Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.06310 · SciPost Physics

The classical two-dimensional Heisenberg model revisited: An $SU(2)$-symmetric tensor network study

Philipp Schmoll, Augustine Kshetrimayum, Jens Eisert, Román Orús, Matteo Rizzi

Published Nov 29, 2021• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The classical Heisenberg model in two spatial dimensions constitutes one of the most paradigmatic spin models, taking an important role in statistical and condensed matter physics to understand magnetism. Still, despite its paradigmatic character and the widely accepted ban of a (continuous) spontaneous symmetry breaking, controversies remain whether the model exhibits a phase transition at finite temperature. Importantly, the model can be interpreted as a lattice discretization of the O(3) O ( 3 ) non-linear sigma model in 1+1 1 + 1 dimensions, one of the simplest quantum field theories encompassing crucial features of celebrated higher-dimensional ones (like quantum chromodynamics in 3+1 3 + 1 dimensions), namely the phenomenon of asymptotic freedom. This should also exclude finite-temperature transitions, but lattice effects might play a significant role in correcting the mainstream picture. In this work, we make use of state-of-the-art tensor network approaches, representing the classical partition function in the thermodynamic limit over a large range of temperatures, to comprehensively explore the correlation structure for Gibbs states. By implementing an SU(2) S U ( 2 ) symmetry in our two-dimensional tensor network contraction scheme, we are able to handle very large effective bond dimensions of the environment up to \chi_E^\text{eff} \sim 1500 χ E eff ∼ 1500 , a feature that is crucial in detecting phase transitions. With decreasing temperatures, we find a rapidly diverging correlation length, whose behaviour is apparently compatible with the two main contradictory hypotheses known in the literature, namely a finite- T T transition and asymptotic freedom, though with a slight preference for the second.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.11.5.098

Related papers

Asymptotic freedom and finite-size scaling of the two-dimensional classical Heisenberg model

Dingyun Yao, Chao Zhang, Z. Y. Xie +2 more

The classical Heisenberg model is one of the most fundamental models in statistical and condensed matter physics. Extensive theoretical and numerical studies suggest that, in two dimensions, this model does not exhibit a finite-temperature phase transition but instead manifests asymptotic freedom. However, some research has also proposed the possibility of a Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) phase transition over the years. In this study, we revisit the classical two-dimensional (2D) Heisenberg model through large-scale simulations with linear system sizes up to $L=16384$. Our Monte Carlo data, without any extrapolation, clearly reveal an exponential divergence of the correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ as a function of the inverse temperature $\ensuremath{\beta}$, a hallmark of asymptotic freedom. Moreover, extrapolating $\ensuremath{\xi}$ to the thermodynamic limit in the low-temperature regime achieves close agreement with the three-loop perturbative calculations. We further propose a finite-size scaling (FSS) ansatz for $\ensuremath{\xi}$, demonstrating that the pseudocritical point ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{L}$ diverges logarithmically with $L$. The thermodynamic and finite-size scaling behaviors of the magnetic susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}$ are also investigated and corroborate the predictions of asymptotic freedom. Our paper provides solid evidence for asymptotic freedom in the 2D Heisenberg model and advances understanding of finite-size scaling in such systems.

arXiv:2503.24226•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 19, 2025•5 citations

Thermal tensor network simulations of the Heisenberg model on the Bethe lattice

Dai-Wei Qu, Wei Li, Tao Xiang

We have extended the canonical tree tensor network (TTN) method, which was initially introduced to simulate the zero-temperature properties of quantum lattice models on the Bethe lattice, to finite temperature simulations. By representing the thermal density matrix with a canonicalized tree tensor product operator, we optimize the TTN and compute accurately the thermodynamic quantities, including the internal energy, specific heat, spontaneous magnetization, etc., at various temperatures. By varying the anisotropic coupling constant $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, we obtain the phase diagram of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg XXZ model on the Bethe lattice, where three magnetic ordered phases, namely the ferromagnetic, XY, and antiferromagnetic phases, are found in low temperatures and separated from the high-$T$ paramagnetic phase by a continuous thermal phase transition at ${T}_{c}$. The XY phase is separated from the other two phases by two first-order phase transition lines at the symmetric coupling points $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$. We have also carried out a linear spin wave calculation on the Bethe lattice, showing that the low-energy magnetic excitations are always gapped, and find the obtained magnon gaps in very good agreement with those estimated from the TTN simulations. Despite the gapped excitation spectrum, Goldstone-like transverse fluctuation modes, as a manifestation of spontaneous continuous symmetry breaking, are observed in the ordered magnetic phases with $|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}|\ensuremath{\le}1$. One remarkable feature there is that the transverse correlation length reaches ${\ensuremath{\xi}}_{c}=1/ln(z\ensuremath{-}1)$ for $T\ensuremath{\le}{T}_{c}$, the maximal value allowed on a $z$-coordinated Bethe lattice.

