Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2107.13996 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Superconductivity in the bilayer Hubbard model: Two Fermi surfaces are better than one

Seher Karakuzu, Steven Johnston, Thomas Maier

Published Dec 6, 2021• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Fully occupied or unoccupied bands in a solid are often considered inert and irrelevant to a material's low-energy properties. But the discovery of enhanced superconductivity in heavily electron-doped FeSe-derived superconductors poses questions about the possible role of incipient bands (those laying close to but not crossing the Fermi level) in pairing. To answer this question, researchers have studied pairing correlations in the bilayer Hubbard model, which has an incipient band for large interlayer hopping ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}$, using many-body perturbation theory and variational methods. They have generally found that superconductivity is enhanced as one of the bands approaches the Lifshitz transition and even when it becomes incipient. Here we address this question using the nonperturbative quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) to study the bilayer Hubbard model's pairing correlations. We find that the model has robust ${s}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$ pairing correlations in the large ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}$ limit, which can become stronger as one band is made incipient. While this behavior is linked to changes in the effective interaction, we further find that it is counteracted by a suppression of the intrinsic pair-field susceptibility and does not translate to an increased ${T}_{c}$. Our results demonstrate that the highest achievable transition temperatures in the bilayer Hubbard model occur when the system has two bands crossing the Fermi level.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.104.245109

Related papers

Enhancing Tc in a composite superconductor/metal bilayer system: A dynamical cluster approximation study

Philip M. Dee, Steven Johnston, Thomas Maier

It has been proposed that the superconducting transition temperature ${T}_{\text{c}}$ of an unconventional superconductor with a large pairing scale but strong phase fluctuations can be enhanced by coupling it to a metal. However, the general efficacy of this approach across different parameter regimes remains an open question. Using the dynamical cluster approximation, we study this question in a system composed of an attractive Hubbard layer in the intermediate coupling regime, where the magnitude of the attractive Coulomb interaction $|U|$ is slightly larger than the bandwidth $W$, hybridized with a noninteracting metallic layer. We find that while the superconducting transition becomes more mean-field-like with increasing interlayer hopping, the superconducting transition temperature ${T}_{\text{c}}$ exhibits a nonmonotonic dependence on the strength of the hybridization ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}$. This behavior arises from a reduction of the effective pairing interaction in the correlated layer that outcompetes the growth in the intrinsic pair-field susceptibility induced by the coupling to the metallic layer. We find that the largest ${T}_{\text{c}}$ inferred here for the composite system is comparable to the maximum value currently estimated for the isolated negative-$U$ Hubbard model.

arXiv:2203.05669•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 3, 2022•11 citations

Pair structure and the pairing interaction in a bilayer Hubbard model for unconventional superconductivity

Thomas Maier, Douglas J. Scalapino

The bilayer Hubbard model with an intralayer hopping $t$ and an interlayer hopping ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}$ provides an interesting testing ground for several aspects of what has been called unconventional superconductivity. One can study the type of pair structures which arise when there are multiple Fermi surfaces. One can also examine the pairing for a system in which the structure of the spin-fluctuation spectral weight can be changed. Using a dynamic cluster quantum Monte Carlo approximation, we find that near half filling, if the splitting between the bonding and antibonding bands ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}/t$ is small, the gap has ${B}_{1g}$ (${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave) symmetry, but when the splitting becomes larger, ${A}_{1g}$ (${s}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$-wave) pairing is favored. We also find that in the ${s}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$ pairing region, the pairing is driven by interlayer spin fluctuations and that ${T}_{c}$ is enhanced.

