Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2105.11464 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Is the EMI model a QFT? An inquiry on the space of allowed entropy functions

César A. Agón, Pablo Bueno, Horacio Casini

Published Aug 17, 2021• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The mutual information I(A, B) of pairs of spatially separated regions satisfies, for any d-dimensional CFT, a set of structural physical properties such as positivity, monotonicity, clustering, or Poincaré invariance, among others. If one imposes the extra requirement that I(A, B) is extensive as a function of its arguments (so that the tripartite information vanishes for any set of regions, I3(A, B, C ) ≡ 0), a closed geometric formula involving integrals over ∂A and ∂B can be obtained. We explore whether this “Extensive Mutual Information” model (EMI), which in fact describes a free fermion in d = 2, may similarly correspond to an actual CFT in general dimensions. Using the long-distance behavior of IEMI(A, B) we show that, if it did, it would necessarily include a free fermion, but also that additional operators would have to be present in the model. Remarkably, we find that IEMI(A, B) for two arbitrarily boosted spheres in general d exactly matches the result for the free fermion current conformal block $$ {G}_{\Delta =\left(d-1\right),J=1}^d $$ G ∆ = d − 1 , J = 1 d . On the other hand, a detailed analysis of the subleading contribution in the long-distance regime rules out the possibility that the EMI formula represents the mutual information of any actual CFT or even any limit of CFTs. These results make manifest the incompleteness of the set of known constraints required to describe the space of allowed entropy functions in QFT.

DOI
10.1007/jhep08(2021)084

Related papers

Long-distance N-partite information for fermionic CFTs

César A. Agón, Pablo Bueno, Guido van der Velde

A bstract The mutual information, I 2 , of general spacetime regions is expected to capture the full data of any conformal field theory (CFT). For spherical regions, this data can be accessed from long-distance expansions of the mutual information of pairs of regions as well as of suitably chosen linear combinations of mutual informations involving more than two regions and their unions — namely, the N -partite information, I N . In particular, the leading term in the I 2 long-distance expansion is fully determined by the spin and conformal dimension of the lowest-dimensional primary of the theory. When the operator is a scalar, an analogous formula for the tripartite information I 3 contains information about the OPE coefficient controlling the fusion of such operator into its conformal family. When it is a fermionic field, the coefficient of the leading term in I 3 vanishes instead. In this paper we present an explicit general formula for the long-distance four-partite information I 4 of general CFTs whose lowest-dimensional operator is a fermion ψ . The result involves a combination of four-point and two-point functions of ψ and $$ \overline{\psi} $$ ψ ¯ evaluated at the locations of the regions. We perform explicit checks of the formula for a (2 + 1)-dimensional free fermion in the lattice finding perfect agreement. The generalization of our result to the N -partite information (for arbitrary N ) is also discussed. Similarly to I 3 , we argue that I 5 vanishes identically at leading order for general fermionic theories, while the I N with N = 7 , 9 , … only vanish when the theory is free.

arXiv:2409.03821•Journal of High Energy Physics•Dec 23, 2024•7 citations

On the mutual information in conformal field theory

Bin Chen, Lin Chen, Peng-xiang Hao +1 more

In this work, we study the universal behaviors in the mutual information of two disjoint spheres in a conformal field theory (CFT). By using the operator product expansion of the spherical twist operator in terms of the conformal family, we show that the large distance expansion of the mutual information can be cast in terms of the conformal blocks. We develop the 1/n prescription to compute the coefficients before the conformal blocks. For a single conformal family, the leading nonvanishing contribution to the mutual information comes from the bilinear operators. We show that the coefficients of these operators take universal forms and such universal behavior persists in the bilinear operators with derivatives as well. Consequently the first few leading order contributions to the mutual information in CFT take universal forms. To illustrate our framework, we discuss the free scalars and free fermions in various dimensions. For the free scalars, we compute the mutual information to the next-to-leading order and find good agreement with the improved numerical lattice result. For the free fermion, we compute the leading order result, which is of universal form, and find the good match with the numerical study. Our formalism could be applied to any CFT potentially.

arXiv:1704.03692•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jun 1, 2017•36 citations

