Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.15487 · Foundations of Physics

Becoming Large, Becoming Infinite: The Anatomy of Thermal Physics and Phase Transitions in Finite Systems

David A. Lavis, Reimer Kühn, Roman Frigg

Published Sep 7, 2021• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract This paper presents an in-depth analysis of the anatomy of both thermodynamics and statistical mechanics, together with the relationships between their constituent parts. Based on this analysis, using the renormalization group and finite-size scaling, we give a definition of a large but finite system and argue that phase transitions are represented correctly, as incipient singularities in such systems. We describe the role of the thermodynamic limit. And we explore the implications of this picture of critical phenomena for the questions of reduction and emergence.

DOI
10.1007/s10701-021-00482-5

Related papers

Phase Transitions, Critical Phenomena, and Finite-Size Scaling

Hans-Peter Eckle

Abstract Interacting many-particle systems may undergo phase transitions and exhibit critical phenomena in the limit of infinite system size, while the precursors of these phenomena are studied in the theory of finite-size scaling. After surveying the basic notions of phases, phase diagrams, and phase transitions, this chapter focuses on critical behaviour at a second-order phase transition. The Landau-Ginzburg theory and the concept of scaling prepare readers for an elementary introduction to the concepts of the renormalization group, followed by an introduction into the field of quantum phase transitions where quantum fluctuations take over the role of thermal fluctuations.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 25, 2019•0 citations

Statistical Mechanics and Critical Phenomena: A Brief Overview

S. B. Santra, Purusattam Ray

The basic concepts of statistical mechanics and its application to many-body systems, phase transitions and critical phenomena will be discussed briefly in this chapter. We will be using these ideas frequently in the subsequent lectures. Statistical mechanics describes the thermodynamic behaviour of macroscopic systems from the laws which govern the behaviour of the constituent elements at the microscopic level. The microscopic elements can be atoms, molecules, dipole moments or magnetic moments, etc. A macroscopic system is generally composed of a large number of these elements (of the order of Avogadro number N A ≈ 6.022 × 1023 per mole). Each element may have a large number of internal degrees of freedom associated with different types of motion such as translation, rotation, vibration etc. The constituent elements may interact with the external field applied to the system. There can also be very complex interaction among the constituent elements. The macroscopic properties of a system in the thermodynamic limit is thus determined by the properties of the constituent molecules, their interaction with external field as well as interaction among themselves. For a system of N elements, volume V and density ρ, the thermodynamic limit is defined as lim N → ∞, lim V → ∞ keeping ρ = N/V finite. In this limit, the extensive properties of the system become directly proportional to the size of the system (N or V), while the intensive properties become independent of the size of the system.

Texts and readings in physical sciences•Jan 1, 2011•2 citations

The Onset of Phase Transitions in Finite Systems

E. Brézin

Abstract In finite systems singularities, such as discontinuities or divergences, associated with phase transitions are rounded. The extrapolation of finite size calculations to the singular thermodynamic limit makes use of scaling laws, introduced by Fisher, which involve the size of the system. The use and the theoretical basis of these laws are briefly reviewed here; some difficulties associated with the analytic calculation of the scaling functions are discussed. The correct treatment of zero‐momentum modes leads to a modified renormalization group picture; above the upper critical dimension (u.c.d.) finite size scaling does not hold but the properties of the finite system are easily calculable; below the u.c.d. the scaling functions are obtained in a systematic expansion in fractional powers of ϵ = 4–d. The rounding of first order transitions is also briefly considered; in spite of the lack of universality of the bulk transition itself, the rounding is universal because the correlation length of the finite system is large.

Physikalische Blätter•Jul 1, 1986•28 citations

Thermodynamic renormalization group

Hiroshi Matsuoka

For a system with a first or second order phase transition at ${\mathit{T}}^{\mathrm{*}}$, we construct a type of renormalization group transformation that maps the reduced temperature t=(T-${\mathit{T}}^{\mathrm{*}}$)/${\mathit{T}}^{\mathrm{*}}$ and the external field h for a system of volume V to t\ensuremath{'} and h\ensuremath{'} for another system of volume V\ensuremath{'}. Our construction is purely thermodynamic without reference to effective Hamiltonians. Using the transformation, we derive the finite size scaling form for the singular part of the free energy, which leads to the scaling laws in the thermodynamic limit. We thus provide a unified thermodynamic framework for phase transitions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Mar 1, 1996•0 citations

CLASSIFICATION THEORY FOR PHASE TRANSITIONS

Rudolf Hilfer A

A refined classification theory for phase transitions in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics in terms of their orders is introduced and analyzed. The refined thermodynamic classification is based on two independent generalizations of Ehrenfests traditional classification scheme. The statistical mechanical classification theory is based on generalized limit theorems for sums of random variables from probability theory and the newly defined block ensemble limit. The block ensemble limit combines thermodynamic and scaling limits and is similar to the finite size scaling limit. The statistical classification scheme allows for the first time a derivation of finite size scaling without renormalization group methods. The classification distinguishes two fundamentally different types of phase transitions. Phase transitions of order λ>1 correspond to well known equilibrium phase transitions, while phase transitions with order λ<1 represent a new class of transitions termed anequilibrium transitions. The generalized order λ varies inversely with the strength of fluctuations. First order and second order transitions play a special role in both classification schemes. First order transitions represent a limiting case separating equilibrium and anequilibrium transitions. The special role or second order transitions is shown to be related to the breakdown of hyperscaling. For anequilibrium transitions the nature of the heat bath in the canonical ensemble becomes important.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Nov 30, 1993•18 citations

Finite-size analysis of first-order phase transitions: Discrete and continuous symmetries

