Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2108.10903

On the Luttinger-Ward functional and the convergence of skeleton diagrammatic series expansion of the self-energy for Hubbard-like models

Behnam Farid

Published Aug 24, 2021• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a number of questions regarding the Luttinger-Ward functional and the many-body perturbation series expansion of the proper self-energy $Σ(\mathbf{k};z)$ specific to uniform ground states (ensemble of states) of interacting fermion systems in terms of skeleton self-energy diagrams and the interacting Green function $G(\mathbf{k};z)$. Utilising a link between the latter series expansion and the classical moment problem (of the Hamburger type), along with the associated continued-fraction expansion, we reaffirm our earlier observation (2007) that for lattice models of fermions interacting through short-range two-body potentials (i.e. for Hubbard-like models) this series is uniformly convergent for almost all wave vectors $\mathbf{k}$ and complex energies $z$. The limit of this series is unique. We inquire into the reasons underlying the contrary observation by Kozik et al. (2015) regarding skeleton-diagrammatic perturbation series expansion of $Σ$. In doing so, we make a number of observations of general interest. Chief amongst these, we observe that contrary to general belief thermal correlation functions calculated in the energy domain (i.e. over the set of the relevant Matsubara frequencies) are generally unreliable, in contrast to those calculated in the imaginary-time domain. In an appendix we present a symbolic computational formalism and short programs for singling out topologically distinct proper self-energy diagrams that are algebraically equivalent up to determinate multiplicative constants. This complements the work presented in our previous publication (2019). [Abridged abstract]

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2108.10903

Related papers

Nonexistence of the Luttinger-Ward Functional and Misleading Convergence of Skeleton Diagrammatic Series for Hubbard-Like Models

Evgeny Kozik, Michel Ferrero, Antoine Georges

The Luttinger-Ward functional $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}[\mathbf{G}]$, which expresses the thermodynamic grand potential in terms of the interacting single-particle Green's function $\mathbf{G}$, is found to be ill defined for fermionic models with the Hubbard on-site interaction. In particular, we show that the self-energy $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}[\mathbf{G}]\ensuremath{\propto}\ensuremath{\delta}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}[\mathbf{G}]/\ensuremath{\delta}\mathbf{G}$ is not a single-valued functional of $\mathbf{G}$: in addition to the physical solution for $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}[\mathbf{G}]$, there exists at least one qualitatively distinct unphysical branch. This result is demonstrated for several models: the Hubbard atom, the Anderson impurity model, and the full two-dimensional Hubbard model. Despite this pathology, the skeleton Feynman diagrammatic series for $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ in terms of $\mathbf{G}$ is found to converge at least for moderately low temperatures. However, at strong interactions, its convergence is to the unphysical branch. This reveals a new scenario of breaking down of diagrammatic expansions. In contrast, the bare series in terms of the noninteracting Green's function ${\mathbf{G}}_{0}$ converges to the correct physical branch of $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ in all cases currently accessible by diagrammatic Monte Carlo calculations. In addition to their conceptual importance, these observations have important implications for techniques based on the explicit summation of the diagrammatic series.

arXiv:1407.5687•Physical Review Letters•Apr 15, 2015•162 citations

Many-body perturbation expansions without diagrams. I. Normal states

Behnam Farid

On the basis of an exact perturbational expression for the interacting one-particle Green function $G$ corresponding to bosons / fermions in terms of the bare interaction potential $v$ and permanents / determinants of the non-interacting one-particle Green function $G_0$, we deduce four recursive perturbation expansions for the self-energy $Σ$. With $W$ denoting the dynamic screened interaction potential, these perturbation expansions are identical to those of $Σ$ in terms of (i) self-energy diagrams and $(v, G_0)$, (ii) $G$-skeleton self-energy diagrams and $(v, G)$, (iii) $W$-skeleton self-energy diagrams and $(W, G_0)$, and (iv) $G$- and $W$-skeleton self-energy diagrams and $(W,G)$. For the calculation of $W$, we rely on a similar exact perturbational expression for the interacting two-particle Green function $G_2$ as for $G$. From this expression, we deduce four recursive perturbation expansions for the polarization function $P$, necessary for the calculation of $W$, that are similar to those for $Σ$ specified above. The correlation functions considered in this paper may be corresponding to ground states, and thermal ensemble of states. For thermal ensemble of states, we consider both the imaginary-time formalism of Matsubara, and the real-time formalism of thermo-field dynamics (TFD). The latter is advantageous for the direct calculation of dynamic correlation functions. In an appendix, we apply the formalisms presented in this paper to the Hubbard Hamiltonian for spin-$\tfrac{1}{2}$ fermions on a lattice in arbitrary $d$ spatial dimensions. In two further appendices, we present methods and short programs for determining the $ν$th-order diagrams corresponding to the perturbation expansions of $G$ in terms of $(v,G_0)$, and $Σ$ in terms of $(v,G_0)$ and $(v,G)$ on the basis of the cycle decompositions of the elements of the symmetric group $S_{2ν}$.