arXiv:1905.12478•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 10, 2019•8 citations

General tensor network theory for frustrated classical spin models in two dimensions

Feng-Feng Song, Tongyu Lin, Guang-Ming Zhang

Frustration is a ubiquitous phenomenon in many-body physics that influences the nature of the system in a profound way with exotic emergent behavior. Despite its long research history, the analytical or numerical investigations on frustrated spin models remain a formidable challenge due to their extensive ground-state degeneracy. In this paper, we propose a unified tensor network theory to numerically solve the frustrated classical spin models on various two-dimensional (2D) lattice geometry with high efficiency. We show that the appropriate encoding of emergent degrees of freedom in each local tensor is of crucial importance in the construction of the infinite tensor network representation of the partition function. The frustrations are thus relieved through the effective interactions between emergent local degrees of freedom. Then the partition function is written as a product of a one-dimensional (1D) transfer operator, whose eigenequation can be solved by the standard algorithm of matrix product states rigorously, and various phase transitions can be accurately determined from the singularities of the entanglement entropy of the 1D quantum correspondence. We demonstrated the power of our general theory by numerically solving 2D fully frustrated XY spin models on the kagome, square, and triangular lattices, giving rise to a variety of thermal phase transitions from infinite-order Brezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions, second-order transitions, to first-order phase transitions. Our approach holds the potential application to other types of frustrated classical systems like Heisenberg spin antiferromagnets.

arXiv:2309.05321•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 4, 2023•15 citations

Symmetries & tensor networks in two-dimensional quantum physics

Henrik Dreyer

The most general description of a quantum many-body system is given by a wave- function that lives in a Hilbert space with dimension exponential in the number of particles. This makes it extremely hard to study strongly correlated phenomena like the fractional quantum Hall effect and high-temperature superconductivity. Whenever interactions are sufficiently local and temperature is low, the system does not explore the full Hilbert space, but its ground state resides in the small corner of Hilbert space described by the area law. Containing little entanglement, the states can then be expressed as tensor networks, a family of wavefunctions with a polynomial number of parameters. On the one hand, tensor networks can be used as a variational manifold in nu- merical computations. On the other hand, they allow building model wavefunctions much like locality allows writing down physically realistic Hamiltonians. Besides allowing for an analytical treatment, these models grant access both to the physical and the entanglement degrees of freedom. This is particularly useful in classifying phases of matter. A large number of phases can be explained in terms of Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. This framework, however, is not complete, as exemplified by the existence of phases with intrinsic topological order in two dimensions. It was a major conceptual advance when tensor networks could explain (non-chiral) topological phases as those where the symmetry resides in the entanglement degrees of freedom. The symmetries corresponding to those topological phases act as discrete, finite groups on the virtual degrees of freedom. The purpose of this Thesis is to generalize this program to include other symmetries. We investigate a class of tensor networks with continuous symmetries and find that they cannot describe gapped physics with a unique ground state. The abelian case is found to describe a non-Lorentz invariant phase transition point into a topologically ordered phase. The physics of the non- abelian case is that of a plaquette state that spontaneously breaks the translation symmetry of the lattice. The non-abelian PEPS arises as the ground state of a local parent Hamiltonian whose ground state manifold is completely characterized by the tensor network. In both cases, we find two types of corrections to the entanglement entropy: first there is a correction that is logarithmic in the size of the boundary and independent of the shape. A further correction depends only on the shape of the partition, imposing further restrictions on regions that are suffciently thin. Finally, we investigate symmetries that mix the virtual with the physical degrees of freedom and are furthermore anisotropic. Their physics is described by subsystem symmetry protected topological order. In particular, we focus on the entanglement entropy in the cluster phase and show that there is a universal constant correction to the entropy throughout the phase. This is important in the program of establishing the entanglement entropy as a detection mechanism for topologically ordered phases. We put forward a numerical algorithm to compute the correction and use it to discover a novel phase of matter in which the cluster phase is embedded.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Variational tensor network renormalization in imaginary time: Two-dimensional quantum compass model at finite temperature

