Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2104.14096 · Scientific Reports

Benchmark of quantum-inspired heuristic solvers for quadratic unconstrained binary optimization

Hiroki Oshiyama, Masayuki Ohzeki

Published Feb 9, 2022• 71 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, inspired by quantum annealing, many solvers specialized for unconstrained binary quadratic programming problems have been developed. For further improvement and application of these solvers, it is important to clarify the differences in their performance for various types of problems. In this study, the performance of four quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem solvers, namely D-Wave Hybrid Solver Service (HSS), Toshiba Simulated Bifurcation Machine (SBM), Fujitsu Digital Annealer (DA), and simulated annealing on a personal computer, was benchmarked. The problems used for benchmarking were instances of real problems in MQLib, instances of the SAT-UNSAT phase transition point of random not-all-equal 3-SAT (NAE 3-SAT), and the Ising spin glass Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model. Concerning MQLib instances, the HSS performance ranked first; for NAE 3-SAT, DA performance ranked first; and regarding the SK model, SBM performance ranked first. These results may help understand the strengths and weaknesses of these solvers.

DOI
10.1038/s41598-022-06070-5

Related papers

A Novel Solver for QUBO Problems: Performance Analysis and Comparative Study with State-of-the-Art Algorithms

Jiecheng Yang, Ding Wang, Xiang Zhao +3 more

Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) provides a versatile framework for representing NP-hard combinatorial problems, yet existing solvers often face trade-offs among speed, accuracy, and scalability. In this work, we introduce a quantum-inspired solver (QIS) that unites branch-and-bound pruning, continuous gradient-descent refinement, and quantum-inspired heuristics within a fully adaptive control architecture. We benchmark QIS3 against eight state-of-the-art solvers, including genetic algorithms, coherent Ising machines, simulated bifurcation, parallel tempering, simulated annealing, our prior QIS2 version, D-Wave's simulated-annealing (Neal), and Gurobi on three canonical QUBO problem classes: Max-Cut, NAE-3SAT, and Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin glass problems. Under a uniform runtime budget, QIS3 attains the best solution on nearly all instances, achieving optimality in 94% of max-cut instances. These results establish QIS3 as a robust, high-performance solver that bridges classical exact strategies and quantum-inspired heuristics for scalable QUBO optimization.

arXiv:2506.04596•Jun 5, 2025•3 citations

A comprehensive benchmark of an Ising machine on the Max-Cut problem

Salwa Shaglel, Markus Kirsch, Mårten Winkler +4 more

Abstract Quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) formulations of combinatorial optimization problems allow for solving them using various quantum heuristics. While large-scale quantum computations are currently still out of reach, we can already numerically test such QUBO formulations on a perhaps surprisingly large scale. In this work, we benchmark Fujitsu’s Digital Annealer (DA) on the Max-Cut problem, which captures the main complexity of the QUBO problem. We make a comprehensive benchmark against leading other heuristic algorithms on graphs with up to 53,000 variables by focusing on the wall-clock time. Moreover, we compare the DA performance against published performance results of the D-Wave hybrid quantum–classical annealer and the recently proposed QIS3 heuristic. Based on performance statistics for over 2000 graphs from the MQLib, we find that the DA yields competitive results. We hope that this benchmark demonstrates the extent to which large QUBO instances can be heuristically solved today, yielding consistent results across different solvers.

arXiv:2507.22117•New Journal of Physics•Jun 5, 2026•2 citations

3-regular three-XORSAT planted solutions benchmark of classical and quantum heuristic optimizers