arXiv:1912.00474•Dec 1, 2019•4 citations

On the Luttinger theorem concerning number of particles in the ground states of systems of interacting fermions

Behnam Farid

We analyze the original proof by Luttinger and Ward of the Luttinger theorem, according to which for uniform ground states of systems of (interacting) fermions, which may be metallic or insulating, the number of k points corresponding to non-negative values of G_s(k;mu) is equal to the total number of particles with spin index s in these ground states. Here G_s(k;mu) is the single-particle Green function of particles with spin index s at the chemical potential mu. For the cases where the two-body interaction potential is short-range, and in particular for lattice models, we explicitly demonstrate that this theorem is unconditionally valid, irrespective of the strength of the bare interaction potential. We arrive at this conclusion by amongst other things demonstrating that the perturbation series expansion for self-energy in terms of skeleton diagrams, as encountered in the proof of the Luttinger-Ward identity, is uniformly convergent for almost all momenta and energies. We further investigate the mechanisms underlying some reported instances of failure of the Luttinger theorem. With one exception, for all the cases considered in this paper, we show that the apparent failures of the Luttinger theorem can be attributed either to shortcomings of the employed single-particle Green functions or to misapplication of this theorem. The one exceptional case brings to light the possibility of a genuine failure of the Luttinger theorem for insulating ground states, which we show to be brought about by a false limit that in principle can be reached on taking the zero-temperature limit without the value of mu coinciding with the zero-temperature limit of the chemical potential satisfying the equation of state at finite temperatures; no such ambiguity can arise for metallic states.

arXiv:0711.0952•Nov 6, 2007•14 citations

Comment on `Non-existence of the Luttinger-Ward functional and misleading convergence of skeleton diagrammatic series for Hubbard-like models'

R. Eder

The known analytical properties of the Green's function and self-energy rule out an ambiguity of the self-energy. The noninteracting Green's functions obtained by Kozik et al. in arXiv:1407.5687 likely have pathological properties.

arXiv:1407.6599•Jul 24, 2014•18 citations

Self-consistent Dyson equation and self-energy functionals: An analysis and illustration on the example of the Hubbard atom

Walter Tarantino, Pina Romaniello, J. A. Berger +1 more

Perturbation theory using self-consistent Green's functions is one of the most widely used approaches to study many-body effects in condensed matter. On the basis of general considerations and by performing analytical calculations for the specific example of the Hubbard atom, we discuss some key features of this approach. We show that when the domain of the functionals that are used to realize the map between the noninteracting and the interacting Green's functions is properly defined, there exists a class of self-energy functionals for which the self-consistent Dyson equation has only one solution, which is the physical one. We also show that manipulation of the perturbative expansion of the interacting Green's function may lead to a wrong self-energy as a functional of the interacting Green's function, at least for some regions of the parameter space. These findings confirm and explain numerical results of Kozik et al. for the widely used skeleton series of Luttinger and Ward [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 156402 (2015)]. Our study shows that it is important to distinguish between the maps between sets of functions and the functionals that realize those maps. We demonstrate that the self-consistent Green's functions approach itself is not problematic, whereas the functionals that are widely used may have a limited range of validity.

arXiv:1703.05587•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 18, 2017•55 citations

Some rigorous results concerning the uniform metallic ground states of single-band Hamiltonians in arbitrary dimensions

Behnam Farid

We reproduce and review some of the main results of three of our earlier papers, utilizing in doing so a considerably more transparent formalism than originally utilized. The most fundamental result to which we pay especial attention in this paper, is that the exact Fermi surface (FS) of the uniform metallic ground state (GS) of any single-band Hamiltonian, describing fermions, is a subset of the FS within the framework of the exact Hartree-Fock theory. We also review some of the physical implications of the latter result. Our considerations reveal that the interacting FS of a uniform metallic GS cannot be calculated exactly to order ν(ν\ge 2) in the coupling constant λof the interaction potential in terms of the self-energy calculated to order νin a non-self-consistent fashion. We show this to be interlinked with the failure of the Luttinger-Ward identity, and thus of the Luttinger theorem, for a self-energy that is not appropriately related to the single-particle Green function from which the FS is deduced. We further show that the same mechanism that embodies the Luttinger theorem within the framework of the exact theory, accounts for a non-trivial dependence of the exact self-energy on λthat cannot be captured within a non-self-consistent framework. We thus establish that the extant calculations that purportedly prove deformation of the interacting FS of the metallic GS of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian with respect to its Hartree-Fock counterpart at the second order in the on-site interaction energy U, are fundamentally deficient. In an appendix we show that the number-density distribution function, to be distinguished from the site-occupation distribution function, corresponding to the GS of the Hubbard Hamiltonian is not non-interacting v-representable, a fact established earlier numerically. [Abridged Abstract]

