Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2108.08849 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Field moment expansion method for interacting bosonic systems

Andrew Eberhardt, Michael Kopp, Alvaro Zamora, Tom Abel

Published Oct 5, 2021• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a numerical method and python package, chimes, that simulates quantum systems initially well approximated by mean field theory using a second order extension of the classical field approach. We call this the field moment expansion method. In this way, we can accurately approximate the evolution of first and second field moments beyond where the mean field theory breaks down. This allows us to estimate the quantum break time of a classical approximation without any calculations external to the theory. We investigate the accuracy of the field moment expansion using a number of well studied quantum test problems. Interacting bosonic systems similar to scalar field dark matter are chosen as test problems. We find that successful application of this method depends on two conditions: the quantum system must initially be well described by the classical theory, and the growth of the higher order moments must be hierarchical.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.104.083007

Related papers

Higher Order Corrections to the Mean-Field Description of the Dynamics of Interacting Bosons

Lea Boßmann, Nataša Pavlović, Peter Pickl +1 more

Abstract In this paper, we introduce a novel method for deriving higher order corrections to the mean-field description of the dynamics of interacting bosons. More precisely, we consider the dynamics of N $$d$$ d -dimensional bosons for large N. The bosons initially form a Bose–Einstein condensate and interact with each other via a pair potential of the form $$(N-1)^{-1}N^{d\beta }v(N^\beta \cdot )$$ (N-1)-1Ndβv(Nβ·) for $$\beta \in [0,\frac{1}{4d})$$ β∈[0,14d) . We derive a sequence of N-body functions which approximate the true many-body dynamics in $$L^2({\mathbb {R}}^{dN})$$ L2(RdN) -norm to arbitrary precision in powers of $$N^{-1}$$ N-1 . The approximating functions are constructed as Duhamel expansions of finite order in terms of the first quantised analogue of a Bogoliubov time evolution.

arXiv:1905.06164•Journal of Statistical Physics•Feb 21, 2020•22 citations

Numerical methods in non-perturbative quantum field theory

Paul Tognarelli

This thesis applies techniques of non-perturbative quantum field theory for solving both bosonic and fermionic systems dynamically on a lattice. The methods are first implemented in a bosonic system to examine the quantum decay of a scalar field oscillon in 2+1D. These configurations are a class of very long-lived, quasi-periodic, non-topological soliton. Classically, they last much longer than the natural timescales in the system, but gradually emit energy to eventually decay. Taking the oscillon to be the inhomogeneous, (quantum) mean field of a self-interacting scalar field enables an examination of the changes to the classical evolution in the presence of quantum fluctuations. The evolution is implemented through applying the Hartree approximation to the quantum dynamics. A statistical ensemble of fields replaces the quantum mode functions to calculate the quantum correlators in the dynamics. This offers the possibility for a reduction in the computational resources required to numerically evolve the system. The application of this method in determining the oscillon lifetimes, though, provides only a negligible gain in computational efficiency: likely due to the lack of any space or time averaging in measuring the lifetimes, and the low dimensionality. Evolving a Gaussian parameter-space of initial conditions enables comparing the classical and quantum evolution. The quantum fluctuations significantly reduce the lifetime compared to the classical case. Examining the evolution in the oscillatory frequency demonstrates the decay in the quantum system occurs gradually. This markedly contrasts the classical evolution where the oscillon frequency has been demonstrated to evolve to a critical frequency when the structure abruptly collapses. Despite the distinctly different evolution and lifetime, a similar range of the Gaussian initial conditions in both cases generates oscillons. This indicates the classical effects dominate the early evolution, and the quantum fluctuations most significantly alter the later decay. The methods are next implemented in a fermionic system to examine "tunnelling of the 3rd kind". This phenomenon is examined in the case where a uniform magnetic field propagates through a classical barrier by pair creation of fermions: these cross unimpeded through the barrier and annihilate to (re-)create the magnetic field in the classically shielded region. A statistical ensemble of fields, similarly to the oscillon simulations, is initially constructed for evaluating the fermionic contribution in the gauge field dynamics. This ensemble, importantly and in contrast to the bosonic case, involves two sets of fields to reproduce the anti-commuting nature of the fermion operator. The ensemble method, again, offers the possibility for a reduction in the computational resources required to evolve the system numerically. A test case indicates the method for the tunnelling system, though, requires impracticable computational resources. Using the symmetries in the system to construct an ansatz for the fields provides an alternative method to evolve the dynamics on a lattice. This procedure effectively reduces the system to a 1+1 dimensional problem with the fermion mode functions summed over the three-dimensional momentum space. The significant decrease in the real-time for the evolution (and quite attainable computational resources) on applying the ansatz provides a practical technique to examine the tunnelling. Measuring the magnetic field in the classically shielded region confirms the analytic estimates. These (qualitatively) reproduced the exponential decrease estimated in the classical transmission on varying the interaction strength between the barrier and the magnetic field. The observed tunnelling signal, moreover, matches the perturbative, analytic estimate within the expected correction in the lattice configuration. These bosonic and fermionic quantum, dynamical simulations demonstrate limitations to the benefits in applying the ensemble method. The highly practical and successful tunnelling computations, in contrast, indicate the potential power of a suitable ansatz to significantly reduce the computational times in simulations on a lattice.

