Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.01593 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Causal optimization method for imaginary-time Green's functions in interacting electron systems

Mancheon Han, Hyoung Joon Choi

Published Sep 7, 2021• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We develop a causal optimization method that ensures causality in numerical calculations of Green's functions in interacting electron systems. Our method removes noncausality of numerical data by finding causal functions closest to the data. By testing our method with an exactly calculable model and applying it to practical dynamical mean-field calculations, we find that intermediate-frequency behaviors of Green's functions are determined solely by causality, and noncausal statistical errors are removed very efficiently. Furthermore, we demonstrate that numerical calculations of the physical branch of the Luttinger-Ward functional can be stabilized by ensuring causality of the noninteracting Green's function. Our method and findings provide a basis for improving stability and efficiency of numerical simulations of quantum many-body systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.104.115112

Related papers

Parameter-free analytic continuation for quantum many-body calculations

Mancheon Han, Hyoung Joon Choi

We develop a reliable parameter-free analytic continuation method for quantum many-body calculations. Our method is based on a kernel grid, a causal spline, a regularization using the second-derivative roughness penalty, and the L-curve criterion. We also develop the L-curve averaged deviation to estimate the precision of our analytic continuation. To deal with statistically obtained data more efficiently, we further develop a bootstrap-averaged analytic continuation method. In the test using the exact imaginary-frequency Green's function with added statistical error, our method produces the spectral function that converges systematically to the exact one as the statistical error decreases. As an application, we simulate the two-orbital Hubbard model for various electron numbers with the dynamical-mean field theory in the imaginary time and obtain the real-frequency self-energy with our analytic continuation method, clearly identifying a non-Fermi-liquid behavior as the electron number approaches the half filling from the quarter filling. Our analytic continuation can be used widely, and it will facilitate drawing clear conclusions from imaginary-time quantum many-body calculations.

arXiv:2301.00129•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 29, 2022•5 citations

Hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for computing imaginary-time correlation functions

Rihito Sakurai, Wataru Mizukami, Hiroshi Shinaoka

Quantitative descriptions of strongly correlated materials pose a considerable challenge in condensed matter physics and chemistry. A promising approach to address this problem is quantum embedding methods. In particular, the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) maps the original system to an effective quantum impurity model comprising correlated orbitals embedded in an electron bath. The biggest bottleneck in DMFT calculations is numerically solving the quantum impurity model, i.e., computing the Green's function. Past studies have proposed theoretical methods to compute the Green's function of a quantum impurity model in polynomial time using a quantum computer. So far, however, efficient methods for computing the imaginary-time Green's functions have not been established despite the advantages of the imaginary-time formulation. We propose a quantum-classical hybrid algorithm for computing imaginary-time Green's functions on quantum devices with limited hardware resources by applying the variational quantum simulation. Using a quantum circuit simulator, we verified this algorithm by computing Green's functions for a dimer model as well as a four-site impurity model obtained by DMFT calculations of the single-band Hubbard model, although our method can be applied to general imaginary-time correlation functions.

arXiv:2112.02764•Physical Review Research•Jun 16, 2022•33 citations

Efficient non-equilibrium Green's function simulations of correlated electron-boson systems

Daniel Karlsson, Robert van Leeuwen, Y. Pavlyukh +2 more

This work contains a computationally efficient Green's function scheme for treating correlated electron-boson systems out of equilibrium. The numerical effort scales linearly with the simulation time, thus competing with that of the fastest quantum methods available. On a more fundamental level the proposed scheme fulfills energy balance as well as other fundamental conservation laws, and it can be systematically improved using standard many-body perturbation theory. We demonstrate its accuracy and stability through benchmarks against exact results in the Holstein model. However, our formulation equally applies to molecules and solids for first-principles transient calculations with quantum bosons, such as photons and phonons.

•Jun 26, 2020•0 citations

Monte Carlo studies of the dynamical response of quantum many-body systems

H.-B. Schüttler, Douglas J. Scalapino

We present a method to obtain dynamical correlation functions of quantum many-body systems in the real-frequency domain from Monte Carlo data of the corresponding imaginary-time Green's functions. The method is based on a least-squares-fit procedure to solve the integral equation relating imaginary-time and real-frequency correlation functions. To demonstrate its feasibility, we have applied our method to imaginary-time Monte Carlo data for the density correlation function of a simple model of interacting spinless fermions in one dimension. We compare our results to the analytical results, available in the limits of zero and strong interaction. We find that despite the presence of noise in the input data, the real-frequency spectra obtained with our method are qualitatively correct. They reflect accurately the particle-hole and the soliton-antisoliton excitations, present in the noninteracting and in the strongly coupled fermion system, respectively. We also compare our method to other approaches that have been proposed for obtaining dynamical correlation functions via Monte Carlo simulation.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 1, 1986•39 citations