arXiv:1107.0401•Physical Review B•Nov 28, 2011•88 citations

Superconducting landscape of the strongly correlated bilayer Hubbard model

Motoharu Kitatani, Yusuke Nomura, 志朗 酒井 +1 more

Coupling two strongly correlated layers opens a distinct route to repulsion-driven superconductivity. Yet the same interlayer coupling makes the optimization of superconductivity highly nontrivial. Using the dynamical vertex approximation, we determine the superconducting landscape in the enlarged parameter space spanned by filling and interlayer hopping. We identify an optimal regime at intermediate interlayer hopping and moderate doping away from half filling, where the system exhibits high superconducting transition temperatures ($T_{\rm c}$) with an interband $s_{\pm}$-wave gap structure. Toward half filling, however, strong self-energy effects can suppress the superconducting tendency by reducing the low-energy spectral weight. We further show that a Fermi-surface distortion induced by longer-range hoppings can weaken this suppression and enhance $T_{\rm c}$. Our results establish how filling, interlayer hopping, and Fermi-surface geometry jointly optimize the superconducting regime in the strongly correlated bilayer Hubbard model.

arXiv:2610.04855•Oct 4, 2026•0 citations

Theoretical study of spin-fluctuation-mediated superconductivity in two-dimensional Hubbard models with an incipient flat band

Tetsuaki Aida, Karin Matsumoto, Daisuke Ogura +2 more

One promising way to enhance superconductivity is to have coexisting wide and incipient narrow bands, where the Fermi level intersecting the wide band lies just above the narrow band, by which finite-energy spin fluctuations act as glue to mediate pair scattering. As an extreme case of the narrow band dispersion, we investigate spin-fluctuation-mediated superconductivity in two-dimensional Hubbard models with an incipient flat band. For all of the systems investigated in this study, the Kagome, Lieb, and bilayer square lattices with a flat band, we find that spin-singlet pairing superconductivity is enhanced when the flat band is nearly fully filled, due to the interband pair scattering even when the flat band becomes dispersive by correlation effects. Among these models, enhancement of superconductivity is weak in the Lieb lattice, possibly because the density of states of the wide band goes to zero at the Dirac point where the flat and wide bands intersect. Also, when the electron density is smaller so that the flat band approaches half-filling, ferromagnetic spin fluctuations and spin-triplet pairing arises, which does not develop strongly compared to the case of the spin-singlet pairing for the incipient band situation.

arXiv:2408.10465•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 19, 2024•9 citations

Magnetic and transport properties of a coupled Hubbard bilayer with electron and hole doping

Karim Bouadim, G. G. Batrouni, F. Hébert +1 more

The single band, two-dimensional Hubbard Hamiltonian has been extensively studied as a model for high temperature superconductivity. While quantum Monte Carlo simulations within the dynamic cluster approximation are now providing considerable evidence for a $d$-wave superconducting state at low temperature, such a transition remains well out of reach of finite lattice simulations because of the ``sign problem.'' We show here that a bilayer Hubbard model, in which one layer is electron doped and one layer is hole doped, can be studied to lower temperatures and exhibits an interesting signal of $d$-wave pairing. The results of our simulations bear resemblance to a recent report on the magnetic and superconducting properties of ${\mathrm{Ba}}_{2}{\mathrm{Ca}}_{3}{\mathrm{Cu}}_{4}{\mathrm{O}}_{8}{\mathrm{F}}_{2}$ which contains both electron and hole doped $\mathrm{Cu}{\mathrm{O}}_{2}$ planes. We also explore the phase diagram of bilayer models in which each sheet is at half-filling.

arXiv:0802.0909•Physical Review B•Apr 30, 2008•48 citations

Superconductivity in the two-dimensional Hubbard model

J. Beenen, David M. Edwards

Quasiparticle bands of the two-dimensional Hubbard model are calculated using the Roth two-pole approximation to the one-particle Green's function. Excellent agreement is obtained with recent Monte Carlo calculations, including an anomalous volume of the Fermi surface near half-filling, which can possibly be explained in terms of a breakdown of Fermi liquid theory. The calculated bands are very flat around the (\ensuremath{\pi},0) points of the Brillouin zone in agreement with photoemission measurements of cuprate superconductors. With doping there is a shift in spectral weight from the upper band to the lower band. The Roth method is extended to deal with superconductivity within a four-pole approximation allowing electron-hole mixing. It is shown that triplet p-wave pairing never occurs. A self-consistent solution with singlet ${\mathit{d}}_{{\mathit{x}}^{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}{\mathit{y}}^{2}}$-wave pairing is found and optimal doping occurs when the van Hove singularity, corresponding to the flat band part, lies at the Fermi level. Nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic correlations play an important role in flattening the bands near the Fermi level and in favoring superconductivity. However, the mechanism for superconductivity is a local one, in contrast to spin-fluctuation exchange models. For reasonable values of the hopping parameter the transition temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ is in the range 10--100 K. The optimum doping ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\delta}}}_{\mathit{c}}$ lies between 0.14 and 0.25, depending on the ratio U/t. The gap equation has a BCS-like form and 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathrm{max}}$/${\mathit{kT}}_{\mathit{c}}$\ensuremath{\simeq}4.

