Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.12303

Universality of swap for qudits: a representation theory approach

James R. van Meter

Published Mar 23, 2021• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An open problem of quantum information theory has been to determine under what conditions universal exchange-only computation is possible for qudits encoded on $d$-state systems for $d>2$. This problem can be posed in terms of representation theory by recognizing that each quantum mechanical swap, generated by exchange-interaction, can be identified with a transposition in a symmetric group, each $d$-state system can be identified with the fundamental representation of $SU(d)$, and each encoded qudit can be identified with an irreducible representation of a Lie algebra generated by transpositions. Towards this end we first give a mathematical definition of exchange-only universality in terms of a map from the special unitary algebra on the product of qudits into a representation of a Lie algebra generated by transpositions. We show that this definition is consistent with quantum computing requirements. We then proceed with the task of characterizing universal families of qudits, that is families of encoded qudits admitting exchange-only universality. This endeavor is aided by the fact that the irreducible representations corresponding to qudits are canonically labeled by partitions. In particular we derive necessary and sufficient conditions for universality on one or two such qudits, in terms of simple arithmetic conditions on the associated partitions. We also derive necessary and sufficient conditions for universality on arbitrarily many such qudits, in terms of Littlewood--Richardson coefficients. Among other results, we prove that universal families of multiple qudits are upward closed, that universality is guaranteed for sufficiently many qudits, and that any family that is not universal can be made so by simply adding at most five ancillae. We also obtain results for 2-state systems as a special case.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2103.12303

Related papers

Universality in quantum computation

Jennifer L. Dodd

A quantum computer is similar to an ordinary computer, except that instead of bits it uses two-level quantum systems (qubits), and the usual logical operations on bits are replaced with noiseless quantum dynamics in the form of unitary gates or Hamiltonian interactions. Many sets of resources that are universal for quantum computation (that is, capable of implementing any quantum computation) have been found, but general conditions for universality are still only partially understood. Improving our understanding of these conditions contributes to two broad goals. On the one hand, understanding what class of physical systems is suitable for quantum computation allows us choose the systems that are most easily controlled or built in the laboratory. On the other hand, identifying the unifying characteristics of such a class provides insight into the fundamental physics responsible for the much greater computational power of quantum computers.        The original results presented in this thesis are a contribution to our understanding of the physical requirements for universal quantum computation. These results lead to the identification of a new, large class of universal dynamics. More specifically, the main problem that is addressed is the following: consider a physical system that is made up of a finite number of qubits that are subject to a natural, fixed interaction described by a two-body Hamiltonian. Suppose we have the ability to control the system only by applying fast one-qubit operations. Under what conditions is this system capable of universal quantum computation? The first original result of the thesis is to prove that universal quantum computation is possible under these conditions given the single extra constraint that the Hamiltonian must entangle, or connect, all of the qubits. In other words, since a two-body Hamiltonian is expressible as a sum of coupling terms each of which acts nontrivially on a pair of qubits, consider the graph whose vertices correspond to qubits and whose edges connect qubits that are coupled by a term in the Hamiltonian. Then this Hamiltonian, together with fast one-qubit unitaries, is universal for quantum computation precisely when the corresponding graph is connected.       This result suggests many potential generalizations, three of which are explored in this thesis. The first generalization is to show that the same result holds for a two-body Hamiltonian that acts on D-dimensional quantum systems (qudits), given fast one-qudit unitaries. A second extension is to the case of a many-body Hamiltonian, that is, a Hamiltonian that has coupling terms that act on more than two qubits. Again, we find that under mild restrictions, such Hamiltonians are universal provided they are connected and that arbitrary one-qubit unitaries are available. We also discover and explore some surprising structure in many-body Hamiltonians that is associated with the parity of the couplings. A third related problem that is addressed is the question of what two-qubit unitaries are universal for quantum computation. This problem was originally solved by J.-L. and R. Brylinski [BB02], who gave a technical proof of the universality of any two-qudit gate that is not the swap gate or a product of one-qudit unitaries, given one-qudit unitaries as a free resource. We develop an elementary and constructive proof for the case of qubits, and prove that our construction is very close to optimal in the number of uses of the two-qubit gate.       Given a qualitative understanding of what dynamical resources are universal for quantum computation, it is natural to consider developing a quantitative measure of the usefulness of quantum dynamics for quantum information processing. This is done in the final chapter of the thesis, in which the beginnings of a quantitative theory of quantum dynamics are developed.

•Jan 1, 2004•7 citations

Encoded universality from a single physical interaction

Julia Kempe, Dave Bacon, David Peter Divincenzo +1 more

We present a theoretical analysis of the paradigm of encoded universality, using a Lie algebraic analysis to derive specific conditions under which physical interactions can provide universality. We discuss the significance of the tensor product structure in the quantum circuit model and use this to define the conjoining of encoded qudits. The construction of encoded gates between conjoined qudits is discussed in detail. We illustrate the general procedures with several examples from exchange-only quantum computation. In particular, we extend our earlier results showing universality with the isotropic exchange interaction to the derivation of encoded universality with the anisotropic exchange interaction, i.e., to the XY model. In this case the minimal encoding for universality is into qutrits rather than into qubits as was the case for isotropic (Heisenberg) exchange. We also address issues of fault-tolerance, leakage and correction of encoded qudits.

•Dec 1, 2001•45 citations

Encoded universality from a single physical interaction

Julia Kempe, Dave Bacon, David Peter Divincenzo +1 more

We present a theoretical analysis of the paradigm of encoded universality, using a Lie algebraic analysis to derive specific conditions under which physical interactions can provide universality. We discuss the significance of the tensor product structure in the quantum circuit model and use this to define the conjoining of encoded qudits. The construction of encoded gates between conjoined qudits is discussed in detail. We illustrate the general procedures with several examples from exchange-only quantum computation. In particular, we extend our earlier results showing universality with the isotropic exchange interaction to the derivation of encoded universality with the anisotropic exchange interaction, i.e., to the XY model. In this case the minimal encoding for universality is into qutrits rather than into qubits as was the case for isotropic (Heisenberg) exchange. We also address issues of fault-tolerance, leakage and correction of encoded qudits.

arXiv:quant-ph/0112013•Quantum Information and Computation•Dec 1, 2001•44 citations

Universality of Single-Qudit Gates

Adam Sawicki, Katarzyna Karnas

We consider the problem of deciding if a set of quantum one-qudit gates $$\mathcal {S}=\{g_1,\ldots ,g_n\}\subset G$$ is universal, i.e. if $${<}\mathcal {S}{>}$$ is dense in G, where G is either the special unitary or the special orthogonal group. To every gate g in $$\mathcal {S}$$ we assign the orthogonal matrix $$\mathrm {Ad}_g$$ that is image of g under the adjoint representation $$\mathrm {Ad}:G\rightarrow SO(\mathfrak {g})$$ and $$\mathfrak {g}$$ is the Lie algebra of G. The necessary condition for the universality of $$\mathcal {S}$$ is that the only matrices that commute with all $$\mathrm {Ad}_{g_i}$$ ’s are proportional to the identity. If in addition there is an element in $${<}\mathcal {S}{>}$$ whose Hilbert–Schmidt distance from the centre of G belongs to $$]0,\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[$$ , then $$\mathcal {S}$$ is universal. Using these we provide a simple algorithm that allows deciding the universality of any set of d-dimensional gates in a finite number of steps and formulate a general classification theorem.

arXiv:1609.05780•Annales Henri Poincaré•Aug 10, 2017•36 citations

Universal Qudit Hamiltonians

Stephen Piddock, Ashley Montanaro

Abstract A family of quantum Hamiltonians is said to be universal if any other finite-dimensional Hamiltonian can be approximately encoded within the low-energy space of a Hamiltonian from that family. If the encoding is efficient, universal families of Hamiltonians can be used as universal analogue quantum simulators and universal quantum computers, and the problem of approximately determining the ground-state energy of a Hamiltonian from a universal family is QMA-complete. One natural way to categorise Hamiltonians into families is in terms of the interactions they are built from. Here we prove universality of some important classes of interactions on qudits (d-level systems): We completely characterise the k-qudit interactions which are universal, if augmented with arbitrary Hermitian 1-local terms. We find that, for all $$k \geqslant 2$$ k ⩾ 2 and all local dimensions $$d \geqslant 2$$ d ⩾ 2 , almost all such interactions are universal aside from a simple stoquastic class. We prove universality of generalisations of the Heisenberg model that are ubiquitous in condensed-matter physics, even if free 1-local terms are not provided. We show that the SU(d) and SU(2) Heisenberg interactions are universal for all local dimensions $$d \geqslant 2$$ d ⩾ 2 (spin $$\geqslant 1/2$$ ⩾ 1 / 2 ), implying that a quantum variant of the Max-d-Cut problem is QMA-complete. We also show that for $$d=3$$ d = 3 all bilinear-biquadratic Heisenberg interactions are universal. One example is the general AKLT model. We prove universality of any interaction proportional to the projector onto a pure entangled state.

arXiv:1802.07130•Communications in Mathematical Physics•Feb 23, 2021•22 citations

Universality in composite quantum systems

Alejandro Borda Kuhlmann

Qudits are the natural generalization of qubits, that is, the basic unit of information in quantum computation. This generalization allows for quantum states to be represented with the same cyclic nature present in qubits, while also permitting the basic unit of information to be stored in d-level systems. In this document, we are concerned with studying universality over qudits on arbitrary dimension d. The question of single-qudit universality of a set of operators can be reduced to studying the adjoint representation of the set and determining whether or not its generated group is finite. Thus, we set out to find universal sets of operators in quantum computation over qudits, for any possible value of d. Moreover, we focus on finding “Clifford + T-like” universal sets of operators in arbitrary dimensions, in the hopes of maintaining a strong analog to the qubits case and its most studied universal set. We accomplish this goal by studying how the Clifford group behaves on arbitrary dimensions, and how this behavior relates to the typical Clifford group in prime dimensions. Furthermore, we find that the Clifford group on arbitrary dimension splits as the typical Clifford group on each of the coprime factors of d, which leads to a fundamental difference between the study of universality on prime power dimensions and arbitrary dimensions containing co-prime factors. Then, we focus on studying the structure of universal sets in dimension d, for any d containing at least two co-prime factors. Thus, after studying which T-like gates drive the single-qudit Clifford group to universality on prime power dimensions; that is, guaranteeing the irreducibility of the adjoint representation and an infinite generated group, we combine these two approaches to obtain “Clifford + T-like” universal sets on all possible dimensions.

•Dec 2, 2025•0 citations
An open problem of quantum information theory has been to determine under what conditions universal exchange-only computation is possible for qudits encoded on ddd-state systems for d>2d>2d>2. This problem can be posed in terms of representation theory by recognizing that each quantum mechanical swap, generated by exchange-interaction, can be identified with a transposition in a symmetric group, each ddd-state system can be identified with the fundamental representation of SU(d)SU(d)SU(d), and each encoded qudit can be identified with an irreducible representation of a Lie algebra generated by transpositions. Towards this end we first give a mathematical definition of exchange-only universality in terms of a map from the special unitary algebra on the product of qudits into a representation of a Lie algebra generated by transpositions. We show that this definition is consistent with quantum computing requirements. We then proceed with the task of characterizing universal families of qudits, that is families of encoded qudits admitting exchange-only universality. This endeavor is aided by the fact that the irreducible representations corresponding to qudits are canonically labeled by partitions. In particular we derive necessary and sufficient conditions for universality on one or two such qudits, in terms of simple arithmetic conditions on the associated partitions. We also derive necessary and sufficient conditions for universality on arbitrarily many such qudits, in terms of Littlewood--Richardson coefficients. Among other results, we prove that universal families of multiple qudits are upward closed, that universality is guaranteed for sufficiently many qudits, and that any family that is not universal can be made so by simply adding at most five ancillae. We also obtain results for 2-state systems as a special case.
A quantum computer is similar to an ordinary computer, except that instead of bits it uses two-level quantum systems (qubits), and the usual logical operations on bits are replaced with noiseless quantum dynamics in the form of unitary gates or Hamiltonian interactions. Many sets of resources that are universal for quantum computation (that is, capable of implementing any quantum computation) have been found, but general conditions for universality are still only partially understood. Improving our understanding of these conditions contributes to two broad goals. On the one hand, understanding what class of physical systems is suitable for quantum computation allows us choose the systems that are most easily controlled or built in the laboratory. On the other hand, identifying the unifying characteristics of such a class provides insight into the fundamental physics responsible for the much greater computational power of quantum computers.        The original results presented in this thesis are a contribution to our understanding of the physical requirements for universal quantum computation. These results lead to the identification of a new, large class of universal dynamics. More specifically, the main problem that is addressed is the following: consider a physical system that is made up of a finite number of qubits that are subject to a natural, fixed interaction described by a two-body Hamiltonian. Suppose we have the ability to control the system only by applying fast one-qubit operations. Under what conditions is this system capable of universal quantum computation? The first original result of the thesis is to prove that universal quantum computation is possible under these conditions given the single extra constraint that the Hamiltonian must entangle, or connect, all of the qubits. In other words, since a two-body Hamiltonian is expressible as a sum of coupling terms each of which acts nontrivially on a pair of qubits, consider the graph whose vertices correspond to qubits and whose edges connect qubits that are coupled by a term in the Hamiltonian. Then this Hamiltonian, together with fast one-qubit unitaries, is universal for quantum computation precisely when the corresponding graph is connected.       This result suggests many potential generalizations, three of which are explored in this thesis. The first generalization is to show that the same result holds for a two-body Hamiltonian that acts on D-dimensional quantum systems (qudits), given fast one-qudit unitaries. A second extension is to the case of a many-body Hamiltonian, that is, a Hamiltonian that has coupling terms that act on more than two qubits. Again, we find that under mild restrictions, such Hamiltonians are universal provided they are connected and that arbitrary one-qubit unitaries are available. We also discover and explore some surprising structure in many-body Hamiltonians that is associated with the parity of the couplings. A third related problem that is addressed is the question of what two-qubit unitaries are universal for quantum computation. This problem was originally solved by J.-L. and R. Brylinski [BB02], who gave a technical proof of the universality of any two-qudit gate that is not the swap gate or a product of one-qudit unitaries, given one-qudit unitaries as a free resource. We develop an elementary and constructive proof for the case of qubits, and prove that our construction is very close to optimal in the number of uses of the two-qubit gate.       Given a qualitative understanding of what dynamical resources are universal for quantum computation, it is natural to consider developing a quantitative measure of the usefulness of quantum dynamics for quantum information processing. This is done in the final chapter of the thesis, in which the beginnings of a quantitative theory of quantum dynamics are developed.
We present a theoretical analysis of the paradigm of encoded universality, using a Lie algebraic analysis to derive specific conditions under which physical interactions can provide universality. We discuss the significance of the tensor product structure in the quantum circuit model and use this to define the conjoining of encoded qudits. The construction of encoded gates between conjoined qudits is discussed in detail. We illustrate the general procedures with several examples from exchange-only quantum computation. In particular, we extend our earlier results showing universality with the isotropic exchange interaction to the derivation of encoded universality with the anisotropic exchange interaction, i.e., to the XY model. In this case the minimal encoding for universality is into qutrits rather than into qubits as was the case for isotropic (Heisenberg) exchange. We also address issues of fault-tolerance, leakage and correction of encoded qudits.
We present a theoretical analysis of the paradigm of encoded universality, using a Lie algebraic analysis to derive specific conditions under which physical interactions can provide universality. We discuss the significance of the tensor product structure in the quantum circuit model and use this to define the conjoining of encoded qudits. The construction of encoded gates between conjoined qudits is discussed in detail. We illustrate the general procedures with several examples from exchange-only quantum computation. In particular, we extend our earlier results showing universality with the isotropic exchange interaction to the derivation of encoded universality with the anisotropic exchange interaction, i.e., to the XY model. In this case the minimal encoding for universality is into qutrits rather than into qubits as was the case for isotropic (Heisenberg) exchange. We also address issues of fault-tolerance, leakage and correction of encoded qudits.
We consider the problem of deciding if a set of quantum one-qudit gates S={g1,…,gn}⊂G\mathcal {S}=\{g_1,\ldots ,g_n\}\subset GS={g1​,…,gn​}⊂G is universal, i.e. if <S>{<}\mathcal {S}{>}<S> is dense in G, where G is either the special unitary or the special orthogonal group. To every gate g in S\mathcal {S}S we assign the orthogonal matrix Adg\mathrm {Ad}_gAdg​ that is image of g under the adjoint representation Ad:G→SO(g)\mathrm {Ad}:G\rightarrow SO(\mathfrak {g})Ad:G→SO(g) and g\mathfrak {g}g is the Lie algebra of G. The necessary condition for the universality of S\mathcal {S}S is that the only matrices that commute with all Adgi\mathrm {Ad}_{g_i}Adgi​​ ’s are proportional to the identity. If in addition there is an element in <S>{<}\mathcal {S}{>}<S> whose Hilbert–Schmidt distance from the centre of G belongs to ]0,12[]0,\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[]0,2​1​[ , then S\mathcal {S}S is universal. Using these we provide a simple algorithm that allows deciding the universality of any set of d-dimensional gates in a finite number of steps and formulate a general classification theorem.
Abstract A family of quantum Hamiltonians is said to be universal if any other finite-dimensional Hamiltonian can be approximately encoded within the low-energy space of a Hamiltonian from that family. If the encoding is efficient, universal families of Hamiltonians can be used as universal analogue quantum simulators and universal quantum computers, and the problem of approximately determining the ground-state energy of a Hamiltonian from a universal family is QMA-complete. One natural way to categorise Hamiltonians into families is in terms of the interactions they are built from. Here we prove universality of some important classes of interactions on qudits (d-level systems): We completely characterise the k-qudit interactions which are universal, if augmented with arbitrary Hermitian 1-local terms. We find that, for all k⩾2k \geqslant 2k⩾2 k ⩾ 2 and all local dimensions d⩾2d \geqslant 2d⩾2 d ⩾ 2 , almost all such interactions are universal aside from a simple stoquastic class. We prove universality of generalisations of the Heisenberg model that are ubiquitous in condensed-matter physics, even if free 1-local terms are not provided. We show that the SU(d) and SU(2) Heisenberg interactions are universal for all local dimensions d⩾2d \geqslant 2d⩾2 d ⩾ 2 (spin ⩾1/2\geqslant 1/2⩾1/2 ⩾ 1 / 2 ), implying that a quantum variant of the Max-d-Cut problem is QMA-complete. We also show that for d=3d=3d=3 d = 3 all bilinear-biquadratic Heisenberg interactions are universal. One example is the general AKLT model. We prove universality of any interaction proportional to the projector onto a pure entangled state.
Qudits are the natural generalization of qubits, that is, the basic unit of information in quantum computation. This generalization allows for quantum states to be represented with the same cyclic nature present in qubits, while also permitting the basic unit of information to be stored in d-level systems. In this document, we are concerned with studying universality over qudits on arbitrary dimension d. The question of single-qudit universality of a set of operators can be reduced to studying the adjoint representation of the set and determining whether or not its generated group is finite. Thus, we set out to find universal sets of operators in quantum computation over qudits, for any possible value of d. Moreover, we focus on finding “Clifford + T-like” universal sets of operators in arbitrary dimensions, in the hopes of maintaining a strong analog to the qubits case and its most studied universal set. We accomplish this goal by studying how the Clifford group behaves on arbitrary dimensions, and how this behavior relates to the typical Clifford group in prime dimensions. Furthermore, we find that the Clifford group on arbitrary dimension splits as the typical Clifford group on each of the coprime factors of d, which leads to a fundamental difference between the study of universality on prime power dimensions and arbitrary dimensions containing co-prime factors. Then, we focus on studying the structure of universal sets in dimension d, for any d containing at least two co-prime factors. Thus, after studying which T-like gates drive the single-qudit Clifford group to universality on prime power dimensions; that is, guaranteeing the irreducibility of the adjoint representation and an infinite generated group, we combine these two approaches to obtain “Clifford + T-like” universal sets on all possible dimensions.