Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.08221 · Physical Review Research

Constraints on probing quantum coherence to infer gravitational entanglement

Onur Hosten

Published Jan 10, 2022• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Finding a feasible scheme for testing the quantum mechanical nature of the gravitational interaction has been attracting an increasing level of attention. Gravity mediated entanglement generation so far appears to be the key ingredient for a potential experiment. In a recent proposal [D. Carney et al., PRX Quantum 2, 030330 (2021)] combining an atom interferometer with a low-frequency mechanical oscillator, a coherence revival test is proposed for verifying this entanglement generation. With measurements performed only on the atoms, this protocol bypasses the need for correlation measurements. Here, we explore formulations of such a protocol, and specifically find that in the envisioned regime of operation with high thermal excitation, semiclassical models, where there is no concept of entanglement, also give the same experimental signatures. We elucidate in a fully quantum mechanical calculation that entanglement is not the source of the revivals in the relevant parameter regime. We argue that, in its current form, the suggested test is only relevant if the oscillator is nearly in a pure quantum state, and in this regime the effects are too small to be measurable. We further discuss potential open ends. The results highlight the importance and subtleties of explicitly considering how the quantum case differs from the classical expectations when testing for the quantum mechanical nature of a physical system.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.4.013023

Related papers

Limits on inference of gravitational entanglement

Yue Ma, Thomas Guff, Gavin W. Morley +2 more

Combining gravity with quantum mechanics remains one of the biggest challenges of physics. In the past years, experiments with optomechanical systems have been proposed that may give indirect clues about the quantum nature of gravity. In a recent variation of such tests [Carney et al., PRX Quantum 2, 030330 (2021)], the authors propose to gravitationally entangle an atom interferometer with a mesoscopic oscillator. The interaction results in periodic drops and revivals of the interferometeric visibility, which under specific assumptions indicate the gravitational generation of entanglement. Here, we study semiclassical models of the atom interferometer that can reproduce the same effect. We show that the core signature---periodic collapses and revivals of the visibility---can appear if the atom is subject to a random unitary channel, including the case where the oscillator is fully classical and situations even without explicit modeling of the oscillator. We also show that the nonclassicality of the oscillator vanishes unless the system is very close to its ground state, and even when the system is in the ground state, the nonclassicality is limited by the coupling strength. Our results thus indicate that deducing entanglement from the proposed experiment is very challenging, since fulfilling and verifying the nonclassicality assumptions constitute a significant challenge in their own right.

arXiv:2111.00936•Physical Review Research•Jan 10, 2022•17 citations

On testing quantum gravity with interactive information sensing

Onur Hosten

We show that the atom interferometric coherence revival test suggested in [arXiv:2101.11629 [quant-ph] (2021)] does not test the quantum nature of the gravitational field when the atoms are coupled to a mechanical oscillator prepared in a thermal state. Specifically we clarify that the same coherence revivals take place in a model where the atoms are coupled to a classical oscillator through a classical gravitational field. We further elucidate the quantum mechanical calculation, showing that entanglement is not the source of the revivals. The suggested test is thus only relevant for pure initial quantum states of the oscillator. In this regime, numerical estimates show that it is unfeasible to do a test of the proposed type.

•Jun 15, 2021•1 citation

Beyond entanglement: Diagnosing quantum mediator dynamics in gravitationally mediated experiments

P. George Christopher, S. Shankaranarayanan

No experimental test to date has provided conclusive evidence on the quantum nature of gravity. Recent proposals, such as the Bose-Marletto-Vedral experiment, suggest that generating entanglement could serve as a direct test. Motivated by these proposals, we study a system of three-harmonic oscillator system, with the mediator oscillator operating in two distinct parameter regimes: a heavy mediator regime and a light mediator regime. These regimes induce qualitatively different entanglement dynamics between the terminal oscillators. Crucially, distinguishing these regimes experimentally remains challenging when relying solely on entanglement measures. We demonstrate that the dynamical fidelity susceptibility offers a viable and sensitive probe to contrast the regimes in practice. Our results provide testable signatures for optomechanical and trapped-ion platforms simulating gravitational interactions, and provide new avenues to characterize quantum-gravity-inspired systems beyond entanglement-based protocols.

arXiv:2506.04300•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Sep 30, 2025•0 citations

A New Approach for Testing the Quantum Nature of Gravity

Shan, Gao

The quantum nature of gravity is one of physics' greatest unsolved problems, with existing experimental proposals facing formidable challenges in maintaining spatial superpositions of massive objects against decoherence. We propose a fundamentally different approach that bypasses these difficulties. The central insight is that a quantum gravitational field can imprint a gauge-invariant phase on a particle's wavefunction even along an open trajectory, arising from the quantum backreaction of the source. This phase, which manifests prior to the final recombination stage of an interferometer and cannot be generated by a classical gravitational field, provides an operationally direct witness to the quantumness of gravity. Our experimental design uses a single photon whose accumulated gravitational phase due to the Earth is transferred via absorption to auxiliary atoms near the end of the interferometer sequence, preserving the open-path character essential for the test. We scale the interferometer to yield a detectable phase of order $10^{-3}$ rad and show how non-local correlation measurements on the atoms can access this gauge-invariant signature. Leveraging established quantum optical and atomic techniques, this proposal offers a feasible path to distinguish quantum from classical gravity. A positive result would provide the first experimental evidence for the quantum nature of gravitational fields, with profound implications for quantum gravity theories.

