarizes the current applications of quantum annealing to combinatorial optimization and includes a theoretical background, hardware designs, algorithm implementation strategies, encoding and embedding schemes, protocols to benchmark quantum annealing, areas of implementation, and links with the quantum algorithms implementation with gate-based hardware and classical solvers. We develop a unified framework, relating adiabatic quantum dynamics, Ising and QUBO models, stoquastic and non-stoquastic Hamiltonians, and diabatic transitions to modern flux-qubit annealers (Chimera, Pegasus, Zephyr topologies), and emergent architectures (Lechner-Hauke-Zoller systems, Rydberg atom platforms), and hybrids of quantum and classical computation. Through our analysis, we find that overhead in embedding and encoding is the largest determinant of the scalability and performance (this is not just the number of qubits). Minor embeddings also usually have a physical qubit count per logical variable of between 5 and 12 qubits, which limits effective problem capacity by 80-92% and, due to chain-breaking errors, compromises the quality of solutions.

quant-pharXiv:2602.03101•International Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology•Feb 4, 2026•3 citations
Quantum annealing (QA) was originally intended for accelerating the solution of combinatorial optimization tasks that have natural encodings as Ising models. However, recent experiments on QA-hardware platforms have demonstrated that, in the operating regime corresponding to weak interactions, the QA hardware behaves like a noisy Gibbs sampler at a hardware-specific effective temperature. This work builds on those insights and identifies a class of small hardware-native Ising models that are robust to noise effects and proposes a procedure for executing these models on QA hardware to maximize Gibbs-sampling performance. The experimental results indicate that the proposed protocol results in high-quality Gibbs samples from a hardware-specific effective temperature. Furthermore, we show that this effective temperature can be adjusted by modulating the annealing time and energy scale. The procedure proposed in this work provides an approach to using QA hardware for Ising-model sampling presenting potential opportunities for applications in machine learning and physics simulation.
Boltzmann sampling is a central component of many computational frameworks, including numerous algorithms in machine learning. Although quantum annealers have been investigated as potential fast Boltzmann samplers, their dependence on environmental noise makes precise control of the effective temperature difficult, introducing uncertainty into the sampling process. As an alternative, we propose diabatic quantum annealing-a faster, purely unitary process-as a controllable Boltzmann sampler in which the effective temperature is determined by the annealing rate. Using the ferromagnetic Ising model and the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model as test cases, we demonstrate that this method achieves rapid and accurate sampling in the high-temperature regime.
Quantum annealers are emerging as programmable, dynamical experimental platforms for probing strongly correlated spin systems. Yet key thermal assumptions, chiefly a Gibbs-distributed output ensemble, remain unverified in the large-scale regime. Here, we experimentally and quantitatively assess Gibbs sampling fidelity across system sizes spanning over three orders of magnitude. We explore a wide parameter space of coupling strengths, system sizes, annealing times, and D-wave hardware architectures. We find that the naively assumed scaling law for the effective temperature requires a non-negligible, coupling-independent offset that is robust across machines and parameter regimes, quantifying residual non-thermal effects that still conform to an effective Gibbs description. These non-idealities are further reflected in a systematic discrepancy between the physical temperature inferred from the sampled ensemble and the nominal cryogenic temperature of the device. Our results systematically assess the viability of quantum annealers as experimental platforms for probing classical thermodynamics, correct previous assumptions, and provide a physically grounded thermometry framework to benchmark these machines for future thermodynamic experiments.