arXiv:cond-mat/9503054•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 1, 1995•109 citations
Fully occupied or unoccupied bands in a solid are often considered inert and irrelevant to a material's low-energy properties. But the discovery of enhanced superconductivity in heavily electron-doped FeSe-derived superconductors poses questions about the possible role of incipient bands (those laying close to but not crossing the Fermi level) in pairing. To answer this question, researchers have studied pairing correlations in the bilayer Hubbard model, which has an incipient band for large interlayer hopping t\ensuremath⊥{t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}t\ensuremath⊥​, using many-body perturbation theory and variational methods. They have generally found that superconductivity is enhanced as one of the bands approaches the Lifshitz transition and even when it becomes incipient. Here we address this question using the nonperturbative quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) to study the bilayer Hubbard model's pairing correlations. We find that the model has robust s\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi{s}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}s\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi pairing correlations in the large t\ensuremath⊥{t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}t\ensuremath⊥​ limit, which can become stronger as one band is made incipient. While this behavior is linked to changes in the effective interaction, we further find that it is counteracted by a suppression of the intrinsic pair-field susceptibility and does not translate to an increased Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. Our results demonstrate that the highest achievable transition temperatures in the bilayer Hubbard model occur when the system has two bands crossing the Fermi level.
It has been proposed that the superconducting transition temperature Tc{T}_{\text{c}}Tc​ of an unconventional superconductor with a large pairing scale but strong phase fluctuations can be enhanced by coupling it to a metal. However, the general efficacy of this approach across different parameter regimes remains an open question. Using the dynamical cluster approximation, we study this question in a system composed of an attractive Hubbard layer in the intermediate coupling regime, where the magnitude of the attractive Coulomb interaction ∣U∣|U|∣U∣ is slightly larger than the bandwidth WWW, hybridized with a noninteracting metallic layer. We find that while the superconducting transition becomes more mean-field-like with increasing interlayer hopping, the superconducting transition temperature Tc{T}_{\text{c}}Tc​ exhibits a nonmonotonic dependence on the strength of the hybridization ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}$. This behavior arises from a reduction of the effective pairing interaction in the correlated layer that outcompetes the growth in the intrinsic pair-field susceptibility induced by the coupling to the metallic layer. We find that the largest Tc{T}_{\text{c}}Tc​ inferred here for the composite system is comparable to the maximum value currently estimated for the isolated negative-UUU Hubbard model.
The bilayer Hubbard model with an intralayer hopping ttt and an interlayer hopping ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}$ provides an interesting testing ground for several aspects of what has been called unconventional superconductivity. One can study the type of pair structures which arise when there are multiple Fermi surfaces. One can also examine the pairing for a system in which the structure of the spin-fluctuation spectral weight can be changed. Using a dynamic cluster quantum Monte Carlo approximation, we find that near half filling, if the splitting between the bonding and antibonding bands ${t}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}/t$ is small, the gap has B1g{B}_{1g}B1g​ (${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave) symmetry, but when the splitting becomes larger, A1g{A}_{1g}A1g​ (${s}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$-wave) pairing is favored. We also find that in the ${s}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$ pairing region, the pairing is driven by interlayer spin fluctuations and that Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is enhanced.