•Dec 14, 2017•0 citations

Quantum corrections to the dynamics of interacting bosons: Beyond the truncated Wigner approximation

Anatoli Polkovnikov

We develop a consistent perturbation theory in quantum fluctuations around the classical evolution of a system of interacting bosons. The zero-order approximation gives the classical Gross-Pitaevskii equations. In the next order we recover the truncated Wigner approximation, where the evolution is still classical but the initial conditions are distributed according to the Wigner transform of the initial density matrix. Further corrections can be characterized as quantum scattering events, which appear in the form of a nonlinear response of the observable to an infinitesimal displacement of the field along its classical evolution. At the end of the paper we give a few numerical examples to test the formalism.

arXiv:cond-mat/0303628•Physical Review A•Nov 4, 2003•137 citations

Real-time quantum evolution in the classical approximation and beyond

Antonio González-arroyo A, Fermín Nuevo

With the goal in mind of deriving a method to compute quantum corrections for the real-time evolution in quantum field theory, we analyze the problem from the perspective of the Wigner function. We argue that this provides the most natural way to justify and extend the classical approximation. A simple proposal is presented that can allow us to give systematic quantum corrections to the evolution of expectation values and/or an estimate of the errors committed when using the classical approximation. The method is applied to the case of a few degrees of freedom and compared with other methods and with the exact quantum results. An analysis of the dependence of the numerical effort involved as a function of the number of variables is given, which allows us to be optimistic about its applicability in a quantum field theoretical context.

arXiv:1205.2715•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 5, 2012•2 citations

Multi-Mode Quantum Synchronization

Lotte van Dongen

The dynamics of interacting many-particle systems on quantum mechanical scale is a broad subject of research in modern physics. The understanding of the quantum correlations, or entanglement, between the particles in an isolated many-body quantum system may however be challenging, as the amount of interactions may be large. To be able to describe the system in a simpler way, mean field theory is often applied; the interactions of all individual particles are substituted by an averaged effect. First and second order mean field approximations are applied to the equations of motion of the amplitudes <ân> for each mode of the many-body system. In first order mean field, under the assumption that each mode has the same magnitude of the (constant) amplitude, the Kuramoto equation follows for the phases of the complex amplitudes. To study this first order approximation and to refine the mean field solution, the equations of motion have been extended to second order mean field. After that, numerical integration is used to solve the system of coupled differential equations for two modes. The solutions seem unstable, which is verified by defining quantum fluctuations beyond mean field. These are shown not to be negligible for a two mode system.It was discovered that the mean field equations of motion show divergent fluctuations for a system of two modes, which opens a whole set of questions on the validity of the first order mean field approximation and therefore the use of the Kuramoto model for quantum many-body dynamics. The extension to the second order mean field solution might be promising as this does include correlations between the operators.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Single classical field description of interacting scalar fields