John Cardy, Peter Nightingale

First-order phase transitions are characterized by $\ensuremath{\delta}$-function singularities in thermodynamic quantities. The way in which these singularities develop in taking the thermodynamic limit is qualitatively different for finite systems and systems infinite in one direction only. The corresponding crossover behavior, which we predict in detail with a renormalization-group analysis, is a unique feature of first-order transitions and is suggested to be of considerable utility. Both systems with discrete and continuous symmetries are discussed. For the latter we verify our results for the two geometries within the spin-wave approximation.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 1, 1983•56 citations
Abstract This paper presents an in-depth analysis of the anatomy of both thermodynamics and statistical mechanics, together with the relationships between their constituent parts. Based on this analysis, using the renormalization group and finite-size scaling, we give a definition of a large but finite system and argue that phase transitions are represented correctly, as incipient singularities in such systems. We describe the role of the thermodynamic limit. And we explore the implications of this picture of critical phenomena for the questions of reduction and emergence.
Abstract Interacting many-particle systems may undergo phase transitions and exhibit critical phenomena in the limit of infinite system size, while the precursors of these phenomena are studied in the theory of finite-size scaling. After surveying the basic notions of phases, phase diagrams, and phase transitions, this chapter focuses on critical behaviour at a second-order phase transition. The Landau-Ginzburg theory and the concept of scaling prepare readers for an elementary introduction to the concepts of the renormalization group, followed by an introduction into the field of quantum phase transitions where quantum fluctuations take over the role of thermal fluctuations.
The basic concepts of statistical mechanics and its application to many-body systems, phase transitions and critical phenomena will be discussed briefly in this chapter. We will be using these ideas frequently in the subsequent lectures. Statistical mechanics describes the thermodynamic behaviour of macroscopic systems from the laws which govern the behaviour of the constituent elements at the microscopic level. The microscopic elements can be atoms, molecules, dipole moments or magnetic moments, etc. A macroscopic system is generally composed of a large number of these elements (of the order of Avogadro number N A ≈ 6.022 × 1023 per mole). Each element may have a large number of internal degrees of freedom associated with different types of motion such as translation, rotation, vibration etc. The constituent elements may interact with the external field applied to the system. There can also be very complex interaction among the constituent elements. The macroscopic properties of a system in the thermodynamic limit is thus determined by the properties of the constituent molecules, their interaction with external field as well as interaction among themselves. For a system of N elements, volume V and density ρ, the thermodynamic limit is defined as lim N → ∞, lim V → ∞ keeping ρ = N/V finite. In this limit, the extensive properties of the system become directly proportional to the size of the system (N or V), while the intensive properties become independent of the size of the system.
Abstract In finite systems singularities, such as discontinuities or divergences, associated with phase transitions are rounded. The extrapolation of finite size calculations to the singular thermodynamic limit makes use of scaling laws, introduced by Fisher, which involve the size of the system. The use and the theoretical basis of these laws are briefly reviewed here; some difficulties associated with the analytic calculation of the scaling functions are discussed. The correct treatment of zero‐momentum modes leads to a modified renormalization group picture; above the upper critical dimension (u.c.d.) finite size scaling does not hold but the properties of the finite system are easily calculable; below the u.c.d. the scaling functions are obtained in a systematic expansion in fractional powers of ϵ = 4–d. The rounding of first order transitions is also briefly considered; in spite of the lack of universality of the bulk transition itself, the rounding is universal because the correlation length of the finite system is large.
For a system with a first or second order phase transition at T∗{\mathit{T}}^{\mathrm{*}}T∗, we construct a type of renormalization group transformation that maps the reduced temperature t=(T-T∗{\mathit{T}}^{\mathrm{*}}T∗)/T∗{\mathit{T}}^{\mathrm{*}}T∗ and the external field h for a system of volume V to t\ensuremath{'} and h\ensuremath{'} for another system of volume V\ensuremath{'}. Our construction is purely thermodynamic without reference to effective Hamiltonians. Using the transformation, we derive the finite size scaling form for the singular part of the free energy, which leads to the scaling laws in the thermodynamic limit. We thus provide a unified thermodynamic framework for phase transitions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
A refined classification theory for phase transitions in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics in terms of their orders is introduced and analyzed. The refined thermodynamic classification is based on two independent generalizations of Ehrenfests traditional classification scheme. The statistical mechanical classification theory is based on generalized limit theorems for sums of random variables from probability theory and the newly defined block ensemble limit. The block ensemble limit combines thermodynamic and scaling limits and is similar to the finite size scaling limit. The statistical classification scheme allows for the first time a derivation of finite size scaling without renormalization group methods. The classification distinguishes two fundamentally different types of phase transitions. Phase transitions of order λ>1 correspond to well known equilibrium phase transitions, while phase transitions with order λ<1 represent a new class of transitions termed anequilibrium transitions. The generalized order λ varies inversely with the strength of fluctuations. First order and second order transitions play a special role in both classification schemes. First order transitions represent a limiting case separating equilibrium and anequilibrium transitions. The special role or second order transitions is shown to be related to the breakdown of hyperscaling. For anequilibrium transitions the nature of the heat bath in the canonical ensemble becomes important.
First-order phase transitions are characterized by $\ensuremath{\delta}$-function singularities in thermodynamic quantities. The way in which these singularities develop in taking the thermodynamic limit is qualitatively different for finite systems and systems infinite in one direction only. The corresponding crossover behavior, which we predict in detail with a renormalization-group analysis, is a unique feature of first-order transitions and is suggested to be of considerable utility. Both systems with discrete and continuous symmetries are discussed. For the latter we verify our results for the two geometries within the spin-wave approximation.