Mutual information from modular flow in general conformal field theories

César A. Agón, Pablo Bueno, Adem Deniz Piskin +1 more

The vacuum mutual information (MI) of subregion algebras provides a universal window into the data of general conformal field theories (CFTs). Exploiting the geometric nature of the modular flow associated to ball-shaped regions and the operator product expansion of twist operators implementing the replica symmetry in an n -fold version of a CFT, it is possible to construct a hierarchy of increasingly refined approximations to the full MI. In this letter, we use the two-point functions of primaries of arbitrary spin in the replicated theory to constrain the twist operators, and find their contribution to the MI of arbitrarily boosted balls in any d -dimensional CFT. When the two-point functions involve the primary with the lowest scaling dimension, our result provides the most precise approximation for the long-distance behavior of the MI, superseding all previous expansions. Building upon this result and certain universal properties of the short- and long-distance regimes, we put forward a new high-precision analytic approximation to the MI for arbitrary separations. The accuracy of our approach is validated against exact d = 2 and lattice d = 3 results. We further apply it to characterize the MI of a d = 4 Maxwell field, a case for which no prior results are available.

arXiv:2604.19860•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 30, 2026•2 citations

Rényi mutual information inequalities from Rindler positivity

David Blanco, Leandro Lanosa, Mauricio Leston +1 more

Abstract Rindler positivity is a property that holds in any relativistic Quantum Field Theory and implies an infinite set of inequalities involving the exponential of the Rényi mutual information I n (A i , $$ \overline{A} $$ A ¯ j ) between A i and $$ \overline{A} $$ A ¯ j , where A i is a spacelike region in the right Rindler wedge and $$ \overline{A} $$ A ¯ j is the wedge reflection of A j . We explore these inequalities in order to get local inequalities for I n (A, $$ \overline{A} $$ A ¯ ) as a function of the distance between A and its mirror region $$ \overline{A} $$ A ¯ . We show that the assumption, based on the cluster property of the vacuum, that I n goes to zero when the distance goes to infinity, implies the more stringent and simple condition that F n ≡ e (n−1)I n should be a completely monotonic function of the distance, meaning that all the even (odd) derivatives are non-negative (non-positive). In the case of a CFT, we show that conformal invariance implies stronger conditions, including a sort of monotonicity of the Rényi mutual information for pairs of balls. An application of these inequalities to obtain constraints for the OPE coefficients of the 4-point function of certain twist operators is also discussed.

arXiv:1909.03144•Journal of High Energy Physics•Dec 1, 2019•5 citations

Reflected entropy for free scalars

Pablo Bueno, Horacio Casini

A bstract We continue our study of reflected entropy, R ( A, B ), for Gaussian systems. In this paper we provide general formulas valid for free scalar fields in arbitrary dimensions. Similarly to the fermionic case, the resulting expressions are fully determined in terms of correlators of the fields, making them amenable to lattice calculations. We apply this to the case of a (1 + 1)-dimensional chiral scalar, whose reflected entropy we compute for two intervals as a function of the cross-ratio, comparing it with previous holographic and free-fermion results. For both types of free theories we find that reflected entropy satisfies the conjectural monotonicity property R ( A, BC ) ≥ R ( A, B ). Then, we move to (2 + 1) dimensions and evaluate it for square regions for free scalars, fermions and holography, determining the very-far and very-close regimes and comparing them with their mutual information counterparts. In all cases considered, both for (1 + 1)- and (2 + 1)-dimensional theories, we verify that the general inequality relating both quantities, R ( A, B ) ≥ I ( A, B ), is satisfied. Our results suggest that for general regions characterized by length-scales L A ∼ L B ∼ L and separated a distance ℓ , the reflected entropy in the large-separation regime ( x ≡ L / ℓ ≪ 1) behaves as R ( x ) ∼ −I ( x ) log x for general CFTs in arbitrary dimensions.

arXiv:2008.11373•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 1, 2020•40 citations