Matthew Kowalsky, Tameem Albash, Itay Hen +1 more

Abstract With current semiconductor technology reaching its physical limits, special-purpose hardware has emerged as an option to tackle specific computing-intensive challenges. Optimization in the form of solving quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problems, or equivalently Ising spin glasses, has been the focus of several new dedicated hardware platforms. These platforms come in many different flavors, from highly-efficient hardware implementations on digital-logic of established algorithms to proposals of analog hardware implementing new algorithms. In this work, we use a mapping of a specific class of linear equations whose solutions can be found efficiently, to a hard constraint satisfaction problem (three-regular three-XORSAT, or an Ising spin glass) with a ‘golf-course’ shaped energy landscape, to benchmark several of these different approaches. We perform a scaling and prefactor analysis of the performance of Fujitsu’s digital annealer unit (DAU), the D-Wave advantage quantum annealer, a virtual MemComputing machine, Toshiba’s simulated bifurcation machine (SBM), the SATonGPU algorithm from Bernaschi et al , and our implementation of parallel tempering. We identify the SATonGPU and DAU as currently having the smallest scaling exponent for this benchmark, with SATonGPU having a small scaling advantage and in addition having by far the smallest prefactor thanks to its use of massive parallelism. Our work provides an objective assessment and a snapshot of the promise and limitations of dedicated optimization hardware relative to a particular class of optimization problems.

arXiv:2103.08464•Quantum Science and Technology•Jan 19, 2022•63 citations

Accuracy and performance evaluation of quantum, classical and hybrid solvers for the Max-Cut problem

Jaka Vodeb, Vid Eržen, Timotej Hrga +1 more

Abstract This paper benchmarks quantum, classical, and hybrid solvers on NP-hard Max-Cut and QUBO problems, emphasizing solution quality relative to known global optima. We evaluate D-Wave’s fast annealing QPU and Hybrid solver against classical simulated annealing (SA) and Toshiba’s simulated bifurcation machine (SBM) using 139 Max-Cut instances (100 to 10,000 nodes). For small instances ( $$\le $$ ≤ 250 nodes) with known global optima, Hybrid and SA consistently achieve optimal solutions, outperforming the QPU. For larger instances, SBM and slower SA yield superior solutions, while Hybrid and faster SA perform less effectively. Computation time varies across solvers.

arXiv:2412.07460•Quantum Information Processing•Jul 3, 2026•9 citations

Efficient digital quadratic unconstrained binary optimization solvers for SAT problems

Robert Simon Fong, Yanming Song, Alexander Yosifov

Abstract Boolean satisfiability (SAT) is a propositional logic problem of determining whether an assignment of variables satisfies a Boolean formula. Many combinatorial optimization problems can be formulated in Boolean SAT logic—either as k-SAT decision problems or Max k-SAT optimization problems, with conflict-driven clause learning (CDCL) solvers being the most prominent. Despite their ability to handle large instances, CDCL-based solvers have fundamental scalability limitations. In light of this, we propose recently-developed quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) solvers as an alternative platform for 3-SAT problems. To utilize them, we implement a 2-step [3-SAT]-[Max 2-SAT]-[QUBO] conversion procedure and present a novel approach using linear systems and Diophantine equation to calculate the number of both satisfied and violated clauses of the original 3-SAT instance from the transformed Max 2-SAT formulation. We then demonstrate, through numerical simulations on several benchmark instances, that digital QUBO solvers can achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on 78-variable 3-SAT benchmark problems. Our work facilitates the broader use of quantum annealers on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, as well as their quantum-inspired digital counterparts, for solving 3-SAT problems.

arXiv:2408.03757•New Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 2025•3 citations

