Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.09138

Comment on "Steady-State Coherences by Composite System-Bath Interactions"

Marco Cattaneo, Gonzalo Manzano

Published Jun 16, 2021• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent Letter, Guarnieri et al. [1] reported on the possibility of generating steady-state coherence (SSC) in the energy basis of a two-level system by the sole action of a single thermal bath also for weak system-bath coupling and due to a composite form of this interaction. The results are based on a time-local Bloch-Redfield master equation without secular approximation and the associated set of Bloch equations, all derived in the Supplemental Material (SM) of Ref. [1]. We comment that the results reported by the authors present both technical flaws and conceptual limitations that substantially impact some of their main conclusions. Our objections mainly concern (a) technical errors in the calculation of SSC (Eqs.(2)-(4) in [1]) and (b) negativity issues associated with the weak-coupling master equation employed by the authors.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2106.09138

Related papers

Steady-State Coherences by Composite System-Bath Interactions

Giacomo Guarnieri, Michal Kolář, Radim Filip

We identify sufficient conditions on the structure of the interaction Hamiltonian between a two-level quantum system and a thermal bath that, without any external drive or coherent measurement, guarantee the generation of steady-state coherences (SSC). The SSC obtained this way, remarkably, turn out to be independent of the initial state of the system, which could therefore be taken as initially incoherent. We characterize in detail this phenomenon, first analytically in the weak coupling regime for two paradigmatic models, and then numerically in more complex systems without any assumption on the coupling strength. In all of these cases, we find that SSC become increasingly significant as the bath is cooled down. These results can be directly verified in many experimental platforms.

arXiv:1802.08283•Physical Review Letters•Aug 15, 2018•96 citations

Enhanced steady-state coherence via repeated system-bath interactions

R. Román-Ancheyta, Michal Kolář, Giacomo Guarnieri +1 more

The appearance of steady-state coherence (SSC) from system-bath interactions proves that quantum effects can appear without an external drive. Such SSC could become a resource to demonstrate a quantum advantage in the applications. We predict the generation of SSC if the target system repeatedly interacts with independent and noncorrelated bath elements. To describe their behavior, we use the collision model approach of system-bath interactions, where the system interacts with one bath element (initially in an incoherent state) at a time, asymptotically (in the fast-collision regime) mimicking a macroscopic Markovian bath coupled to the target system. Therefore, the SSC qualitatively appears to be the same as if the continuous Markovian bath were used. We confirm that the presence of composite system-bath interactions under the rotating-wave approximation is the necessary condition for the generation of SSC using thermal resources in collision models. Remarkably, we show that SSC substantially increases if the target system interacts collectively with more than one bath element at a time. A few bath elements collectively interacting with the target system is sufficient to increase SSC at nonzero temperatures at the cost of a tolerable lowering of the final state purity. From the thermodynamic perspective, the SSC generation in our collision models is inevitably linked to a nonzero power input (and thus heat dissipated to the bath) necessary to reach the steady state, although such energetic cost can be lower compared to cases relying on SSC nongenerating interactions.

arXiv:2008.05200•Physical Review A•Dec 22, 2021•30 citations

Steady state coherence in a qubit is incompatible with a quantum map

Hans C. Fogedby

We consider the recent proposal of steady state coherences in a single qubit in the case of a composite system-bath interaction. Based on a field theoretical approach we reanalyse the issue within a Redfield description. We find that the Redfield approach in accordance with a recent proposal yields steady state coherences but also violates the properties of a quantum map yielding negative populations. The issue is resolved by applying the Lindblad equation which is in accordance with a proper quantum map. The Lindblad equation, however, also implies the absence of steady state coherence. We conclude that steady state coherence in a a qubit is incompatible with a quantum map.

quant-pharXiv:2602.15790•Feb 18, 2026•0 citations

Fundamental limitations in Lindblad descriptions of systems weakly coupled to baths