Andrew Eberhardt, Alvaro Zamora, Michael Kopp +1 more

We test the degree to which interacting Bosonic systems can be approximated by a classical field as total occupation number is increased. This is done with our publicly available code repository, QIBS, a new massively parallel solver for these systems. We use a number of toy models well studied in the literature and track when the classical field description admits quantum corrections, called the quantum breaktime. This allows us to test claims in the literature regarding the rate of convergence of these systems to the classical evolution. We test a number of initial conditions, including coherent states, number eigenstates, and field number states. We find that of these initial conditions, only number eigenstates do not converge to the classical evolution as occupation number is increased. We find that systems most similar to scalar field dark matter exhibit a logarithmic enhancement in the quantum breaktime with total occupation number. Systems with contact interactions or with field number state initial conditions, and linear dispersions, exhibit a power law enhancement. Finally, we find that the breaktime scaling depends on both model interactions and initial conditions.

arXiv:2111.00050•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Feb 22, 2022•8 citations
We introduce a numerical method and python package, chimes, that simulates quantum systems initially well approximated by mean field theory using a second order extension of the classical field approach. We call this the field moment expansion method. In this way, we can accurately approximate the evolution of first and second field moments beyond where the mean field theory breaks down. This allows us to estimate the quantum break time of a classical approximation without any calculations external to the theory. We investigate the accuracy of the field moment expansion using a number of well studied quantum test problems. Interacting bosonic systems similar to scalar field dark matter are chosen as test problems. We find that successful application of this method depends on two conditions: the quantum system must initially be well described by the classical theory, and the growth of the higher order moments must be hierarchical.
Abstract In this paper, we introduce a novel method for deriving higher order corrections to the mean-field description of the dynamics of interacting bosons. More precisely, we consider the dynamics of N ddd d -dimensional bosons for large N. The bosons initially form a Bose–Einstein condensate and interact with each other via a pair potential of the form (N−1)−1Ndβv(Nβ⋅)(N-1)^{-1}N^{d\beta }v(N^\beta \cdot )(N−1)−1Ndβv(Nβ⋅) (N-1)-1Ndβv(Nβ·) for β∈[0,14d)\beta \in [0,\frac{1}{4d})β∈[0,4d1​) β∈[0,14d) . We derive a sequence of N-body functions which approximate the true many-body dynamics in L2(RdN)L^2({\mathbb {R}}^{dN})L2(RdN) L2(RdN) -norm to arbitrary precision in powers of N−1N^{-1}N−1 N-1 . The approximating functions are constructed as Duhamel expansions of finite order in terms of the first quantised analogue of a Bogoliubov time evolution.
This thesis applies techniques of non-perturbative quantum field theory for solving both bosonic and fermionic systems dynamically on a lattice. The methods are first implemented in a bosonic system to examine the quantum decay of a scalar field oscillon in 2+1D. These configurations are a class of very long-lived, quasi-periodic, non-topological soliton. Classically, they last much longer than the natural timescales in the system, but gradually emit energy to eventually decay. Taking the oscillon to be the inhomogeneous, (quantum) mean field of a self-interacting scalar field enables an examination of the changes to the classical evolution in the presence of quantum fluctuations. The evolution is implemented through applying the Hartree approximation to the quantum dynamics. A statistical ensemble of fields replaces the quantum mode functions to calculate the quantum correlators in the dynamics. This offers the possibility for a reduction in the computational resources required to numerically evolve the system. The application of this method in determining the oscillon lifetimes, though, provides only a negligible gain in computational efficiency: likely due to the lack of any space or time averaging in measuring the lifetimes, and the low dimensionality. Evolving a Gaussian parameter-space of initial conditions enables comparing the classical and quantum evolution. The quantum fluctuations significantly reduce the lifetime compared to the classical case. Examining the evolution in the oscillatory frequency demonstrates the decay in the quantum system occurs gradually. This markedly contrasts the classical evolution where the oscillon frequency has been demonstrated to evolve to a critical frequency when the structure abruptly collapses. Despite the distinctly different evolution and lifetime, a similar range of the Gaussian initial conditions in both cases generates oscillons. This indicates the classical effects dominate the early evolution, and the quantum fluctuations most significantly alter the later decay. The methods are next implemented in a fermionic system to examine "tunnelling of the 3rd kind". This phenomenon is examined in the case where a uniform magnetic field propagates through a classical barrier by pair creation of fermions: these cross unimpeded through the barrier and annihilate to (re-)create the magnetic field in the classically shielded region. A statistical ensemble of fields, similarly to the oscillon simulations, is initially constructed for evaluating the fermionic contribution in the gauge field dynamics. This ensemble, importantly and in contrast to the bosonic case, involves two sets of fields to reproduce the anti-commuting nature of the fermion operator. The ensemble