•Nov 8, 2025•2 citations

Using an Atom Interferometer to Infer Gravitational Entanglement Generation

Daniel Carney, Holger Müller, Jacob M. Taylor

If gravitational perturbations are quantized into gravitons in analogy with the electromagnetic field and photons, the resulting graviton interactions should lead to an entangling interaction between massive objects.We suggest a test of this prediction.To do this, we introduce the concept of interactive quantum information sensing.This novel sensing protocol is tailored to provable verification of weak dynamical entanglement generation between a pair of systems.We show that this protocol is highly robust to typical thermal noise sources.Moreover, the sensitivity can be increased both using an initial thermal state and/or an initial phase of entangling via a nongravitational interaction.We outline a concrete implementation testing the ability of the gravitational field to generate entanglement between an atomic interferometer and a mechanical oscillator.Preliminary numerical estimates suggest that near-term devices could feasibly be used to perform the experiment.

arXiv:2101.11629•PRX Quantum•Aug 18, 2021•113 citations

Entanglement witness for combined atom interferometer-mechanical oscillator setup

Gayathrini Premawardhana, Deven P. Bowman, Jacob M. Taylor

We investigate how to entangle an atom interferometer and a macroscopic mechanical oscillator to create nonclassical states of the oscillator. This work is done in the context of an experimental-theoretical collaboration that aims to implement the proposal in the paper “Using an Atom Interferometer to Infer Gravitational Entanglement Generation,” written by Carney . []. Here, we propose an entanglement witness (EW), from whose violation the generation of entanglement can be determined. We do this for three scenarios: the noiseless case, when including thermal noise, and with atomic dephasing. Thermal noise can arise from two sources: the first being when the oscillator starts in a thermal state, and the second when a continuous thermal bath is in contact with the oscillator. We find that for the appropriate oscillator quality factor Q , violation always exists for any value of coupling λ and thermal occupancy n ¯ . Cooling the oscillator to its ground state provides an O ( n ¯ ) improvement in the EW violation than when starting in a thermal state; in this case, we find that couplings of λ = 10 − 4.5 require at least ∼ 10 5.2 measurements for violation to be observed. For atomic dephasing, we find that EW violation can exist for an atom interferometer with a coherence time of 600 s, which is the parameter our experimental collaborators hope to reach. Finally, we consider how to use magnetic interactions to realize this idea within the context of the torsional pendulum that has been planned for our collaboration.