Coupling two strongly correlated layers opens a distinct route to repulsion-driven superconductivity. Yet the same interlayer coupling makes the optimization of superconductivity highly nontrivial. Using the dynamical vertex approximation, we determine the superconducting landscape in the enlarged parameter space spanned by filling and interlayer hopping. We identify an optimal regime at intermediate interlayer hopping and moderate doping away from half filling, where the system exhibits high superconducting transition temperatures (TcT_{\rm c}Tc​) with an interband s±s_{\pm}s±​-wave gap structure. Toward half filling, however, strong self-energy effects can suppress the superconducting tendency by reducing the low-energy spectral weight. We further show that a Fermi-surface distortion induced by longer-range hoppings can weaken this suppression and enhance TcT_{\rm c}Tc​. Our results establish how filling, interlayer hopping, and Fermi-surface geometry jointly optimize the superconducting regime in the strongly correlated bilayer Hubbard model.
One promising way to enhance superconductivity is to have coexisting wide and incipient narrow bands, where the Fermi level intersecting the wide band lies just above the narrow band, by which finite-energy spin fluctuations act as glue to mediate pair scattering. As an extreme case of the narrow band dispersion, we investigate spin-fluctuation-mediated superconductivity in two-dimensional Hubbard models with an incipient flat band. For all of the systems investigated in this study, the Kagome, Lieb, and bilayer square lattices with a flat band, we find that spin-singlet pairing superconductivity is enhanced when the flat band is nearly fully filled, due to the interband pair scattering even when the flat band becomes dispersive by correlation effects. Among these models, enhancement of superconductivity is weak in the Lieb lattice, possibly because the density of states of the wide band goes to zero at the Dirac point where the flat and wide bands intersect. Also, when the electron density is smaller so that the flat band approaches half-filling, ferromagnetic spin fluctuations and spin-triplet pairing arises, which does not develop strongly compared to the case of the spin-singlet pairing for the incipient band situation.
The single band, two-dimensional Hubbard Hamiltonian has been extensively studied as a model for high temperature superconductivity. While quantum Monte Carlo simulations within the dynamic cluster approximation are now providing considerable evidence for a ddd-wave superconducting state at low temperature, such a transition remains well out of reach of finite lattice simulations because of the ``sign problem.'' We show here that a bilayer Hubbard model, in which one layer is electron doped and one layer is hole doped, can be studied to lower temperatures and exhibits an interesting signal of ddd-wave pairing. The results of our simulations bear resemblance to a recent report on the magnetic and superconducting properties of Ba2Ca3Cu4O8F2{\mathrm{Ba}}_{2}{\mathrm{Ca}}_{3}{\mathrm{Cu}}_{4}{\mathrm{O}}_{8}{\mathrm{F}}_{2}Ba2​Ca3​Cu4​O8​F2​ which contains both electron and hole doped CuO2\mathrm{Cu}{\mathrm{O}}_{2}CuO2​ planes. We also explore the phase diagram of bilayer models in which each sheet is at half-filling.
Quasiparticle bands of the two-dimensional Hubbard model are calculated using the Roth two-pole approximation to the one-particle Green's function. Excellent agreement is obtained with recent Monte Carlo calculations, including an anomalous volume of the Fermi surface near half-filling, which can possibly be explained in terms of a breakdown of Fermi liquid theory. The calculated bands are very flat around the (\ensuremath{\pi},0) points of the Brillouin zone in agreement with photoemission measurements of cuprate superconductors. With doping there is a shift in spectral weight from the upper band to the lower band. The Roth method is extended to deal with superconductivity within a four-pole approximation allowing electron-hole mixing. It is shown that triplet p-wave pairing never occurs. A self-consistent solution with singlet ${\mathit{d}}_{{\mathit{x}}^{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}{\mathit{y}}^{2}}$-wave pairing is found and optimal doping occurs when the van Hove singularity, corresponding to the flat band part, lies at the Fermi level. Nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic correlations play an important role in flattening the bands near the Fermi level and in favoring superconductivity. However, the mechanism for superconductivity is a local one, in contrast to spin-fluctuation exchange models. For reasonable values of the hopping parameter the transition temperature Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ is in the range 10--100 K. The optimum doping ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\delta}}}_{\mathit{c}}$ lies between 0.14 and 0.25, depending on the ratio U/t. The gap equation has a BCS-like form and 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathrm{max}}$/kTc{\mathit{kT}}_{\mathit{c}}kTc​\ensuremath{\simeq}4.