method, again, offers the possibility for a reduction in the computational resources required to evolve the system numerically. A test case indicates the method for the tunnelling system, though, requires impracticable computational resources. Using the symmetries in the system to construct an ansatz for the fields provides an alternative method to evolve the dynamics on a lattice. This procedure effectively reduces the system to a 1+1 dimensional problem with the fermion mode functions summed over the three-dimensional momentum space. The significant decrease in the real-time for the evolution (and quite attainable computational resources) on applying the ansatz provides a practical technique to examine the tunnelling. Measuring the magnetic field in the classically shielded region confirms the analytic estimates. These (qualitatively) reproduced the exponential decrease estimated in the classical transmission on varying the interaction strength between the barrier and the magnetic field. The observed tunnelling signal, moreover, matches the perturbative, analytic estimate within the expected correction in the lattice configuration. These bosonic and fermionic quantum, dynamical simulations demonstrate limitations to the benefits in applying the ensemble method. The highly practical and successful tunnelling computations, in contrast, indicate the potential power of a suitable ansatz to significantly reduce the computational times in simulations on a lattice.
We develop a consistent perturbation theory in quantum fluctuations around the classical evolution of a system of interacting bosons. The zero-order approximation gives the classical Gross-Pitaevskii equations. In the next order we recover the truncated Wigner approximation, where the evolution is still classical but the initial conditions are distributed according to the Wigner transform of the initial density matrix. Further corrections can be characterized as quantum scattering events, which appear in the form of a nonlinear response of the observable to an infinitesimal displacement of the field along its classical evolution. At the end of the paper we give a few numerical examples to test the formalism.
With the goal in mind of deriving a method to compute quantum corrections for the real-time evolution in quantum field theory, we analyze the problem from the perspective of the Wigner function. We argue that this provides the most natural way to justify and extend the classical approximation. A simple proposal is presented that can allow us to give systematic quantum corrections to the evolution of expectation values and/or an estimate of the errors committed when using the classical approximation. The method is applied to the case of a few degrees of freedom and compared with other methods and with the exact quantum results. An analysis of the dependence of the numerical effort involved as a function of the number of variables is given, which allows us to be optimistic about its applicability in a quantum field theoretical context.
The dynamics of interacting many-particle systems on quantum mechanical scale is a broad subject of research in modern physics. The understanding of the quantum correlations, or entanglement, between the particles in an isolated many-body quantum system may however be challenging, as the amount of interactions may be large. To be able to describe the system in a simpler way, mean field theory is often applied; the interactions of all individual particles are substituted by an averaged effect. First and second order mean field approximations are applied to the equations of motion of the amplitudes <ân> for each mode of the many-body system. In first order mean field, under the assumption that each mode has the same magnitude of the (constant) amplitude, the Kuramoto equation follows for the phases of the complex amplitudes. To study this first order approximation and to refine the mean field solution, the equations of motion have been extended to second order mean field. After that, numerical integration is used to solve the system of coupled differential equations for two modes. The solutions seem unstable, which is verified by defining quantum fluctuations beyond mean field. These are shown not to be negligible for a two mode system.It was discovered that the mean field equations of motion show divergent fluctuations for a system of two modes, which opens a whole set of questions on the validity of the first order mean field approximation and therefore the use of the Kuramoto model for quantum many-body dynamics. The extension to the second order mean field solution might be promising as this does include correlations between the operators.
We test the degree to which interacting Bosonic systems can be approximated by a classical field as total occupation number is increased. This is done with our publicly available code repository, QIBS, a new massively parallel solver for these systems. We use a number of toy models well studied in the literature and track when the classical field description admits quantum corrections, called the quantum breaktime. This allows us to test claims in the literature regarding the rate of convergence of these systems to the classical evolution. We test a number of initial conditions, including coherent states, number eigenstates, and field number states. We find that of these initial conditions, only number eigenstates do not converge to the classical evolution as occupation number is increased. We find that systems most similar to scalar field dark matter exhibit a logarithmic enhancement in the quantum breaktime with total occupation number. Systems with contact interactions or with field number state initial conditions, and linear dispersions, exhibit a power law enhancement. Finally, we find that the breaktime scaling depends on both model interactions and initial conditions.