Piotr Czarnik, Jacek Dziarmaga, Andrzej M. Oleś

Progress in describing thermodynamic phase transitions in quantum systems is obtained by noticing that the Gibbs operator ${e}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}H}$ for a two-dimensional (2D) lattice system with a Hamiltonian $H$ can be represented by a three-dimensional tensor network, the third dimension being the imaginary time (inverse temperature) $\ensuremath{\beta}$. Coarse graining the network along $\ensuremath{\beta}$ results in a 2D projected entangled-pair operator (PEPO) with a finite bond dimension $D$. The coarse graining is performed by a tree tensor network of isometries. The isometries are optimized variationally, taking into account full tensor environment, to maximize the accuracy of the PEPO. The algorithm is applied to the isotropic quantum compass model on an infinite square lattice near a symmetry-breaking phase transition at finite temperature. From the linear susceptibility in the symmetric phase and the order parameter in the symmetry-broken phase, the critical temperature is estimated at ${\mathcal{T}}_{c}=0.0606(4)J$, where $J$ is the isotropic coupling constant between $S=\frac{1}{2}$ pseudospins.

arXiv:1512.07168•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 11, 2016•37 citations

Thermal Ising Transition in the Spin- 1/2 J1 - J2 Heisenberg Model

Olivier Gauthé, Frédéric Mila

Using an SU(2) invariant finite-temperature tensor network algorithm, we provide strong numerical evidence in favor of an Ising transition in the collinear phase of the spin-1/2 J_{1}-J_{2} Heisenberg model on the square lattice. In units of J_{2}, the critical temperature reaches a maximal value of T_{c}/J_{2}≃0.18 around J_{2}/J_{1}≃1.0. It is strongly suppressed upon approaching the zero-temperature boundary of the collinear phase J_{2}/J_{1}≃0.6, and it vanishes as 1/log(J_{2}/J_{1}) in the large J_{2}/J_{1} limit, as predicted by Chandra et al., [Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 88 (1990)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.64.88]. Enforcing the SU(2) symmetry is crucial to avoid the artifact of finite-temperature SU(2) symmetry breaking of U(1) algorithms, opening new perspectives in the investigation of the thermal properties of quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnets.