Devashish Tupkary, Abhishek Dhar, Manas Kulkarni +1 more

It is very common in the literature to write a Markovian quantum master equation in Lindblad form to describe a system with multiple degrees of freedom and weakly connected to multiple thermal baths which can, in general, be at different temperatures and chemical potentials. However, the microscopically derived quantum master equation up to leading order in a system-bath coupling is of the so-called Redfield form, which is known to not preserve complete positivity in most cases. Additional approximations to the Redfield equation are required to obtain a Lindblad form. We lay down some fundamental requirements for any further approximations to the Redfield equation, which, if violated, leads to physical inconsistencies such as inaccuracies in the leading order populations and coherences in the energy eigenbasis, violation of thermalization, and violation of local conservation laws at the nonequilibrium steady state. We argue that one or more of these conditions will generically be violated in all the weak system-bath-coupling Lindblad descriptions existing in the literature to our knowledge. As an example, we study the recently derived universal Lindblad equation and use these conditions to show the violation of local conservation laws due to inaccurate coherences but accurate populations in the energy eigenbasis. Finally, we exemplify our analytical results numerically in an interacting open quantum spin system.

arXiv:2105.12091•Physical Review A•Mar 16, 2022•93 citations

Local coherence by thermalized intra-system coupling

Michal Kolář, Radim Filip

Abstract Quantum superposition of energy eigenstates can appear autonomously in a single quantum two-level system coupled to a low-temperature thermal bath, if such coupling has a proper composite nature. We propose here a principally different and more feasible approach employing engineered interactions between two-level systems being thermalized into a global Gibbs state by weakly coupled thermal bath at temperature T. Therefore, in such case quantum coherence appears by a different mechanism, whereas the system-bath coupling does not have to be engineered. We demonstrate such autonomous coherence generation reaching maximum values of coherence. Moreover, it can be alternatively built up by using weaker but collective interaction with several two-level systems. This approach surpasses the coherence generated by the engineered system-bath coupling for comparable interaction strengths and directly reduces phase estimation error in quantum sensing. This represents a necessary step towards the autonomous quantum sensing.

arXiv:2211.08851•Quantum Science and Technology•Jun 13, 2024•5 citations

Tunable steady-state coherence via composite system–environment interactions beyond weak tunnel coupling

Ming He, Yuyan Weng, Shijie Xu +1 more

We study a two-level system with an additional tunneling effect, where the general interaction with an Ohmic-class spectrum can be controlled by adjusting the coupling angle. We outline the derivation of the time-local microscopic non-Markovian master equation after renormalizing the eigenstates in the two-level system, hence removing the restriction of weak tunneling coupling. Further, two quantum coherence measures are exploited to analyze steady-state coherences (SSC). We identify that under strong tunneling effects, a specific coupling angle enables SSC generation that is both independent of the Ohmic-like spectral density and capable of reaching substantial magnitudes. Moreover, in the vicinity of this critical angle, SSC exhibits an opposite dependence on the Ohmic parameter in different regions. In addition, we examine the impact of Ohmic parameters and environmental temperature on SSC, demonstrating that optimizing these factors provides an effective strategy to maximize SSC.