A High-Performance Digital QUBO Solver for Quantum-Inspired Optimization

Chia‐Ho Ou, Po-Yuan Chu, Tsung-Hsuan Tsai +2 more

As Moore’s Law slows, alternative computing paradigms are essential for tackling complex combinatorial optimization problems. This paper introduces DigiQUBO, a high-performance digital Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) solver designed for quantum-inspired optimization. DigiQUBO leverages a advanced Digital Annealing (DA) approach to efficiently solve large-scale QUBO problems, offering a competitive alternative to traditional annealing methods. To evaluate its effectiveness, DigiQUBO is applied to the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), a well-known NP-hard problem with applications in logistics, network design, and computational biology. In solving a 40-city Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), DigiQUBO achieved an average route distance improvement of 13% compared to Simulated Annealing (SA), and a reduction of 37% compared to D-Wave’s LeapHybridSampler, while maintaining comparable runtime to Fujitsu DA3. DigiQUBO significantly enhances solution quality and computational efficiency by integrating two key advanced techniques: two-way one-hot group encoding for improved constraint satisfaction and Bayesian Optimization for automated annealing parameter tuning. Performance comparisons against Simulated Annealing (SA), Fujitsu DA3, and D-Wave’s LeapHybridSampler demonstrate superior results in balancing accuracy and execution time. The results highlight DigiQUBO as a promising digital annealing technology that bridges the gap between classical and quantum optimization, offering a practical and efficient solution in the post-Moore’s Law era.