Tripartite information at long distances

César A. Agón, Pablo Bueno, Horacio Casini

We compute the leading term of the tripartite information at long distances for three spheres in a CFT. This falls as r^{-6\Delta} r − 6 Δ , where r r is the typical distance between the spheres, and \Delta Δ the lowest primary field dimension. The coefficient turns out to be a combination of terms coming from the two- and three-point functions and depends on the OPE coefficient of the field. We check the result with three-dimensional free scalars in the lattice finding excellent agreement. When the lowest-dimensional field is a scalar, we find that the mutual information can be monogamous only for quite large OPE coefficients, far away from a perturbative regime. When the lowest-dimensional primary is a fermion, we argue that the scaling must always be faster than r^{-6\Delta_f} r − 6 Δ f . In particular, lattice calculations suggest a leading scaling r^(6\Delta_f+1) r ( 6 Δ f + 1 ) . For free fermions in three dimensions, we show that mutual information is also non-monogamous in the long-distance regime.

arXiv:2109.09179•SciPost Physics•May 10, 2022•20 citations
Abstract The mutual information I(A, B) of pairs of spatially separated regions satisfies, for any d-dimensional CFT, a set of structural physical properties such as positivity, monotonicity, clustering, or Poincaré invariance, among others. If one imposes the extra requirement that I(A, B) is extensive as a function of its arguments (so that the tripartite information vanishes for any set of regions, I3(A, B, C ) ≡ 0), a closed geometric formula involving integrals over ∂A and ∂B can be obtained. We explore whether this “Extensive Mutual Information” model (EMI), which in fact describes a free fermion in d = 2, may similarly correspond to an actual CFT in general dimensions. Using the long-distance behavior of IEMI(A, B) we show that, if it did, it would necessarily include a free fermion, but also that additional operators would have to be present in the model. Remarkably, we find that IEMI(A, B) for two arbitrarily boosted spheres in general d exactly matches the result for the free fermion current conformal block GΔ=(d−1),J=1d{G}_{\Delta =\left(d-1\right),J=1}^dGΔ=(d−1),J=1d​ G ∆ = d − 1 , J = 1 d . On the other hand, a detailed analysis of the subleading contribution in the long-distance regime rules out the possibility that the EMI formula represents the mutual information of any actual CFT or even any limit of CFTs. These results make manifest the incompleteness of the set of known constraints required to describe the space of allowed entropy functions in QFT.
A bstract The mutual information, I 2 , of general spacetime regions is expected to capture the full data of any conformal field theory (CFT). For spherical regions, this data can be accessed from long-distance expansions of the mutual information of pairs of regions as well as of suitably chosen linear combinations of mutual informations involving more than two regions and their unions — namely, the N -partite information, I N . In particular, the leading term in the I 2 long-distance expansion is fully determined by the spin and conformal dimension of the lowest-dimensional primary of the theory. When the operator is a scalar, an analogous formula for the tripartite information I 3 contains information about the OPE coefficient controlling the fusion of such operator into its conformal family. When it is a fermionic field, the coefficient of the leading term in I 3 vanishes instead. In this paper we present an explicit general formula for the long-distance four-partite information I 4 of general CFTs whose lowest-dimensional operator is a fermion ψ . The result involves a combination of four-point and two-point functions of ψ and ψ‾ \overline{\psi} ψ​ ψ ¯ evaluated at the locations of the regions. We perform explicit checks of the formula for a (2 + 1)-dimensional free fermion in the lattice finding perfect agreement. The generalization of our result to the N -partite information (for arbitrary N ) is also discussed. Similarly to I 3 , we argue that I 5 vanishes identically at leading order for general fermionic theories, while the I N with N = 7 , 9 , … only vanish when the theory is free.
In this work, we study the universal behaviors in the mutual information of two disjoint spheres in a conformal field theory (CFT). By using the operator product expansion of the spherical twist operator in terms of the conformal family, we show that the large distance expansion of the mutual information can be cast in terms of the conformal blocks. We develop the 1/n prescription to compute the coefficients before the conformal blocks. For a single conformal family, the leading nonvanishing contribution to the mutual information comes from the bilinear operators. We show that the coefficients of these operators take universal forms and such universal behavior persists in the bilinear operators with derivatives as well. Consequently the first few leading order contributions to the mutual information in CFT take universal forms. To illustrate our framework, we discuss the free scalars and free fermions in various dimensions. For the free scalars, we compute the mutual information to the next-to-leading order and find good agreement with the improved numerical lattice result. For the free fermion, we compute the leading order result, which is of universal form, and find the good match with the numerical study. Our formalism could be applied to any CFT potentially.