International Journal of Modern Physics C•May 2, 2025•0 citations
In a recent Letter, Guarnieri et al. [1] reported on the possibility of generating steady-state coherence (SSC) in the energy basis of a two-level system by the sole action of a single thermal bath also for weak system-bath coupling and due to a composite form of this interaction. The results are based on a time-local Bloch-Redfield master equation without secular approximation and the associated set of Bloch equations, all derived in the Supplemental Material (SM) of Ref. [1]. We comment that the results reported by the authors present both technical flaws and conceptual limitations that substantially impact some of their main conclusions. Our objections mainly concern (a) technical errors in the calculation of SSC (Eqs.(2)-(4) in [1]) and (b) negativity issues associated with the weak-coupling master equation employed by the authors.
We identify sufficient conditions on the structure of the interaction Hamiltonian between a two-level quantum system and a thermal bath that, without any external drive or coherent measurement, guarantee the generation of steady-state coherences (SSC). The SSC obtained this way, remarkably, turn out to be independent of the initial state of the system, which could therefore be taken as initially incoherent. We characterize in detail this phenomenon, first analytically in the weak coupling regime for two paradigmatic models, and then numerically in more complex systems without any assumption on the coupling strength. In all of these cases, we find that SSC become increasingly significant as the bath is cooled down. These results can be directly verified in many experimental platforms.
The appearance of steady-state coherence (SSC) from system-bath interactions proves that quantum effects can appear without an external drive. Such SSC could become a resource to demonstrate a quantum advantage in the applications. We predict the generation of SSC if the target system repeatedly interacts with independent and noncorrelated bath elements. To describe their behavior, we use the collision model approach of system-bath interactions, where the system interacts with one bath element (initially in an incoherent state) at a time, asymptotically (in the fast-collision regime) mimicking a macroscopic Markovian bath coupled to the target system. Therefore, the SSC qualitatively appears to be the same as if the continuous Markovian bath were used. We confirm that the presence of composite system-bath interactions under the rotating-wave approximation is the necessary condition for the generation of SSC using thermal resources in collision models. Remarkably, we show that SSC substantially increases if the target system interacts collectively with more than one bath element at a time. A few bath elements collectively interacting with the target system is sufficient to increase SSC at nonzero temperatures at the cost of a tolerable lowering of the final state purity. From the thermodynamic perspective, the SSC generation in our collision models is inevitably linked to a nonzero power input (and thus heat dissipated to the bath) necessary to reach the steady state, although such energetic cost can be lower compared to cases relying on SSC nongenerating interactions.
We consider the recent proposal of steady state coherences in a single qubit in the case of a composite system-bath interaction. Based on a field theoretical approach we reanalyse the issue within a Redfield description. We find that the Redfield approach in accordance with a recent proposal yields steady state coherences but also violates the properties of a quantum map yielding negative populations. The issue is resolved by applying the Lindblad equation which is in accordance with a proper quantum map. The Lindblad equation, however, also implies the absence of steady state coherence. We conclude that steady state coherence in a a qubit is incompatible with a quantum map.
It is very common in the literature to write a Markovian quantum master equation in Lindblad form to describe a system with multiple degrees of freedom and weakly connected to multiple thermal baths which can, in general, be at different temperatures and chemical potentials. However, the microscopically derived quantum master equation up to leading order in a system-bath coupling is of the so-called Redfield form, which is known to not preserve complete positivity in most cases. Additional approximations to the Redfield equation are required to obtain a Lindblad form. We lay down some fundamental requirements for any further approximations to the Redfield equation, which, if violated, leads to physical inconsistencies such as inaccuracies in the leading order populations and coherences in the energy eigenbasis, violation of thermalization, and violation of local conservation laws at the nonequilibrium steady state. We argue that one or more of these conditions will generically be violated in all the weak system-bath-coupling Lindblad descriptions existing in the literature to our knowledge. As an example, we study the recently derived universal Lindblad equation and use these conditions to show the violation of local conservation laws due to inaccurate coherences but accurate populations in the energy eigenbasis. Finally, we exemplify our analytical results numerically in an interacting open quantum spin system.
Abstract Quantum superposition of energy eigenstates can appear autonomously in a single quantum two-level system coupled to a low-temperature thermal bath, if such coupling has a proper composite nature. We propose here a principally different and more feasible approach employing engineered interactions between two-level systems being thermalized into a global Gibbs state by weakly coupled thermal bath at temperature T. Therefore, in such case quantum coherence appears by a different mechanism, whereas the system-bath coupling does not have to be engineered. We demonstrate such autonomous coherence generation reaching maximum values of coherence. Moreover, it can be alternatively built up by using weaker but collective interaction with several two-level systems. This approach surpasses the coherence generated by the engineered system-bath coupling for comparable interaction strengths and directly reduces phase estimation error in quantum sensing. This represents a necessary step towards the autonomous quantum sensing.
We study a two-level system with an additional tunneling effect, where the general interaction with an Ohmic-class spectrum can be controlled by adjusting the coupling angle. We outline the derivation of the time-local microscopic non-Markovian master equation after renormalizing the eigenstates in the two-level system, hence removing the restriction of weak tunneling coupling. Further, two quantum coherence measures are exploited to analyze steady-state coherences (SSC). We identify that under strong tunneling effects, a specific coupling angle enables SSC generation that is both independent of the Ohmic-like spectral density and capable of reaching substantial magnitudes. Moreover, in the vicinity of this critical angle, SSC exhibits an opposite dependence on the Ohmic parameter in different regions. In addition, we examine the impact of Ohmic parameters and environmental temperature on SSC, demonstrating that optimizing these factors provides an effective strategy to maximize SSC.