arXiv:2503.09990•Physical Review Research•Sep 19, 2025•0 citations
Finding a feasible scheme for testing the quantum mechanical nature of the gravitational interaction has been attracting an increasing level of attention. Gravity mediated entanglement generation so far appears to be the key ingredient for a potential experiment. In a recent proposal [D. Carney et al., PRX Quantum 2, 030330 (2021)] combining an atom interferometer with a low-frequency mechanical oscillator, a coherence revival test is proposed for verifying this entanglement generation. With measurements performed only on the atoms, this protocol bypasses the need for correlation measurements. Here, we explore formulations of such a protocol, and specifically find that in the envisioned regime of operation with high thermal excitation, semiclassical models, where there is no concept of entanglement, also give the same experimental signatures. We elucidate in a fully quantum mechanical calculation that entanglement is not the source of the revivals in the relevant parameter regime. We argue that, in its current form, the suggested test is only relevant if the oscillator is nearly in a pure quantum state, and in this regime the effects are too small to be measurable. We further discuss potential open ends. The results highlight the importance and subtleties of explicitly considering how the quantum case differs from the classical expectations when testing for the quantum mechanical nature of a physical system.
Combining gravity with quantum mechanics remains one of the biggest challenges of physics. In the past years, experiments with optomechanical systems have been proposed that may give indirect clues about the quantum nature of gravity. In a recent variation of such tests [Carney et al., PRX Quantum 2, 030330 (2021)], the authors propose to gravitationally entangle an atom interferometer with a mesoscopic oscillator. The interaction results in periodic drops and revivals of the interferometeric visibility, which under specific assumptions indicate the gravitational generation of entanglement. Here, we study semiclassical models of the atom interferometer that can reproduce the same effect. We show that the core signature---periodic collapses and revivals of the visibility---can appear if the atom is subject to a random unitary channel, including the case where the oscillator is fully classical and situations even without explicit modeling of the oscillator. We also show that the nonclassicality of the oscillator vanishes unless the system is very close to its ground state, and even when the system is in the ground state, the nonclassicality is limited by the coupling strength. Our results thus indicate that deducing entanglement from the proposed experiment is very challenging, since fulfilling and verifying the nonclassicality assumptions constitute a significant challenge in their own right.
We show that the atom interferometric coherence revival test suggested in [arXiv:2101.11629 [quant-ph] (2021)] does not test the quantum nature of the gravitational field when the atoms are coupled to a mechanical oscillator prepared in a thermal state. Specifically we clarify that the same coherence revivals take place in a model where the atoms are coupled to a classical oscillator through a classical gravitational field. We further elucidate the quantum mechanical calculation, showing that entanglement is not the source of the revivals. The suggested test is thus only relevant for pure initial quantum states of the oscillator. In this regime, numerical estimates show that it is unfeasible to do a test of the proposed type.
No experimental test to date has provided conclusive evidence on the quantum nature of gravity. Recent proposals, such as the Bose-Marletto-Vedral experiment, suggest that generating entanglement could serve as a direct test. Motivated by these proposals, we study a system of three-harmonic oscillator system, with the mediator oscillator operating in two distinct parameter regimes: a heavy mediator regime and a light mediator regime. These regimes induce qualitatively different entanglement dynamics between the terminal oscillators. Crucially, distinguishing these regimes experimentally remains challenging when relying solely on entanglement measures. We demonstrate that the dynamical fidelity susceptibility offers a viable and sensitive probe to contrast the regimes in practice. Our results provide testable signatures for optomechanical and trapped-ion platforms simulating gravitational interactions, and provide new avenues to characterize quantum-gravity-inspired systems beyond entanglement-based protocols.
The quantum nature of gravity is one of physics' greatest unsolved problems, with existing experimental proposals facing formidable challenges in maintaining spatial superpositions of massive objects against decoherence. We propose a fundamentally different approach that bypasses these difficulties. The central insight is that a quantum gravitational field can imprint a gauge-invariant phase on a particle's wavefunction even along an open trajectory, arising from the quantum backreaction of the source. This phase, which manifests prior to the final recombination stage of an interferometer and cannot be generated by a classical gravitational field, provides an operationally direct witness to the quantumness of gravity. Our experimental design uses a single photon whose accumulated gravitational phase due to the Earth is transferred via absorption to auxiliary atoms near the end of the interferometer sequence, preserving the open-path character essential for the test. We scale the interferometer to yield a detectable phase of order 10−310^{-3}10−3 rad and show how non-local correlation measurements on the atoms can access this gauge-invariant signature. Leveraging established quantum optical and atomic techniques, this proposal offers a feasible path to distinguish quantum from classical gravity. A positive result would provide the first experimental evidence for the quantum nature of gravitational fields, with profound implications for quantum gravity theories.
If gravitational perturbations are quantized into gravitons in analogy with the electromagnetic field and photons, the resulting graviton interactions should lead to an entangling interaction between massive objects.We suggest a test of this prediction.To do this, we introduce the concept of interactive quantum information sensing.This novel sensing protocol is tailored to provable verification of weak dynamical entanglement generation between a pair of systems.We show that this protocol is highly robust to typical thermal noise sources.Moreover, the sensitivity can be increased both using an initial thermal state and/or an initial phase of entangling via a nongravitational interaction.We outline a concrete implementation testing the ability of the gravitational field to generate entanglement between an atomic interferometer and a mechanical oscillator.Preliminary numerical estimates suggest that near-term devices could feasibly be used to perform the experiment.
We investigate how to entangle an atom interferometer and a macroscopic mechanical oscillator to create nonclassical states of the oscillator. This work is done in the context of an experimental-theoretical collaboration that aims to implement the proposal in the paper “Using an Atom Interferometer to Infer Gravitational Entanglement Generation,” written by Carney . []. Here, we propose an entanglement witness (EW), from whose violation the generation of entanglement can be determined. We do this for three scenarios: the noiseless case, when including thermal noise, and with atomic dephasing. Thermal noise can arise from two sources: the first being when the oscillator starts in a thermal state, and the second when a continuous thermal bath is in contact with the oscillator. We find that for the appropriate oscillator quality factor Q , violation always exists for any value of coupling λ and thermal occupancy n ¯ . Cooling the oscillator to its ground state provides an O ( n ¯ ) improvement in the EW violation than when starting in a thermal state; in this case, we find that couplings of λ = 10 − 4.5 require at least ∼ 10 5.2 measurements for violation to be observed. For atomic dephasing, we find that EW violation can exist for an atom interferometer with a coherence time of 600 s, which is the parameter our experimental collaborators hope to reach. Finally, we consider how to use magnetic interactions to realize this idea within the context of the torsional pendulum that has been planned for our collaboration.