The vacuum mutual information (MI) of subregion algebras provides a universal window into the data of general conformal field theories (CFTs). Exploiting the geometric nature of the modular flow associated to ball-shaped regions and the operator product expansion of twist operators implementing the replica symmetry in an n -fold version of a CFT, it is possible to construct a hierarchy of increasingly refined approximations to the full MI. In this letter, we use the two-point functions of primaries of arbitrary spin in the replicated theory to constrain the twist operators, and find their contribution to the MI of arbitrarily boosted balls in any d -dimensional CFT. When the two-point functions involve the primary with the lowest scaling dimension, our result provides the most precise approximation for the long-distance behavior of the MI, superseding all previous expansions. Building upon this result and certain universal properties of the short- and long-distance regimes, we put forward a new high-precision analytic approximation to the MI for arbitrary separations. The accuracy of our approach is validated against exact d = 2 and lattice d = 3 results. We further apply it to characterize the MI of a d = 4 Maxwell field, a case for which no prior results are available.
Abstract Rindler positivity is a property that holds in any relativistic Quantum Field Theory and implies an infinite set of inequalities involving the exponential of the Rényi mutual information I n (A i , A‾ \overline{A} A A ¯ j ) between A i and A‾ \overline{A} A A ¯ j , where A i is a spacelike region in the right Rindler wedge and A‾ \overline{A} A A ¯ j is the wedge reflection of A j . We explore these inequalities in order to get local inequalities for I n (A, A‾ \overline{A} A A ¯ ) as a function of the distance between A and its mirror region A‾ \overline{A} A A ¯ . We show that the assumption, based on the cluster property of the vacuum, that I n goes to zero when the distance goes to infinity, implies the more stringent and simple condition that F n ≡ e (n−1)I n should be a completely monotonic function of the distance, meaning that all the even (odd) derivatives are non-negative (non-positive). In the case of a CFT, we show that conformal invariance implies stronger conditions, including a sort of monotonicity of the Rényi mutual information for pairs of balls. An application of these inequalities to obtain constraints for the OPE coefficients of the 4-point function of certain twist operators is also discussed.
A bstract We continue our study of reflected entropy, R ( A, B ), for Gaussian systems. In this paper we provide general formulas valid for free scalar fields in arbitrary dimensions. Similarly to the fermionic case, the resulting expressions are fully determined in terms of correlators of the fields, making them amenable to lattice calculations. We apply this to the case of a (1 + 1)-dimensional chiral scalar, whose reflected entropy we compute for two intervals as a function of the cross-ratio, comparing it with previous holographic and free-fermion results. For both types of free theories we find that reflected entropy satisfies the conjectural monotonicity property R ( A, BC ) ≥ R ( A, B ). Then, we move to (2 + 1) dimensions and evaluate it for square regions for free scalars, fermions and holography, determining the very-far and very-close regimes and comparing them with their mutual information counterparts. In all cases considered, both for (1 + 1)- and (2 + 1)-dimensional theories, we verify that the general inequality relating both quantities, R ( A, B ) ≥ I ( A, B ), is satisfied. Our results suggest that for general regions characterized by length-scales L A ∼ L B ∼ L and separated a distance ℓ , the reflected entropy in the large-separation regime ( x ≡ L / ℓ ≪ 1) behaves as R ( x ) ∼ −I ( x ) log x for general CFTs in arbitrary dimensions.
We compute the leading term of the tripartite information at long distances for three spheres in a CFT. This falls as r^{-6\Delta} r − 6 Δ , where r r is the typical distance between the spheres, and \Delta Δ the lowest primary field dimension. The coefficient turns out to be a combination of terms coming from the two- and three-point functions and depends on the OPE coefficient of the field. We check the result with three-dimensional free scalars in the lattice finding excellent agreement. When the lowest-dimensional field is a scalar, we find that the mutual information can be monogamous only for quite large OPE coefficients, far away from a perturbative regime. When the lowest-dimensional primary is a fermion, we argue that the scaling must always be faster than r^{-6\Delta_f} r − 6 Δ f . In particular, lattice calculations suggest a leading scaling r^(6\Delta_f+1) r ( 6 Δ f + 1 ) . For free fermions in three dimensions, we show that mutual information is also non-monogamous in the long-distance regime.