Gapless fracton phases are characterized by the conservation of certain charges and their higher moments. These charges generically couple to higher rank gauge fields. In this paper we study systems conserving charge and dipole moment, and construct the corresponding gauge fields propagating in arbitrary curved backgrounds. The relation between the symmetries of these class of systems and spacetime transformations is discussed. In fact, we argue that higher rank symmetric gauge theories are closer to gravitational fields than to a standard gauge theory.
Gapless fracton phases are characterized by the conservation of certain charges and their higher moments. These charges generically couple to higher rank gauge fields. In this paper we study systems conserving charge and dipole moment, and construct the corresponding gauge fields propagating in arbitrary curved backgrounds. The relation between the symmetries of these class of systems and spacetime transformations is discussed. In fact, we argue that higher rank symmetric gauge theories are closer to gravitational fields than to a standard gauge theory.
Fracton theories possess exponentially degenerate ground states, excitations with restricted mobility, and nontopological higher-form symmetries. This paper shows that such theories can be defined on arbitrary spatial lattices in three dimensions. The key element of this construction is a generalization of higher-form gauge theories to so-called Fp gauge theories, in which gauge transformations of rank-k fields are specified by rank-(k−p) gauge parameters. The Z2 rank-two theory of type F2, placed on a cubic lattice and coupled to scalar matter, is shown to have a topological phase exactly dual to the well-known X-cube model. Generalizations of this example yield novel fracton theories. In the continuum, the U(1) rank-two theory of type F2 is shown to have a perturbatively gapless fracton regime that cannot be consistently interpreted as a tensor gauge theory of any kind. The compact scalar fields that naturally couple to this F2 theory also show gapless fracton behavior; on a cubic lattice they have a conserved U(1) charge and dipole moment, but these particular charges are not necessarily conserved on more general lattices. The construction straightforwardly generalizes to F2 theories of nonabelian rank-two gauge fields, giving first examples of pure nonabelian higher-rank theories.
Fractonic phases are new phases of matter that host excitations with restricted mobility. We show that a certain class of gapless fractonic phases are realized as a result of spontaneous breaking of continuous higher-form symmetries whose conserved charges do not commute with spatial translations. We refer to such symmetries as nonuniform higher-form symmetries. These symmetries fall within the standard definition of higher-form symmetries in quantum field theory, and the corresponding symmetry generators are topological. Worldlines of particles are regarded as the charged objects of 1-form symmetries, and mobility restrictions can be implemented by introducing additional 1-form symmetries whose generators do not commute with spatial translations. These features are realized by effective field theories associated with spontaneously broken nonuniform 1-form symmetries. At low energies, the theories reduce to known higher-rank gauge theories such as scalar/vector charge gauge theories, and the gapless excitations in these theories are interpreted as Nambu-Goldstone modes for higher-form symmetries. Due to the nonuniformity of the symmetry, some of the modes acquire a gap, which is the higher-form analogue of the inverse Higgs mechanism of spacetime symmetries. The gauge theories have emergent nonuniform magnetic symmetries, and some of the magnetic monopoles become fractonic. We identify the ’t Hooft anomalies of the nonuniform higher-form symmetries and the corresponding bulk symmetry-protected topological phases. By this method, the mobility restrictions are fully determined by the choice of the commutation relations of charges with translations. This approach allows us to view existing (gapless) fracton models such as the scalar/vector charge gauge theories and their variants from a unified perspective and enables us to engineer theories with desired mobility restrictions.
The objective of the present work -- a literature review on both gapped and gapless fractonic theories -- is to pedagogically fill in the gaps between the research on fractons, and an undergraduate physics education (particularly quantum and statistical mechanics). Some familiarity with classical field theory is assumed. We will begin this work by reviewing the gauging of the Ising model to obtain the toric code. Then, following the chronological order of fracton research, we will establish the gauged spin model picture of gapped fracton theories. Next (after introducing lattice gauge theory) we will cover the developments on the tensor gauge theory front in describing gapless fracton theories. We then explain how conservation of dipole moment is key in the development of field-theoretic descriptions of fracton models, and conclude by providing future plans for work on gauging such field theories. Finally, we point out two more future plans: one being an established theoretical advance which in fact inspired this work, and the other being exciting experimental advances in ultracold atomic physics which could lead to the physical realization of fracton physics. Highlights of this work include: a derivation of the gauge field dynamics (field strength/curvature) term in the gauging of a spin system to obtain the toric code, a reduction of the 3 terms of the Kogut-Susskind lattice QED Hamiltonian to the 2 terms of the toric code, a proof of the correspondence between the invariance of a gauge field and a particular Gauss's law constraint in a tensor gauge theory context, a demonstration that conservation of dipole moment accounts for the same immobility/fractalization phenomenology that we also show from a gauged spin model perspective, and proof of the necessity for polynomial shift symmetries and higher-order spatial derivatives in a Lagrangian in order to have dipole moment conservation.