Quantum annealing was originally proposed as an approach for solving combinatorial optimization problems using quantum effects. D-Wave Systems has released a production model of quantum annealing hardware. However, the inherent noise and various environmental factors in the hardware hamper the determination of optimal solutions. In addition, the freezing effect in regions with weak quantum fluctuations generates outputs approximately following a Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution at an extremely low temperature. Thus, a quantum annealer may also serve as a fast sampler for the Ising spin-glass problem, and several studies have investigated Boltzmann machine learning using a quantum annealer. Previous developments have focused on comparing the performance in the standard distance of the resulting distributions between conventional methods in classical computers and sampling by a quantum annealer. In this study, we focused on the performance of a quantum annealer as a generative model from a different aspect. To evaluate its performance, we prepared a discriminator given by a neural network trained on an a priori dataset. The evaluation results show a higher performance of quantum annealer compared with the classical approach for Boltzmann machine learning in training of the generative model. However the generation of the data suffers from the remanent quantum fluctuation in the quantum annealer. The quality of the generated images from the quantum annealer gets worse than the ideal case of the quantum annealing and the classical Monte-Carlo sampling.
Quantum annealing is an emerging metaheuristic used for solving combinatorial optimisation problems. However, hardware based physical quantum annealers are primarily limited to a single vendor. As an alternative, we can discretise the quantum annealing process (discretised quantum annealing or DiQA) and use it on gate-model quantum computers. In this work, we first benchmark DiQA against simulated annealing for a similar number of steps. We then propose and evaluate a hybrid quantum classical heuristic: Quantum Accelerated Simulated Annealing (QASA), where the traditional classical annealing procedure can be sped up with the use of (relatively) low depth DiQA circuits. This is done by (i) running a partial annealing scheme with a fraction of the depth of the complete circuit (ii) sampling the results from the circuit and fitting a Gibbs distribution on it and (iii) Using the inverse temperature of the Gibbs distribution and the best sample to initialise simulated annealing (SA). Our simulation results show QASA performing comparably to SA but for a reduced amount of steps. With the promising results of our work, we hope to generate interest for potential future work in the area of fixed-parameter quantum optimisation.
Quantum annealing is an emerging metaheuristic used for solving combinatorial optimisation problems. However, hardware based physical quantum annealers are primarily limited to a single vendor. As an alternative, we can discretise the quantum annealing process (discretised quantum annealing or DiQA) and use it on gate-model quantum computers. In this work, we first benchmark DiQA against simulated annealing for a similar number of steps. We then propose and evaluate a hybrid quantumclassical heuristic: Quantum Accelerated Simulated Annealing (QASA), where the traditional classical annealing procedure can be sped up with the use of (relatively) low depth DiQA circuits. This is done by (i) running a partial annealing scheme with a fraction of the depth of the complete circuit (ii) sampling the results from the circuit and fitting a Gibbs distribution on it and (iii) Using the inverse temperature of the Gibbs distribution and the best sample to initialise simulated annealing (SA). Our simulation results show QASA performing comparably to SA but for a reduced amount of steps.With the promising results of our work, we hope to generate interest for potential future work in the area of fixed-parameter quantum optimisation.
Critical decision-making issues in science, engineering, and industry are based on combinatorial optimization; however, its application is inherently limited by the NP-hard nature of the problem. A specialized paradigm of analogue quantum computing, quantum annealing (QA), has been proposed to solve these problems by encoding optimization problems into physical energy landscapes and solving them by quantum tunnelling systematically through exploration of solution space. This is a critical review that summarizes the current applications of quantum annealing to combinatorial optimization and includes a theoretical background, hardware designs, algorithm implementation strategies, encoding and embedding schemes, protocols to benchmark quantum annealing, areas of implementation, and links with the quantum algorithms implementation with gate-based hardware and classical solvers. We develop a unified framework, relating adiabatic quantum dynamics, Ising and QUBO models, stoquastic and non-stoquastic Hamiltonians, and diabatic transitions to modern flux-qubit annealers (Chimera, Pegasus, Zephyr topologies), and emergent architectures (Lechner-Hauke-Zoller systems, Rydberg atom platforms), and hybrids of quantum and classical computation. Through our analysis, we find that overhead in embedding and encoding is the largest determinant of the scalability and performance (this is not just the number of qubits). Minor embeddings also usually have a physical qubit count per logical variable of between 5 and 12 qubits, which limits effective problem capacity by 80-92% and, due to chain-breaking errors, compromises the quality of solutions.