arXiv:2201.02171•Physical Review Letters•Jun 2, 2022•19 citations
The classical two-dimensional Heisenberg model revisited: An SU(2)SU(2)SU(2)-symmetric tensor network study
The classical Heisenberg model in two spatial dimensions constitutes one of the most paradigmatic spin models, taking an important role in statistical and condensed matter physics to understand magnetism. Still, despite its paradigmatic character and the widely accepted ban of a (continuous) spontaneous symmetry breaking, controversies remain whether the model exhibits a phase transition at finite temperature. Importantly, the model can be interpreted as a lattice discretization of the O(3) O ( 3 ) non-linear sigma model in 1+1 1 + 1 dimensions, one of the simplest quantum field theories encompassing crucial features of celebrated higher-dimensional ones (like quantum chromodynamics in 3+1 3 + 1 dimensions), namely the phenomenon of asymptotic freedom. This should also exclude finite-temperature transitions, but lattice effects might play a significant role in correcting the mainstream picture. In this work, we make use of state-of-the-art tensor network approaches, representing the classical partition function in the thermodynamic limit over a large range of temperatures, to comprehensively explore the correlation structure for Gibbs states. By implementing an SU(2) S U ( 2 ) symmetry in our two-dimensional tensor network contraction scheme, we are able to handle very large effective bond dimensions of the environment up to \chi_E^\text{eff} \sim 1500 χ E eff ∼ 1500 , a feature that is crucial in detecting phase transitions. With decreasing temperatures, we find a rapidly diverging correlation length, whose behaviour is apparently compatible with the two main contradictory hypotheses known in the literature, namely a finite- T T transition and asymptotic freedom, though with a slight preference for the second.
The classical Heisenberg model is one of the most fundamental models in statistical and condensed matter physics. Extensive theoretical and numerical studies suggest that, in two dimensions, this model does not exhibit a finite-temperature phase transition but instead manifests asymptotic freedom. However, some research has also proposed the possibility of a Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) phase transition over the years. In this study, we revisit the classical two-dimensional (2D) Heisenberg model through large-scale simulations with linear system sizes up to L=16384L=16384L=16384. Our Monte Carlo data, without any extrapolation, clearly reveal an exponential divergence of the correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ as a function of the inverse temperature $\ensuremath{\beta}$, a hallmark of asymptotic freedom. Moreover, extrapolating $\ensuremath{\xi}$ to the thermodynamic limit in the low-temperature regime achieves close agreement with the three-loop perturbative calculations. We further propose a finite-size scaling (FSS) ansatz for $\ensuremath{\xi}$, demonstrating that the pseudocritical point ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{L}$ diverges logarithmically with LLL. The thermodynamic and finite-size scaling behaviors of the magnetic susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}$ are also investigated and corroborate the predictions of asymptotic freedom. Our paper provides solid evidence for asymptotic freedom in the 2D Heisenberg model and advances understanding of finite-size scaling in such systems.
We have extended the canonical tree tensor network (TTN) method, which was initially introduced to simulate the zero-temperature properties of quantum lattice models on the Bethe lattice, to finite temperature simulations. By representing the thermal density matrix with a canonicalized tree tensor product operator, we optimize the TTN and compute accurately the thermodynamic quantities, including the internal energy, specific heat, spontaneous magnetization, etc., at various temperatures. By varying the anisotropic coupling constant $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, we obtain the phase diagram of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg XXZ model on the Bethe lattice, where three magnetic ordered phases, namely the ferromagnetic, XY, and antiferromagnetic phases, are found in low temperatures and separated from the high-TTT paramagnetic phase by a continuous thermal phase transition at Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. The XY phase is separated from the other two phases by two first-order phase transition lines at the symmetric coupling points $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$. We have also carried out a linear spin wave calculation on the Bethe lattice, showing that the low-energy magnetic excitations are always gapped, and find the obtained magnon gaps in very good agreement with those estimated from the TTN simulations. Despite the gapped excitation spectrum, Goldstone-like transverse fluctuation modes, as a manifestation of spontaneous continuous symmetry breaking, are observed in the ordered magnetic phases with $|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}|\ensuremath{\le}1$. One remarkable feature there is that the transverse correlation length reaches ${\ensuremath{\xi}}_{c}=1/ln(z\ensuremath{-}1)$ for $T\ensuremath{\le}{T}_{c}$, the maximal value allowed on a zzz-coordinated Bethe lattice.