arXiv:1305.2089•May 9, 2013•3 citations
We consider a number of questions regarding the Luttinger-Ward functional and the many-body perturbation series expansion of the proper self-energy Σ(k;z)Σ(\mathbf{k};z)Σ(k;z) specific to uniform ground states (ensemble of states) of interacting fermion systems in terms of skeleton self-energy diagrams and the interacting Green function G(k;z)G(\mathbf{k};z)G(k;z). Utilising a link between the latter series expansion and the classical moment problem (of the Hamburger type), along with the associated continued-fraction expansion, we reaffirm our earlier observation (2007) that for lattice models of fermions interacting through short-range two-body potentials (i.e. for Hubbard-like models) this series is uniformly convergent for almost all wave vectors k\mathbf{k}k and complex energies zzz. The limit of this series is unique. We inquire into the reasons underlying the contrary observation by Kozik et al. (2015) regarding skeleton-diagrammatic perturbation series expansion of ΣΣΣ. In doing so, we make a number of observations of general interest. Chief amongst these, we observe that contrary to general belief thermal correlation functions calculated in the energy domain (i.e. over the set of the relevant Matsubara frequencies) are generally unreliable, in contrast to those calculated in the imaginary-time domain. In an appendix we present a symbolic computational formalism and short programs for singling out topologically distinct proper self-energy diagrams that are algebraically equivalent up to determinate multiplicative constants. This complements the work presented in our previous publication (2019). [Abridged abstract]
The Luttinger-Ward functional $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}[\mathbf{G}]$, which expresses the thermodynamic grand potential in terms of the interacting single-particle Green's function G\mathbf{G}G, is found to be ill defined for fermionic models with the Hubbard on-site interaction. In particular, we show that the self-energy $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}[\mathbf{G}]\ensuremath{\propto}\ensuremath{\delta}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}[\mathbf{G}]/\ensuremath{\delta}\mathbf{G}$ is not a single-valued functional of G\mathbf{G}G: in addition to the physical solution for $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}[\mathbf{G}]$, there exists at least one qualitatively distinct unphysical branch. This result is demonstrated for several models: the Hubbard atom, the Anderson impurity model, and the full two-dimensional Hubbard model. Despite this pathology, the skeleton Feynman diagrammatic series for $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ in terms of G\mathbf{G}G is found to converge at least for moderately low temperatures. However, at strong interactions, its convergence is to the unphysical branch. This reveals a new scenario of breaking down of diagrammatic expansions. In contrast, the bare series in terms of the noninteracting Green's function G0{\mathbf{G}}_{0}G0​ converges to the correct physical branch of $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ in all cases currently accessible by diagrammatic Monte Carlo calculations. In addition to their conceptual importance, these observations have important implications for techniques based on the explicit summation of the diagrammatic series.
On the basis of an exact perturbational expression for the interacting one-particle Green function GGG corresponding to bosons / fermions in terms of the bare interaction potential vvv and permanents / determinants of the non-interacting one-particle Green function G0G_0G0​, we deduce four recursive perturbation expansions for the self-energy ΣΣΣ. With WWW denoting the dynamic screened interaction potential, these perturbation expansions are identical to those of ΣΣΣ in terms of (i) self-energy diagrams and (v,G0)(v, G_0)(v,G0​), (ii) GGG-skeleton self-energy diagrams and (v,G)(v, G)(v,G), (iii) WWW-skeleton self-energy diagrams and (W,G0)(W, G_0)(W,G0​), and (iv) GGG- and WWW-skeleton self-energy diagrams and (W,G)(W,G)(W,G). For the calculation of WWW, we rely on a similar exact perturbational expression for the interacting two-particle Green function G2G_2G2​ as for GGG. From this expression, we deduce four recursive perturbation expansions for the polarization function PPP, necessary for the calculation of WWW, that are similar to those for ΣΣΣ specified above. The correlation functions considered in this paper may be corresponding to ground states, and thermal ensemble of states. For thermal ensemble of states, we consider both the imaginary-time formalism of Matsubara, and the real-time formalism of thermo-field dynamics (TFD). The latter is advantageous for the direct calculation of dynamic correlation functions. In an appendix, we apply the formalisms presented in this paper to the Hubbard Hamiltonian for spin-12\tfrac{1}{2}21​ fermions on a lattice in arbitrary ddd spatial dimensions. In two further appendices, we present methods and short programs for determining the νννth-order diagrams corresponding to the perturbation expansions of GGG in terms of (v,G0)(v,G_0)(v,G0​), and ΣΣΣ in terms of (v,G0)(v,G_0)(v,G0​) and (v,G)(v,G)(v,G) on the basis of the cycle decompositions of the elements of the symmetric group S2νS_{2ν}S2ν​.