IEEE Nanotechnology Magazine•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations
Recently, inspired by quantum annealing, many solvers specialized for unconstrained binary quadratic programming problems have been developed. For further improvement and application of these solvers, it is important to clarify the differences in their performance for various types of problems. In this study, the performance of four quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem solvers, namely D-Wave Hybrid Solver Service (HSS), Toshiba Simulated Bifurcation Machine (SBM), Fujitsu Digital Annealer (DA), and simulated annealing on a personal computer, was benchmarked. The problems used for benchmarking were instances of real problems in MQLib, instances of the SAT-UNSAT phase transition point of random not-all-equal 3-SAT (NAE 3-SAT), and the Ising spin glass Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model. Concerning MQLib instances, the HSS performance ranked first; for NAE 3-SAT, DA performance ranked first; and regarding the SK model, SBM performance ranked first. These results may help understand the strengths and weaknesses of these solvers.
Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) provides a versatile framework for representing NP-hard combinatorial problems, yet existing solvers often face trade-offs among speed, accuracy, and scalability. In this work, we introduce a quantum-inspired solver (QIS) that unites branch-and-bound pruning, continuous gradient-descent refinement, and quantum-inspired heuristics within a fully adaptive control architecture. We benchmark QIS3 against eight state-of-the-art solvers, including genetic algorithms, coherent Ising machines, simulated bifurcation, parallel tempering, simulated annealing, our prior QIS2 version, D-Wave's simulated-annealing (Neal), and Gurobi on three canonical QUBO problem classes: Max-Cut, NAE-3SAT, and Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin glass problems. Under a uniform runtime budget, QIS3 attains the best solution on nearly all instances, achieving optimality in 94% of max-cut instances. These results establish QIS3 as a robust, high-performance solver that bridges classical exact strategies and quantum-inspired heuristics for scalable QUBO optimization.
Abstract Quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) formulations of combinatorial optimization problems allow for solving them using various quantum heuristics. While large-scale quantum computations are currently still out of reach, we can already numerically test such QUBO formulations on a perhaps surprisingly large scale. In this work, we benchmark Fujitsu’s Digital Annealer (DA) on the Max-Cut problem, which captures the main complexity of the QUBO problem. We make a comprehensive benchmark against leading other heuristic algorithms on graphs with up to 53,000 variables by focusing on the wall-clock time. Moreover, we compare the DA performance against published performance results of the D-Wave hybrid quantum–classical annealer and the recently proposed QIS3 heuristic. Based on performance statistics for over 2000 graphs from the MQLib, we find that the DA yields competitive results. We hope that this benchmark demonstrates the extent to which large QUBO instances can be heuristically solved today, yielding consistent results across different solvers.
Abstract With current semiconductor technology reaching its physical limits, special-purpose hardware has emerged as an option to tackle specific computing-intensive challenges. Optimization in the form of solving quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problems, or equivalently Ising spin glasses, has been the focus of several new dedicated hardware platforms. These platforms come in many different flavors, from highly-efficient hardware implementations on digital-logic of established algorithms to proposals of analog hardware implementing new algorithms. In this work, we use a mapping of a specific class of linear equations whose solutions can be found efficiently, to a hard constraint satisfaction problem (three-regular three-XORSAT, or an Ising spin glass) with a ‘golf-course’ shaped energy landscape, to benchmark several of these different approaches. We perform a scaling and prefactor analysis of the performance of Fujitsu’s digital annealer unit (DAU), the D-Wave advantage quantum annealer, a virtual MemComputing machine, Toshiba’s simulated bifurcation machine (SBM), the SATonGPU algorithm from Bernaschi et al , and our implementation of parallel tempering. We identify the SATonGPU and DAU as currently having the smallest scaling exponent for this benchmark, with SATonGPU having a small scaling advantage and in addition having by far the smallest prefactor thanks to its use of massive parallelism. Our work provides an objective assessment and a snapshot of the promise and limitations of dedicated optimization hardware relative to a particular class of optimization problems.
Abstract This paper benchmarks quantum, classical, and hybrid solvers on NP-hard Max-Cut and QUBO problems, emphasizing solution quality relative to known global optima. We evaluate D-Wave’s fast annealing QPU and Hybrid solver against classical simulated annealing (SA) and Toshiba’s simulated bifurcation machine (SBM) using 139 Max-Cut instances (100 to 10,000 nodes). For small instances ( ≤\le ≤ ≤ 250 nodes) with known global optima, Hybrid and SA consistently achieve optimal solutions, outperforming the QPU. For larger instances, SBM and slower SA yield superior solutions, while Hybrid and faster SA perform less effectively. Computation time varies across solvers.
Abstract Boolean satisfiability (SAT) is a propositional logic problem of determining whether an assignment of variables satisfies a Boolean formula. Many combinatorial optimization problems can be formulated in Boolean SAT logic—either as k-SAT decision problems or Max k-SAT optimization problems, with conflict-driven clause learning (CDCL) solvers being the most prominent. Despite their ability to handle large instances, CDCL-based solvers have fundamental scalability limitations. In light of this, we propose recently-developed quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) solvers as an alternative platform for 3-SAT problems. To utilize them, we implement a 2-step [3-SAT]-[Max 2-SAT]-[QUBO] conversion procedure and present a novel approach using linear systems and Diophantine equation to calculate the number of both satisfied and violated clauses of the original 3-SAT instance from the transformed Max 2-SAT formulation. We then demonstrate, through numerical simulations on several benchmark instances, that digital QUBO solvers can achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on 78-variable 3-SAT benchmark problems. Our work facilitates the broader use of quantum annealers on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, as well as their quantum-inspired digital counterparts, for solving 3-SAT problems.
As Moore’s Law slows, alternative computing paradigms are essential for tackling complex combinatorial optimization problems. This paper introduces DigiQUBO, a high-performance digital Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) solver designed for quantum-inspired optimization. DigiQUBO leverages a advanced Digital Annealing (DA) approach to efficiently solve large-scale QUBO problems, offering a competitive alternative to traditional annealing methods. To evaluate its effectiveness, DigiQUBO is applied to the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), a well-known NP-hard problem with applications in logistics, network design, and computational biology. In solving a 40-city Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), DigiQUBO achieved an average route distance improvement of 13% compared to Simulated Annealing (SA), and a reduction of 37% compared to D-Wave’s LeapHybridSampler, while maintaining comparable runtime to Fujitsu DA3. DigiQUBO significantly enhances solution quality and computational efficiency by integrating two key advanced techniques: two-way one-hot group encoding for improved constraint satisfaction and Bayesian Optimization for automated annealing parameter tuning. Performance comparisons against Simulated Annealing (SA), Fujitsu DA3, and D-Wave’s LeapHybridSampler demonstrate superior results in balancing accuracy and execution time. The results highlight DigiQUBO as a promising digital annealing technology that bridges the gap between classical and quantum optimization, offering a practical and efficient solution in the post-Moore’s Law era.