Performance analysis of a physically constructed orthogonal representation of imaginary-time Green's function

Naoya Chikano, Junya Otsuki, Hiroshi Shinaoka

The imaginary-time Green's function is a building block of various numerical methods for correlated electron systems. Recently, it was shown that a model-independent compact orthogonal representation of the Green's function can be constructed by decomposing its spectral representation. We investigate the performance of this so-called intermediate representation (IR) from several points of view. First, we develop an efficient algorithm for computing the IR basis functions of arbitrary high degree. Second, for two simple models, we study the number of coefficients required to represent the Green's function within a given tolerance. We show that the number of coefficients grows only as $O(ln\ensuremath{\beta})$ for fermions and converges to a constant for bosons as temperature $T=1/\ensuremath{\beta}$ decreases. Third, we show that this remarkable feature is ascribed to the properties of the physically constructed basis functions. The fermionic basis functions on the real-frequency axis have features whose width is scaled as $O(T)$, which is consistent with the low-$T$ properties of quasiparticles in a Fermi liquid state. On the other hand, the properties of the bosonic basis functions are consistent with those of spin/orbital susceptibilities at low $T$. These results demonstrate the potential wide applications of the IR to calculations of correlated systems.

arXiv:1803.07257•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 3, 2018•48 citations

The Quantum Many-Body Problem: Methods and Analysis

Michael Lindsey

This dissertation concerns the quantum many-body problem, which is the problem of predicting the properties of systems of several quantum particles from the first principles of quantum mechanics. Included under this umbrella are various problems of fundamental importance in quantum chemistry, condensed matter physics, and materials science. Of particular interest is the electronic structure problem, the problem of determining the state of the electrons in a system with fixed atomic nuclei. Since direct numerical solution of the many-body Schrödinger equation is intractable even for systems of moderate size, a diverse array of approximate methods has been developed. The broad goals of this dissertation are to improve the mathematical understanding of certain widely-used approximations, as well as to propose new methods. Roughly speaking, we consider three (overlapping) categories of methods: Green's function methods, embedding methods, and variational methods.One can understand Green's function methods in terms of many-body perturbation theory, which computes series expansions of physical quantities about a non-interacting reference system. These expansions can be expressed graphically in terms of Feynman diagrams, which can in turn be reorganized, in some cases, into an expansion in terms of so-called bold diagrams. Green's function methods can be specified by choosing a subset of bold diagrams to approximate the sum. At the same time, such methods can be understood in terms of an object known as the Luttinger-Ward (LW) functional, which admits a representation in terms of the bold diagrams. Many aspects of these constructions are purely formal, and indeed the existence of the fermionic LW functional as a single-valued functional has recently been called into question. To contribute to the understanding of these issues, we provide rigorous proofs of the combinatorial construction and analytic interpretation of the bold diagrams in the simplified setting of a classical field theory. In this setting we also provide a rigorous non-perturbative construction of the LW functional via convex duality and prove several key properties, including continuity up to the boundary of its domain and asymptotics in the limit of large interaction.Quantum embedding methods, meanwhile, view a large system as being composed of smaller fragments that are treated with high accuracy and embedded in the larger system in a mutually consistent way. Inspired by a connection between the boundary analysis of the LW functional and embedding, we perform similar analysis for the 1-RDM theory for fermionic systems, which is also developed via convex duality, illustrating a relation to fermionic embedding methods such as the density matrix embedding theory (DMET).Another embedding method of note is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT), which is at the same time a Green's function method that can be understood in terms of the LW functional. DMFT relies on the solution of impurity problems, which specify the embedding of an interacting system into a non-interacting bath. Underlying DMFT is a result about the sparsity pattern of the self-energy matrix for impurity problems, which to our knowledge has not been proved in the literature. We provide a rigorous proof of this result in various classical and quantum settings. We go on to investigate the fermionic DMFT in depth, identifying the key mathematical structures that appear in the algorithmic loop for solving it and using these to prove the well-posedness of this loop, in a certain sense.Finally, we introduce a suite of new approaches to the quantum many-body problem that provide variational lower bounds to the ground-state energy. These methods, which combine the themes of convexity and embedding, are based on novel convex relaxations of the variational principles for the ground-state energies of many-body systems. To begin, we recover a second-quantized version of the formalism of strictly correlated electrons (SCE), which yields an exact expression for the exchange-correlation functional in Kohn-Sham density functional theory in the limit of infinite Coulomb repulsion in terms of the solution of a multi-marginal optimal transport problem. We introduce a semidefinite relaxation method for approximately solving this problem and obtaining a lower bound for the ground-state energy. The ideas underlying this relaxation are generalized considerably, outside the context of SCE, to yield much tighter lower bounds, which we validate numerically for both quantum spin systems and fermionic systems. We also describe how these relaxation methods can be interpreted as embedding methods via convex duality.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
We develop a causal optimization method that ensures causality in numerical calculations of Green's functions in interacting electron systems. Our method removes noncausality of numerical data by finding causal functions closest to the data. By testing our method with an exactly calculable model and applying it to practical dynamical mean-field calculations, we find that intermediate-frequency behaviors of Green's functions are determined solely by causality, and noncausal statistical errors are removed very efficiently. Furthermore, we demonstrate that numerical calculations of the physical branch of the Luttinger-Ward functional can be stabilized by ensuring causality of the noninteracting Green's function. Our method and findings provide a basis for improving stability and efficiency of numerical simulations of quantum many-body systems.
We develop a reliable parameter-free analytic continuation method for quantum many-body calculations. Our method is based on a kernel grid, a causal spline, a regularization using the second-derivative roughness penalty, and the L-curve criterion. We also develop the L-curve averaged deviation to estimate the precision of our analytic continuation. To deal with statistically obtained data more efficiently, we further develop a bootstrap-averaged analytic continuation method. In the test using the exact imaginary-frequency Green's function with added statistical error, our method produces the spectral function that converges systematically to the exact one as the statistical error decreases. As an application, we simulate the two-orbital Hubbard model for various electron numbers with the dynamical-mean field theory in the imaginary time and obtain the real-frequency self-energy with our analytic continuation method, clearly identifying a non-Fermi-liquid behavior as the electron number approaches the half filling from the quarter filling. Our analytic continuation can be used widely, and it will facilitate drawing clear conclusions from imaginary-time quantum many-body calculations.
Quantitative descriptions of strongly correlated materials pose a considerable challenge in condensed matter physics and chemistry. A promising approach to address this problem is quantum embedding methods. In particular, the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) maps the original system to an effective quantum impurity model comprising correlated orbitals embedded in an electron bath. The biggest bottleneck in DMFT calculations is numerically solving the quantum impurity model, i.e., computing the Green's function. Past studies have proposed theoretical methods to compute the Green's function of a quantum impurity model in polynomial time using a quantum computer. So far, however, efficient methods for computing the imaginary-time Green's functions have not been established despite the advantages of the imaginary-time formulation. We propose a quantum-classical hybrid algorithm for computing imaginary-time Green's functions on quantum devices with limited hardware resources by applying the variational quantum simulation. Using a quantum circuit simulator, we verified this algorithm by computing Green's functions for a dimer model as well as a four-site impurity model obtained by DMFT calculations of the single-band Hubbard model, although our method can be applied to general imaginary-time correlation functions.
This work contains a computationally efficient Green's function scheme for treating correlated electron-boson systems out of equilibrium. The numerical effort scales linearly with the simulation time, thus competing with that of the fastest quantum methods available. On a more fundamental level the proposed scheme fulfills energy balance as well as other fundamental conservation laws, and it can be systematically improved using standard many-body perturbation theory. We demonstrate its accuracy and stability through benchmarks against exact results in the Holstein model. However, our formulation equally applies to molecules and solids for first-principles transient calculations with quantum bosons, such as photons and phonons.
We present a method to obtain dynamical correlation functions of quantum many-body systems in the real-frequency domain from Monte Carlo data of the corresponding imaginary-time Green's functions. The method is based on a least-squares-fit procedure to solve the integral equation relating imaginary-time and real-frequency correlation functions. To demonstrate its feasibility, we have applied our method to imaginary-time Monte Carlo data for the density correlation function of a simple model of interacting spinless fermions in one dimension. We compare our results to the analytical results, available in the limits of zero and strong interaction. We find that despite the presence of noise in the input data, the real-frequency spectra obtained with our method are qualitatively correct. They reflect accurately the particle-hole and the soliton-antisoliton excitations, present in the noninteracting and in the strongly coupled fermion system, respectively. We also compare our method to other approaches that have been proposed for obtaining dynamical correlation functions via Monte Carlo simulation.