We analyze the original proof by Luttinger and Ward of the Luttinger theorem, according to which for uniform ground states of systems of (interacting) fermions, which may be metallic or insulating, the number of k points corresponding to non-negative values of G_s(k;mu) is equal to the total number of particles with spin index s in these ground states. Here G_s(k;mu) is the single-particle Green function of particles with spin index s at the chemical potential mu. For the cases where the two-body interaction potential is short-range, and in particular for lattice models, we explicitly demonstrate that this theorem is unconditionally valid, irrespective of the strength of the bare interaction potential. We arrive at this conclusion by amongst other things demonstrating that the perturbation series expansion for self-energy in terms of skeleton diagrams, as encountered in the proof of the Luttinger-Ward identity, is uniformly convergent for almost all momenta and energies. We further investigate the mechanisms underlying some reported instances of failure of the Luttinger theorem. With one exception, for all the cases considered in this paper, we show that the apparent failures of the Luttinger theorem can be attributed either to shortcomings of the employed single-particle Green functions or to misapplication of this theorem. The one exceptional case brings to light the possibility of a genuine failure of the Luttinger theorem for insulating ground states, which we show to be brought about by a false limit that in principle can be reached on taking the zero-temperature limit without the value of mu coinciding with the zero-temperature limit of the chemical potential satisfying the equation of state at finite temperatures; no such ambiguity can arise for metallic states.
Perturbation theory using self-consistent Green's functions is one of the most widely used approaches to study many-body effects in condensed matter. On the basis of general considerations and by performing analytical calculations for the specific example of the Hubbard atom, we discuss some key features of this approach. We show that when the domain of the functionals that are used to realize the map between the noninteracting and the interacting Green's functions is properly defined, there exists a class of self-energy functionals for which the self-consistent Dyson equation has only one solution, which is the physical one. We also show that manipulation of the perturbative expansion of the interacting Green's function may lead to a wrong self-energy as a functional of the interacting Green's function, at least for some regions of the parameter space. These findings confirm and explain numerical results of Kozik et al. for the widely used skeleton series of Luttinger and Ward [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 156402 (2015)]. Our study shows that it is important to distinguish between the maps between sets of functions and the functionals that realize those maps. We demonstrate that the self-consistent Green's functions approach itself is not problematic, whereas the functionals that are widely used may have a limited range of validity.
We reproduce and review some of the main results of three of our earlier papers, utilizing in doing so a considerably more transparent formalism than originally utilized. The most fundamental result to which we pay especial attention in this paper, is that the exact Fermi surface (FS) of the uniform metallic ground state (GS) of any single-band Hamiltonian, describing fermions, is a subset of the FS within the framework of the exact Hartree-Fock theory. We also review some of the physical implications of the latter result. Our considerations reveal that the interacting FS of a uniform metallic GS cannot be calculated exactly to order ν(ν\ge 2) in the coupling constant λof the interaction potential in terms of the self-energy calculated to order νin a non-self-consistent fashion. We show this to be interlinked with the failure of the Luttinger-Ward identity, and thus of the Luttinger theorem, for a self-energy that is not appropriately related to the single-particle Green function from which the FS is deduced. We further show that the same mechanism that embodies the Luttinger theorem within the framework of the exact theory, accounts for a non-trivial dependence of the exact self-energy on λthat cannot be captured within a non-self-consistent framework. We thus establish that the extant calculations that purportedly prove deformation of the interacting FS of the metallic GS of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian with respect to its Hartree-Fock counterpart at the second order in the on-site interaction energy U, are fundamentally deficient. In an appendix we show that the number-density distribution function, to be distinguished from the site-occupation distribution function, corresponding to the GS of the Hubbard Hamiltonian is not non-interacting v-representable, a fact established earlier numerically. [Abridged Abstract]