Frustration is a ubiquitous phenomenon in many-body physics that influences the nature of the system in a profound way with exotic emergent behavior. Despite its long research history, the analytical or numerical investigations on frustrated spin models remain a formidable challenge due to their extensive ground-state degeneracy. In this paper, we propose a unified tensor network theory to numerically solve the frustrated classical spin models on various two-dimensional (2D) lattice geometry with high efficiency. We show that the appropriate encoding of emergent degrees of freedom in each local tensor is of crucial importance in the construction of the infinite tensor network representation of the partition function. The frustrations are thus relieved through the effective interactions between emergent local degrees of freedom. Then the partition function is written as a product of a one-dimensional (1D) transfer operator, whose eigenequation can be solved by the standard algorithm of matrix product states rigorously, and various phase transitions can be accurately determined from the singularities of the entanglement entropy of the 1D quantum correspondence. We demonstrated the power of our general theory by numerically solving 2D fully frustrated XY spin models on the kagome, square, and triangular lattices, giving rise to a variety of thermal phase transitions from infinite-order Brezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions, second-order transitions, to first-order phase transitions. Our approach holds the potential application to other types of frustrated classical systems like Heisenberg spin antiferromagnets.
The most general description of a quantum many-body system is given by a wave- function that lives in a Hilbert space with dimension exponential in the number of particles. This makes it extremely hard to study strongly correlated phenomena like the fractional quantum Hall effect and high-temperature superconductivity. Whenever interactions are sufficiently local and temperature is low, the system does not explore the full Hilbert space, but its ground state resides in the small corner of Hilbert space described by the area law. Containing little entanglement, the states can then be expressed as tensor networks, a family of wavefunctions with a polynomial number of parameters. On the one hand, tensor networks can be used as a variational manifold in nu- merical computations. On the other hand, they allow building model wavefunctions much like locality allows writing down physically realistic Hamiltonians. Besides allowing for an analytical treatment, these models grant access both to the physical and the entanglement degrees of freedom. This is particularly useful in classifying phases of matter. A large number of phases can be explained in terms of Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. This framework, however, is not complete, as exemplified by the existence of phases with intrinsic topological order in two dimensions. It was a major conceptual advance when tensor networks could explain (non-chiral) topological phases as those where the symmetry resides in the entanglement degrees of freedom. The symmetries corresponding to those topological phases act as discrete, finite groups on the virtual degrees of freedom. The purpose of this Thesis is to generalize this program to include other symmetries. We investigate a class of tensor networks with continuous symmetries and find that they cannot describe gapped physics with a unique ground state. The abelian case is found to describe a non-Lorentz invariant phase transition point into a topologically ordered phase. The physics of the non- abelian case is that of a plaquette state that spontaneously breaks the translation symmetry of the lattice. The non-abelian PEPS arises as the ground state of a local parent Hamiltonian whose ground state manifold is completely characterized by the tensor network. In both cases, we find two types of corrections to the entanglement entropy: first there is a correction that is logarithmic in the size of the boundary and independent of the shape. A further correction depends only on the shape of the partition, imposing further restrictions on regions that are suffciently thin. Finally, we investigate symmetries that mix the virtual with the physical degrees of freedom and are furthermore anisotropic. Their physics is described by subsystem symmetry protected topological order. In particular, we focus on the entanglement entropy in the cluster phase and show that there is a universal constant correction to the entropy throughout the phase. This is important in the program of establishing the entanglement entropy as a detection mechanism for topologically ordered phases. We put forward a numerical algorithm to compute the correction and use it to discover a novel phase of matter in which the cluster phase is embedded.
Progress in describing thermodynamic phase transitions in quantum systems is obtained by noticing that the Gibbs operator ${e}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}H}$ for a two-dimensional (2D) lattice system with a Hamiltonian HHH can be represented by a three-dimensional tensor network, the third dimension being the imaginary time (inverse temperature) $\ensuremath{\beta}$. Coarse graining the network along $\ensuremath{\beta}$ results in a 2D projected entangled-pair operator (PEPO) with a finite bond dimension DDD. The coarse graining is performed by a tree tensor network of isometries. The isometries are optimized variationally, taking into account full tensor environment, to maximize the accuracy of the PEPO. The algorithm is applied to the isotropic quantum compass model on an infinite square lattice near a symmetry-breaking phase transition at finite temperature. From the linear susceptibility in the symmetric phase and the order parameter in the symmetry-broken phase, the critical temperature is estimated at Tc=0.0606(4)J{\mathcal{T}}_{c}=0.0606(4)JTc​=0.0606(4)J, where JJJ is the isotropic coupling constant between S=12S=\frac{1}{2}S=21​ pseudospins.
Using an SU(2) invariant finite-temperature tensor network algorithm, we provide strong numerical evidence in favor of an Ising transition in the collinear phase of the spin-1/2 J_{1}-J_{2} Heisenberg model on the square lattice. In units of J_{2}, the critical temperature reaches a maximal value of T_{c}/J_{2}≃0.18 around J_{2}/J_{1}≃1.0. It is strongly suppressed upon approaching the zero-temperature boundary of the collinear phase J_{2}/J_{1}≃0.6, and it vanishes as 1/log(J_{2}/J_{1}) in the large J_{2}/J_{1} limit, as predicted by Chandra et al., [Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 88 (1990)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.64.88]. Enforcing the SU(2) symmetry is crucial to avoid the artifact of finite-temperature SU(2) symmetry breaking of U(1) algorithms, opening new perspectives in the investigation of the thermal properties of quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnets.