Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2104.10703 · New Journal of Physics

Wave–particle complementarity: detecting violation of local realism with photon-number resolving weak-field homodyne measurements

Tamoghna Das, Marcin Karczewski, Antonio Mandarino, Marcin Markiewicz, Bianka Wołoncewicz, Marek Żukowski

Published Mar 1, 2022• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Nowadays photon-number resolving weak-field homodyne measurements allow realization of emblematic gedankenexperiments revealing correlations of optical fields. This covers experiments on (a) excitation of a pair of spatial modes by a single photon, and (b) two spatial modes in a weakly squeezed vacuum state, involving constant local oscillator strengths. Proving Bell nonclassicality of such correlations demands measurements of complementary observables. We show that typical arrangement of weak-field homodyne detection with measurement settings defined by phases of local oscillators of constant strength does not provide enough complementarity for confirming Bell nonclassicality. In the case of experiment (a) we provide an exact local hidden variable model restoring all quantum probabilities, whereas in the case of experiment (b) we show that the claims of its nonclassicality are unfounded. A full complementarity of wave aspects vs particle (number) can be achieved in a measurement situation in which respectively the local oscillators are on or off. This is shown to lead to an operational scenario, in the case of both experiments (a) and (b), which reveals indisputable violations of local realism. Such schemes may find possible applications in device-independent quantum protocols.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/ac54c8

Related papers

Can single photon excitation of two spatially separated modes lead to a violation of Bell inequality via weak-field homodyne measurements?

Tamoghna Das, Marcin Karczewski, Antonio Mandarino +3 more

Abstract We reconsider the all-optical weak homodyne-measurement based experimental schemes aimed at revealing Bell nonclassicality (‘nonlocality’) of a single photon. We focus on the schemes put forward by Tan et al (TWC, 1991) and Hardy (1994). In our previous work we show that the TWC experiment can be described by a local hidden variable model, hence the claimed nonclassicality is apparent. The nonclassicality proof proposed by Hardy remains impeccable. We investigate which feature of the Hardy’s approach is crucial to disclose the nonclassicality. There are consequential differences between TWC and Hardy setups: (i) the initial state of Hardy is a superposition of a single photon excitation with vacuum in one of the input modes of a 50–50 beamsplitter. In the TWC case there is no vacuum component. (ii) In the final measurements of Hardy’s proposal the local settings are specified by the presence or absence of a local oscillator field (on/off). In the TWC case the auxiliary fields are constant, only phases are varied. We show that in Hardy’s setup the violation of local realism occurs due to the varying strength of the local oscillators. Still, one does not need to operate in the fully on/off detection scheme. Thus, the nonclassicality in a Hardy-like setup cannot be attributed to the single-photon state alone. It is a consequence of its interference with the photons from auxiliary local fields. Neither can it be attributed to the joint state of the single photon excitation and the local oscillator modes, as this state is measurement setting dependent. Despite giving spurious violations of local realism, the TWC scheme can serve as an entanglement indicator, for the TWC state. Nevertheless an analogue indicator based on intensity rates rather than just intensities overperforms it.

arXiv:2102.06689•New Journal of Physics•Jun 30, 2021•23 citations

Optimal Interferometry for Bell Nonclassicality Induced by a Vacuum–One-Photon Qubit

Tamoghna Das, Marcin Karczewski, Antonio Mandarino +2 more

Bell nonclassicality of a single-photon superposition in two modes, often referred to as ``nonlocality of a single photon,'' is one of the most striking nonclassical phenomena discussed in the context of foundations of quantum physics. Here we show how to robustly violate local realism within the weak-field homodyne measurement scheme for any superposition of one photon with vacuum. Our modification of the previously proposed setups involves tunable beam splitters at the measurement stations, and the local oscillator fields significantly varying between the settings, optimally being on or off. As photon-number-resolving measurements are now feasible, we advocate for the use of the Clauser-Horne Bell inequalities for detection events using precisely defined numbers of photons. We find a condition for optimal measurement settings for the maximal violation of the Clauser-Horne inequality with weak-field homodyne detection, which states that the reflectivity of the local beam splitter must be equal to the strength of the local oscillator field. We show that this condition holds not only for the vacuum--one-photon qubit input state, but also for the superposition of a photon pair with vacuum, which suggests its generality as a property of weak-field homodyne detection with photon-number resolution. Our findings suggest a possible path to employ such scenarios in device-independent quantum protocols.

arXiv:2109.10170•Physical Review Applied•Sep 27, 2022•12 citations

Phase-sensitive tests of nonlocality of quantum-mechanical fields

Sze N. Tan, Murray Holland, Daniel F. Walls

Nonlocal effects associated with quantum-mechanical states have been theoretically interesting because they emphasize the differences between classical and quantum mechanics. We describe a system in which a single input photon causes a nonlocal influence on two spatially separated homodyne detectors, as evidenced by a violation of Bell's inequalities. Unlike previous configurations for violating Bell's inequalities, the correlation is not imposed on a pair of particles that spatially separate before being detected. Rather, the correlation arises from the interaction of the local oscillators at each homodyne detector with the spatially extended field of the input photon. The above effect is only one of a class of situations in which nonlocal correlations can be imposed on separated homodyne detectors by quantum mechanical fields. By deriving the conditions for violating Bell's inequality with phase-sensitive detectors, new tests can be developed that relate to squeezed light and other nonclassical fields.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1990•0 citations

Dual problem of nonclassicality

А. А. Семенов, A. B. Klimov

We show that nonclassicality of phase-space quasi-probability distributions is tied to violations of principles of physical reality in device-dependent scenarios. In this context, the nonclassicality problem has its dual form expressed as a device-dependent analog of Bell inequalities. This approach is applicable even to systems with only one spatial party. The derived inequalities are employed for testing nonclassicality with emblematic optical measurements: photocounting including the case of realistic photon-number resolution; unbalanced, balanced, and eight-port homodyne detection.

•Sep 12, 2020•0 citations

Novel nonclassical effects in the homodyne detection of squeezed light

Arlis Dodson, Reeta Vyas

Nonclassical effects exhibited by the homodyned field when light from an optical parametric oscillator (OPO) is mixed with coherent light from a local oscillator are discussed. Calculations are carried out exactly without making the strong local oscillator approximation. It is found that, depending upon the local oscillator phase and the parameters characterizing the light from the OPO, the second order intensity correlation function of the superposed field violates various classical inequalities g(2)(0) ≥ 1, g(2)(0) ≥g(2)(τ), and |g(2)(0) –1| ≥ | g(2)(τ)–1|. Thus we can see sub-Poissonian or super-Poissonian statistics and bunching or antibunching. We express the fields at the beam splitter in terms of independent real Gaussian stochastic processes with coherent component. Using these properties of the dynamical field variables, we derive analytic expressions for quantities directly measurable in photon counting experiments. It is found that the waiting time distribution shows two extrema at nonzero times. The second order intensity correlation function is found to vanish at nonzero time in violation of a classical inequality.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations

Statistics of difference events in homodyne detection

W. Vogel, Jens Grabow

The statistics of the difference events in a balanced homodyne-detection scheme is studied without using the standard assumption of a strong, classical local oscillator. Starting from the quantum theory of photon counting, we derive the probability distribution for the difference events in the two detection channels. In the limit of the local oscillator being strong compared with the signal, the difference-number statistics tends to the statistics of the electric-field strength of the signal field. For weak signals, this limit may be obtained already far from a classical behavior of the local oscillator. While changing the local oscillator intensity, a transition of the observable concerning the signal field occurs from the photon-number difference towards the electric-field strength. Such a measurement scheme renders it possible to observe the quantum features of a coherent state or a single-photon state from the point of view of the field-strength statistics, a picture which is closely related to classical optics. The possibility to get some insight in the statistical properties of the phase difference of two microscopic fields is discussed.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1993•89 citations
Abstract Nowadays photon-number resolving weak-field homodyne measurements allow realization of emblematic gedankenexperiments revealing correlations of optical fields. This covers experiments on (a) excitation of a pair of spatial modes by a single photon, and (b) two spatial modes in a weakly squeezed vacuum state, involving constant local oscillator strengths. Proving Bell nonclassicality of such correlations demands measurements of complementary observables. We show that typical arrangement of weak-field homodyne detection with measurement settings defined by phases of local oscillators of constant strength does not provide enough complementarity for confirming Bell nonclassicality. In the case of experiment (a) we provide an exact local hidden variable model restoring all quantum probabilities, whereas in the case of experiment (b) we show that the claims of its nonclassicality are unfounded. A full complementarity of wave aspects vs particle (number) can be achieved in a measurement situation in which respectively the local oscillators are on or off. This is shown to lead to an operational scenario, in the case of both experiments (a) and (b), which reveals indisputable violations of local realism. Such schemes may find possible applications in device-independent quantum protocols.
Abstract We reconsider the all-optical weak homodyne-measurement based experimental schemes aimed at revealing Bell nonclassicality (‘nonlocality’) of a single photon. We focus on the schemes put forward by Tan et al (TWC, 1991) and Hardy (1994). In our previous work we show that the TWC experiment can be described by a local hidden variable model, hence the claimed nonclassicality is apparent. The nonclassicality proof proposed by Hardy remains impeccable. We investigate which feature of the Hardy’s approach is crucial to disclose the nonclassicality. There are consequential differences between TWC and Hardy setups: (i) the initial state of Hardy is a superposition of a single photon excitation with vacuum in one of the input modes of a 50–50 beamsplitter. In the TWC case there is no vacuum component. (ii) In the final measurements of Hardy’s proposal the local settings are specified by the presence or absence of a local oscillator field (on/off). In the TWC case the auxiliary fields are constant, only phases are varied. We show that in Hardy’s setup the violation of local realism occurs due to the varying strength of the local oscillators. Still, one does not need to operate in the fully on/off detection scheme. Thus, the nonclassicality in a Hardy-like setup cannot be attributed to the single-photon state alone. It is a consequence of its interference with the photons from auxiliary local fields. Neither can it be attributed to the joint state of the single photon excitation and the local oscillator modes, as this state is measurement setting dependent. Despite giving spurious violations of local realism, the TWC scheme can serve as an entanglement indicator, for the TWC state. Nevertheless an analogue indicator based on intensity rates rather than just intensities overperforms it.
Bell nonclassicality of a single-photon superposition in two modes, often referred to as ``nonlocality of a single photon,'' is one of the most striking nonclassical phenomena discussed in the context of foundations of quantum physics. Here we show how to robustly violate local realism within the weak-field homodyne measurement scheme for any superposition of one photon with vacuum. Our modification of the previously proposed setups involves tunable beam splitters at the measurement stations, and the local oscillator fields significantly varying between the settings, optimally being on or off. As photon-number-resolving measurements are now feasible, we advocate for the use of the Clauser-Horne Bell inequalities for detection events using precisely defined numbers of photons. We find a condition for optimal measurement settings for the maximal violation of the Clauser-Horne inequality with weak-field homodyne detection, which states that the reflectivity of the local beam splitter must be equal to the strength of the local oscillator field. We show that this condition holds not only for the vacuum--one-photon qubit input state, but also for the superposition of a photon pair with vacuum, which suggests its generality as a property of weak-field homodyne detection with photon-number resolution. Our findings suggest a possible path to employ such scenarios in device-independent quantum protocols.
Nonlocal effects associated with quantum-mechanical states have been theoretically interesting because they emphasize the differences between classical and quantum mechanics. We describe a system in which a single input photon causes a nonlocal influence on two spatially separated homodyne detectors, as evidenced by a violation of Bell's inequalities. Unlike previous configurations for violating Bell's inequalities, the correlation is not imposed on a pair of particles that spatially separate before being detected. Rather, the correlation arises from the interaction of the local oscillators at each homodyne detector with the spatially extended field of the input photon. The above effect is only one of a class of situations in which nonlocal correlations can be imposed on separated homodyne detectors by quantum mechanical fields. By deriving the conditions for violating Bell's inequality with phase-sensitive detectors, new tests can be developed that relate to squeezed light and other nonclassical fields.
We show that nonclassicality of phase-space quasi-probability distributions is tied to violations of principles of physical reality in device-dependent scenarios. In this context, the nonclassicality problem has its dual form expressed as a device-dependent analog of Bell inequalities. This approach is applicable even to systems with only one spatial party. The derived inequalities are employed for testing nonclassicality with emblematic optical measurements: photocounting including the case of realistic photon-number resolution; unbalanced, balanced, and eight-port homodyne detection.
Nonclassical effects exhibited by the homodyned field when light from an optical parametric oscillator (OPO) is mixed with coherent light from a local oscillator are discussed. Calculations are carried out exactly without making the strong local oscillator approximation. It is found that, depending upon the local oscillator phase and the parameters characterizing the light from the OPO, the second order intensity correlation function of the superposed field violates various classical inequalities g(2)(0) ≥ 1, g(2)(0) ≥g(2)(τ), and |g(2)(0) –1| ≥ | g(2)(τ)–1|. Thus we can see sub-Poissonian or super-Poissonian statistics and bunching or antibunching. We express the fields at the beam splitter in terms of independent real Gaussian stochastic processes with coherent component. Using these properties of the dynamical field variables, we derive analytic expressions for quantities directly measurable in photon counting experiments. It is found that the waiting time distribution shows two extrema at nonzero times. The second order intensity correlation function is found to vanish at nonzero time in violation of a classical inequality.
The statistics of the difference events in a balanced homodyne-detection scheme is studied without using the standard assumption of a strong, classical local oscillator. Starting from the quantum theory of photon counting, we derive the probability distribution for the difference events in the two detection channels. In the limit of the local oscillator being strong compared with the signal, the difference-number statistics tends to the statistics of the electric-field strength of the signal field. For weak signals, this limit may be obtained already far from a classical behavior of the local oscillator. While changing the local oscillator intensity, a transition of the observable concerning the signal field occurs from the photon-number difference towards the electric-field strength. Such a measurement scheme renders it possible to observe the quantum features of a coherent state or a single-photon state from the point of view of the field-strength statistics, a picture which is closely related to classical optics. The possibility to get some insight in the statistical properties of the phase difference of two microscopic fields is discussed.