The imaginary-time Green's function is a building block of various numerical methods for correlated electron systems. Recently, it was shown that a model-independent compact orthogonal representation of the Green's function can be constructed by decomposing its spectral representation. We investigate the performance of this so-called intermediate representation (IR) from several points of view. First, we develop an efficient algorithm for computing the IR basis functions of arbitrary high degree. Second, for two simple models, we study the number of coefficients required to represent the Green's function within a given tolerance. We show that the number of coefficients grows only as $O(ln\ensuremath{\beta})$ for fermions and converges to a constant for bosons as temperature $T=1/\ensuremath{\beta}$ decreases. Third, we show that this remarkable feature is ascribed to the properties of the physically constructed basis functions. The fermionic basis functions on the real-frequency axis have features whose width is scaled as O(T)O(T)O(T), which is consistent with the low-TTT properties of quasiparticles in a Fermi liquid state. On the other hand, the properties of the bosonic basis functions are consistent with those of spin/orbital susceptibilities at low TTT. These results demonstrate the potential wide applications of the IR to calculations of correlated systems.
This dissertation concerns the quantum many-body problem, which is the problem of predicting the properties of systems of several quantum particles from the first principles of quantum mechanics. Included under this umbrella are various problems of fundamental importance in quantum chemistry, condensed matter physics, and materials science. Of particular interest is the electronic structure problem, the problem of determining the state of the electrons in a system with fixed atomic nuclei. Since direct numerical solution of the many-body Schrödinger equation is intractable even for systems of moderate size, a diverse array of approximate methods has been developed. The broad goals of this dissertation are to improve the mathematical understanding of certain widely-used approximations, as well as to propose new methods. Roughly speaking, we consider three (overlapping) categories of methods: Green's function methods, embedding methods, and variational methods.One can understand Green's function methods in terms of many-body perturbation theory, which computes series expansions of physical quantities about a non-interacting reference system. These expansions can be expressed graphically in terms of Feynman diagrams, which can in turn be reorganized, in some cases, into an expansion in terms of so-called bold diagrams. Green's function methods can be specified by choosing a subset of bold diagrams to approximate the sum. At the same time, such methods can be understood in terms of an object known as the Luttinger-Ward (LW) functional, which admits a representation in terms of the bold diagrams. Many aspects of these constructions are purely formal, and indeed the existence of the fermionic LW functional as a single-valued functional has recently been called into question. To contribute to the understanding of these issues, we provide rigorous proofs of the combinatorial construction and analytic interpretation of the bold diagrams in the simplified setting of a classical field theory. In this setting we also provide a rigorous non-perturbative construction of the LW functional via convex duality and prove several key properties, including continuity up to the boundary of its domain and asymptotics in the limit of large interaction.Quantum embedding methods, meanwhile, view a large system as being composed of smaller fragments that are treated with high accuracy and embedded in the larger system in a mutually consistent way. Inspired by a connection between the boundary analysis of the LW functional and embedding, we perform similar analysis for the 1-RDM theory for fermionic systems, which is also developed via convex duality, illustrating a relation to fermionic embedding methods such as the density matrix embedding theory (DMET).Another embedding method of note is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT), which is at the same time a Green's function method that can be understood in terms of the LW functional. DMFT relies on the solution of impurity problems, which specify the embedding of an interacting system into a non-interacting bath. Underlying DMFT is a result about the sparsity pattern of the self-energy matrix for impurity problems, which to our knowledge has not been proved in the literature. We provide a rigorous proof of this result in various classical and quantum settings. We go on to investigate the fermionic DMFT in depth, identifying the key mathematical structures that appear in the algorithmic loop for solving it and using these to prove the well-posedness of this loop, in a certain sense.Finally, we introduce a suite of new approaches to the quantum many-body problem that provide variational lower bounds to the ground-state energy. These methods, which combine the themes of convexity and embedding, are based on novel convex relaxations of the variational principles for the ground-state energies of many-body systems. To begin, we recover a second-quantized version of the formalism of strictly correlated electrons (SCE), which yields an exact expression for the exchange-correlation functional in Kohn-Sham density functional theory in the limit of infinite Coulomb repulsion in terms of the solution of a multi-marginal optimal transport problem. We introduce a semidefinite relaxation method for approximately solving this problem and obtaining a lower bound for the ground-state energy. The ideas underlying this relaxation are generalized considerably, outside the context of SCE, to yield much tighter lower bounds, which we validate numerically for both quantum spin systems and fermionic systems. We also describe how these relaxation methods can be interpreted as embedding methods via convex duality.