FINDING: Fractonic Chern-Simons theory extends topological gauge theory to higher-rank symmetric tensor gauge fields, enabling fracton phases with restricted mobility and subdimensional topological order. | MATH: Higher-rank gauge fields: Aij (symmetric tensor) with gauge transformation δAij=∂i∂jα; fractonic Chern-Simons action: S=4πk∫ϵμνρAμ∂νAρ generalized to higher-rank; fracton charge conservation: ∂i∂jJij=0; dipole moment conservation: ∫xiρ constant. | CONNECTION: Crystallographic group symmetries (e.g., cubic, hexagonal) constrain allowed higher-rank tensor gauge fields; lattice structures (e.g., square, triangular) yield subdimensional particle mobility; no direct golden ratio or base-60 link found. | DEPTH: 8 — Fractonic Chern-Simons theory unifies higher-rank gauge theory with topological order, revealing new quantum phase Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
This thesis summarizes my efforts to bridging the gap between two recently proposed classes of topological matter: higher-order topological insulators (HOTI) and fracton phases of matter.Getting a clear understanding of these systems will answer fundamental questions about the effects of symmetry and topology in quantum materials and open doors to novel devices.In particular, fracton states have the potential to serve as building blocks for quantum hard drives and logic elements, and HOTIs can exhibit robust electronic modes and electromagnetic responses.These classes of quantum phases are unified by the existence of additional conservation laws, e.g., conservation of the electric dipole moment.In HOTI phases dipole conservation is typically a ground-state property that allows the system to have a well-defined electric quadrupole moment which generates protected electronic states and/or fractional charge localized at the corners of a sample.In fracton phases, dipole conservation is a microscopic conservation law that greatly constrains the motion of individual charges around the system.In both cases, the added conservation laws are often tied to symmetries of the underlying lattices, which in turn places crystalline symmetries at the forefront of my research.This thesis argues that the connections between the two classes of theories are not superficial and in fact, should be thought of as instances of a broader class of vector charge theories.To demonstrate that, I mainly focus on two setups: the first one, where the dynamical degrees of freedom carry an electric dipole moment instead of a familiar electric charge, and the second one, where the vector charge is a momentum of an electronic state in a WSM with a specific Weyl node configuration.While both of these scenarios provide an excellent ground for developing an intuition about theories with a vector-like charge, it should be clear that the physics is very different in both of these cases.However, I will show that, upon their realization on the lattice, the low energy response theories in both of these setups have a very similar underlying mathematical structure.The vector charges naturally couple to exotic background fields expressed as symmetric tensors of rank 2. This thesis provides a comprehensive review of these results.I was lucky to spend six years studying, teaching, and doing research at the University of Illinois.This was a time of immense intellectual and personal growth which I will cherish for the rest of my life.First and foremost, I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my advisor, Taylor L. Hughes, who always managed to provide me with just the right mix of guidance and creative freedom to keep me enjoying working on research.I am tremendously indebted to Taylor for giving me an opportunity to work on a variety of ambitious projects, which influenced the way I set my own goals now.He also put me in contact with the broader community of condensed matter physicists which allowed me to meet many brilliant researchers along my academic path.It would be impossible for me to finish this thesis without constant help and support from many people.I have learned my ropes in science from a community of mathematicians and physicists working at the Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Physics in Moscow.ITEP's never-ending seminars and constant interaction with other students, postdocs, and senior scientists taught me that science has a flat structure and the best ideas sometimes come from an afternoon chat over a cup of tea.I am indebted to my advisors, Alexander Gorsky and Anatoly Dymarsky who taught me how broad the entire field of theoretical physics is and how many exciting questions there are to ponder over.
We extend recent work on hydrodynamics with global multipolar symmetries — known as “fracton hydrodynamics” — to systems in which the multipolar symmetries are gauged. We refer to the latter as “fracton magnetohydrodynamics”, in analogy to conventional magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), which governs systems with gauged charge conservation. We show that fracton MHD arises naturally from higher-rank Maxwell’s equations and in systems with one-form symmetries obeying certain constraints; while we focus on “minimal” higher-rank generalizations of MHD that realize diffusion, our methods may also be used to identify other, more exotic hydrodynamic theories (e.g., with magnetic subdiffusion). In contrast to semi-microscopic derivations of MHD, our approach elucidates the origin of the hydrodynamic modes by identifying the corresponding higher-form symmetries. Being rooted in symmetries, the hydrodynamic modes may persist even when the semi-microscopic equations no longer provide an accurate description of the system.